Last Stand by KeyurRana 2019-05-04T15:47:54Z ♥ 2
The game is clear (kudos for the detailed tutorial) and the mechanics are solid !
The sound effects are pretty good and since this is a jam game you could have added some royalty free music, music is always a great addition to a game.
The graphics are simple and functional, however maybe something a little less clean but more personal could have given a bit more character to the game.
While playing I felt like something was missing but I still can't figure exactly what. Maybe a bit more personality or craziness (more bombastic effects perhaps ?). Well that's just my personal appreciation though, I like when I can sense the creator(s) behind a game.
Anyway the game works well, it's pretty polished and you had time to fit in quite a lot (such as the helpful tutorial and UI), good job !
LD45 — Start with nothing (8)
adventure again by gamefive 2019-10-20T11:05:49Z ♥ 1
Pretty cool game, short and simple which I clearly prefer that to long and frustrating. The controls work well and the platforming is satisfying.
The graphic have a certain charm too, but doing them on paper and taking a photo of them after causes a little lack of cohesiveness. For instance the paper doesn't always have the same color and the junction between different sprites can be a bit jarring. The blue background isn't very paper-y either, perhaps a texture like this http://img.hisupplier.com/var/userImages/2008-11/20/glpaper$004445729(s).jpg might have worked better. Anyways that's mostly nitpicks but a potential lead for improvement next time.
Good job !
PIPO THE GHOST by woody_builder 2019-10-19T10:23:40Z ♥ 1
The gameplay is really solid and it's cool you had time for the tutorials ! The music could he a bit louder I thought there wasn't any at the beginning. Some sound effects could have been a nice addition too. Overall it's a pretty impressive game for a jam, good job !
!Another Chance by aleksandar2901 2019-10-19T10:11:27Z ♥ 0
Cool game ! The music was nice (especially when turning into the devil theme), it did get a bit repetitive when retrying the game a few time to see the different outcomes though. Speaking of which it would have been nice to have a skip button, it got a bit boring to go through the intro four times in a row. It would also have been cool if there were a bit more variation for the different outcomes but I guess you didn't have time for more. Good job !
Out of the Box by Mr.MadCat 2019-10-19T09:53:22Z ♥ 0
I made it in 22 death. Really cool game ! The graphics are simple but work pretty well and the animations were a nice touch. The music is pretty nice and fitting too.
A few nitpicks : * The jump sound effect is really weird and kind of breaks the immersion. * Putting attack on control is a bit of a weird choice in my opininion (at least on my macbook pro's keyboard layout it wasn't very ergonomic). * Lastly the spike collisions could be a bit more forgiving I think.
I think the game could also use a bit more juice (I highly advise both these videos if you haven't watched them yet) https://youtu.be/Fy0aCDmgnxg https://youtu.be/AJdEqssNZ-U
The platforming is pretty solid and it was cool you had time to fit a boss battle in there. Good job !
POLYMON by PIXAMENTORY 2019-10-19T09:38:53Z ♥ 0
The music is really great ! The controls are a bit weird but after some practice and using a coward / last hit strategy the game became pretty fun, good job !
Rubber Duck Genesis by Rayne 2019-10-19T09:31:22Z ♥ 1
Cool visual effects (especially the intro) !
Bumpkin's Spooky Adventure by BrotherBondProduction 2019-10-19T09:24:47Z ♥ 0
The respawn / upgrade system is cool ! The game could be a bit more intuitive. At the beginning I didn't understand why clicking didn't shoot anything and I guess there's a health timer but it isn't very clear at the beginning when you lose HP for what appears to be no reason.
Lucifer's Rise by hydrate 2019-10-16T08:07:49Z ♥ 0
The graphics are nice, especially the main character, although at times they seem to lack a bit of cohesiveness (the player has an outline but the animals and the platforms don’t for instance). Audio-wise the music is good but the sfx is a bit jarring.
As pointed out in the comments before me the input layout is a bit confusing.
Overall I think this games falls in a common jam pitfall, which is being too long and too punishing. Most people rating jam games are doing several in a row which doesn’t necessarily make them the most patient, especially when the game feels frustrating. After playing a few minutes of the game you realize it’s going to take a while to get to a 1000 coins. Moreover when after buying a lot of items in order not to lose money when hit by mobs, you get killed precisely because you didn’t have money, you really don’t feel like retrying.
My general advice for jam games would be to try to make short games that don’t throw up too much roadblocks to the players trying to finish them. Making challenging games is risky, particularly when they depend on tight controls, a feat pretty hard to nail in the span of two/three days.
I hope it doesn’t come off as me trying to bash the game, I just believe that honest feedback and pointers on how to potentially improve are the most useful in the long run. It’s still a nice game, and you can be proud of yourselves for finishing it !