Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD40 → Interview at Cacophony
By parttimeindie, Papiertig0r and christoph
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 396 | 3.61 | 83 | |
| Fun | 476 | 3.41 | 84 | |
| Innovation | 77 | 3.93 | 84 | |
| Theme | 193 | 3.93 | 82 | |
| Graphics | 838 | 3.00 | 84 | |
| Audio | 35 | 4.16 | 85 | |
| Humor | 439 | 3.19 | 79 | |
| Mood | 537 | 3.32 | 81 |
Our game is ready now. You can try it in the browser on our itch.io page. Just follow the link: https://interview-at-cacophony.itch.io/interview-at-cacophony follow. A Windows version in full resolution is also available on the download page.
Have fun and thank you for every review
placeholder
Great work, I love the concept. It reminds me of my days back at music college! The audio was great quality, and this isn't a style of game I've really seen before. A great take on the theme.
I loved this, it got super hard when I had to pick five instruments. I guess my ear is not well trained!
Really fun game with a great concept. It's funny and gets quite challenging as more instruments are added in. The game looks nice too. Good job!
Haha, thank you for reminding that I am terrible at music. I succedd the three instruments by luck and never succeed the four instruments :) But I loved to mix sounds to see if that worked, it was fun!
Thanks to all of you for the kind words and thanks to my two team mates for creating t his game :)
Really funny game. I especially enjoy the disapproving noises he makes when I choose wrong. It made me realize how bad I am at distinguishing instruments haha. Although some of them seem to be much louder than others, I couldn't hear the piano or the harp at all. Really nice use of the theme as well you get 5 stars for theme and innovation.
Really fun game! I just wish i wasn't so bad at it! hahaa.. The snippet of music you hear never gets old, and it puts a smile on my face when the guy sings!
Great job, the game accomplishes well what the theme has to offer. This could be used in a music school for sure! Well done!
I love the concept! Frustrating at times, but oh so satisfying when you get it!
This is an excellent ear training tool! I actually like the fact that it's so cacophonous and not super melodic. It really adds to the difficulty. Nice work! The instrument that I had the hardest time with was the cello. It just gets a little too buried in the mix. I'm going to share this with my high school music appreciation class.
This is a cool idea! Brings me back to my days in band haha.
Great idea, for me it seemed hard enough that it maybe have been nice to re-listen-to the music without having to try and pick (when I knew I had missed some), but that might just be my bad ear! Well done.
Haha,i really don't know much about instruments,but the game is really fun,musics are great,and the graphics are funny
I like the idea, but for some reason i couldn't select the instrument near the singer. (this was in web build.)
@samuli-salonen There is still a bug in the web gl build with the lightning for the voice, you can click it and it will lighten most of the room. We are going to fix that bug.
nice idea and great performance, you feel like at musical school
This is a lot of fun! Difficult to my untrained ear, though. Overall, well done!
Man, that is difficult. I really would have liked a replay button :grin:
Interesting take on the theme. The difficulty ramps quickly and I was only able to get through a few levels. This game as a little bit of an educational feel, I could see it turning into a children's game helping them with listening skills and introducing them to music.
Really Good! Now I want a noncacophonian version with different music genres depending on the diffuculty!
How wonderfully creative! Great use of the theme!
"Interview at cacophony is a music-puzzler or, as we call it, a musuzzler." Haha, I love this!
I found this game entry because one of your team members posted about the music samples, and I'm so glad I tried it out. This is different from everything I ever played before, and I really enjoyed it! Great job you guys :)
Unique and quite fun game. Too hard for my ears though. Even on easy I have a hard time picking 5 instruments. Would help if you could listen to it again without making a guess you're almost sure is wrong anyway, because you've had to guess. At least on easy.
Ok! Really fun game. This game is harde well thanks for "Good luck" XD good entry
It's a super nice idea and the musical pieces are well executed. Pretty fun as well, for a while. The interface and graphics are quite meh tho, but it works for the game.
This is a nice idea for the theme. I found it quite challenging, especially because I could not hear again the segment to double check. Maybe adding an easier mode for those like me would make the game more including. I think graphically it could have been designed a little better, especially since a big part of the screen is just background.
@fullmontis if you guessed wrong you can hear it again, this will decrease your grade. But yes maybe we should have made it possible to relisten in an easier mode, without the penalty.
Cool idea! I love seeing people with such original ideas. Really nice game. :smile:
The most original game I have played so far. Awesome, fun and unusual, just what I like :) Must have been hard work to create all that music and set it together. Good job!
Theme naild it but it's a pretty hard game. But a good idea, well done!
Wow, this idea is amazing and fits the theme very good. The graphics are not the best, but who cares on such a good music concept. Great work
Oh my goodness this game is hilarious and is probably now my new choice for most favorite game of the Jam so far. Wonderful job!
Haha, I am not good at this. But really cool idea. After selecting more than three instruments, the feedback "I said you should select 3 instruments" really cracked me up for some reason. Great job!
It seems like there's a bug right now where the electric guitar sometimes doesn't have any sound when it's playing the instruments for you to guess. I got it once on the first level and it had the bug, but on level 4 it didn't. Otherwise, this is a really cool idea for a game, I personally couldn't pick out any more than two instruments at a time reliably, but I might well just be bad
@osterzone Thanks for review, the fact that the instruments make no sound while playing the music is not a mistake, it should be so that the player can concentrate better on the song and is not distracted by other sounds. The instruments only play a tone after the music has finished playing.
Nice sort of educational game and cool to see something like that in ludum dare! well executed!
Interesting game! Characters looked clunky and weird in my opinion though...
It was very hard but I enjoyed this game ! It let the player confirm his ability to recognize instrument and this is interesting. I would like a little easier version. Good job !
So funny to play! Amazing entry! I really enjoyed the game, never made to the end though, 6 instruments is too difficult for me haha.
Good. Weird models, but nice entry.
I love this kind of entries, it was nothing I would have expected. Fits the jam's theme perfectly (the more instruments the harder it gets to recognize them). Such as simple, yet super original idea which works like a charm. As a music aficionado I really dig this one, found myself playing for quite a while.
My only suggestion would be being able to "cancel" listening to your selection, as many times you realize pretty fast that it was incorrect, yet you have to listen the sample completely.
Congrats on delivering this, one of my favs so far!
@oceanosaurus We thought about canceling the sounds, but since we ran short on time we needed to cut stuff :/, but thanks for the nice review :)
Very original idea. Good game for hearing training.
Creative, reminds me of my Music classes: "Now, did this piece contain a harpsicord?"
Nice concept! Its differently got difficult in a good way, as it matches the theme :) Well done and all the best! Pls feel free to play and rate my game: https://ldjam.com/events/ludum-dare/40/split
I really quite enjoyed this game, and even though I am a music student it still challenged me quiet a bit. It was really unique, and the interpretation of the theme was done really well. The graphics were simple enough to get the point across, although I would have like a bit more animation or movement, maybe instruments growing as well as the lighting when you click them. The audio was nice and clear and you could hear the instruments, except for the harp. For some reason I always found that the harp was nigh-on impossible to hear. Other than that this was really unique, and I had loads of fun testing my skills on it, great game.
I guess i didnt got the game and maybe it isnt for me but i can see what u were trying to do but it just isnt for mr good game though
I like the idea. And the sounds are realy great. Nice concept and a pretty decent game!
Well, I normally feel pretty bad about my musical skill/aptitude but now I feel especially bad. I was not able to get past the first part. Great idea, just not made for me.
Nice game, It's simple and quirky and I like that, fun to play around with. But the mouse detection seems to be a bit off at least in the browser version. Job well done.
Super interesting entry! It was a bit too hard to me but still was quite fun ahah It's pretty nice thought to keep the correct instruments selected! I think being able to select instruments when the song is still playing could be nice too :)
This game was incredibly fun! Was difficult at times, but very interesting. You included a good variety of different instruments and created a great overall experience. Great job!
Great entry, really interesting and loved it. I'm not very good at instruments, but it was still fun to try this out! :D
Nice idea! Great music. I included it in my Ludum Dare 40 compilation video series, if you’d like to take a look. :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dENfZnM6OQM
very nice music puzzler indeed! I needed to practice a few times before I was able to finish on the easy mode ;) It's an interesting idea as there are not many games like this.
what I think, would be really cool to have is a "hear melody again" button but I guess it's part of the challange. It would also be great to be able to choose instruments while the melody is playing.
I think the piano is not "working" (when it gives focus of light on it).
It would be interesting to be able to listen at a chosen time, allowing the person to prepare for the test (instead of doing it automatically at first).
The art was very cool, as was the concept of using Music and puzzle.