Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD49 → Feedback comment stats → pcmaster
Feedback comments for LD49
pcmaster's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | pcmaster's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 4 07:31:26 | Un Stabled | ♥ 1 | The screaming got me, felt very fulfilling :D I tore it down! Thanks for having played mine as well. With yours, people won't have to turn off the music at least. What a shame, you didn't find time for some sounds as well. Good job still! :) | |
| Oct 4 07:52:37 | 21m 11s | UNTetris | ♥ 1 | Impressive. I love the polished graphics. The music is absolutely fitting. It isn't very hard and controlling it with mouse is a bit cumbersome but I didn't care :) I would totally take this a step further and release the game, improving the controls a bit and perhaps making it less physics based and more logic based. A very good job and a totally solid entry, congratz! |
| Oct 4 09:33:29 | 1h 40m | The Unstable Zone | ♥ 1 | This was totally unexpected. I love the tenser and tenser music. Also the flashback change of style. I managed to escape and now I wonder if there's more to find, I'll try to play again. A good entry :) |
| Oct 4 09:37:42 | 4m 13s | You won't believe your result from this personality test! | ♥ 2 | LOL! As an IMBAD you often lose yourself in thought - which isn’t necessarily a bad thing - and lose yourself in supermarkets - which definitely is. ‘HOW DO I GET OUT OF HERE’, you howl at the yoghurt, hoping that a staff member will hear you and come to your rescue. They never do. The yoghurt is indifferent. It's true. And the supermarket part is SO true for me. I now start to suspect the yoghurt! |
| Oct 4 10:13:26 | 35m 44s | Fission Horse in The Escape From the Condemned Stables | ♥ 1 | Poor fission horsie, how he's sweatin' :D It's very good that it 'auto-saves' at the start of each section/sub-level. Pretty tricky. Very nice. Love the pixel art. Love the sounds. Love the hardcore oldskool physics. I didn't get past the long jump though 🤔 An awesome job! |
| Oct 4 10:38:44 | 25m 18s | Help me there are buildings falling from the sky onto my precious mountain | ♥ 2 | You absolutely nailed the theme. I managed 98 buildings on my 2nd try with a score of 2825. A very funny little game. Love the sounds and music, perfect. Also the crappy sticky physics, awesome :) Congratz!!! |
| Oct 4 11:45:56 | 1h 07m | Stabilaser | ♥ 1 | Very nice pixel art, music and little puzzles. The WebGL mouse controls were problematic for me (latest Firefox) as it didn't capture the mouse and I ran into screen borders, without the in-game cursor reacting properly. Consider also compiling a Win64 version or verifying that playing WebGL in a window is fine. |
| Oct 4 12:11:53 | 25m 57s | Unstable Mines | ♥ 2 | This was smooooooth! The graphics are so simple that I'd just leave them almost like this for a final product. Big plus for the sounds and the music. A very great job, indeed! :) |
| Oct 4 15:14:37 | 3h 02m | Beep Boop Boba | ♥ 2 | This was sleeeeek! Love the sounds, the graphics, the animations. Extra points for making everything out of Unity cubes/voxels. It is incredibly intuitive, just like Overcooked. Btw, do I have to serve the customers in order or can I hand out what I have out of order? An awesomely strong entry, congratz! :) |
| Oct 4 15:39:23 | 24m 46s | Unstable Engines | ♥ 0 | I managed to finish. The control for forward and right never changed for me, only reverse and left. Still a nice entry, very good you made it, congratz!!! You should opt out of audio, perhaps? :) It works just fine in Firefox 92. |
| Oct 5 06:56:28 | 15h 17m | Larry the Vengeful Balloon | ♥ 1 | Hahaha, shout out for another one-button game. Love it. I think you chose very well to invest time into polish (the bent screen effect), the music and sounds are top-notch. The graphics are more than adequate. The game plays very smoothly. Not sure what to add - ship this commercially today? :) |
| Oct 5 07:39:21 | 42m 53s | Un Stabl | ♥ 2 | A horsey shoutout 🐴 Very unstable, indeed! I actually like the graphics, especially the crazy eyes. I love and hate at the same time how the horse slides off the edges of crates. Pretty hardcore. Good job :) |
| Oct 5 09:43:52 | 2h 04m | Earthquake City Builder | ♥ 0 | I managed to survive into a state with population 540, where I withstand any earthquake. Love the boxy graphics. The UI and controls are sometimes suboptimal but it can be fixed. I'd make the healthbars smaller. The game is very nice to continue investing into :) It is also definitely a game I've played the longest so far, congratz :) |
| Oct 5 15:30:07 | 5h 46m | Stack Droid Saves The Party | ♥ 1 | Duuuude, that walk animation 🤣 I love the sounds, the graphics in general, the dialogues, the physics. The only thing a bit weird was the camera. An awesome, cute, BIG, polished and strong entry, congratz!!! |
| Oct 6 13:46:30 | 22h 16m | Potions for Dummies | ♥ 3 | I love that Ievan Polkka tune in the intro music :) Very elaborate, nice. The intro is awesome, as mentioned. The controls are pretty solid. I, too, had hard time understanding what's happening with each ingredient but that's maybe because I should play it at home outside of work as well for a bit longer :) A very PRO entry, guys :) |
| Oct 6 13:57:46 | 11m 16s | Plate Spinner 2021 | ♥ 1 | I love your game. Very straightforward, nicely executed. What somehow didn't work for me were gamepad controls over WebGL. The character movement is very imprecise and I had a feeling that some of my button/joystick actions were not registered (Firefox 92, RTX 2080). Nevertheless, congrats, a lovely game! |
| Oct 6 14:09:46 | 12m 00s | Icecream Crusher | ♥ 2 | I've won with 4000! It actually did feel very satisfying when that last ice-cream got him down! I love everything: graphics, sounds, the fluidity, the attacks, the intro... Congratz on this game, I really liked playing it. Extra thumbs up for a 1-button-game :) |
| Oct 6 15:56:17 | 1h 46m | Unstable98.exe | ♥ 2 | LOOOOOOOOOOL! That xhamster, doooodes :D I'm laughing since I've installed that virus for the first time :) On my 4th try I thought I had it figured out. But a second or two were missing before 'success'... I really haven't figured out how to use our long forgotten hero ;( It's just hovering on the windows... Hilarious, brings back memories, thank you for making this! So polished also! |
| Oct 7 08:23:26 | 16h 27m | Forecards | ♥ 2 | Very nice! I love the little animations and the graphics in general. The music and sounds are exceptional. A better (visual) feedback when something happens would be nice; when an element hits a card, putting it back into the hand doesn't seem enough. Then I wasn't quite sure of the collider sizes -- whether a city will be hit or not. Also elements coming from the bottom of the screen are hard to detect because that's where the hand with your cards is, it's just obstructing a little. Also the wordplay in the name and the level of English is top! It plays very smoothly. All in all, VERY beautiful and solid, congratz! Please continue making games :) |
| Oct 7 08:34:02 | 10m 36s | Unconsious | ♥ 0 | Lovely! I love the shadows and the pixel-art in general. The sounds and music are totally top! After playing for the second time, I got the gist of it. The throwing mechanic is fine. The bouncy physics is chaotic but it fits the theme very well. All in all, a well chosen scope and a grand execution, congratulations on your solid and beautiful entry :) Make sure you play others' games and leave comments, you need to play and rate at least 20 to get ~the same amount of ratings for yours to get a final score! Don't leave that for the last day :) Pro-tip: Name the ZIP/RAR better than "Game" next time :) |
| Oct 7 14:39:10 | 6h 05m | Stonx! | ♥ 4 | Your game has proven to me that I'd totally not survive on the sto(n)x market :) Nice but frustrating, when the board shook me off :) |
| Oct 7 15:08:32 | 29m 22s | Noinun40 | ♥ 1 | Plus points for the music. A nice reinterpretation of match-3. Simple graphics. A good scope choice for the compo and thanks for playing mine :) |
| Oct 8 07:39:13 | 16h 30m | Where's My Tripod? | ♥ 1 | I like games I can win, despite being an amateur :) I love the animals and the pixel-art in general. The sounds and music are just perfect for this. A very furry entry, made my morning, thank you - please make sure you keep making games in the future! :) |
| Oct 8 08:19:23 | 40m 10s | Euro Drunk Simulator | ♥ 4 | After reading it works also with the arrows I managed to WIN. It felt rewarding. I love the little details, like the beer bottle on the windscreen. Very nice. The town seems pretty big but I finished the game in a minute? Maybe think about allocating your resources and time differently for the next game? I love the outro cinematic! A success you put this together -- please continue making games! :) The framerate is veeeeeeery low (on my RTX 3090 24 GB RAM + 128 GB RAM + Xeon W-2295 36-core). |
| Oct 8 12:59:10 | 4h 39m | Fractured Space | ♥ 0 | I also gave up before the second key :( Even if you oupted out of Sound, I'd still add a free music score and at least minimalistic sound effects. The art is very nice and funny. The controls are working but I noticed that you don't normalise the zoom level well and when you move in a diagonal, it gets sqrt(2) times bigger than going just X or Y, or something like that :) |
| Oct 8 18:47:40 | 5h 48m | Parcel Panic | ♥ 1 | Panicking doesn't win you this game! Skill does? I don't have the skillzz :D Great pixelated graphics, love it. Great bfxr/sfxr (?) sounds. The music is top. The difficulty is quite brutal though, as many people mentioned. |
| Oct 12 08:27:02 | 85h 39m | Unstable Driving | ♥ 1 | Hehe, pretty a psychotic fun :D But I like that mostly I could continue in the same direction when picking up diamond :) The chosen sounds fit it. Your take on the theme is fair, good job and thanks for the comment on mine :) |
| Oct 12 08:32:24 | 5m 22s | Orbitris | ♥ 1 | Respects for having made this in pure C + Emscripten. The controls are alright and the mechanic is novel. I still suck at it :D I'm not sure I see that much unstability in it but that's up to interpretation so I ain't even mad. A really good job! :) |
| Oct 12 09:48:56 | 1h 16m | Dr. Frank | ♥ 0 | A very oldskool, minimialistic experience :) Thumbs up for the sprites, their tiny animations, the generated sounds, the music and the effect :) However it was very hard for me to see which potion was highlighted :( Good job, be sure to keep making games :) |
| Oct 12 14:27:32 | 4h 38m | HONK III | ♥ 1 | Hi guys. Very nice to see another Honk. Honk III is awesome. Plays well. I love everything about it... HONK's theme is HONK. HONK, HONK, MOTHERDUCKER! We get it. The Ludum Dare theme is UNSTABLE. Hooooonk! I totally respect that you found the time to gather and make "a" game during Ludum Dare. I wish my crew(s) were more disciplined :P HONK! |
| Oct 14 12:02:25 | 45h 34m | Radioactive Guns 'n' Stuff | ♥ 1 | Thumbs up for the banana gun :) Other than that I agree with everyone above. Keep making games and try to polish it a tad more :) |
| Oct 15 15:02:18 | 26h 59m | Return To The Ranch: Project Freedom | ♥ 0 | Poor horseys, I got to run them over pretty a lot :) Plus after I hit the farmer, my buldozer flipped around like a crazey horsey. A plus for gamepad controls. Another plus for a horsey game :D |
| Oct 15 18:20:19 | 3h 18m | Dimensional Degradation | ♥ 2 | After playing the Jam version, I couldn't help myself and also played the post-Jam! The sounds really add something. Visual (and any other kind of) feedback is immensely important! Now your shooting feels 2x better -- still plenty of room to improve. I like the little shotgun reload animation. Other than that, next time, I'd suggest scoping the game smaller and focusing on key gameplay mechanics, in this case shooting feedback and what happens when you fall, plus what happens when you pick up stuff. The enemies would also deserve a pushback or an effect when you succesfully hit them. I'd place some keys/pickups already near the beginning, so you'd get an idea of what they do early on. In the UI, I'd show how many out of how many you managed to collect. Unfortunately, I didn't play long anough to unfold the mysteries of your world :( Congrats on putting this together and please, continue making games :) |
| Oct 15 18:27:56 | 7m 37s | The Mines | ♥ 3 | I have to say those ghosts appearing immediately after mining out a block... gave me the creeps a few times -- good job! 👻 I also like the initial screen, which is even a bit animated. The sounds are good. The meshes are nice. The (ambient) lighting in the dark would need some work. I'd increase the camera FOV a bit. Unfortunately, in several tries I was always killed, so neither I made it out alive :( I guess the difficulty is alright, it is I, who is lame -- good job altogether! 🔦 |
| Oct 15 18:36:02 | 8m 06s | Russian AllCash | ♥ 2 | A very solid job on the modelling and animation front! Shame it crashes after falling, it should stop the movement instead. Also a different jump length would be better (based on how long you hold the space bar). Be sure to leave comments and ratings (even with the help of the Yandex translator!) for more other games! You need at least 20 ratings, there's still enough time. Good job, guys, and please continue making games! :) Make games = play games = learn some more English = don't worry = have fun! |
| Oct 17 19:55:15 | 49h 19m | Life Gives You Lemons | ♥ 1 | While this genre isn't my cup of tea at all, I couldn't resist to see how the story unfolds :) A good job. Love the pixelart, it controls alright and even I was able to get to the end. But is it the end? :) |
| Oct 19 15:42:04 | 43h 46m | Weak Signal | ♥ 1 | Would you care spoiling it for everyone and giving hints on how to actually play/control this? I couldn't figure out why my packets wouldn't drop (they flew just a tiny bit) and how long will my drone remain without signal? I cannot get any grasp :( |
| Oct 19 16:55:39 | 1h 13m | Speedboat Alchemy | ♥ 0 | Awesome! I totally love this genre. The alchemy mixing of ammo was fun but I'm not sure whether there were any rules or if it was totally random. I love the graphics, I love what remains of each destroyed ship. I love the music and sounds as well. The only downside, as with many Unity3D projects quickly thrown together, is performance on slighly more shitty HW. A very solid entry! |
| Oct 20 09:22:35 | 16h 26m | Zandaka | ♥ 1 | Hi! I managed to win the game quite quickly by just spawning 3 waves. After each, I quickly collected the spawned little blue balls and "E"-ed them to the central altair. The chaos didn't rise too quickly so it was fairly easy. I didn't do anything with the altairs in the corners. I did read the description twice but I still don't see why I'd do anything else :( Also -- was there a purpose for the shooting? From my own experience, providing clear instructions is important but your 'wall of text' ("Learn") doesn't work that well :( Also, next time, consider adding ANY kind of feedback -- sound and/or visual to what's happening. Maybe try generating a few sounds quickly and plugging them in. This added feedback would make it much more easy to understand what's happening. And it takes only a few minutes even if it isn't that pretty. I like the smooth graphics (seems out of the box Unreal?) and light play. Also the controls are more than alright! All in all, congratz on managing to repair the build and put it all up :) |
| Oct 20 11:30:38 | 2h 08m | Waitin' Satan | ♥ 1 | A very solid entry. Great sounds and music \m/. The difficulty is too much for me (but I'm lame :D), so that's more than fine. I managed the first two levels after several tries. The jumping part... I still have to defeat! Plus points for the many levels, for the balancing, for the overall polish. A really good job! Make sure to leave much more comments to the others' games to get enough ratings! 666 |
| Oct 20 12:07:18 | 36m 40s | Hopper Unstable | ♥ 1 | I had to replay it because I was curious to find out what how to shoot the spells :) Only then I picked up the wand. Nice graphics, good sounds, very cute. Nice game mechanics. Short, yeah, but still a good job! |
| Oct 20 12:16:23 | 9m 05s | Unstable Christmas | ♥ 1 | Well... I had to restart the game three times and read everything here to figure out and notice that the gifts and bombs that show for a split second at the beginning aren't actually a glitch. I collected the gifts (I think) and I avoided the bombs but I'm not sure what do do next. I can't go back to the house or anything. A friendly advice: I clearly see you guys both wanted to contribute. So you started painting and drawing and animating. And the art is nice, indeed! But for the next time, be sure to have the core gameplay mechanics working first, before creating any art. With placeholder ugly cubes/squares or whatever. Only then start spending time on the assets. Still congratulations on putting this together and publishing it here, cheers! |
| Oct 20 16:38:26 | 4h 22m | Hell's Dishes | ♥ 1 | Great job putting this together. Great, unlike my skills in your game :) Extra thumbs up for the music and sounds. |
| Oct 20 16:44:47 | 6m 21s | Unstable Society | ♥ 1 | That tinfoil hat - ROFL :D I love how the paranoia spreads. A very simple and straightforward game. Clean. Oldschool as fuck. Maybe too minimalistic (I didn't finish it yet). Not sure what to add, great job :) |
| Oct 21 09:35:11 | 16h 50m | Volcano soother | ♥ 1 | Hi! I drove immediately to the yellow circle at start and pressed E but nothing happened. At least I couldn't tell. Did I pick up the ice? Then I got lost, had no idea where to drive :( Also pressing space does nothing, just U works. It needs a minimap, as everybody suggests and any kind of a feedback. |
| Oct 21 09:53:34 | 18m 23s | Cawtastrophe | ♥ 2 | Points up for the music and sounds. Points up for the jokes. However, it's too easy to cheat the game by throwing all the cubes off. Still congratz on putting this together :) EDIT: Forgot to mention the bird mesh, killed it :) |
| Oct 21 13:46:36 | 3h 53m | 🕷💩Poopy Parker💩🕷 | ♥ 1 | ROFL! I'm shitting my pants. This is really the best shit out there, as far as what I've played is concerned. Guys, really, rush and go give other games ratings! QUICKLY, you need 20!!! The controls are just fine. And the movements. And the meshes. And the colour palettes. And a cutscene. And the levels... And... and... it all looks so wiped...ehm...polished! And the music and sounds! You guys... an UBER-EPIC job! |
| Oct 21 14:59:37 | 1h 13m | Unstable Foundations | ♥ 2 | Very minimalistic! It felt rewarding to click the pieces for a while, I like how rapidly they fall. I like that it resets itself after you spill some off the platform. Thanks for rating mine and run go rate many more games, you need 20 ratings :) |
| Oct 21 17:40:30 | 2h 40m | Status (LD 49) | ♥ 1 | This was actually fun. I don't even feel insulted (nice insults there) :D |
| Oct 21 20:00:54 | 2h 20m | The Space-Ton Device | ♥ 1 | I really tried in the last minute... but you really have to start rating other games much earlier and not wait until the very end :\ A nice and very straightforward game tho, congratz! |