skywolf 2013-12-17 08:44
I rather liked it, only one thing i didn't like, the difficulty was not consistent:
1) medium
2) easy
3) very easy
4) easy
5) hard
...
what's up with that? :P
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD28 → Shooting Atoms For Peace
By mephi
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 1 | 100 | ||
| Fun | 81 | 3.47 | ||
| Audio | 164 | 3.22 | ||
| Overall | 169 | 3.31 | ||
| Theme | 194 | 3.02 | ||
| Innovation | 200 | 3.05 | ||
| Graphics | 299 | 3.11 | ||
| Mood | 380 | 2.59 | ||
| Humor | 387 | 1.91 |
I rather liked it, only one thing i didn't like, the difficulty was not consistent:
1) medium
2) easy
3) very easy
4) easy
5) hard
...
what's up with that? :P
That is a sweet game..! Nice work..!
I was waiting for the colours to start having an effect...
Also, when I reached the end and tried to start again, a second instance of the music started playing, and it said I was in level 12, and had a permanent Failed screen...
Nice chain reaction games! Having double music running on my laptop. More level and item type will be great!
@SkyWolf, thanks! Yes we, didn't get to sort the levels by difficulty.
@Xeke_Death, thanks! That is an interesting idea about the colors. The level 12 and the music are bugs, I'll fix them in a post-jam version :)
@harsanalif - the same about the music bug. Hopefully we'll add more levels if we continue it.
I can agree on what SkyWOlf said:
1) medium
2) easy
3) very easy
4) easy
5) too hard
…
I would have tried more times if not every time the level would reset.
I found it hard to see where the neutrons were going even there was a grid. Maybe some sort of mouse-hover effect would help.
I won't rate the art because I don't know which of the sprites are your work. I can just say that they are good chosen. ;-)
Nevertheless of my critique I liked it. Pretty solid work.
Good puzzle game. Would be nice if the atoms and cannon keep their position after a retry.
Level 5 after level 4 was uhh... D:
Is that even crossable? Tried many variations, but couldn't get past, and I really wanted to play the whole thing. :(
The concept is really cool, the graphics are fitting and I'm digging the track otherwise!
@Cbeed - thanks for the feedback!
After reading what koller-digital wrote, I think you maybe right about the resetting of the level. It probably creates more useless burden for the player than "joy of beating the hard difficulty".
@Diptoman - yes that's beatable! But really takes some thinking...
Thanks for the kind words!
Fun little game! If I could change one thing it would probably be to keep the position of all things between tries. But other than that it was great!
Very enjoyable little game.
This game is a jewel, but i think the first level is quite hard than others, however good job, i love it!
Nice concept, but poorly executed. I agree with the remarks on difficulty progression as well as the rotations of nodes reseting when you press 'retry' was confusing and frustrating, I could see this being quite addictive if done right though :D
Cool game. It'd be good if the cannon (and maybe the atoms - but that could make it too easy) kept the rotation after each shot. I spent ages plotting out a level only to have the cannon fire off in its default direction, screwing it all up :(
Great idea! But really confused way to design levels. More organized ones and increasing difficulty would be better! :)
Nice work!
Nice concept, agree the difficulty was a bit erratic and some levels you didn't even need to move anything, just press shoot. Level 10 was really good and challenging, then the final level was very easy in comparison. And also agree it would be better to not revert all your moves back when you retry a level.
Anyway overall an enjoyable game, nice job!
Small bug: After you finish the game the music starts playing twice
interesting concept! i liked it. maybe adding a reset to default function along witht he saving rotations after failing would be good
Very neat game. I have only two complaints:
1. The game is too easy, too the point where you don't even have to do anything on some level (even on the later ones, level 7, for example)
2. The level state resets when you "lose" and you have to rotate everything again.
Nice puzzle game but the difficulty curve was very inconsistent.
As others have said: difficulty was weird. Also, it would be über-cool if the atoms rotations didn't reset on restart. I don't know if part of the mechanic is remembering how did you spin those atoms, but it was a process mostly of trial and error. You could, for example, allow shooting more times, but give an special award for making the level with the least shoots, or the fastest time to reaction.
Very nice and polished game. The difficulty curve was strange indeed but otherwise it's a hit.
Thank you guys for the feedback!
I've uploaded a post-jam version where most of the issues are addressed - check the details on top.
@torcado194 - yes i thought of adding "reset" after I made it to keep the positions (as everyone seems to wanted it). but it's still missing. for now you can do it by refreshing the webpage, it will keep your progress but reset your level.
@chiguireitor - Allowing more shoots would negate the theme, you only got one neutron to start the reaction :) Otherwise, outside of the theme it's an option. The fastest time for reaction and counting less rotations is also a thing I thought about. Definitely would go in if I continue the game.
Indeed multiple shots would break the theme. I think this is the kind of puzzle that would probably thrive on mobile, does your codebase support that?
Great game!
I liked the style and the SFX, I liked the mechanics and the level design, but I didn't like at all the difficulty curve. Fix that and you'll have a great game.
Nice art.
I had a strange bug where the same settings didn't always produce the same result. (i.e. something flying in one direction sometimes hit things on its path, and sometimes it didn't)
Really tight game, and stupidly addictive. Well done :)
Nice game, i like it! :)
Pretty great puzzle game. Really enjoyed it. Would help if it was more obvious when molecules weren't aligned with each other, though, so you can plan better
Wow, very nice game indeed! Very enjoyable puzzle which is easy to understand :) The chain-reactions are also pretty cool to watch. The music is awesome by the way! One of the most harmonious games so far
Interesting idea :)
Fun game, really liked the music!
Awesome game, nice mechanics, addictive, nice graphics and sounds / soundtrack. Planning to release it on mobile devices? it could be a good idea.
Cool puzzle game!
Really enjoyable, good job. :D
Fun and addictive puzzle! The audio didn't work for me for some reason (so I haven't rated it) but that didn't impact my enjoyment at all. A solid LD entry, fun to play and original! Well done!
Thank you everyone for the comments and the feedback!
@chiguireitor - yes, being javascript game it will run on mobile. Phaser has some resolution detection methods too, but I'll probably rewrite it in another tech for mobile.
@netmute - yes, this bug is happening in the original version. In the post jam one it's fixed.
@henrykun - yes, I am thinking about mobile version.
@steamgirl - thanks for the kind words! In what browser did you play it? I forgot to write it's best played in Chrome or latest FireFox. There you should have audio too.
Solid little puzzle game, only complaint is that the background pattern made discerning the projectile path a little difficult.
Nice solid game, I played the post-Jam version as I couldn't figure out the first level of the Jam version. But it's a lovely made puzzle game, which you don't see too often in LD.
Great game!
I believe, that you yould sort the levels a bit differently, because I had the feeling, that the dificulty was swinging up and down a little.
Besides that, the graphics look great and the music is nice too.
Nice work, keep it on :)
This is fun, but I don't like how the configuration of the atoms resets when it fails :/
Great gameplay! Level 11 is very very hard!!
A little bug! When the game is finish and replay! There is an increment level (level 12) and the game is empty.
Yay. So many games with Phaser this LD. Shot guide lines would be useful - and persistent rotation state.
Neat game. I really liked the chain-reaction concept.
It was a fun game, although it started to get extremely difficult and a little bit brain-melting when I had to try to keep track of all the rotation combos that I hadn't tried yet. The music was amazing, and the sound effects were perfect.
Very very fun! Special kudos for game design <3