andrio 2013-04-29 08:27
Interesting concept!
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD26 → Ginnungagap
By kyyninen
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 1 | 100 | ||
| Humor | 306 | 2.64 | ||
| Mood | 443 | 3.03 | ||
| Graphics | 515 | 3.08 | ||
| Innovation | 573 | 3.11 | ||
| Overall | 674 | 3.06 | ||
| Fun | 700 | 2.82 | ||
| Audio | 950 | 1.98 | ||
| Theme | 1231 | 2.63 |
Interesting concept!
Nice.
Hunger was far too little of a threat however, as my health seemed to go up all the time from eating the gun-men or children. In fact, the gun guys were more helpful than a hiderance. They hit me once in total I think, but as they (like the children) couldn't escape to hoses, they were easy food. Ended up just quitting, because I couldn't see that it would ever end (day 12 or so)
Solid game, good use of day night cycle
This is a really interesting concept! Though the gunmen weren't really enough of a threat.
idk why but i find the idea funny lol. seems liek an anti survival game
wow. Really fun and cool idea!
Thanks for the comments!
re: hunger & health
Few hours before submitting I was thinking about removing health generation from eating. You would get 1 health when hunger meter empties at the dawn, no more. Decided against it, since I had no real gauge how difficult the game would be to someone else. I'll make it so in next version.
re: gunmen
I went back and forth on gunmen generation frequency. Now it's set to sparse since my room mate seemed to have major problems against them! Admittedly he was drunk at the time. Maybe larger quantity and removal of the healing during day would make them a bigger threat?
That's original !
I kept eating.
Nice concept ! I love the visuals, "handmade style".
awww. i'm on a mac :(
looks good! i like it )
Gameplay is really fun. Great work!
Great idea! That's a new type of gameplay. I like it a lot, it was fun to play :)
Thanks for comments everyone! I'm working on making the game more challenging based on feedback. Here's a test build for those interested: http://bit.ly/17v9aY6 It's not thoroughly playtested yet, so there might be lots of odd stuff happening!
For some reasons I just meet one hunter at the beginning then nothing. The game lack a clear goal but the feeling of being a monster lurking in the wood is pretty well done.
Oooooh, I like the test build! :D
Perfect concept, this is great!
NOM NOM NOM
Cool visuals and concept. I'll be honest, I had no idea what I was doing or what the icons represented!
DIE HUMANS!
interesting concept but for win you just need to wait in the map center
I didn't really understand what the goal of the game was nor what the meters in the corner meant.
But I really liked hunting down the humans when they shot at me.
I played for quite a while until I finally died after eating a grey person, I'm guessing they are bad for you?
Good job! :)
Very interesting concept.
Thanks for comments! Keep 'em coming!
re: lack of instructions
I'm torn on this subject. Personally I would prefer not to have any kind of written text as a part of the game proper, but some sort of tutorial screen is clearly needed, at least so far as to instruct what UI elements mean! I'll have to think on this. Changed entry description to offer at least some advice.
re: lack of goal
Currently the only goal of the game is to survive as long as possible. Death is the only ending state. The post-compo version features a scoring system that should give some motivation to try to survive longer. My personal high score is 4770 :)
I like the feeling of this one. The graphics were simple, but the story was good.
Cool idea to play as the monster. I'd have loved if people would scream and run away from us when we got near them :).
Very cool concept, I like the art and graphic, well done ;)
Hm, interesting. I'd like to see what the game screen looks like in the endgame... Where you're totally surrounded by huts and your hunger is almost impossible to satisfy, and you're running out of forest etc.
Nice graphics and game, really like it :) it was fun to eat people who harm forests :D
Does not work under Linux using Wine, like all GameMaker games.. The loading bar shows, but the screens stays white then.
Somehow I find it creepy. All these strange dark windy woods end these pale colors, and you just trying to find some human to eat. With some music it could be so strange. The atmosphere is very refreshing. Good mood :)
Very good game, with intresting concept, I had fun playing it !
Thanks for comments and encouragements everyone! They really mean a lot to me :)
re: sounds
I was planning on adding more effects and atmospheric sounds but time ran out! I'll see about adding some sort of gasping sound for panicking villagers and wind-loop for next version, maybe some sounds specific to time of day? Music is a bit outside of my skill set I'm afraid.
@kddekadenz & finefin
Sorry about that :( I tried to import the project to the free version of Game Maker Studio for cross platform support but it lost half the objects on the way. Maybe down the line, when I have better grasp on this programming stuff.
@Argembarger
I'd love to see that as well! Free MYSTERY STEAM GIFT (which might or might not be Psychonauts) to the first who provides screenshot with no trees and plenty of huts?
I thoroughly enjoyed the mood and theme of the game.
The simulation aspects are well conceived as well.
Also the sounds, while rudimentary, gave a distinct feeling of futility. Wood chopping everywhere! Pesky humans.
Really original game and nice gfx :) The game should have utilized sneaking a bit more, now it is mostly just constant running around but still very good.
Very original and overall a great game I must say! Every day in the game feels like a small story of how the poor guardian tries to stop the invasion of people into the forest, just to find out they have built more houses on the other side of the forest. The controls and graphics felt polished, only thing missing is an ambient soundtrack.
Very nice game, and an impressive concept. I can easily see that concept evolve into something great :)
I enjoyed playing this a lot
nice concept
very well done :D
Thank you, kind strangers! For the next version I'm adding audio and trying couple of things to make stealth-based approach more viable. Here's a test build: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0BylyOE6bMNbFNlJfU2FkYnFGWVU/edit?usp=sharing Again, highly experimental, probably unstable as well! (ps. try moving very slowly)
The game doesn't pose much of a challenge unless far later in the game the humans breed like rabbits and take over.
The idea of the game has potential. Try expanding it.
The game's somewhat confusing, made worse by the view moving up and down following the mouse. The forest was so scarcely populated that I didn't have much to do for most of my playtime. And then, I ate a blue-headed guy and my health went actually down for no apparent (or explained) reason.
The graphics are cool, and I especially liked the sort of washed-out look of the overlay. Also, the overall game's design is quite fitting of the theme.
I just feels this game needs to better express what the player's supposed to be doing (and there's no need for any intrusive exposition or tutorial; just a more thorough design of the game's elements), and to keep you busy instead of having you just strolling through the forest with nothing to do.
A promising game to follow.
Thanks for constructive feedback!
@wademcgillis
Yeah, the compo version is pretty unbalanced in favour of player. Currently I'm working on making most of the game variables adjustable through ini-file. That should allow for rapid iteration to find that sweet spot in challenge curve.
@TenTonToon (and @Jesper Oskarsson)
Pale apparitions are ghosts that generate when villagers are sufficiently terrified of woods. I originally implemented them to give hunters something to hunt for in addition of player, and also to give player some encouragement to not go full speed ahead all the time. In post-compo version I made them appear more ghastly (glow everywhere!), but they remain still pretty unintuitive. I should rethink their generation and purpose, or at least make them only appear at night.
I originally hoped to teach game concepts through gameplay, but well, yeah :( Current tutorial in the post-compo version is hopefully pretty unintrusive, it shows few tooltips on the screen and lasts for about 10 sec. Still aiming for teaching through design, but it's going to take some time.
I'm definitely still honing the overall design of the game, and it's a real boon to have this many people comment on what works in the game and what doesn't. For that, I'm deeply grateful :)
Great game. The mood is very interesting. Your game reminded me Slender. Congrats dude!
Well-executed game from an interesting idea. I kinda liked the visuals -- a little eerie strangely to me.
I thought this was too easy but I like the concept, i really like games where you're a powerful monster and eat humans, nice job!
I really like the color palette you chose, and the idea of being a great big scary monster running around in the woods eating people.
brilliant -- i really like the concept of the game -- nice job
Omnomnom! Tasty game!
I like the graphics and what an interesting setting and character. At first I thought it would be cool if the people started settling in other areas, then they did. Loved that!