framematt 2014-04-28 00:33
I love it, it is quite relaxing.
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD29 → The Gathering
By oatsbarley
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 1 | 100 | ||
| Graphics | 57 | 4.26 | ||
| Overall | 110 | 3.77 | ||
| Mood | 126 | 3.69 | ||
| Fun | 196 | 3.51 | ||
| Innovation | 375 | 3.33 | ||
| Audio | 381 | 3.03 | ||
| Humor | 885 | 1.99 | ||
| Theme | 1167 | 2.16 |
I love it, it is quite relaxing.
Awesome work barley, any chances of you continuing it? (I'm Slader16 on Tigs)
The game is awesome! Although I would like to have a tooltip that tells you how much each of the buildings cost...
Thanks guys!
@Slader - Probably not anytime soon ): I'm super busy with other games right now. Maybe sometime in the future, though!
@Kulomin - Thanks for the feedback! There's a tooltip in the bottom right of the screen that tells you things about stuff you hover over. I'm not super happy with the UI in general, and I can see why it'd not be obvious!
This really is a fun game. Nice work! And I love the visuals.
This is totally awesome! Really liked the graphic style and overall execution - it amazes me that you did this in 48 hours! nicely done! :)
Nice, like Matt says, relaxing. Definitely should consider continuing this project post-Ludum.
Interesting design and soothing gameplay :)
Love the visuals and mood definitely a really solid entry.
This is such a promising game, but unfortunately it seems almost unbeatable to me.
Things quickly go out of sync after a few nights, with mosters coming out of the woods in the morning instead in the night, the building menu only popping up way after noon, and the movement speeds seemingly changing as well.
Also, since it doesnt seem to matter which buildings the monsters visually attack, i always lose at least 3/4 of all my buildings in the morning, with all of my food resetting as it seems impossible to collect more in a day than gets consumed by hunger. This leads to me always building new houses late in the evening when my few remaining citizens finally come out of the woods again, only to immediately be destroyed again, leaving me with even less houses for the next day and the day actually "starting" even later than last time.
I think it would work nicely if the syncing issues were fixed and it would be a bit more predictable which houses get destroyed in the morning.
I really like the visuals and the idea, but it does seem to lack the polish. Correct me if i am doing something fundamentally wrong here, but i really couldnt figure out how to make this work.
@Lars Thanks for the feedback. I can reassure you that it is beatable! It's just a bit tricky. A lot of how the game goes depends on how you start.
The general strategy is: make a couple houses very close to the forest, and a lodge far away from it. For the first day, build houses next to the first two as soon as you have the resources for them, but try to keep in mind the hunger value. The second day you might want to build another lodge, and keep building houses. By the end of the second or during the third, start building villas while keeping your house level constant. Maybe build another lodge or two if the wood is too low.
Once you get over the initial night with 3 or so houses left intact, you should be good to go. Eventually you have enough resources for guard towers and then it's just a case of building a perimeter.
I haven't noticed any sync issues on my end, but the monsters do come at the end of the night and leave just after dawn. If I had a bit more time, I'd probably adjust the timing of the monsters, since having them appear and disappear with the night is more intuitive! Houses disappear when all of their occupants are dead (you can mouse over a building to see its occupants), and this includes dying from hunger at the start of the next day.
The houses nearest the forest are the ones that get chosen.
Thanks again for your feedback. Let me know if you're still having trouble!
Thanks for the explanation.
I tried it again now and had no problems beating it. I just didnt really understand the Hunger mechanic right the first time. I always spammed as many houses as i could, leaving me with almost 0 Food at the end of the day, resulting in most of my village starving, obviously making it harder each day. I did not realize houses would disappear because of food-shortage, i just assumed the hunger would consume as much food as there is and thats it.
With your tips and strategy it went much better. Its a thing i often notice with LD-games, though. I experienced it myself last time as well. You think your game has just the right difficulty or even is very easy because you, as the developer, have no problems beating it, but in reality people will often struggle with the difficulty set by the dev.
As for the syncing-issues: I still do think they happen. At least the monsters spawn in the middle at the night at the beginning, and then a bit later every time. Because i was building all of my houses very far away from the forest the first time, that was very noticeable as they didnt even get to reach my houses before disappearing. Following your strategy one hardly notices anymore though.
Anyway, upped my ratings since it was mostly because of me being bad, and not the game being as buggy as i first thought. Really love the concept and visuals. Cheers.
I'm glad it clicked for you!
I'll stick a bit of info about the hunger mechanic into the description, since that's something I completely forgot to explain anywhere!
I totally agree about the balancing. It's hard to tell whether it's balanced when you're really good at the game. It's very easy to make it too difficult!
Thanks for your comments, this sort of feedback is very useful.
Amazing art style!
rally beautiful game, with suitable ambient countryside sounds.
Very nice, I got destroyed by monsters but I'm going to give it another go when I'm not falling asleep on my keyboard.
13 days, 140 villagers.
A very respectable loss, I say. For the greater good!
Wow, this is awesome! I really like the low-poly art style.
I love it! The graphics are simple, yet beautiful. The game is fun to play. Great job!
This guys from forest always destroy my village. :(
Great mood, beautiful graphics (watch out molyneux) and I love building games.
That said, I think it is balanced way too hard with bears spawning very quickly and not responding to how far the houses are. Still, it's a gorgeous building game :)
I revise: difficulty is just right, you just need to build huts like a mad man and sacrifice all your villagers as front line to protect the villas - ugh :(
Very nice visuals. Love the font! It took me a while to figure out how to play, partly because the Unity webplayer didn't seem to want to take the input focus for some reason (pretty sure that's not a problem with my browser though, not your game). Once I figured it out it was relaxing and fun, if a little slow moving.
I won! It's nice to play a short game that gives you a sense of accomplishment - well done. What else are you working on?
Thanks for the feedback, everyone!
@elefantopia - I'm glad you had a good time with it. I'm working on Cloudface right now (http://www.cloudfacegame.com) in a small team and a little puzzle game on my own!
@philip_sinclair - Haha, the ambient bird noises is from outside my window. I forgot I was recording, so when I processed the audio I had to go through and remove all the keyboard clacking and exasperated cries.
This is a really great looking game. I couldn't figure it out, though. I managed to place a few houses, but all but one got destroyed every night. I didn't manage to get villa to generate gold and so never got to build a guard house.
Admittedly, the gameplay isn't really my style, but I love the art. Amazing how pretty it is considering the time constraints, and the audio definitely helps with the overall tone!
Interesting game man. good job :)
Nice visual!
impressive amount of work done! very nice
Really great visuals! Village building is always fun :)
The art is amazing and the concept is nice. It is just hard at first to understand how you play.
Great artwork, great music... very relaxing.
Weird, I was playing it, I totally messed up so reloaded page and got a 404. Now the link isn't working =/
I get 404 under the "Web" link.:(
Thanks guys!
@Tifu - Hmm, I moved some stuff around in the folder on Google Drive and it might have screwed something up. It should be fixed now, though!
It took me 17 days and 148 where killed, but I made it to the end :) This is probably the best entry I have seen so far! The art style is so lovely and the game idea is great!
I was hooked! Great artwork!
That was awesome. Pretty, well-balanced, challenging. Very, very nice
This game is awesome! It's relaxing, and yet exciting each night :P - This is undoubtedly among the best games I've played this dare! Very good job!
Wow really well done, very nice graphics and sounds! the gameplay was unique and fun too! Also one of the few games with some mood that I've played!
I found it a little too slow paced but besides thatit was a very relaxing and enjoyable experience.
Really ambitious game (and executed pretty well too!).
Graphics are nice, just wish there was more in game (the walkthrough you posted basically beat the game for me)indications of what everything does.
Lovely visual style, together with the font it's extremely charming. I don't see a real connection to the theme though...did I miss anything?
Gameplay feels a bit mundane and there's nothing which really feels fresh or new to me. Overall I'd say this is mostly about the looks, gameplay is just too shallow for my taste.
Thanks for the feedback everyone.
@Maschinen - The link with the theme is sort of explained in the description at the top of the page. The forest is an endless source of food, but beneath the surface it's a murderous man-eating entity.
There's also a link in the gameplay, in that you're building a town and at the same time sacrificing the poorer villagers to the forest to save everybody else.
@spotco - The walkthrough is there just in case you're stuck with the game. A lot of people found it hard to get past the first few nights!
good work! loved the birds (- ; the description of the villa with "lots and lots of gold" was just a plain lie! :P
had fun! thx for making the game
Peaceful relaxing game, great on mood, although I didn't get how it fits with the theme. Reminds me of Black and White :)
Interesting entry. Quite hard to beat, had a good village going using the strategy you mentioned. Things had to be a little more detailed, though, since I couldn't see how much the buildings cost to build. But the visuals and mood are really great.
Love this sorts of games, A+ on execution.
I really liked this game but at one point all of a sudden all my houses did the dying animation but when I moused over where they had been it still showed how many occupants were in it and when the sun rose people popped out out of no where.
I could never get a guard regardless of how many homes I put in the way to protect it. You make me angry >:[
Hi. Seemed a bit slow overnight. Sun was going in unexpected direction - probably a cultural thing. Love the visuals, material crinkly paper look and the gentleness of it - including gentle monster murder... A more involved/developed version would be interesting to see.
really beautiful graphics and overall atmosphere. well done! so amazing that you made this in 48 hours
Thanks for the feedback!
@Diptoman - there's a tooltip at the bottom left of the screen, but I have a feeling it's getting cut off for people who have shorter screens.
@dkkarate - that's weird. The houses disappearing was probably due to starvation (the hunger value was higher than the food value) but people shouldn't have been appearing. Thanks for the heads up!
@mjrevel - the guard doesn't come out of the guard tower! He shoots from the windows. I probably should have made that clearer, as every other building spawns a visible villager.
@mrexcessive - the camera is pointing north and the sun is going from east to west. I'm fairly certain that's how it goes everywhere! ;)
Thanks again, guys.
Ooh nice look!
I quite like the game, but I had 3 straight nights of no deaths and nothing happened. Is there a "you win" screen at all?
Its very fun to play, thats for sure, some nice calming music would be cool hehe
10 days, 50 loss, 190 inhabitants ! \o/
Loved the graphics and mood :)
Cool, game worked now. Once I had a better idea of what I was doing it was pretty fun. I like the art style, feels like its all made out of paper.
Thanks guys!
@joe40001 - the win condition triggers at the start of the next day. It _should_ be 3 nights, but I might have accidentally made it 4! There is a win screen.
This is awesome. Thank you for making this.
Awesome game. I love the idea of not expanding too quickly, making sure you have enough food before building more.
Pretty cool. I like the simple polygon graphics and the general mood. It's kind of soothing in a way. Simple but fun strategic mechanics. Like it!
One of my favorite game. Cool visual, easy to play... Cool game!!
I think this is the game I spent the most time to play. It's relaxing, well balanced, maybe a bit slow, but a solid game. One of my favorite yet, great job :D
great game, no relation to the theme whatsoever
I like it, I could totally get into a game like this; where is the theme though?
Thanks for the feedback. There's two ways the theme plays into the game:
- The forest is the thing that allows your village to grow, but under the cover of darkness it's actually out to kill everyone.
- You're building the foundations of a new village/town on the idea of sacrificing the poorest members of your society.
I won after 11 days and lost 106 villagers but the entire screen was totally full of buildings. 6 forresters, 6 villas, more tents than I could count, and enough towers along the forest line to wrap around the earth 3 times. Felt pretty good to get that far. My only problem with the game is I guess I didn't really feel the theme at all. :(
I like the low-poly graphic style and enjoyed the simple but addictive gameplay a lot! Well done!
One of the best entries tried so far! Finished the game in 10 days (on about 5th try) and 88 of people died. Good job!
Everything about the game is great, except it lacks replayability. Once you figure out the winning strategy, it's kinda pointless to play again. Then again, figuring out the winning strategy took longer than most LD games keep you entertained.
Nice game, really complete and deep. Dont see the relation with the theme though but a great game anyway!
11 days have past, and 68 villagers have perished.
I don't think I did too bad, especially considering my 2nd villa was built just to the right of the center of the forest (misclick) and somehow managed never to fall (although it did drop to 1 occupant a couple times).
The biggest problem I had was waiting for tents near the mouth of the forest to get completely removed to make room for turrets, since I failed to leave spaces for turrets when I initially started building.
@VDZ - that's a good point. Admittedly replayability wasn't really high on my list when I was making the game, since I didn't expect anyone to play it more than once when they were voting. If I do something more with it I'll definitely look into that, though!
@SnoringFrog - there must be a collisions bug if it let you put a building in the forest, whoops! And I think some sort of building removal would be a good idea, to help out in situations like you described with the tents and the guard towers.
Thanks for your comments!
Good game, poor people when I in charge ;) Nice polished game considering time limit.
Despite a few comments here, I'd rate this game well on the side of easy, which is "relaxing" vs a frenetic miss a move and you're dead kind of thing.
I created a "minigame" to push the game to its limits. I've gotten a couple of wins on the 600+ man range. With a little work I think someone can hit 700+. But around there feels like the limit - just running out of room in all categories because the villagers can't serve the last couple of rows of houses.
But the engine still sorta worked with 600 items, so that's impressive for a Ludum Dare.
That "sacrificing" idea is vicious and bears a bit of thought. Remember, the "you win" clock doesn't start if you're losing people! So you can keep building and then you put a couple of cannon fodder tents way at the front.
It's Occupy Wall Street except you are the 1%!
This is my favorite type of game. :)
Enjoyed the graphics especially the sunrise and sunset. The little monsters are cute. I felt like there should have been a cursor to mark build spots but it's a minor detail.
I love the build and defend mechanic. I felt a little bad sacrificing the villagers with the small houses early on, but it was fun to build more fancy stuff later.
Hope you do more with this.
Pretty decent little city builder! The monsters from the forest are a nice addition.
It was fun at first, but then, I got a bit bored.. Loved the graphics and the city builder kind of thing.
Very relaxing. Loving the art style :)
This is nice and relaxing. Until night time! D:
I love the geometric graphics! And the ambient sounds are perfect!
This is quite fun. I've been playing it far longer than I expected. It has a very cool graphical style. Well done. Now back to the game...
Thanks for your comments, everyone. They mean a lot, and I'm definitely taking on board your suggestions/criticisms!
13 days, 127 death: http://imgup.motion-twin.com/twinoid/1/f/c20df8d0_8297.jpg
Nice game! :)
Awesome entry!
amazing graphics, and relaxing yet addicting gameplay. Would love to play this on a tablet while on a long ride, great job!
One of my favorite submissions so far