Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → Users → Rafael Sales

Rafael Sales

Games

YearLDThemeGameDivisionRankOvFuInThGrAuHuMoCo
201326MinimalismIAOcompo2603.483.163.763.933.203.481.812.93100

Performance over time

overall score (left axis) percentile (right axis)

Correlations

Feedback left by Rafael Sales

Rafael Sales leaves an average of 191.0 feedback comments each event.

LD26 — Minimalism (191)

Geneva Convection by TylerGlaiel 2013-05-20T23:49:00

Cool game. Great graphics and simple mechanic. Hard to get master and really fun. Congrats!

Nod by Rose 2013-05-20T23:44:00

Cool idea. Very simple, but deep. I wanna play more, actually, but I liked. Congrats!!

(R,G,B) by KilledByAPixel 2013-05-20T23:42:00

Awesome game. Perfect graphics and interesting mood. Congratulations!

FOLD by jwaap 2013-05-20T23:38:00

Cool game. Amazing graphics and great concept. Congrats!!

People by BenW 2013-05-20T23:34:00

Great game. Beautiful and poetic. Congrats!

Telekinetic Minimalist Cult 5: Packrat Nightmare by RobotLovesKitty 2013-05-20T23:24:00

Good game. Congrats!

Be The Wind by dstozek 2013-05-20T23:16:00

Great game. It is very Flow style and extremely well done. Congrats!!

Dream Fishing by Sophie Houlden 2013-05-20T22:48:00

Great game. Awesome art and controls! Congrats!!

Leaf Me Alone by Claw 2013-05-20T22:44:00

Fantastic game! One of the best entries! Marvelous art, sound and mood. Congratulations!

Minimalism : Find the red Cube by Martin_Monosys 2013-05-20T22:32:00

Cool game. Nice idea, innovative and simple. Congratulatios!

Mr. Minimal by sP0CkEr2 2013-05-20T22:25:00

Fun game. Extremely simple but interesting. I only thought that it's too easy. After level 15 I stopped because I didn't realized that the challenging curve is increasing. Nice work!

The Only Winning Move Is Not To Play by csanyk 2013-05-20T22:15:00

Here didn't work. In the beginning I thought that the concept is just the blank screen with 3 texts, but reading the comments, it seems that there is something to play. I didn't rate because I didn't play :(

Don't Get Wet by Komradus 2013-05-20T22:00:00

Cool game! Interesting mechanic. Hard to be master. Nice!

X PRESS by Pitoum 2013-05-14T18:05:00

Awesome game. Even without great innovations is a great game. Very fun and well done. Congratulations!

# by Kitch 2013-05-14T17:27:00

Great game. Extremely fits to the theme and is a fun shooter with some pieces of puzzle. Congrats!!

Prototype by OnlySlightly 2013-05-14T17:20:00

Good work. It's nice play this kind of experiments. Congrats!

T.O.M.B. by Knighty 2013-05-14T17:17:00

Cool game. Interesting mechanic and awesome graphics. Congrats!

This is not a minimalist game by Volute 2013-05-14T17:09:00

AMAZING game. It's really impressive how the concept was well done. I've played until the end. Congratulations a lot!

Hexzilla by Bernhard 2013-05-13T15:44:00

Fucking awesome game! Great game to build smart strategies and get master playing a simple but deep game mechanic. Congratulations!

The Minimalism Quest by Pol 2013-05-13T15:34:00

Excelente work! Complete and fun experience. I'm without problems to list here. Congratulations!

[placeholder] by mtrc 2013-05-13T15:29:00

Fantastic puzzle!!! You really catch an awesome solution to the theme. Congratulations!

I Know Nothing by MathiO 2013-05-13T15:24:00

Impressive game experienge. I've immersed really deep in the universe that I've created. Congratulations!

A by infernet89 2013-05-13T15:15:00

Extremely minimalist and interesting. I stopped in the Tetris level, the second one, because looks like a long run, comparing to the first level. Congrats!

Mustache Armies by TurboDindon 2013-05-13T15:10:00

Extremely well done and fun. I hope to see some twist in concept to fit better to the theme. Congrats!

Ginnungagap by kyyninen 2013-05-12T18:11:00

Great game. The mood is very interesting. Your game reminded me Slender. Congrats dude!

Life/Routine by lightnarcissus 2013-05-12T18:04:00

Fantastic concept. Extremely interesting the "level editor" and the inverted rhythm game. Cool idea. Congrats!

for science! by xandy 2013-05-11T00:38:00

Cool game. I like this type of mechanic, but it isn't innovative. The gravity is weird too. Congrats anyway!

Zephyr by joe40001 2013-05-11T00:34:00

Cool game. I tried to play the game by myself, but it was totally impossible. I needed to watch the tutorial with high attention to understand what's going on. I believe that the game concept is really good, but you need to simplify a lot the mechanic, because 4 minutes to explain your mechanic is too much. Congratulations anyway!

Less is More? by atraxgames 2013-05-11T00:29:00

Incredible game! It's a really intelligent concept, fitting perfectly to the theme. Congratulations a lot !!!

Drug Hunt by kill0u 2013-05-11T00:24:00

Fantastic concept and implementation. However is a hard game and complex to understand how to play. Congratulations anyway!

Skware by tankete 2013-05-08T22:07:00

Great puzzle! Fantastic idea and fun experience. It's hard to understand in the beginning, but after is addictive. Congrats!

Aduno by Justin Mullin 2013-05-08T21:54:00

Fantastic puzzle! Really innovative and fun. Congratulations!

Minianimalism! by lorancou 2013-05-08T21:42:00

Funny game. Great avatar editor, creating funny possibilities! Congrats!

Alien Raid by LTyrosine 2013-05-08T21:35:00

Great mood and music! I believe that the first enemies wave could be faster to increase the fun in the early experience. Congrats!

Dehoarder by SmilingCat 2013-05-08T21:27:00

Interestint! It's a punch when you play the game and realize that you are so attached to your things like this character. Nice job dude. Congrats!

Don't Hit The Core by TheSarcastic 2013-05-08T21:22:00

Great innovation! Simple mechanic and hard game. Nice job!

Controlled State by GameNacho 2013-05-08T21:19:00

Great game. It's really immersive, like you said. Congrats!

Paddlewhite by Dohan 2013-05-08T21:12:00

Cool game. Nice controls, graphics and mood. Well done and fun, but I think that it's fit the theme. Congrats anyway!

Bridge Crosser by zkenshin 2013-05-08T21:07:00

Funny game. It's really simple and fun. I believe that mouse could be avoided to simplify even more the controls. Congrats anyway!

Planes by phaze0 2013-05-08T21:04:00

Cool game. The purpose of an old school experience is interesting, but a better interface could improve the quality. Congrats anyway! Keep making games!

Save the potato! by loxo 2013-05-08T20:59:00

Cool idea. I liked the minimalist controls and hard level design. Good job. Keep making games!

OnlyOne by mrexcessive 2013-05-07T13:11:00

Intelligent puzzle and simple but innovative gameplay. Congrats!

Abduction - finally... by MartianWatts 2013-05-07T13:02:00

Nice game! Good vibe and fun gameplay. Even though the difficult in the beggining is very high, so I suggest to reduce it just to extend the early experience. Congratz anyway!!

MinimalisMan by Adipson 2013-05-06T17:08:00

Good game. Great art and mood. However the pacing is very low, with tons of texts and a loooong introduction. Congratz anyway!!

Hiddensquares by Tozy 2013-05-06T14:58:00

Fantastic game. Intelligent mechanic and really hard. I love puzzles, but I admit that your game destroyed a little my early engagement. The second level could be easier to keep maitaining my attention on the top! Congratz anyway!!

Cube Colors by PabloAlexandre31 2013-05-06T14:51:00

Very intelligent puzzle! It's a simple but deep game. I just believe that the difficult increased very fast and this can kick out your players. But the game has quality and this is really simple to adjust. Congratz!

Platonic Dot Solid by Prelucid 2013-05-06T14:42:00

Good game. The character is interesting, but physics and controls are weird. If you press the arrows with a normal force and jump, the character goes really far. Congratz anyway!

Erase by iterative deepening 2013-05-05T16:01:00

Fantastic game!! Really minimalist, fun and great art. Congratulations dude!!

S by rodrigomotta 2013-05-05T15:53:00

Beatiful game. Nice gameplay, very innovative and challenging. Maybe create some hints after few seconds could help players to improve the fun. Congratulations dude!

Block Runner by Flai 2013-05-05T15:43:00

Great runner. Interesting and simplistic solution to the theme. Congratz! Keep working dude

Minimal Force by Madball 2013-05-05T14:51:00

Nice game. Immersive story and challenging enemies. In my opinion to make a great platform game you need to invest a lot of time to polish the movement and I missed that on your game. Congratz anyway!

Pendulum by Yakka 2013-05-05T14:43:00

Hahahahaha. Funny solution, dude. It's a very simple game, but it's fun. Congratz!

U by KEFIR 2013-05-05T14:36:00

Awesome game! Fits very well to the theme and has a challenging level design. Congratz!

.Dot by sudojess 2013-05-04T02:58:00

Great music, art and mood, dude. It`s the kind of game that I like and I`ve really enjoyed your game. In my opinion the jump needs more polish to improve the experience, because sometimes the control is wierd. Congratz anyway!

Snobits by gmaker 2013-05-03T21:20:00

Cool game. Lost Vikings feelings!! Congratulations dude!

SquareRoot by Masadow 2013-05-03T21:18:00

Simple but fun. Cool game. Congratz!

Funky Lincoln Saves the Day by TheCze 2013-05-03T21:16:00

Awesome game! Typing mechanics are really funny and hard to master. Congratz!

Sociales Santillana by Ithildin 2013-05-03T21:13:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Bezier Challenge by Travis Irby 2013-05-03T21:08:00

Great game. Impressive solution to the theme. Congratulations!

Gods Will Be Watching by GreyShock 2013-05-03T21:03:00

Great game. Perfect mood and awesome story. Congratz!

Root Route! by netpro2k 2013-05-03T20:55:00

Cool game. Interesting game mechanic. Congratz!

Essense by Jorjon 2013-05-03T20:47:00

It's poetry. Beautiful game! Congratz!!

simpLify by SonnyBone 2013-05-03T20:41:00

Amazing game!!! Beautiful art, intelligent puzzles and a simple but deep story. The concept of minimalist music is perfect too. Congratulations a lot!!!

Fortuitous by Follett 2013-05-03T20:35:00

Very interesting game. Extremely hard, but very intelligent one. Congratz!!!

::.::::::. by rwos 2013-05-03T20:29:00

Incredible game! The visual effects are fucking awesome!! Congratulations!

Minirena by Sh1rogane 2013-05-03T20:25:00

Cool game. Extremely minimalist. Congratz!

Kitten's Pixel by MvT 2013-05-03T20:24:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Dual Perspective by SXPanda 2013-05-03T20:18:00

Fantastic game! Really intelligent solution for the theme. Congratz!!!

MOTHBOTS by terrivellmann 2013-05-03T20:13:00

Fucking awesome!! Excelent art and gameplay. Congratz!

cGame by deeJayUA 2013-05-03T20:09:00

Fantastic mechanic. Extremely intelligent and well done. Congratz!

Speedy Blocks by CptBubbles 2013-05-03T20:03:00

Very fun. In the beginning was really chaotic, but after some time is relaxing and addictive. Congratz!

Hot Potato! - A Multiplayer Potato Launcher Combat Game by LogiQ121 2013-05-03T19:52:00

Cool game. Casual and deep mechanic. Congratz!

Newborn by Lowlet 2013-05-03T19:48:00

Crazy universe!! Congratz!!!

IceBreaker by pentaphobe 2013-05-03T19:45:00

Good job. Interesting mood and mechanic. Congratz!

Minimalism - the shoot 'em up by CiderPunk 2013-05-03T19:43:00

Funny game! hahaha

Mondriaan by Corné Dorrestijn 2013-05-03T19:42:00

Nice job. Interesting mechanic. Congratz!

Molbert by JawbonedHero 2013-05-03T19:40:00

Great idea, art and puzzles. Congratz!

One fine morning our machines are gonna cut us down by netmute 2013-05-03T19:38:00

Interesting game. Congratz!

Digital H by winesays 2013-05-03T19:34:00

Very interesting mood and gameplay. Congratz!

Anti-Tac-Tic by Super Hamster 2013-05-03T19:28:00

Good idea. Congratz!

Tessitron by radmars 2013-05-03T19:25:00

Awesome game. Very well done and polished. Great work. Congratz!

<Title> by rukbotto 2013-05-03T19:22:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Braindead by damala 2013-05-03T19:19:00

Hahahaha. Nice try dude. Keep working to improve your skills!

Squares by bulle 2013-05-03T19:15:00

Interesting game. Extremely simple and intelligent. Congratz!

MiniCubizm by Sonic96PL 2013-05-03T19:03:00

Cool game dude. Congratz!

UNDRCOVR by 16Skittles 2013-05-03T19:01:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Minimalist Horror Story by MinionStudios 2013-05-03T18:58:00

Great mood and art! Congratz!!

Pieces by Husky 2013-05-03T18:51:00

Intelligent puzzle. Congratz!!

Canon by sparkleswirl 2013-05-03T18:46:00

Really nice game. Very immersive and perfectly fits to the theme. Congratz!

Tower of Pixel by AlanZucconi 2013-05-03T18:41:00

Great art and mood. Congratz!

Z Jumper by Zaelza 2013-05-03T18:36:00

Cool game. Interesting approach with the platforms. Congratz!

SeedLife by shawn42 2013-05-03T18:29:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Fjoxel by Pixelsalt 2013-05-03T18:15:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Quick Copy by koller-digital 2013-05-03T17:36:00

Perfectly fits to the theme. Extremely simple and intelligent. Congratz!

Towers of Rage by robotality 2013-05-03T17:29:00

Veeeery nice game. Extremely nostalgic. I tried to use kicks, but puncks is much more efficient, at least in the early stages. Congratz!!

Aaron and Alex by smilingrob 2013-05-03T17:23:00

Very interesting game. The part of typing remembers me the game "The Typing of the Dead". Congratz!

Vs. by KJScott 2013-05-03T16:56:00

Extremely abstract and interesting. Congratz!

Justice by nintendoeats 2013-05-03T16:51:00

Great mood! Really immersive game. Congratz!

Monoboy by jhrrsn 2013-05-03T16:45:00

Veeeeery interesting game! Great mood and challenging level design. Congratz!

Minimalistic PotatoPeople by goerp 2013-05-03T16:40:00

Cool game dude. Congratz!

Samus Regrets by Tifu 2013-05-03T16:29:00

Metroid feelings! The second enemy, that one looks like a brain is really hard. Congratz!

I don't wanna be an @ by ashdnazg 2013-05-03T15:41:00

Cool game dude. Congratz!

Bouncy Ball Extreme by Ray_Mickelino 2013-05-03T15:36:00

Cool game. Congratz!

Miximal by Cheshyr 2013-05-03T01:15:00

Good game. Congratz!

tequilaJumper by mort96 2013-05-03T01:09:00

Good idea. Congratz!

shon by bitnenfer 2013-05-03T01:06:00

Great game. Perfectly fits the theme. Congratz!

BEAPE by Xgor 2013-05-03T01:02:00

Cool game. Congratz!

RedShot by Jellycakes 2013-05-03T00:43:00

Cool game. Congratz!

'moeba by Oliver Simon 2013-05-02T21:27:00

Interesting mechanic, really minimalist concept, but the controls are weird.

Mini Pirates! by josefnpat 2013-05-02T21:24:00

Unique game for 2013. Congratz!

MIN by s0ulcrusher 2013-05-02T21:22:00

Good job. Incredible universe!!!

The Call by fullmontis 2013-05-02T21:17:00

Deep concept. Congratz!

Moonshine by TravisChen 2013-05-02T21:14:00

Awesome art!!! Congratz!!

XYZ by ataxkt 2013-05-02T21:11:00

Fantastic puzzle! Congratz!!!

Join by Perry 2013-05-02T21:07:00

Very simple, but really interesting. Congratz!

Hipster Annihilator 9000 by deige101 2013-05-02T21:05:00

Funny game.

WhiteSpace by argo15 2013-05-02T21:00:00

Great mechanic. Crazy universe that you have created.

Pixemalism by boddiul 2013-05-02T20:58:00

Good job!

Steam-Cube by Monoquartz 2013-05-02T20:54:00

Good job.

Brutaliz'Art LD26 by lotusgame 2013-05-02T20:51:00

Funny game :)

Random Legend Adventure by Captain_Genial 2013-05-02T20:48:00

Kid Chamaleon feelings!!! Great game :D

Angry Viking vs Minimalist Hipsters by reverso13 2013-05-02T20:44:00

HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA... I understand you dude. I know a lot of Minimalist Hipsters. Congratz!

AlterSpace by guestcheap 2013-05-02T20:41:00

Very intellinge approach. Congratz!

The Vale by Tyro 2013-05-02T20:34:00

Great work. Universe really deep. I love it. Congratz!

_M_ by GranaDa 2013-05-02T20:29:00

Impressive quality. Extremely immersive. Congratz!

Wandering Darkness by Graham Weldon 2013-05-02T20:21:00

Great game! Fits perfectly to the theme. Congratz!

Dungeon Struggle by Thijsku 2013-05-02T20:03:00

Cool game. I missed the option to attack walking backwards. Congratz!

The Despicable Caverns of Deadly Doom by BumpkinRich 2013-05-02T19:58:00

Great mood. Sounds to me like one great Atari game :) Congratz!

Illuminion by Qaterknan 2013-05-02T19:55:00

Inteliggent puzzle. Very interesting. Congratz!

Balls Balls Balls by matthias_zarzecki 2013-05-02T19:51:00

Awesome game. The mechanic is very intelligent. Congratz!

Ming Imah Lism the Wizard ! by Gustera 2013-05-02T19:45:00

Cool game. Congratz!

PRISMA by Dark Acre Jack 2013-05-02T19:42:00

Great game dude! The mood is incredible! :D

You Must Escape by GertJohnny 2013-05-02T19:36:00

Fantastic game. Congratulations!!!

MinimalJump by Xatulu 2013-05-02T19:29:00

Cool game dude. Congratz!

DudeJump by agnulf 2013-05-02T19:25:00

Cool game. The running cycle is REALLY good :D

Between the lines by martijn 2013-05-02T19:22:00

Fucking awesome concept. Congratz!

Distradiction by shines 2013-05-02T19:13:00

Cool game. Congratz!

True treasure of Kartoffelschloss by mortus 2013-05-02T19:10:00

Good game. Awesome art! Congratz!

Mondrian Click by CherryNukaCola 2013-05-02T19:01:00

Good game. Extremely minimalist :)

Steve Can't Zen by DaanVanYperen 2013-05-02T18:57:00

Fun and funny game. I finished it. Congratz!

hru by gilmore606 2013-05-02T18:01:00

Fantastic game! I enjoyed a lot. You've reached an interesting curve of challenging. Congratz!

Chez Angelo by EdoMiyamoto 2013-05-02T17:53:00

Awesome vibe. Congratz!

Earth Defender by Hellequin 2013-05-02T17:26:00

Cool game. Congratz!

The Road by GeorgeBroussard 2013-05-02T17:23:00

Cool game. The concept is very deep. It's very hard too.

Beyond Minimalism by SaintHeiser 2013-05-02T17:06:00

Great game. Immersive universe.

IN MALI SOMMI by Capro 2013-05-01T22:24:00

Cool game.

DeaN by Sakuyan 2013-05-01T22:21:00

Awesome game. The art is fantastic and the reverse concept of death is interesting.

Dwalk by Joritan Cety 2013-05-01T22:16:00

Cool game.

INO by Nikich 2013-05-01T22:06:00

Interesting game, but extremely hard.

Minimal Theory by ENP 2013-05-01T22:01:00

Great game. Very interesting but don't fit with the theme so well.

L'Hypnose by Wan 2013-05-01T21:46:00

Good game. More Art than game, actually :)

Minimal Leapings by ben657 2013-05-01T21:39:00

Potato!! :)

Y.A.H.G (G for Game) by EggDestroyer 2013-05-01T21:35:00

Interesting concept.

Triangles by DaGamesta 2013-05-01T21:33:00

Good game. Very hard and quite complicated to understand the mechanic.

Random Objects Smash by Moist 2013-05-01T21:28:00

Cool game!

LOWBAT by Foxtacy 2013-04-30T16:22:00

Fun game!

Minimum Friction by pvwradtke 2013-04-30T16:18:00

Cool game. Interesting and hard mechanic. Congratz!

Flowf Against the Potatoes by katsumottojp 2013-04-30T15:00:00

Really funny game! The love of little brother for the player is touching.

Ragdoll Fly by FaBrito 2013-04-30T14:54:00

Very fun and funny game. The Goofy scream is awesome, lol. Congratz!

Formless Reliquary by PsenFilip 2013-04-30T14:48:00

Awesome game! Very well implemented and addictive. Congratz!

Square Swarm by santovirus 2013-04-30T14:34:00

Hey dude! I didn't understand how to play, or the game concept is exactly see the square storm?

RED by Tiago 2013-04-29T22:45:00

Great game! The mood is really interesting!!

QbQbQb by rezoner 2013-04-29T22:38:00

Very very nice! Addictive and very well polished. Congratz!

CHAMELEON RUN by Split82 2013-04-29T22:27:00

Fantastic game. One of the best entries! Congratz!!

Don't Fart by Galvesmash 2013-04-29T21:24:00

hahahaha... Crazy and funny idea!

TNAFT by Mysterarts 2013-04-29T20:57:00

Great concept!

Bounce me by Norritt42 2013-04-29T20:54:00

Nice game! Really challenging and fun. Congratz!

llab by tonic 2013-04-29T20:50:00

Great game!! Very innovative and addictive :)
I believe that a well done bouncing ball could help to solve some challenges.

Love Connection by Jon Reid 2013-04-29T20:34:00

Great game. Well done!

Super Clutter Blaster 2013 by Homletmoo 2013-04-29T20:28:00

Good game. Really fun!

the pretentious apple by Bluebutton 2013-04-29T20:26:00

Great gameplay.

The Only String by Tuba 2013-04-29T20:21:00

Good and funny game.

Too Many Items by jtzp4 2013-04-29T20:16:00

Funny idea.

Less qq, more pew-pew by MauMaGau 2013-04-29T20:11:00

Good idea.

BatWorld by Farjuan 2013-04-29T20:09:00

Very interesting and innovative!

ToyMech by dasrkrain 2013-04-29T20:04:00

Interesting mechanic, but controls are wierd (maybe becayse I played with Chrome).

Super MiniMan by Alink 2013-04-29T19:56:00

Hard controls, but nice mood.

Ghost Garden by ceMelusine 2013-04-29T19:54:00

Good game. Very immersive. You have created a crazy universe!

ShrunkenAdventures by FuzzyWuzzie 2013-04-29T19:45:00

Good game. Very simple, but elegant. A great example where silence works better than background music.

5 Days On 2 Days Off by BradleySmith 2013-04-29T19:37:00

Great work. The universe that you created is very immersive. Congratz!

(Follow the) Line by Chman 2013-04-29T19:33:00

Awesome game. Extremely addictive!! :)

Pixel Pusher by igrowbeards 2013-04-29T19:29:00

Great game. Very innovative and hard. Good job.

Return Home by Manuel777 2013-04-29T19:23:00

Nice game and great art! The kind of game that fits better on mobile devices.

KeepTheMusicAlive by iamorim 2013-04-29T19:16:00

Nice game. Very innovative. I suggest to highlight more the volume on HUD to see easily when you are with volume 1.

Minimun Life by AlanBazan 2013-04-29T19:02:00

Very nice game. The message is really deep and it totally rocked the theme. Good job!

Lone Blade by Floko 2013-04-29T17:56:00

Great game. The use of the theme is perfect and the game progress is fun with different weapons. Congratz!

Path by apenasisso 2013-04-29T17:51:00

Awesome game! I believe that controls needs some improvements but it's really fun, because is hard and challenging. Good job!

My Peculiar Car by brantkings 2013-04-29T17:44:00

Very nice game! It's really hard to learn the best way to drive this car. And the sax makes no sense but it's fun. Congratz!!

A fish called Revenge by Tiago Ling Alexandre 2013-04-29T17:30:00

Fun game. I didn't find the boss even searching deeply the level. Besides of that the mood of game is nice.

Overly Detailed Stickman by ttakamoto 2013-04-29T17:09:00

Funny game. The kind of game that you begin serious and is impossible don't smile.

Shp Shft Mz by rzfmzn 2013-04-29T17:03:00

Good game! The core mechanic is interesting and challenging. In my point of view, the bugs are critical because my experience could be much better with a stable game.