We couldn't get four controllers to work at once, so we had to have keyboard and gamepad players. One of the gamepad players couldn't get the character to rotate at will, as the character would only rotate sometimes.
You should definately find a sound designer, as the game could really use some sound, it would definately improve the response to game elements and would sharpen the humor.
Rotation is a bit too slow for the forward movement, and up and down felt like should change your speed but didn't do a thing.
Though it adds to the competition the color icon around the holes look a bit weird.
Graphics are really good, though the characters could use some animations, like leaning to where they're turning, give them a silly walk, or something.
It feels like this would be a really great game if you further developed it. Keep at it, good job!