Hello, you asked for me to give your game similar feedback as you did mine, so here I am!
First of all, I think the game concept is really cool. The idea of making a boat that's continually sinking and you have to keep adding new structures on top of the boat to keep it above the water, creating this comical ship that's mostly below water. The art style fits the game perfectly, and the waves specifically look really good.
But I think the main reasons the game didn't do as well is the following:
1. There was a huge visual bug with the hulls breaking and filling with water. Most of the time it wouldn't even display anything except for the *very* subtle sprite change which isn't very noticeable. It's a good system when it works (usually works consistently after surviving for a while for some reason), but with the bug I didn't even know the hulls were breaking until I turned on the debug info.
2. The components need a lot of balancing. The castle component hurts more than it helps and hulls take so long to sink that you don't really need anything but a couple fans to go as far as you want if you keep fixing the hulls (so stacking components to stay above water level just makes the ship sink faster).
3. The audio could've had a bit more to it. The audio was definitely good, but I think more people would've rated it higher if the sound effects had been more prominent (something like boiler sounds and a loud metal sound when stuff breaks).
4. The graphics could've been more dynamic. I personally think the graphics were great, but I think a lot of people would've rated it even higher if there had been more distinct animations for when stuff breaks, or if there was just more complicated, impressive-looking stuff going on.
That's all I have, I think the game was really good, and the biggest issue was just the visual glitch I mentioned earlier.
I am good.png