Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD40 → Feedback comment stats → Noble Robot
Feedback comments for LD40
Noble Robot's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Noble Robot's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 5 21:25:40 | Island Businessman | ♥ 0 | I couldn't get the game to work. I hit play and saw the grid. I could select one of them and see a list of items, but clicking those had no effect. Tried with both keyboard and controller. I like the concept, though. I hope others will be able to get it working. | |
| Dec 5 21:32:26 | 6m 46s | Increasing | ♥ 1 | Yeah, this game isn't fun, but who cares! I gave you high marks on the theme, because it fit narratively and not just mechanically like most of the games. |
| Dec 5 21:41:48 | 9m 22s | Snake++ | ♥ 0 | I like the idea of a snake game where you don't know how big you are because most of your body is off screen, and where you have to search around for items and the exit rather than just knowing where they are. I don't know if that's a common feature of snake clones (I haven't played many), but that was cool. Unfortunately, the controls were a little laggy for me, which made the game hard to play. I don't know if this was just for me, though, so I didn't let it impact my review. I liked the art style, but I hated the music (sorry). I also agree with another comment that adding [space] to start the game would be useful. I restarted the game a few times before I realized I needed to click the button with my mouse(!). |
| Dec 5 21:53:35 | 11m 47s | Sunshine Simulator | ♥ 0 | The game is a little obtuse at the beginning, but that's likely because you weren't able to get playtest feedback until now (ha!). The concept is clever and solid. Very chill. |
| Dec 5 22:00:48 | 7m 13s | Cats Them All! | ♥ 2 | I understand the reason for it, but the laggy mouse follow is very annoying. If this game could be played with keyboard or gamepad, it would feel a lot better. I totally love that as the stack of cats gets higher, it reduces the height of playspace, like Tetris. It's a good, natural way to visualize the game's mechanics. Honestly, I didn't like this game at first, but I kept playing it, so it's got a satisfying hook that most LD games don't have. Well done! |
| Dec 5 22:05:49 | 5m 01s | Home Decoration. | ♥ 1 | I don't know, but this might be my favorite LD40 game. I really liked the writing. I know there isn't much to it, but it's smart and funny without trying too hard, you know what I mean? |
| Dec 10 06:49:02 | 104h 43m | D_Sync | ♥ 1 | I love the concept! I especially like your take on the theme, which is more unique than most of the games. However, I found I wasn't able to use the rewind feature very much, because I didn't have a lot of time to react in the time after I realized that I made a mistake but before I fell and died. If my timing wasn't good enough to make the jump, it wasn't likely going to be good enough to scramble to correct it. I would suggest letting players rewind even if they die, so they can eventually experience the consequences of using the rewind too often. The game would still be difficult, and players who never use the rewind will have an easier time getting further. Anyway, really, really great job! |
| Dec 10 07:02:51 | 13m 49s | Alphabet Cereal | ♥ 0 | Started out with very few vowels, so I couldn't make any words longer than 3 or 4 letters to begin with, and it only got worse from there! :-D I do like the concept, though, it was just a bit frustrating in this early stage. |
| Dec 10 07:16:54 | 14m 03s | ARCADE OVERFLOW | ♥ 1 | Great stuff! Love the simultaneous gameplay, and especially love the timing. They way they introduce themselves one at a time. Just as you get a handle on it, the next game pops in. Love it! |
| Dec 10 10:28:55 | 3h 12m | KEY MASTER | ♥ 1 | I really like this concept. I agree that it's a bit too challenging as-is, but I was motivated to keep at it. More cues (visual or otherwise) for the key changes would be welcome. I bet this idea would be very interesting if carried over to a gamepad control scheme, too! |
| Dec 10 10:47:47 | 18m 52s | Phobos | ♥ 1 | Great graphics! Cool concept, and I like that it's a pseudo-platfomer where you just toggle from platform to platform. At a certain point the action kinda plateaued, but it never got dull. I would love to see this expanded for a future release. |
| Dec 10 11:04:15 | 16m 28s | Robosseum | ♥ 2 | Very buggy, so I don't think I got the intended experience, but it's a really solid concept. I rated the game high on theme and especially mood, because I like the "oh crap" moments that it delivers on. I also liked discovering that the enemies are also healed by the health zones, and that they also deal more damage when they are low on HP (although due to the bugs, enemies didn't attack me much, and some were immune to my attacks). Great work, foiled a bit by high ambitions, but that's great, too! |
| Dec 10 11:12:08 | 7m 53s | Hats On! | ♥ 1 | This was sooo fun. It got super challenging as it went on, which is good design, but the difficulty curve was a little steep. Great little concept, well executed. Nicely done! |
| Dec 10 11:21:50 | 9m 42s | Office Escape | ♥ 1 | Cute little linear comedy game. Didn't really fit the theme, but made up for it with a well done art style and rewarding one-click "puzzles." |
| Dec 10 11:38:36 | 16m 46s | Problems? | ♥ 0 | A bit hard to get a handle on at first, but cool idea executed with confidence. Well done! |
| Dec 25 13:40:11 | 362h 01m | Games Games Games | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we really loved)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:40:56 | 45s | Apparently I'm a detective | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought was hilarious)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:41:32 | 36s | Green Chefs and Pancakes | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought was a excellent prototype)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:44:01 | 2m 29s | Moths | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:44:21 | 20s | Kiwi is the Key | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought was very unique)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:44:56 | 35s | Ketchup Quest - Endless Arcade Fighting to Protect Your Saucy Stash | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we were bad at but loved anyway)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:45:31 | 35s | Too Many Rules! | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought had an incredibly cool concept)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:46:16 | 45s | Avoidance | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we couldn't quite get the hang of, but thought was cool)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:46:42 | 26s | No Coins Allowed | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we got a total kick out of)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:48:53 | 2m 11s | Heartless Jump | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought had an excellent core mechanic)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:49:20 | 27s | Tail | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we were very bad at, but loved the art)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:49:46 | 26s | Claustrophobia | ♥ 2 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought would be awesome/terrible in VR)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:50:27 | 41s | Between Stations | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we only got a taste of, but really liked)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:51:12 | 45s | Brick Racer | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we liked more the more we played it)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:52:02 | 50s | Coinminator 2000 | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which, as I mentioned in a previous comment, has a very similar mechanic to ours)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:53:46 | 1m 44s | NoteBoy | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought had one of the best uses of the theme)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:54:21 | 35s | Heavy Hearts | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought had good controls and was super cute)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:54:55 | 34s | FIT_IN | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we intend to go back to in order to get a better score)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:55:19 | 24s | TOO MANY CATS! | ♥ 2 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought was silly in all the right ways)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:55:40 | 21s | The Adequate Shepherd | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:56:12 | 32s | Mini Mystery | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we had a hard time with but really loved the mood and mechanic)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:56:47 | 35s | I'm not here | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we couldn't stop playing even after the recording ended)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:57:14 | 27s | AntiBucket | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we thought was a great twist on a familiar formula)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:57:39 | 25s | Just Another Day | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we couldn't get enough of)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:58:03 | 24s | Crosstalk | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which put us in a calming mood)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:58:17 | 14s | HUDdled | ♥ 2 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which was one of our favorites)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 13:58:41 | 24s | The Gravedigger | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we couldn't figure out but liked anyway)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:00:11 | 1m 30s | Dangle Copter | ♥ 1 | We at Nice Games Club just published our Ludum Dare Let's Play episode, where we played thirty-six (!!) games, including yours (which was so charming we could barely handle it)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:02:26 | 2m 15s | Critters Inc. | ♥ 1 | Greetings from the Widget Satchel team! We just published a Let's Play episode of Nice Games Club where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:03:08 | 42s | Babies with Guns | ♥ 1 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we found more clever than it has any right to be)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:03:26 | 18s | Synapse | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we fell completely in love with)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:04:02 | 36s | The Fabulous Orchestra Of Mister Vincent | ♥ 2 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours (which we seriously couldn't stop gushing over)! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:04:37 | 35s | Enjoy the Flowers | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |
| Dec 25 14:04:54 | 17s | I'll Take You To Tomato Town | ♥ 0 | Our team does a weekly indie gamedev podcast called Nice Games Club, and we just did a Let's Play episode where we played thirty-six (!!) Ludum Dare 40 games, including yours! [Check it out here!](http://nicegames.club/2017/12/nice-plays-ludum-dare-40-games-2017/) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BGt66ZnLME |