benswinden 2013-08-26 02:40
Really cool atmosphere. I really wanted the fish to swim alot faster though, it kind of felt like i was swimming through molasses
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD27 → LEGACY
By thriek
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 1 | 100 | ||
| Mood | 68 | 3.66 | ||
| Audio | 92 | 3.48 | ||
| Graphics | 115 | 3.82 | ||
| Theme | 440 | 3.29 | ||
| Innovation | 492 | 3.05 | ||
| Overall | 497 | 3.11 | ||
| Humor | 735 | 1.96 | ||
| Fun | 1067 | 2.17 |
Really cool atmosphere. I really wanted the fish to swim alot faster though, it kind of felt like i was swimming through molasses
A nice moody game, the music was a real treat.
However I found the fish moved so sluggishly and the clock rarely started at 10 when it moved to the new fish that I was constantly in the "fish has died" screen - more so than in the game screen! Without a clear objective, I got bored quite quickly :(
The idea is nice though and I think with some polish and more indication that you are actually progressing it could be a poignant little art game. :)
Great presentation. The audio really fits the setting. Clever use of the theme.
Thanks for the comments guys! Yeah I really enjoyed making it, I plan to add some indicators that progression is actually occurring and a few other things, but just didn't have time. After the judging is over I'll come back to it, I think :)
wasn't sure when I started moving, then by the third try I understood but got bored, great art thought
Not sure what I'm doing here...
Gave you 5/5. Very, very strong submission. With a little polish and better physics, I would play this on my phone.
mpath, thanks! That means alot.
I'm going to add some speed changing obstacles and other stuff after the judging is done, to really get the game to where I wanted it to be :)
The first resentment kicked me straight in the feels. I never let it happen again T_T
This submission has awesome atmosphere. I do agree with some of the other comments about the fish speed, though. It's very slow.
This is a pretty grim take on the Pixar classic Finding Nemo. I never see the fish ever produce offspring, so I got really confused with what was going on.
It's okay. It got really boring fast and it didn't have any personal impact on me.
I'm not a huge fan of art games, and this isn't going to tip me that way, so I didn't exactly enjoy it. That being said, you can see the quality of the work. The graphics were a bit bland, but they were cohesive and had a bit of shine to them. The music was awesome, and that working together with the mechanics made for a great feel. It was an interesting take on choosing between progress and commitment. On the one hand, if you leave the child behind you get much further, but there's nothing out there, so there's not really a point. On the other if you stay with your child you get more time, but again to what end? I would have liked to see more options than stay or leave, but it was definitely a fresh idea.
Interesting take on the theme, i found the music really gave the game a good mood but the speed of the fish got old quite fast.
really beautiful and atmospheric! would love to be able to play without the time limit and just... swim :)
I found it a bit hard—too slow for the distances between "air bubbles"—which was frustrating because I really wanted to see the nice environment.
You managed to create an atmosphere in few seconds, well done !
Great game and excellent immersion
interesting
A little sad
Really interesting idea.
Beautifully done. Well done this game is incredible
I can't run this on my mac:P
Sorry! I just added a quick fix to the mac version to allow playing, otherwise it might be a dropbox permissions issue...
Nice animations!
awesome sound effect, very moody
Really nice little game. :)
It's beautiful
Pretty unique experience, and very atmospheric. The mood is great.
Is there an end to this game? It got boring when all I could see was more bubbles in the distance with no end in sight. Got my fish's strength up to about 40 seconds.
No women fish? Come on.
Love this! Graphics and concept are beautiful :)
Oh and it took me 11 generations, im slow i think
I really like this game. At first I was like, why do'st you resent me fishy!? Then I was like. Oh.. That's cute. Stay with me and we die togethar!
I really liked this a lot. Very good atmosphere.
The graphics were beautiful. Great game!
Very nice game! It looks and sounds amazing. Some of the best art and audio I've seen for this competition yet!
Good atmosphere and interesting mechanics. I did notice that the timer would consistently go below 0 and then add extra time to the next life, not sure if intended but did not look to be. Other than that though, good idea and fit well with theme!
Great mood, great caustics, music's really atmospheric too. Kind of wish the fish could swim in vertically too, but then again, maybe I just didn't figure out how, and they actually can.
Touching tale of a fish and his father.
How dare you make me feel a feel.
:D Thanks so much for the feedback guys
Controls are very hard, can't really judge the depth with bullet. Theme and audio are good !
Great atmosphere. Wished the fish controlled a little tighter. Dug the water reflections. Good job!
ohh, artsy
I felt that the controls were frustrating and floaty, I was expecting to have more nimble controls but then had very slow movements. It could also be more interesting opening up the range of motion, so rotating left and right. Otherwise you nailed the water effect!
Really cool art style, too bad the movement are limitated... i wanted to go up (y-axis on current view).
Hearing you guys, I wanted to add 360 movement but didn't have time to deal with all the issues that could create in the time, more and more I want to complete this project in full if feedback continues to be good. :)
Interesting idea, some life-deaths cicle will take the fish children to a future life in ocean, but it will be sad to see them dying all the time...
Love the art and atmosphere
Amazing atmosphere.
Really think you should fix counter so it doesn't count down to -1 constantly.
Noted :)
Nice work on athmosphere. You yould add a little more feedbacks about progression of the player.
Liked the contemplative atmosphere. Poor fishes :( This reminds me Rogue Legacy ^^
Good work !
I found it very hard, but it's a nice concept and graphics are cool. Great job!
OAUU!!! Deep is eat me!
Great art and music: they created a very relaxing, dreamy mood.
As for fun, the idea is interesting (a bit sad, so it has a melancholic vibe that I'm particularly fond of), and I really liked the legacy idea. I think it could have been a bit more complex, but I guess that time may have got in the way. Also, at times I wasn't completely sure if I'd left my offspring behind or not until the countdown was over.
A very good entry nonetheless. Congrats! =)
Beautiful game. Great mood. :)
Original idea and cool game!
Love it ! The atmosphere is very special
really nice fish animation
It's good experiment. It looks good and moody. Nice job :)
Great graphics and atmosphere. Good work ! :)
This is a very beautiful game. It gets a bit tedious towards the end, I started wondering if there would even be one.
The controls are a bit slow.
The mood in this game is awesome, and the music is just right for this setting.
Good job.
Beautiful game. Well done.
Nice music, very moody. Reminded me of the farm song in Ocarina of Time somewhat :)
The water effects gave a nice touch.
I patiently waited for my sons for 9 generations, then I had 30 seconds and just rushed through, leaving the last poor guy behind.
The fish models are quite nice, although I wish I could see their faces. Nice ambiance music too.
Great visuals and audio! Nice work!
Very good atmosphere
Great mood and music, good job!
Really beautiful game! I love how the water was designed. Tough game, but very nice!
Interesting idea and a strong atmosphere. However there was not much to discover.
makes you wanna go deeper.
Great graphics and awesome soundtrack
Mood is great. Nice work!
Nice atmosphere, and good work on the environment.
I liked how you get to choose if you go far, or if you stay ith your son to strenghten the bond and family resistance.
Nice work!
eery music, touching theme. innovative use of 10 seconds and cool water physics.
Love the mood. The underwater effect was beautiful and the ambient music fitted so well. Nice entry :)
That was an interesting experience. It's visually pleasing and the soundscape creates an interesting mood - I like it.
At first, I was utterly confused, but after some generations, I picked up what was happening myself. I'm not sure whether I would make anything clearer - I think games like this should have some exploration. I would've liked an ending screen. though, and the controls could've been a bit less soft.
Really interesting experience, thank you! And congratulations on finishing your first LD entry!
Really liked the setting for this, but the gameplay could use a lot of work. For a long, long time I couldn't work out the controls. I was using WASD but didn't really know what was going on and at one stage I actually thought I was playing as the smaller fish. Mostly I think this was because it didn't really feel as though I was moving until I could really see the terrain come a lot closer into view. I liked the music and thought it was awesome that you had time to produce that within the 48 hours on top of making a game like this. Would have really liked to have seen how this game turned out with some more work, and perhaps a different theme attached to it.
Interesting use of the theme.
Very atmospheric and experimental game, yet using a simple but efficient gameplay. Congrats, man.
Wish this wasn't so short. Maybe I'm doing something wrong! Good take on the 10 second theme. Soothing.
Nice audio. Agree on control speed, a little frustrating. Was unclear to me what the rules were. I swam toward the white bubbles/dots but they didn't always give me more time, which I assumed.
Beautiful. I loved it, and will remember it.
Great music/graphics. Great job, I loved it. I featured this game in my LD27 compilation video, if you'd like to check it out :) http://youtu.be/jm5J5gdV81o
Love the mood, but it feels too slow. I didn't make much progress, and at first didn't even understand that you could stay with the little fish. Interesting game overall.