gzalo 2023-05-01 02:44
Great game!!! love the idea!! 5 stars :star2:
you have to continue it developing it, it has great potential
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD53 → Decrypting Handwriting
By pauljs
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 132 | 3.73 | 62 | |
| Fun | 195 | 3.40 | 62 | |
| Innovation | 1 | 4.73 | 62 | |
| Theme | 254 | 3.67 | 62 | |
| Graphics | 319 | 3.00 | 61 | |
| Humor | 284 | 2.42 | 50 | |
| Mood | 187 | 3.36 | 56 |
Great game!!! love the idea!! 5 stars :star2:
you have to continue it developing it, it has great potential
*I really like your game*
Thanks, keep working on it :D
I can't decide if I had fun while playing that, which at least means it was extemely engaging. I was not a fan of the address list being in no obvious order. perhaps by surname rather than id, but CTRL+F helped me enough to not need any specific order in the end. More just a nit pick. Good Job!
I was really difficult to read handwriting, so I didn't finish the game. Also controls might update the image on every update, instead of releasing mouse, so I can see how much I rotated the image. Enhancing works in the opposite directoins, it seems, and doesn't make any sense, why would I move it to lower value. The focus length might be better fit for this control.
@justslavic Thank you for your feedback! But to give you a bit of context, i did all of that on purpose, i wanted the control scanner to be a bit cluncky to give the mood of a hard to control scanner and so-on, for me it is part of the mood i am building! But maybe it didn't transpire enough, thank you for your feedback, nonetheless!
I liked it, a unique concept. You really captured the difficulty of decrypting an address using different handwriting and levels of damage on the paper.
My only question, why does increasing "enhance", ALWAYS pixelates the images? I'd say if the "ideal" position was picked randomly somewhere on the slider and then you would need to fine tune your "enhance", to get the clearest possible image.
@slimeboos that's honestly a great idea and would have fit perfectly, the enhance is a thing i added at the end last minut because i like the idea to have the stupid "enhance picture" from movie that is not a real thing x) But yes you are totally right finding the right enhancement would have been way more fun/on point than just having a slider (which indeed would have been better in the opposing direction!)
Really cool idea! I don't have all too much to add, you found a simple yet unique idea and ran with it.
Wow, a great submission. I watched that video as well and was really impressed with how they did. I thought my handwriting was bad until I watched that/played this game! This would be a great way to (ethically dubiously) collect more training data for classification if you had users label individual characters ;)
This was a neat concept. A little too challenging for the level of fun but I did enjoy figuring out some of them.
The most unique entry I've reviewed thus far. Thanks! I really like the premise. I'd love to see how it would play if the static document was instead a list of search results from the info you fill in. Maybe you could have wildcard character to represent what you're not sure about when filling it out. That's not a critique as much as a brainstorm. :slight_smile:
I had fun and enjoyed playing.
decrypting.png
Ok! Got in thanks to crtl-F too. The last one was definitely tricky. Liked the enhance filter joke.
i'm a secret agent now 😎
This was super cool! I love the idea and what you did with it! I honestly have nothing more to say other than maybe add more adresses. Really well done!
soo huge!!
i absolutely LOVED this game. It reminds me of spy books with coded messages I loved as a kid, I want you to make more levels!! I could play that all day, my favourite game of the jam so far. Super unique and innovative idea, amazing entry :)
Truely unique and quirky and fun! I like the mood which callback on the old scanner or old equipment that post man can still have even today, with laggy and not perfect tool. I cheat a little by copy-paste the data in a excel and having the ability to sort the data, but I think it fit the game too!
Some of my favourite entry so far
What a clever idea! Would love a more developed version of this with more advanced search and sort tools. But it's cool to sleuth over the PDF too. Very cool vibe - like Papers, Please or Stop Talking and Nobody Explodes, etc. Tactile and really makes you feel like you're sleuthing. One of the most original entries I've played.
Very clever idea, loved this! Just needs some CSI music or something in the background and it would be perfect. Fantastic work!
Thanks for hanging out in the stream and bringing your game!
Here is a link to the VOD that starts at your section. https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1809875425?t=00h34m50s
Never in my life did I think I'd be taking the postal exam in a jam
But that was one of the most unique experiences I've ever had in one
Very unique entry, the last address took me a while to figure out!
I love the idea! One of the most unique games I've played during the jam so far :)
I'll be honest, this feels more like work rather than a game. Not that i apreciate the idea and implementation of it, but to me it's one of thos ethat rely more on the presentation being top-notch, and this one unfortunately feels too clunky to be fun.
I'm a sleeper agent now.
Remarkably engaging for what it is.
Really nice idea! I just found way too hard, as English isn't my native language. maybe a difficulty setting would be nice, but it is of course really difficult to implement a difficulty setting to a jam game. Nice one!
this is totally out of the box! love it!
Such a great idea, finally got round to playing it off stream, and I've got to say, it's interesting and just clever in general, turning an interesting mechanic like that and turning it into something engaging is so hard, and you nailed it. Well done.
very original content! Had a good time working through this. Its gonna be tough to appeal to everyone with these sort of games, but great if you got a bit of time to focus on it! Appreciated the warning about doxxing too, thoughtful.
Your idea is truly unique, I never saw something like this in a LD contest. Nicely done.
Ok i must admit i saw the last address on Tobugis stream, but i figured out all the others ! Like i said in the chat, its such an original and great concept ! Amazingly innovative <3 <3
What an innovative idea! I think this game is great and different from the others I have seen
Hahaha this is awesome, I immediately thought of the Tom Scott video when I saw this, and it really recreated the experience for me :D
One of a kind idea, I absolutely loved it. Felt so proud when I passed the test! xD Hoping to see it more polished, or maybe taken and used in some other context/game? Would be awesome!
This idea is soo nice ! Got caught in it for a long time ! Really well done <3
Super duper cool game, it was really fun to decipher the writings like an old postman.
Very clever idea. Would've liked some more like the last one where you really had to be creative with how you deciphered the address.
In the beginning i really liked the game when after the time passes it made me feel really anxious. Your idea is really amazing
Super unique, great idea for a game, and well put together! Good job!
Cool game, gave up on address 5 though that person deserves to be cremated
I have a hard enough time reading printed letters... I can't believe you've done this!
Clever use of the theme and it gives me a new appreciation for those who figure out where those hand written addressed letters go!
**Idea is great**, I feel like I am detective, and it's so cool! But I spend a lot of time figure out where is this some adresses id's. And it is very hard and I don't finished the game, and it's disapointment for my experience. May be you should add single level at start, and make total length of submission form smaller.
I think you should simplify this game, and add some reveal to scanner where he can help you amd reveal some letters or words. And I don't like that list as pdf (literaly it's pdf), I wanna see the more simple and more gamified version of this game. Now it feels just like interesting work instrument if detective xD
This was fantastic, thank you for making such a unique game. Also loved the video that inspired this game, great entry!
I really loved the game, of course there could be some improvements, like moving the image with the mouse and other things that have already been mentioned here, but the game works well as it is, there are no bugs, and it's fun to try to decipher the addresses. I think this was the most innovative game for me so far, and I really appreciated it. Congratulations :D
I DID IT!!! This is such a creative idea, I loved it. Only thing is that my eyesight is already kinda trash so I would have appreciated some bigger lettering on those buttons ;w; I'm surprised at how doable this was, from the screenshots it looked almost impossible, but with enough stubbornness I kept going. I think some QOL features on the scanner would be nice, like making the sliders for movement, zoom, etc update automatically as you change them, and I'm not sure what the use of the "enhance" slider is since you never want it to make the picture blocky anyway, I guess it's just there for that secret agent feel. x) Awesome game great job!!
Wow, this is the most original idea I've seen so far! At first, I was a bit confused, but once I understood everything, I felt determined to find all the id addresses and felt extremely accomplished when I entered everything and successfully obtained the code. I felt like a real secret agent inside the agency! 😎 I'm glad my best friend sent this game to me, congratulations on the creativity and great game with such a unique concept! (ღ˘⌣˘ღ)
Thanks for submitting your game to be played on the stream! If you wanted to watch my reaction again here’s the vod timestamped to your game https://youtu.be/0LdDwOAkfzc?t=5460
Thanks for submitting your game on the stream! Here’s the stream if you wanted to re-watch initial thoughts (timestamps in the description to jump to your game!) [youtube link](youtu.be/jljB3XXZHcg)
Very cool and innovative idea! Would've loved to see more usage of the different image filters and stuff at the top. It seemed like once I turned on enhance all the way and remove scan lines, that I no longer needed to touch that at all. Enjoyed needing to scrape for bits of readable information and poring over the document to narrow the addresses down. Lots of potential here :)
A unique twist on gaming, making you feel like a secret agent. A bit tricky, but tons of fun. Great job!