Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → AndideBob
Feedback comments for LD52
AndideBob's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | AndideBob's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 10 10:22:52 | Jigsaw | ♥ 2 | Super fun multiplayer as always, works best on stream with multiple people. The implementation works really well, it would be super fun if you could upload the picture to use for the puzzle. All in all a super impressive Jam Entry. | |
| Jan 10 10:47:08 | 24m 16s | Lil Death | ♥ 3 | This game is great, the on hit death is a bit punishing, but pogoing and getting combos feels so good. A one time shield or something might make the game even more enjoyable. Either way this is super impressive and feels really good. Well done! |
| Jan 10 19:59:19 | 9h 12m | Click On Fish | ♥ 1 | Glad this ended up as good as it is. Was fun watching you make it and it is fun to play it and watch people play it. As people said before this is a classical Pomo game. Really enjoyed it. Job well done! |
| Jan 10 20:14:45 | 15m 26s | Furious Farm: Total Reap-Out | ♥ 1 | Such a good game. The music is a bop, the gameplay is unique and fun, the upgrades make sense and the items are really fun too. I got a score of 244k+. Really enjoyed this. Well done! |
| Jan 10 20:32:26 | 17m 41s | In The Rye | ♥ 1 | I honestly don't know what to say. If I had stopped playing at any point I would have thought WTF, but that one message at the end brought it all together. Really well done, but maybe add a little content warning to the game page. |
| Jan 12 22:04:45 | 49h 32m | Poormetheus | ♥ 1 | An interesting take on the theme, and it is cool that you came up with an alternate conclusion to the story. I like the visuals, and my only complaint is, that the text when you eat the liver is always the same, a little more variety here would have made this a nice round experience for me. Well done! |
| Jan 12 22:09:37 | 4m 52s | Afterlife Assistance Agency | ♥ 1 | What a fun short game! The graphics are super impressive, and the soundtrack together with the soundeffects complements everything very well. I like how chaotic things get, once you get past like 10 souls. My highscore is 15, but maybe I will try again later. Well done! |
| Jan 12 22:57:34 | 47m 57s | Totally Normal Farming Simulator | ♥ 1 | I give up... I found a lot of the things, but some of the puzzles are just too hard for me I guess. I have no idea what to do with the fish, or the anvil, or the lightbulb, and I have tried a lot of things, believe me. If you want to give me a hint, please do. But this is where I gave up: screenshot_tnfs.png All in all this was a fantastic puzzle game, I agree with the sentiment, that the stuff laying around gets too much as some point, but all in all this was super fun and super surprising in what you can create. Well done! |
| Jan 12 23:07:12 | 9m 38s | Dynia | ♥ 1 | This was so good! The chaos is amazing, the fast reset works great and the controls are just precise enough to not be too frustrating. Well done! Also CARS: screenshot_dynia.png |
| Jan 13 08:17:36 | 9h 10m | Rot Waits for No One | ♥ 2 | This was surprisingly stressful, I love how much you got out of this one relatively simple mechanic. The fact that you have to draw newly every single time works really well, but I would love to see some upgrades, which allow me to water multiple tiles at once or something like this. Really well done! |
| Jan 13 09:03:33 | 45m 57s | Veggie Tamer | ♥ 1 | An interesting take on the theme, I found the controls a bit confusing, as well as the fact that you can only do certain actions once. Other than that I had a great time, all the different vegetable types are great, even though the cacarrott is still my favourite. Well done! |
| Jan 13 10:47:39 | 1h 44m | Crowings Do | ♥ 0 | I love the artstyle, and it is a funny take on the theme. It is a bit frustrating, that you can pick up people/crops that are just growing, sometimes a human just chose to grow right were I was landing. Overall this is a fun game though and as I said before, it is super fun to look at! Well done! |
| Jan 14 15:58:39 | 29h 11m | The Pets Over The Innsmouth | ♥ 2 | This was really cool! I loved the artstyle, this was almost like a full on graphic novel! The gameplay was a little bland, but all in all this is a super impressive entry for a jam! Really well done! |
| Jan 14 16:09:42 | 11m 03s | Scattered Seeds | ♥ 1 | An interesting little game, the mechanic of killing enemies to gain their abilities worked really well, I also like that you don't HAVE to use the abilities, therefor the game not becoming impossible if you missed a seed. The game is also really well paced, explaining stuff as you go along, I think that works really nicely. Well done! |
| Jan 14 16:15:16 | 5m 34s | Ethereal Harvest | ♥ 1 | A simple little game, I can easily see this being expanded with different abilities and weapons you unlock with the souls. However I did not feel like I was getting stronger by collecting the souls, all the enemies still took the same amount of hits. Also I think that there should be a little risk reward connected to harvesting the souls, because currently you just kill everything and then harvest. If you had to be fast or something like this it might feel a little more rewarding to harvest the souls. Also, what's with the jumpscare at the end? :D All in all a solid entry, well done! |
| Jan 14 16:23:18 | 8m 02s | Beat & Feast | ♥ 3 | A fun little rythm game, I don't know if there is punishment for hitting the wrong buttons, but I assume so as I got a score of 1 at the end after i was smashing all the keys all the time, but a little visual representation would have been nice. The graphics are super cute though and making a rythm game druing a jam can't have been easy. Well done! |
| Jan 14 16:32:29 | 9m 11s | Scythe | ♥ 0 | Super fun small game! Don't know what to say about it honestly, everything just fits. Maybe a resart button would be nice as I tried to beat your score. AND THEN I DID! crops_cleared.png |
| Jan 14 16:47:22 | 14m 53s | Vegetales - Panic at the Greenhouse | ♥ 4 | What a lovely little game, I gotta say that I am a bit disappointed that your little credits avatars didn't appear as characters in the game! I also would have honestly not minded a few more puzzles with the mechanics you put into place. I mean you even implemented a full on boss fight! This was awesome! |
| Jan 17 06:55:58 | 62h 08m | They Hide in the Fields | ♥ 2 | A really cool take on the theme and a very original idea in general. I love the claustrophobic feel you created when in between the corn. The spacial audio also helps a lot. Really well done! |
| Jan 18 07:51:11 | 24h 55m | Ramming into Trees | ♥ 1 | The game idea is great, however it is a little unclear when you actually lose fruits, there are the sound effects, but a little more of a visual indication might help. Otherwise the game looks and feels great, the only complaint I would have about the controls, is that you have to press B to buy stuff, it might be better if you had like a little gate that you have to drive through to buy. It is also quite hard to read all the text when you are going fast. Okay, enough complaining, the game is great and I had fun playing it, I also like that you end it by going to the game developer. Well done! :D |
| Jan 18 08:25:32 | 34m 21s | Unhappy Beaver | ♥ 2 | A funny little game, I think it would have been a little more intuitive to turn the character straight to where you are pointing the right stick, instead of using it to rotate your character, but that's just personal preference. I love the sound effects even though they were a little loud. I think that nobody would mind if you uploaded a post jam version that also supported another input. Overall what you have here is good, but as it was said before, a little more polish could go a long way! |
| Jan 18 08:32:28 | 6m 56s | Another Veggie Harvester Unit | ♥ 0 | I like the general idea of this, learning about different languages regarding a specific topic. The general implementation is good, I am just wondering if the physics based driving (which was a lot of fun, especially when you don't touch the ground for like 20 seconds straight) was the best method for implementing this idea. Either way, a cute short game with a cool idea. Well done! |
| Jan 18 08:40:25 | 7m 57s | The Dust Harvest | ♥ 1 | A cool little game, as you mentioned the start is quite rough, but once you get the hang of it it is actually quite fun. I could really see this working as a bigger game where you unlock more stuff with your stored harvest, and more enemies and bosses, etc. A solid jam entry! Also I don't understand why you don't want to get rated on graphics, I find the style quite good and it doesn't seem like you used any third party assets. |
| Jan 18 08:49:08 | 8m 43s | M.E.A.T. Rancher 2199 | ♥ 1 | A really satisfying little game, the first time around I got really overwhelmed, but then I realized how the yellow crops are spreading and once you focus on just keeping them under control the game gets almost too easy. I think it could help that once you are full you actually don't cut down the fields anymore, so you are forced to return as fast as possible, because you can't stop the spread anymore while you are full. Just a suggestion. Either way, a little highscore would have been a nice touch too. All in all, well done! |
| Jan 18 08:58:37 | 9m 29s | Garden of Eldritch Delights | ♥ 1 | A super cool idea that could use a little polish. The sound was a bit too loud to start with, some options are always nice. Secondly I though that I had to deliver the fruit my god asked for to them and the fact that whichever plant grows is luck based didn't help there. Then my god suddenly was summoned after the second fruit I gave them, maybe that was a bug, I don't know. Either way unfortunately I only played the game alone, but I can see this being really fun with two players. Also the art is super nice! Well done! |
| Jan 18 09:14:56 | 16m 19s | Turbeets racing | ♥ 2 | Fun little game, but the third level seems too hard for me :D I tried like 10 times and the closest I got was -61. What can I say, the game looks and feels great, could make a fun endless runner. Well done! |
| Jan 18 09:20:40 | 5m 44s | Blighted Crop | ♥ 0 | A cute little game that looks great. I wish I could hold down the mouse button to swing instead of clicking frantically. I think I did quite well: plums.png A fun little experience that I could see expanded in the future with some actual goals to achieve, maybe upgrades that you can buy with your plums to make your harvesting more efficient. Good job! |
| Jan 18 10:03:39 | 42m 59s | Plantus Infestantibus | ♥ 0 | I don't think I can add much to what others have pointed out before. Showing where enemies will attack would be a huge help. Getting reset to level 1 on hit is quite punishing. Otherwise the game looks great and it all fits! I also love the plants vs zombies reference on the first plant. A bit of polish and this could be really great. Well done! |
| Jan 18 13:51:03 | 3h 47m | Fenasi | ♥ 1 | A fun little game, I found the fact that you have to gather all the tools first a little unnecessary, but once you had them the game made sense. I played until all the enemies were defeated and harvested up to 100 life again. You might want to adjust the balancing a little bit, since I felt I spent the most time getting water. All in all a solid entry! |
| Jan 18 14:37:07 | 46m 04s | ORGAN GRINDER | ♥ 3 | Super solid game, the controls work, the upgrades make sense and the overall gameplay is fun. I wish the icons for the currency and the ammo would not be the same, that was a bit confusing at first. But overall this is a super solid, super fun game that I could very well see expanded into something awesome! |
| Jan 18 14:44:01 | 6m 54s | Initial Harvester | ♥ 1 | Fun little game, I think I got a pretty decent score here: harvestmaster.png I honestly have nothing to complain about here, a super solid small game that has me curious if it is possible to harvest everything... Well done! |
| Jan 18 15:00:34 | 16m 33s | Farmula Grain Prix | ♥ 1 | What an amazing game, unfortunately the game crashed (in the web version) as I was trying to buy something when all slots were already taken. Buying fountains early really helped in the late game. I love how you have taken this simple idea and just took it to the moon! Like everything about this feels so good and polished, it reminds me of the flash games of yore. Really well done, definetly one of my favourites this LD! |
| Jan 18 15:14:45 | 14m 11s | Tranquil World | ♥ 1 | A chill little game, but the world felt a little empty. I wish that there was some intention behind the collecting, who am I collecting the fruits for? why are there no animals or other people around. Something like that, maybe a story you can find by exploring. Either way, what you set out to create was a chill experience and I think you managed to do just that. Well done! |
| Jan 18 15:41:58 | 27m 13s | Goblin Sylvester the Mighty Harvester | ♥ 2 | A really awesome game, the graphics are awesome and the 3D and pixelart work so nice together. I wish there was an indicator to what is worth how much, because I just focused on the golden things whenever I could, but that seemed to have worked out: goblin.png All in all an amazing little game! Really well done! |
| Jan 18 15:46:06 | 4m 08s | Corn Cannon | ♥ 1 | What a silly little game, I gave it 3 tries and this is the best score I got: itscorn.png The chill music works nicely with the general stress free atmosphere of the game. I with there was a little sound for charging the cannon and a sound for the corn plopping down. All in all, a solid entry. Well done! EDIT: I also found out that my face is indestructable, so that's neat! |
| Jan 20 16:03:44 | 48h 17m | Body Harvesters | ♥ 1 | This was awesome! Felt like a good flash game of old. I wish for more honestly, more buildings to place, more enemies, and maybe a little faster gameplay curve (the beginning of the game stretches a good bit). humans_harvested.png Honestly, this was awesome! Well done! |
| Jan 20 17:23:40 | 1h 19m | Harvest Song | ♥ 1 | A funny little rythm game where you have to hit the beet (get it?)! This was simple but great, and the idea of making a rythm based game during a jam still blows my mind. Really impressive that you pulled it off! |
| Jan 20 19:30:16 | 2h 06m | Shield Bash | ♥ 1 | A fun game so far, with tight mechanics, however a little bit too hardcore for my taste, I couldn't even beat the first boss and I gave it a good few tries. Some indication of how much health the boss has left would help out (not necessarily a health bar, but just something visual). I tried fighting the mage as well, however I am unsure how my new ability is supposed to help me in the fight... But maybe this is just not my kind of game, sorry. But as I said the implementation and the controls are tight, I could see this going somewhere, and an audience is clearly there! |
| Jan 20 21:44:23 | 2h 14m | LD52 Moonlight | ♥ 2 | What a fun little game with a lot of potential, the mechanic of planting your health to get it back increased is a cool idea, however once your health is full and you play rather careful you don't really have to use it anymore. Some more enemies and actual character development on levelup could make this a really interesting game though. Either way, for a jam this is really impressive, graphic and gameplay wise! |
| Jan 20 22:08:30 | 24m 07s | Cardwork Cycle | ♥ 1 | This was super cool! I am really impressed with how well your balancing works! The cards are all intelligently designed and the mechanics of the game are super easy to pick up. I am surprised that you did not add AOE damage cards, instead the vampirie blast felt a bit overpowered. Either way I could really see this developing into something truly awesome, all the groundwork is done. Really well done! |
| Jan 20 22:16:21 | 7m 51s | When It's Harvest Time | ♥ 1 | What a weirdly intriguing experience... I am not sure first person works best for this type of game, since you tend to run backwards into stuff, also getting to the vending machine got hard after a while. I wish there was a way to skip the "intro" as it was a bit tedious after the 3rd or 4th time. All in all this was a super fun short experience! Well done! |
| Jan 21 16:06:48 | 17h 50m | Salvage City | ♥ 1 | An interesting game, I think that the controls would feel a little nicer if they worked like this: - up key -> accelerate - down key -> slow down - left and right -> rotate head left or right But that is just my preference. I loved and am really impressed by how well the destruction of the buildings works and was quite surprised by the ending of placing the buildings. A really cool entry with some impressive tech in there. Well done! |
| Jan 21 16:20:02 | 13m 14s | Star Journey of a Little Fur Seal | ♥ 0 | What an interesting little game, the little twist with everything changing was fun and caught me really of guard the first time around. I like the way the game controls, I am just wondering if it would be a little more fun to control if the spinning changed direction on every click. That way you still have to wait sometimes, but it would make it easier to go in a straight line. Either way the graphics and soundscape work nicely. Well done! |
| Jan 21 16:42:15 | 22m 13s | Wheat World | ♥ 1 | God this game feels so good! The platforming is super tight and challenging (I would love a gamepad controlled version!). Please make more of this, this was so cool, I can't imagine the shenanigans you could come up with the corn cobs and carrots combined. Seriously this is so well done! One of my favourites this LD for sure! |
| Jan 25 10:40:42 | 89h 58m | Hey can you go harvest those cave mushrooms for me, thanks | ♥ 1 | Wow! What a really cool game. I love the static controls in a 3D environment. It felt very smooth. The graphics are awesome and give off an awesome mood! I didn't finish the game due to time, but I was expecting a horror element at any point! My favourite effect is how everything get pitchblack when the torch runs out and slowly fades back to a low light. Really well done, I hope to see more of this in the future! |
| Jan 25 19:56:51 | 9h 16m | Speed Farmer | ♥ 1 | I gotta say I am baffled by the times people here in the comments got... I stumbled around for like 5 minutes before I harvested my first crop :D Once I got the hang of it it went a little smoother though. I must say you have done great work here for a jam game! The visuals are nice, the mechanics work, and I love the little world you built. Really well done! |
| Jan 25 20:09:35 | 12m 44s | Cookie Typer! | ♥ 1 | A weird idea of a game, strangely captivating (even though I was basically hoping for something more to happen). I wish there was just more to do, like more upgrades, other ways of investing your money. It also bothered me, that the letter I typed showed up as upper and lower case, even though it did not make a difference for the submitting. If you are looking to keep working on this I think it could be fun to make the things you type actual recipies for different types of cookies (the same 20 words over and over get boring after a short while). And then just think of how the player could use their money. |
| Jan 25 20:18:43 | 9m 08s | You Will Be Fertiliser. | ♥ 1 | What a cool concept! The progression felt really good until I hit the 3rd quest, then it got really stressful and I once to to missing only 2 wheat... but eventually I gave up. I would love to see this with some more balancing and even more challenges. The mechanic of using your death is super cool. Really well done! |
| Jan 25 22:05:12 | 1h 46m | Star Tech: Deep Space Mine | ♥ 1 | Finally got around to playing your game! I saw a bunch of the making on stream, and I gotta say it turned out just as nice as I expected it to. The mechanic is super unique and works really well. I do believe that there might be some balancing still to be done, but overall this was fun and really satisfying if you actually got a good combo going that worked even after a ring was turning. Really well done! |
| Jan 26 09:54:16 | 11h 49m | Cursor Farm | ♥ 0 | Okay, I give up... I got everything maxed out, I farmed like crazy and near the end I even found a bug which let me max out my money. But I just can't get that last achievement... (The bug is, that you can click the produce (like bacon) when it flies away to the top right, so if you keep clicking it there, you constantly get the money for every click) pigs.png All in all a very addictive little idle/clicker game! I turned the sound off at some point and just played it on the side. I think the farms could be a bit more rewarding, or their ticks a bit faster than what feels like 10 seconds. But I played this for a good hour, so I really can't say that it gets boring or mundane. Well done! |
| Jan 26 14:45:08 | 4h 50m | FARM 64 | ♥ 2 | What a fun shooter, I am sad that my score was not submitted and I gotta say that I am a bit disappointed by the fact that the british tractor did not speak with an accent or overly posh. All in all this is a solid little game, but I think the ammo on the weapons is either to low for how "weak" they feel, or they just need to be stronger. The mechanic of opening up different areas with the currency is cool, but I mostly found myself growing health and then running from one health spot to the next, because the most effective weapon was the scythe, so I also constantly took damage. The pathing around the hill is a bit broken for the lawnmowers, so they are no threat once you go a bit up the slope. Oh and also the tractors kept spawning in the maze for me and then just kinda floating in the air without moving, don't know what's that about. As I said all in all a very solid game that could be super fun with a bit of balancing and some polish. |
| Jan 26 21:14:37 | 6h 29m | Frozen Dragon | ♥ 2 | A super cute little farming game, I found the mechanic of having to switch back to your hand a little confusing but after I got used to it this was a really pleasant experience. The graphics are awesome and the music and sound effects work really nicely to underline the general chill tone of the game. Well done! |
| Jan 27 06:56:16 | 9h 41m | dungeon soul harvest | ♥ 1 | An interesting idea the reverse tower defense. But you should try to explain the game and controls a bit better. For those who are stuggling to do anything (like me for the first 5 minutes): - Right click with the shovel builds paths, while left click removes them - With the arrows you can move your sphere thingy anywhere with a path - Every piece of level you build costs souls, every piece you remove gives you souls - Spikes or water, once placed can not be removed - Once you have a path between the staris and your green sphere thingy, hit play and watch the magic happen I don't think the little cross thingy does anything, and in the web version the buttons just stopped working at some point, thankfully there is the download version. I think you have something really interesting here that when expanded could turn into a very fun game. I would love to see where you could take this. A nice prototype for a jam though, well done! |
| Jan 27 07:16:55 | 20m 39s | Delivery Boy | ♥ 1 | A moody little game, especially once it gets later and the lighting comes into play. 2 times I did not manage to collect all the resources, always one short (I almost feel like the game is designed to make me fail). I loved the art, every sprite looks so good. I almost wish there was more, and also a sense of danger (maybe buried mines or something, so nothing too actiony but rather looming dread). All in all an nice entry with a good bit of potential. Well done! |
| Jan 27 10:14:50 | 2h 57m | Call of the Harvest | ♥ 1 | There is a lot in this game, the overworld looks interesting and I think you could do a lot (like hiding upgrade for the battle etc). The battles themselves are cool with each enemy having it's own kinda mechanic, not bad, however the hitboxes seem a bit weird, like I got hit a bunch of times without touching anything. As for the story I don't even know what's going on, but I assume some eldrich chenanigans are going down. All in all I think you might have bitten of more than you can chew for a jam, but ended up with something solid either way. Also maybe you will find the time to update the game page description after all :P All in all a good entry for a gamejam! |
| Jan 27 11:01:26 | 46m 36s | Basket Catch | ♥ 1 | A cute game that reminded me of some old flash games! I was surprised that I could use any element as often as I wanted, but in the end it turned out good, because I would not have managed some levels without putting down like 10 rocks in a row. Really well done! |
