Awesome job Dubious Potions. This is one of those rare LD games which is such a smooth production that it starts to not look like a jam game any more. Sure, it's a fairly short game, but it's a seamless experience. Great art, animations, sound, puzzles, and no bugs to speak of.
I love the collage style, really reminds me of a specific genre that for which I don't really have a name, but Samorost is the main comparison that comes to mind (I wish I knew the name of an old series I played as a kid on Newgrounds that really has this kinda vibe). Super cool to see that the art was physically made and photographed for the game.
The animations are lovely, moving around and between the layers of depth is really satisfying. Interacting with everything feels smooth, and the shaking inventory items are a nice touch. The UI in the interactions also looks great, (it reminds me of Rusty Lake). The UI does feel like it comes from a different game than the main art style - it doesn't have the same scrappy collage feel, but that's a very minor nitpick.
The pigeon is a good pigeon. 10/10 for the pigeon. Let's get a pigeon category added to LD.
I'd love to get some music in here! I'll caveat that with the understanding that some games like this get away without music, but I think Samorost could pass without music becuase of it's particularly weird and abstract vibe, it's "spaceyness", and also having a more detailed soundscape. Failing music, just getting some more environmental sound would go a long way. The forest sounds great and has nice variety, I'd love to hear more of that in the other areas.
Admittedly I'm early in my LD59 exploration, but at the time of playing, this has been my favourite.
Thanks for the game!