Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD46 → Feedback comment stats → Kiln

Kiln

Feedback comments for LD46

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Kiln's comment
Apr 21 17:52:21		Tiny Fragments	♥ 1	Great game, I loved the animations for when he went between frames. The music wasn't too distracting and fit well with the game. If I had to make a suggestion, and really this isn't something that's NECESSARY just something that could be, but maybe add a pause button for when you have to make quick adjustments. For me it was fine, but I know some people can't make rapid decisions which could lead to frustration. Overall though, 10/10 game. :)
Apr 21 18:04:45	12m 24s	Lich Clicker	♥ 2	I loved the voice over, that was a great touch that I've not seen anywhere else. Very humorous game. Obviously, from a gameplay perspective it's a little simplistic, but I don't mind that. I'm a big fan of clicker games so it wins on that point alone.
Apr 21 18:07:21	2m 36s	Remember, Apollo	♥ 1	Amazing game. I loved the self-contained mini-story, it was very good. Definitely gave me an "Oh S---" moment at the end. The music was great. The mechanics were a little weird at times, like when you'd bounce into another room on accident and completely skip a checkpoint, but other than that, 10/10.
Apr 21 18:10:22	3m 01s	Happy Life	♥ 5	I loved how well this fit the theme, it probably fits the theme more than most. As noted as a known bug, my game did crash near the end, but that's fine. Overall, the game was fun. I think my only slight criticism was that the options to respond to your wife go away a little TOO fast compared to everything else. Sometimes I'd barely have enough time to read what she'd said before the responses disappeared.
Apr 21 18:15:24	5m 02s	ADRENA-LINE	♥ 0	Simple, yet fun and addicting. I definitely played 4-5 times. I like that it stays on the screen you lost at so you're able to see where you went wrong.
Apr 21 18:17:41	2m 17s	The Dragon's Curse	♥ 2	I'm assuming the music wasn't yours because you opted out, but nevertheless it was a great choice. Very fitting to the game itself, and even if it wasn't yours, picking the right music is still important. I loved the game, very Oregon Trail-like in gameplay I think, but definitely your own. It plays like an Interactive Fiction game which is fun.
Apr 21 18:25:30	7m 49s	Pass it On	♥ 2	This was fun. I'm not too sure how it fit the theme, but regardless the concept is neat and not one I've seen done before as an online game. I remember playing this in middle school drama class, so it definitely brought back some memories.
Apr 21 18:36:42	11m 12s	Embers	♥ 0	I loved everything about this game. The blending for the shadows, the art style, the music, the gameplay, everything. I especially loved the fire particles coming off from her hair, just a really nice touch.
Apr 21 18:40:29	3m 47s	Dog Feeder	♥ 1	I don't know if this was intended or not, but boy were the controls wonky to use. The concept was fine, but it was really awkward to switch from using the mouse to click the UI to having to quickly swap to the keyboard, using unusual keys no less, to control the game. I think I'd lose every level the first time because I couldn't get my hands in the right place fast enough. I think either having a small countdown at the start of each level would fix this, otherwise maybe switching the keys to something easier to use like WASD or arrow keys.
Apr 21 18:44:35	4m 06s	King's Table	♥ 1	I loved this concept! Great re-purposing of chess pieces. The balancing might be slightly off, I felt like I wasn't getting nearly that many coins-per-kill compared to just how much any of the pieces cost, but at the same time on the first level a single bishop swept nearly every wave, so I don't know.
Apr 21 19:11:15	26m 40s	Mycelium	♥ 2	I loved the art direction for this game, it's very uniform and cute-yet-creepy at the same time (and I mean creepy in a good way). I was a little confused for a bit what to do from the get-go, but I eventually got the hang of it. Nice and interesting concept!
Apr 21 19:18:10	6m 55s	The Game of our Lives	♥ 1	Beautiful non-game, and pseudo-tribute to Conway! It definitely has a very peaceful and relaxing vibe to it, and while yes it's very simple, it's still fun in a way.
Apr 21 19:30:37	12m 27s	Woodpunk	♥ 1	I want a full game in this art style alone. I don't even care what it's about, the game is just amazing! The audio was amazing. The controls were great. Honestly, it's a wonder how y'all did this in three days, it's just insane.
Apr 21 19:58:11	27m 34s	Body and Soul	♥ 1	This is a clear winner if I ever saw one. I loved the snappiness the game had, and the effects for each upgrade were great, my favourite was the sword for sure. It felt very fun to use.
Apr 21 20:01:24	3m 13s	Matchstick Elegy	♥ 1	While not my favourite gameplay-wise, I definitely won't knock it in that department. The game is well-made with neat mechanics. I love the concept of the logs having two sides to burn to extend their duration, that was smart. The audio was good as well. Overall an enjoyable game.
Apr 21 20:06:17	4m 53s	L♪vely Rhythm	♥ 0	I love the concept. I'm not hugely into rhythm games myself, but I can definitely see this being enjoyable. The music was also nice and easy to follow.
Apr 21 20:20:30	14m 13s	Holy Plague	♥ 3	A really interesting take on the idea of "keep it alive". I loved the art style and the ability to choose which side to be on, very cool!
Apr 21 20:30:24	9m 54s	Keep "IT" Alive	♥ 1	Very hard game, but nevertheless an interesting concept! I liked the audio cues, very fitting with the pressure of the game.
Apr 21 20:35:50	5m 26s	The Ludum Dare Flame 🔥	♥ 1	This game is so simple yet so interesting. I've never seen a multiplayer idle game before but I hope I see more of them now because it's such a neat and interesting idea. It's like sitting in an IRC channel chatting with strangers, but being able to do something menial while you chat. It's like sitting around an actual fire in the middle of a forest. Amazing!
Apr 21 21:31:42	55m 52s	Dragon Drop	♥ 1	Very cute game. Admittedly, I was a bit confused at first, but I quickly got the hang of it. Neat little puzzle game.
Apr 21 23:59:11	2h 27m	Fire Age	♥ 3	I love the fog idea, that was a nice touch to the game. It did feel like the game was maybe a bit too zoomed out, I don't know. It feels like it could've been zoomed in just a tad more, but other than that an overall nice game!
Apr 22 01:41:36	1h 42m	Look back	♥ 1	I love the art style for this game. The concept is good too. I could definitely see this being fleshed out into an entire game!
Apr 22 04:18:34	2h 36m	Lost Goblins	♥ 1	An interesting puzzle game! Great use of the theme, and the art style is actually pretty neat. While being low-res, it almost gives me an old school Windows 95 kind of vibe. Nice work!
Apr 22 04:20:55	2m 21s	Slime Mama	♥ 2	This was a fun game to play! It's so simple yet so satisfying to just lob objects everywhere and the art style is cute. I especially liked the animation for when Mama Slime respawns the Baby Slime. Very nice!
Apr 22 04:38:04	17m 09s	MACHINA	♥ 1	Phenomenal game, I hope the teaser that more is to come was accurate because I want more. I love minimalist games like this, they always looks very sleek and well-made. The shaders for the dialogue were nice, and the background animation was a great touch to keep the background from being wasted. I'd love to see more levels and variety added in the future!
Apr 22 04:45:12	7m 08s	platformEGG	♥ 1	Cute game. Graphics and audio were on point! Bit harsh having to restart when you die, but understandable. I lost once because I threw the egg on a platform over some spikes and the egg sat on the edge and slowly slid off, which of course made me go "WTH?" but it's cool that you programmed it to behave in such a way that that happens so KUDOS TO THAT. 😃
Apr 22 05:01:35	16m 23s	Bard: Keep the Story Alive	♥ 1	Very cute game. Loved the little noises they made instead of talking, I'm a big fan of game gibberish. Interesting concept too that I could see being fleshed out a bit more.
Apr 22 05:11:08	9m 33s	Desktop Garden	♥ 1	Hugely cute idea. I love that you added a peaceful mode too, I like having it just sit there on my screen. I kind of want more games like this. The idea is so simple yet so fascinating.
Apr 22 05:20:10	9m 02s	Genomix	♥ 2	Very cute game. I definitely could see this expanded, and heck, I could even see it being used as an educational tool of sorts as well, if done properly.
Apr 22 05:34:53	14m 43s	Last Healer	♥ 2	Very appealing art style and an interesting concept. Never seen a game where you play as the healer in a dungeon crawl. Add in some Music/SFX and I think this could be a pretty fun game!
Apr 22 05:52:03	17m 10s	A Night In The Dark	♥ 1	Very cute game. I liked the shader for the darkness, that was nice. Also interesting having the enemy be unkillable so they're a constant threat. Overall, a pretty decent concept. 😄
Apr 22 06:05:46	13m 43s	Flood	♥ 1	Interesting game. I could just be bad, but I did find it a tad challenging, even from the get-go. The wall jump mechanic felt a bit off to me, but again that could just be me. Overall, the art style was good. Very cute game.
Apr 22 06:19:51	14m 05s	Turtle Daddy	♥ 2	Love love love the art for this game. The audio is perfect. The gameplay is very smooth and responsive. You did good!
Apr 22 06:25:18	5m 27s	Straying Alive	♥ 0	Simplistic graphics actually worked for this game. At first I thought it was an Agar.io clone, which to be fair it is very similar, but it's not exactly the same thing which definitely works in it's favor. Needs some kind of SFX or background music to go along with it maybe, but overall good job!
Apr 22 06:36:59	11m 41s	The joys of parenthood	♥ 2	Interesting little minigame-game. Bit confusing at first, but when I got the hang of it, it was kinda fun! And for PICO-8, the graphics aren't bad.
Apr 22 06:43:40	6m 41s	Beer Tavern	♥ 1	Interesting concept! Kind of reminds me of Tiny Tower (a mobile game) which I used to spend unreasonable amounts of time playing. The graphics are also simple, yet fun nevertheless.
Apr 22 07:37:31	53m 51s	Keep Me Breathing	♥ 2	Beautifully done artwork. The audio was nice. The concept was great, I especially loved the RGB slider mechanic. It seems like a somewhat difficult game to balance however. My plant died because the temperature gauge kept fluctuating rapidly and it didn't matter how fast I was at changing it, the temp wouldn't go up/down fast enough to reach it in time before it died. Overall though, phenomenal job!
Apr 22 07:46:51	9m 20s	Dorfromantik	♥ 3	Gorgeous game! Gives me Settlers of Catan vibes which is a game I absolutely adore. I can't wait to see what this game becomes!
Apr 22 08:01:57	15m 06s	DOC+ORS	♥ 1	Interesting concept. I love the art direction. I was a bit confused at first with what I was doing, but I eventually got the hang of it I think. Still left a pile of corpses cause that's just what I do 😎
Apr 22 08:21:46	19m 49s	Tumble Baby	♥ 1	I hate slider puzzles, but that doesn't mean I don't like this game. It's very cute, aesthetically pleasing, and an overall nice concept. I did get stuck when the baby crawled into the pit w/ the guns and there's no reset button so that was that, but overall it was a fun game.
Apr 22 16:03:08	7h 41m	Social Distancing For LadyBugs	♥ 1	The sound effects worked well for this game, and while it may not be the most complex of games it does what it does really well which is good. A recommendation I would make, if any, would be to reward the player for hitting more at a time, and giving the player an audio cue for that. Beyond that, it's a simple, but well-made game.
Apr 22 16:30:51	27m 43s	Sunlit	♥ 3	I got to around 103 before stopping. It's a very lovely game with a great concept. At one point my tree did grow through one of the circles, which made trimming it a bit odd but I did get through it so that was mostly fine. The only criticism I can see giving this is to perhaps "prettify" the background. There was a squirrel in there, maybe have it interact with the tree somehow, or scurry off, I don't know. You could also use actual trees to block light instead of misc. shapes, and maybe have us trim those to keep the tree alive. But even without those ideas, the game itself is great.
Apr 22 17:38:59	1h 08m	My Mother is a Caravan?	♥ 5	The overall concept is good. The artwork is nice, especially in the intro scene. Could do with a little more visual feedback when the player is hit. I know you've got that hit animation and the audio cue which is good, but when you're fighting enemies, the audio from swinging your sword and your focus being drawn towards the enemies kind of detracts from that, making it harder to notice when you're hit. A good and quick screen shake or screen flash would definitely help this aspect, but other than that, your game is great. Nice job!
Apr 23 00:41:02	7h 02m	OwOrbit	♥ 1	Nice art direction, bit difficult at times. Sometimes it's a little unavoidable. I understand balancing is probably difficult with this type of game, so best of luck to you on that should you continue this project. Beyond that, it's not a half bad game.
Apr 23 00:52:12	11m 10s	Coronary Flypass	♥ 0	Great audio. Took me a second to understand that you need to try to lift off a few times. Had a cool time where a pigeon knocked the heart out but I caught it again. Not a bad concept overall, the liftoff was the only thing I had some issues with.
Apr 23 01:30:04	37m 52s	THE SECRET FLAME	♥ 2	Gorgeous game. I love the music and the particles of the flame especially. I can see this being a whole game, and I hope one day it is!
Apr 24 04:11:21	26h 41m	Pro Fishing: The Fishing Mini-Game Game	♥ 1	The graphics are very lovely, very GBA-like. The controls are nice, though a touch tricky to get the hang of initially. I wasn't sure if I was clicking on the bubbles, or how to aim for the bubbles. There is quite a bit of content in this though, for a Jam game, which is really nice. Good job!
May 12 19:01:34	446h 50m	Keeper of the Flame	♥ 1	I loved the music, really gave me a Zelda-vibe. I felt like I was in a dungeon in the original NES Zelda which is definitely a huge plus for me. The mechanics are solid. I failed a few times but I never really felt like it was the game's fault, which is good. The art style was good. I liked the added touch of the grates in the background actually dumping water into the room, I thought that was nice. The "Flame Doused" and "Brazier Lit" animations were also well done. I think my only slight criticism might be just the control scheme is a little off, but that might just be a me thing. Using the arrow keys was fine, but having my fingers on A, S, and X seemed a bit off. Maybe something like Z, X, C might do better, or any combo where all your fingers are on one line on the keyboard, I don't know. Clearly I'm just nitpicking at this point. The game overall was great as-is. 😄