Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → Phillip Scott

Phillip Scott

Feedback comments for LD52

← LD51   LD54 →

Phillip Scott's games and stats for all events →

TimestampSince previousGamePhillip Scott's comment
Jan 9 20:59:21 Leviticus ♥ 1 Couldn't figure out the controls, clicked the seeds but they disappeared, Cute art though!
Jan 9 21:08:45 9m 24s Grave Harvest ♥ 8 Nice liked the art, good game feel too! image_2023-01-09_210843585.png
Jan 9 21:17:22 8m 37s Boar'd'Hell ♥ 1 Oh wow Great fun! really well done! image_2023-01-09_211719143.png
Jan 9 21:22:32 5m 10s Harvest Harvest Crush ♥ 1 Tricky but fun - hard to multi task :D
Jan 9 21:28:22 5m 50s Wheat Master ♥ 1 Super Chill game - as soon as I saw it was a clicker I was like YAY! but then it went all zen, really enjoyed this one! well done :)
Jan 9 21:35:40 7m 18s Harvesting Hustle ♥ 1 Super Cure graphics - needed the comment section to figure out what I was meant to do :D good job!
Jan 9 21:43:09 7m 29s MegaBurgers ♥ 1 Poor cows :) fun little game I like the tractors :D
Jan 9 21:46:23 3m 14s Hamburger Harvest ♥ 1 I like making the "aaaaaaaah" noise at the end when my dream burger is made :D that was fun!
Jan 9 22:20:10 33m 47s Pointless Harvest ♥ 2 Fun little repetitive and the bigger tractors seem to take a while, but it is so satisfying, had a small issue not able to like an egg to get my golars but really fun overall!
Jan 9 22:29:08 8m 58s Island Survivor ♥ 1 This was fun, sounds was funny vampire survival vibes image_2023-01-09_222905973.png
Jan 9 22:34:04 4m 56s Harvest Rush ♥ 3 Had some fun with though one - the crops respawning gave me a little jump scare though (little loud :)) image_2023-01-09_223335511.png Fun and simple - thought for a second that I had to replant them with the tools
Jan 9 22:39:21 5m 17s Monkey Business ♥ 1 Nice entry, I kept trying to feed the monkey its own poop 10/10 🆔 image_2023-01-09_223920064.png
Jan 9 22:51:50 12m 29s Harvest Puzzle Box ♥ 3 Ah I liked this good job! would like more control over the cube though this scene at the end is nice - I would point a screen shot for spoilers
Jan 9 23:02:13 10m 23s Astral Aberration ♥ 1 No idea what is going on - but I think I am having fun 😄 went to board a spiderish looking thing and game crashed 😢 image_2023-01-09_230212684.png
Jan 9 23:12:31 10m 18s No Harvest ♥ 3 Good entry! Polished and fun, liked the art - kept raging at the lightening as it is a bad shape 😄 image_2023-01-09_231230632.png
Jan 9 23:38:47 26m 16s Forked Up ♥ 1 great amount of content and like that it gradually unlocks - gets a little repetitive (especially when you get juggled on top of an enemy and insta die!) well done!
Jan 10 00:10:21 31m 34s Brains ♥ 1 Got Stuck on level 3 had to watch the play through for that part (thanks!) other level sometime got completed by accident - really cool concept like the move to the beat element
Jan 10 00:16:59 6m 38s TanksGiving ♥ 1 Fun and chill - think I was doing too well, it crashed 😢 image_2023-01-10_001656352.png
Jan 10 00:27:05 10m 06s Calorie Crunch ♥ 3 Nice entry - no idea how to make half of the things so resorted to feeding my new friend toxic waste well done image_2023-01-10_002704133.png
Jan 10 00:31:34 4m 29s Hey Day ♥ 0 Oh no! I harvested too hard 🙈 image_2023-01-10_003131749.png
Jan 10 10:28:27 9h 56m Gun Harvester ♥ 1 Fun game - seed selection on the screen might be better but I found I can change seeds in the shop but I was mainly just buying lilacs this is what happen when I bought lots of roses 😆 image_2023-01-10_102824169.png
Jan 10 10:36:34 8m 07s Little Eden ♥ 3 Looks and plays well, great amount of polish - had some weird screen size issues. Would have liked to expand the farm with some kind of pickup or something. Maybe need to balance feeding people and use as ammo would be a fun concept. Well Done!
Jan 10 10:53:18 16m 44s Powered Plants ♥ 2 This was great really addictive, only small gripe is that you can death spiral quickly. Great Entry! image_2023-01-10_105315745.png
Jan 10 11:08:40 15m 22s Agricultural Ascension ♥ 4 Really amazing, puzzles can get head scratchingly great. love the look of the game too, could see this as a great mobile game well done!
Jan 10 11:29:04 20m 24s Red Harvester ♥ 2 Nice Entry -felt like Wall-E meats Matt Damon 😄 addictive, Just could not keep up with the energy image_2023-01-10_112901991.png
Jan 10 11:54:55 25m 51s Fields of Fire ♥ 3 Decent tower defence game, a little easy once you get into it and the was are a very LONG! Art was nice enough, UI could have used a little more polish but all round decent entry! Game was a little overwhelming at first - the restart bugged the game and needed to refresh the browser also if you do not click start at first you start with lots of plants to harvest 😄 I am annoyed that my 300k veggies was not in the screen shot Good job image_2023-01-10_115258467.png
Jan 10 12:05:06 10m 11s Buzzkill ♥ 2 Solid Entry, the units deselecting after a command was given was a little annoying, I was not expecting how crazy the fights would look and feel great job image_2023-01-10_120503309.png
Jan 10 12:13:10 8m 04s Orbital Oranges ♥ 1 Looks really nice, shame about running out of time
Jan 10 12:18:46 5m 36s Crop Circle ♥ 0 This was really great! art, sounds the idea all solid very well done! image_2023-01-10_121843466.png
Jan 10 12:30:55 12m 09s Dream Reaper ♥ 3 Nice Entry liked the art and sound as others have noted the movement gets a little tiring especially if you die and need to go through the whole level again. Level design was nice too Well done
Jan 10 12:45:55 15m 00s Scythe of Souls ♥ 1 nice job for such a small time - I would have cut the costs by a ton and spawned more ghosts, would have made it more frantic and allowed more people to see your upgrades
Jan 10 12:58:27 12m 32s Harvest all Humans! ♥ 2 Combat, graphics and sound were all great, 30 was a lot though as the harvesting was very slow
Jan 10 13:17:38 19m 11s 9CELL ♥ 2 Wow so dark, I could not keep up with my family demands image_2023-01-10_131735754.png
Jan 10 13:23:33 5m 55s Slim Pickings ♥ 2 So many particles 😄 well done feels nice and well polished image_2023-01-10_132330821.png
Jan 10 13:50:23 26m 50s Petra Rabbit's Carrot Chase ♥ 2 funny, simple and cute - want to rotate the camera up and down though
Jan 10 15:00:21 1h 09m Poppy Defense ♥ 2 Fantastic I just played this for the longest I have played any game this jam so far - I love the proc gen if you go back to the menu. Only thing I would add is a bestiary to understand enemies weaknesses etc Great job! image_2023-01-10_150017418.png
Jan 10 15:11:10 10m 49s Bewitched Boomerang ♥ 4 looks great, liked the variety of the different plants, want a little more time before they rot. image_2023-01-10_151107067.png
Jan 10 15:23:39 12m 29s Shroomer Caves ♥ 2 Really fun - can see this becoming a full game different veggies etc image_2023-01-10_152326694.png
Jan 10 15:54:38 30m 59s Veggie Voyager ♥ 3 Hah this was funny the controller was surprisingly robust great job, the spinning UFOs raged me though 😆 One thing I might suggest would be to make the character a different color to the ground, found myself squinting a little
Jan 10 15:59:44 5m 06s Techno Plants ♥ 3 Love the tunes, I could not find the tempo - might be my keyboard or something. Like Im pressing on the beat but maybe only move 1 in 10
Jan 10 16:08:28 8m 44s Betty Raba - Don't Be Harvested ♥ 3 Game looks fantastic, music is great and fitting. the hit box on the blades is a bit rough - I would also like some feedback when I get hit. as others have said the controller is a little slippery great job
Jan 10 16:23:11 14m 43s Combine Harv-racer ♥ 1 This is great, how did you do the wheat are they tiles or individual sprites with colliders?? Those cows, first time I hit one I laughed out loud! Great job! image_2023-01-10_162308215.png
Jan 10 16:29:31 6m 20s The Crystallographer ♥ 1 Super addictive and loved the look and feel would be nice to strategize to decide which gem to buy Great job ❤️ image_2023-01-10_162917883.png
Jan 10 16:39:36 10m 05s Karmavrest ♥ 1 Great looking and an impressive amount of story the ying yang mechanic was really interesting too ❤️ Great job!
Jan 10 17:29:50 50m 14s Noxious Harvest ♥ 1 Movement aside, the texturing and look of the machine is great - some of the puzzles were a little telegraphed and I really want to hear the steam and clanks from this monstrous machine but overall great job! image_2023-01-10_172948220.png
Jan 10 17:52:17 22m 27s Harvest Dune ♥ 4 I liked this entry planning turrets and learning the map was quite fun the sand worm looked great (the screen shake was a little crazy :)) and I liked the tense feeling of will I make it or not! Art and sounds were or point too. Great Job image_2023-01-10_175215054.png
Jan 10 17:59:40 7m 23s Click On Fish ♥ 1 Voice lines were funny - I clicked the fish
Jan 10 18:11:00 11m 20s Body Harvest! ♥ 1 nice idea - the monster likes cheeseburgers, I approve of this monster
Jan 10 18:16:44 5m 44s Death In Time ♥ 1 Fun idea and execution I was stalking Gus for a while before I harvested him 😆
Jan 10 18:21:40 4m 56s The Harvester ♥ 0 keep trying to play this like a turn based game and getting annoyed 😄 the art, sounds and mood of the game are good but its hard to play it in real time for me
Jan 10 19:15:59 54m 19s Lavender Fields Forever ♥ 2 Best game of the jam for me so far - funny, thoughtful and interesting, cute animals, like the shooting and I HATE THE GNOMES! Found a few instances of them running through my walls - what advanced technology do they POSSESS! Great entry - make this more please!
Jan 10 19:27:23 11m 24s Money grows on trees ♥ 2 BANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAN!!!!! Lovely art and addictive clicker! I had over 185k at the end Fun game!opera_myyc9fm82n.jpg
Jan 10 19:39:57 12m 34s Crop Drop ♥ 2 So chill, had same issues with the game not completing on level 2 or 3. like the possibilities that your game has well done!
Jan 10 20:05:30 25m 33s Carrot Jack ♥ 1 Great amounts of polish and really cute graphics - took me a while to understand that it wasn't turn based 😄 Well done
Jan 10 20:24:12 18m 42s Tony Crow's Pro Scyther ♥ 4 Wow This is simply amazing! great game and super fun I would love to see more levels and tricks! The voice acting was hilarious! Controls we great and the flips after each element made it feel great! Seriously well done! image_2023-01-10_202409756.png
Jan 10 21:11:03 46m 51s Boat ♥ 1 super chill and nice game really enjoyed my time with it - simple art but effective Followed around Father boat to see what it did at the end was amused that he ends up at the heart spinning on the spot 😆 image_2023-01-10_211058535.png
Jan 10 21:50:31 39m 28s Infernal Garden ♥ 1 Fun game, so much polish! felt like the seeds were a little rare but that's probably preference like the art and sounds Gameplay wise I think it could have used a dash or something image_2023-01-10_215028518.png
Jan 10 21:59:16 8m 45s Martian Mind Hunter ♥ 2 Everyone is shooting and there is goop everywhere, fun game the LODs on zone is a nice touch. Hard to understand everything that is going on and game is very unforgiving 😆 Well done! image_2023-01-10_215915428.png
Jan 10 22:41:45 42m 29s Grow Golf ♥ 2 Wow super clever game, well rounded and polished the screen edges prevent some power being used but other than that it was very intuitive - can see myself coming back to this one - make it work on mobile? 🙏 Well done!
Jan 10 22:59:30 17m 45s Human Harvest ♥ 3 Great game, a small explanation of what each upgrade did would be nice but the art, sounds and game play are all great. good level of polish. Enjoyed understand that my ship was getting "heavy" too (at least to looked like it did) great job!
Jan 10 23:07:59 8m 29s Afterlife Assistance Agency ♥ 2 @procrasteroid is right the characters look like guess who people. Funny game - I had one person that was off screen for 10 seconds! was mildly panicking that I could not see them and the casually walked down.
Jan 10 23:18:46 10m 47s Farmtown Mowdown ♥ 1 I swear they always spawn behind me.... old school graphics were amazing! sounds good... AK esk gun - crappy compared to my shotty ❤️ was fun! really well done!
Jan 10 23:26:35 7m 49s Scarecrow Attack ♥ 2 hah punching crows! I wanted more crows, maybe some feather and screeching - maybe I have a problem.... was fun thanks for making! image_2023-01-10_232633668.png
Jan 11 00:01:31 34m 56s Click Click Farm ♥ 2 Wow this is great - I was going to come and ask you to add some kind of brush tool. I love how this snowballs and that it feels great along that journey. Well done such a chill vibe! image_2023-01-11_000129585.png
Jan 11 00:19:05 17m 34s Dynia ♥ 1 Really fun and funny game loved the wooden toy look and the sudoku label. well done! image_2023-01-11_001902242.png
Jan 11 00:49:41 30m 36s The Ballad of Eric Hernandez, Cattle Rancher ♥ 2 Modern day art - inspiring!
Jan 11 10:25:41 9h 36m Drake's Fortune ♥ 2 Physics YES! Destruction YES! art was simple but effective and the fire particles were nice, sound was ok Aiming felt off to me, even with gravity etc it never appeared to go close to the little aim dot. Castles looked great, maybe more explosions etc would have made it even more fun. lacks an end goal. Loved that each time I went in was a little different, would have liked to see more stuff with wood in it and really see burning buildings. Overall good job! I played until I had all the upgrades image_2023-01-11_102539406.png
Jan 11 10:47:19 21m 38s 7 days to harvest ♥ 5 crazy fun and super satisfying I do want to punch the workers in the face - the clearly don't want me to succeed 😄 The game presents a good level of challenge with only a few bits of frustration Liked the art, characters, sounds and the story Would have liked to see a boost meter (maybe I missed it?). Good job!
Jan 11 11:00:47 13m 28s Children of the Combine ♥ 3 what......wait.......that game was......hmmmm. I loved it, it was confusing and crashed twice when loading the comics. I just wandered about listening to the voice lines and I laughed out loud at the end panels.... Gameplay wise I could feel some of the level colliders and the combine should perhaps be able to turn whilst stationary. but overall I had a fun time, good job!
Jan 11 11:05:05 4m 18s CrapCirclz ♥ 2 Interesting concept - really liked the look of the game, I did not like the camera angle. Game also crashed (killed the itch.io window) any time I used the ctrl function.
Jan 11 11:13:54 8m 49s Starvesters ♥ 2 Great visuals and audio - obviously the control issue is painful but the atmosphere you have built here is impressive, the bloom and lens dirt is a nice touch too. Well done!
Jan 11 19:23:22 8h 09m A Conversation With A Stranger ♥ 1 I really did not expect the twist, instantly engaged me! We'll keep trying ❤️
Jan 11 20:42:55 1h 19m Troll-mart ♥ 6 Nice entry the hook was really fun and the art was hilarious well done image_2023-01-11_204253104.png
Jan 11 21:12:16 29m 21s Space Harvest 9000! ♥ 1 Could not figure out why seeds can be planted on un tilled ground, and why they would never grow. reading the comments has not helped - made it to the last level though Art is simple and nice. But feel like the gameplay doesn't explain it's self that well or I am just missing it 😆 good job though
Jan 11 22:19:12 1h 06m The Cactilogue ♥ 1 Liked the minigames though they were a little laggy for me. wanted to change the cactus in a pot, but couldn't 😢 art is super cute and the growth animation was very well done! Good job 🌵
Jan 12 12:05:00 13h 45m #NoOneDeservesToBeAnEggHoover ♥ 0 Like the story idea, there was a little too much fluff in it, the mini game did not add to the experience that much. I understand that it was meant to be monotonous (it was) but it was not a fun experience as a player - I would have preferred to be on the side of the hacker and discovering the situation, would have provided more fun with a very similar story imho. That being said I think what you achieved the in timeframe was good - well done!
Jan 12 12:21:24 16m 24s Water Tower ♥ 1 Fun sniping - exactly how I water my plants, some variation in the plants would help, but the bullet drop is fun to play with. good job
Jan 12 12:24:54 3m 30s A Day in the Life of Death ♥ 1 So cute and funny - great amount of stuff for a Jam game! the art is great and the pink outfit.... 😆 Well done!
Jan 12 18:55:54 6h 31m abundance ♥ 1 This was great - got softlocked into a death bouncing between vertical lasers, but PDA, storytelling and atmosphere were all really well done. Platforming felt really tight with some jump requiring high precision but the game was very forgiving and edged towards rage but never massively close to it. Thanks and well done! image_2023-01-12_185550705.png
Jan 12 19:21:14 25m 20s Carvest ♥ 1 Great idea, lots of fun to be had with it, Stacking speed boosts is genuinely fun!
Jan 12 20:40:35 1h 19m Hivesters ♥ 2 Great art I love the bugs :D, There is a massive amount done here, the minimap was great and it ran amazingly well
Jan 12 22:03:13 1h 22m Consumption ♥ 1 Super polish art I really like the drain mechanic, though I could not buy everything as I one shot enemies, be nice to upgrade consumption to can health from weaker enemies. really enjoyed this well done and congrats!
Jan 13 13:43:01 15h 39m The Pets Over The Innsmouth ♥ 3 Amazing art, gameplay was very simple and took a ages to get anywhere. good job!
Jan 14 10:19:19 20h 36m HARRR Vests ♥ 2 Really fun idea! liked the pixel art a lot, be fun to see holes that you cut in the clothes by mistake 😄 Audio would have made this better - pirate shanty etc. The arm and the tattoos were really nice - I knew about the needle and thread from stream though 😉 Really fun mechanic good work! Went back and listened to the music and that fit your game well
Jan 14 10:37:51 18m 32s Kingdom's Logistics ♥ 1 Great job for compo lots of system interacting is always hard - the art style is a little mixed and obviously some audio would help. I found the UI was a little hard to read with the yellow text image_2023-01-14_103728267.png but overall - kept me playing for longer than I expected - I enjoyed it! Well done
Jan 14 11:16:14 38m 23s Crowings Do ♥ 0 Nice drawings - audio is funny too image_2023-01-14_111504063.png With the full refresh that happens after a while the difficulty resets - so it could be easy to game to get a high score by just waiting and getting some of the easier ones. but its a fun type of mini game as others have said well done!
Jan 14 11:19:29 3m 15s HarvesTurnip ♥ 1 Really fun game, like the mixture of mechanics. Great graphics love the mushroom death 😆 Very addictive - well done!
Jan 14 12:12:50 53m 21s Cattle Juice ♥ 1 I like the alien designs and the ship is cool - the upgrade shop is neat too. I feel that the game has some pacing issues - I like the challenge of farming the guards without killing the cattle (fun joke BTW!). The people moving off the screen is a little annoying too. I played maybe the wrong way - trying to last as long as possible 😆 image_2023-01-14_121107346.png Though at the end I hit escape and then could not go full screen again due to F11 making my browser window full screen 😄 Overall I think its quite fun, but would be better if it was a little faster, and maybe a little more agency in the fights. Well done!
Jan 14 13:06:29 53m 39s It was all for the Tuna ♥ 2 Love the vibe of this - almost quit due to not understanding that you could upgrade, glad I read some of the comments here to know that I could. Art, shaders, music and the actual catching were all fantastic! The map was also a really nice touch ❤️ Really enjoyed this well done. image_2023-01-14_130604080.png
Jan 14 13:18:15 11m 46s Slime Crime ♥ 2 Wow this is really fun! the upgrades are interesting and there are tons of them, the big big is hard but satisfying to fight. Almost want more enemies to fight. Sounds and music are good. Well Done!
Jan 14 15:39:58 2h 21m Plant, Harvest, Make money! ♥ 0 I love this idea the puzzles worked out very well - the simple graphics were ok, sound sounded the mood well. Puzzles were challenging but the game kept me engaged, only main point of criticism was that the undo and reset were too close and too similar. I loved the difference between all the plants - oranges being the normal, apples being speed up, melons you need to delay and corn being that delay source. The last level really showed this system - though it is maybe a little to tight, with only one answer. Loved this - very well done! image_2023-01-14_153956247.png
Jan 14 15:55:19 15m 21s Catchy ♥ 1 Nice art - caught everything apart from the catfish - sneaky one that one. liked the movement, would like to have had more agency in the fishing part, but I get you were going for a chill vibe. wind and the movement mechanics were really nice - felt like a sailor. Good entry and well done!
Jan 14 16:02:18 6m 59s Nesting ♥ 1 Art was really cute, liked the flapping - liked getting heavier with more trash and sticks - though with such a short game, it made finding the feel of the controller a little more difficult as it was constantly changing. nice entry! well done ❤️ image_2023-01-14_160216812.png
Jan 14 16:20:14 17m 56s Potato Farming Simulator ♥ 2 A farming game! liked the physicality of it, picking up things and putting them down. Few areas of improvement: - Not being able to see my money in the shop is a little annoying. - You need to press escape twice to open the menu in the browser if you are full screen, then click the button again - maybe an addition button would help here. - Don't remember if it was told but I thought that went I ordered seeds they would arrive quicker, thought it had bugged. - There is not a massive amount to do, the time pressure is great fun, but it would be better if I could multitask more, its mainly just water and sleep, with the reset taking away things it was quite frustrating. more planting and management would have helped here, do I have enough water, can I plan out new areas etc Graphics were simple but nice. Overall I had and interesting time, but got stale quite quickly.
Jan 14 17:19:05 58m 51s Harvest Survivor ♥ 1 Nice game, addictive and challenging. Few comments and my feedback (mostly compared to vampire survivors): - The colliders on the enemies is to big and your starting range on melee feels really small. - The rocks having three colliders that do not match up to the sprints is frustrating - Enemies speeds starts to fast - it might be more fun to increase this over time. - Health pickups from killing enemies would be fun as the challenge is already high - The power ups are nice, but some feel a little too low of a change to be worth picking. - I beat the game using speed and farm speed, as the combat felt quite lackluster (gameplay wise, not graphically) - Given the speed of the veggies the attacks facing forwards feels a little off. Graphically it is amazing the pixel art is fantastic! I like the theme and the horde of veggies falling you around is great. just has some mildly frustrating areas in it. Good entry and well done 👍 image_2023-01-14_171903327.png
Jan 14 17:50:16 31m 11s The Time Traveler's Garden ♥ 6 Wow such a nice looking game - especially the future side! Is there any kind of end? I didn't make it massively far due to the enemies being quite hard (especially the massive sandwich recipe!) As others have said the lack of feedback from the combat was a little bothersome, as it was not clear that I had to kill them at first. I kind of devolved to just spamming attack and running around 😄 Things like choosing what seeds to plant on your own, so you can balance the difficulty and the orders would be a nice improvement same with using different kitchen utensils as weapons. The adaptive music is cool, You got a lot done the the three days Great work!
Jan 14 18:02:34 12m 18s Crop Rush ♥ 1 This was a fun one, Thanks, Felt like the combine was a little sensitive to move (maybe that's a me problem) liked the challenge of figuring out the route! Well done ❤️ image_2023-01-14_180233072.png
Jan 14 18:14:04 11m 30s Fox Puppies Want Food For The Winter ♥ 1 Really nice art great job Gameplay was a little simple for me, would have liked to see some challenge or puzzles. Well done on submitting! image_2023-01-14_181402474.png
Jan 16 18:47:22 48h 33m Midday Garden ♥ 2 I love the art style of this, seen it on LombyGGs stream. played the itch version - looks like the particles spawning are causing a frame rate issue - are you using an object pool? This game is great lots of potential - day/night cycle changes, dynamic events like seasons etc. Really chill vibe - love the power feeling after a while like wave 15+ ish image_2023-01-16_184716804.png
Jan 16 18:55:19 7m 57s UFO and Harvest ♥ 1 Love the graphics and look of this game - the fuel resource is a little limiting, but overall nice! I really like the jumping between different planetoids but feel like the jumping is the thing that should use the fuel. Then you need to plan your route better. The background moving and rotating is giving me slight motion sickness (be nice if there was an option to turn that off) Nice entry!
Jan 16 19:42:37 47m 18s Froot ♥ 1 Controls were a little hard to grasp - but overall was fun to play and liked the complexity increase over time with the new levels