Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD24 → Feedback comment stats → Kmad
Feedback comments for LD24
Kmad's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Kmad's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27 14:06:00 | Dr. Helix | I played all of the way through this afternoon, I like the surprises when transforming creatures with the genome gun and then starting to use them tactically (like turning those electric orbs into weapons) makes it really fun. | |
| Aug 27 20:24:00 | 6h 18m | Evo Smash | I tried this out, it runs very smoothly on my system. Classic game mechanics with some nice touches such as choosing a side and the day/night cycle. I think it just needs to be a bit more challenging and tactical. Good effort though. |
| Aug 27 20:28:00 | 4m 00s | Strike of Rage ! | Superb, it has only a tenuous connection to the theme but it really is very playable. You consistently produce brilliant games in such a short space of time. |
| Aug 27 20:32:00 | 4m 00s | It's evolution, baby | Doesn't run for me either I'm afraid, I get the same error about an incorrect side-by-side configuration as a previous commenter. |
| Aug 27 20:45:00 | 13m 00s | Artificial Selection | My feedback is similar to some of the other comments. Interesting premise and plenty of potential but the issues lie with audio/visual feedback and the interface. I wasn't sure initially what the objects were and so plenty of trial and error was required. It's a very ambitious game concept, congrats on getting as far as you have with it in just 48hrs. |
| Aug 27 20:56:00 | 11m 00s | Alien Rockpool | It's a nice concept, I like the fact that it is a bit more open and emergent. It runs very smoothly, looks good and sounds great (the audio is much better than most of the entries that I've played so far). It's just a bit too easy and there are a few technical issues here and there but those are understandable. I read your post mortem and I can relate - I had a similar problem - writing way too much code for basic functionality that should've been done before the competition. |
| Aug 27 21:11:00 | 15m 00s | The Plurality | Interesting concept, I thought the narrative really held it together. Hope you expand on this in the future, good work. |
| Aug 27 21:20:00 | 9m 00s | Death Hockey | Wasn't sure what to expect with this one but it was actually fun and pretty funny. Solid, simple mechanic although a bit difficult to control at times. The cleaner was a nice touch. |
| Aug 28 07:16:00 | 9h 56m | Pixelomoeba | Simple, fun mechanic that works well. |
| Aug 28 07:34:00 | 18m 00s | Pixelapse | Good concept, I like the way the game itself evolves and changes. I also had a problem with the lack of friction, the character slide a bit too much and it made some of the later jumps frustrating. Great work. |
| Aug 28 07:39:00 | 5m 00s | Panspermia | At times a bit difficult but it's fun, has an interesting game mechanic and looks great. Well done! |
| Aug 28 07:51:00 | 12m 00s | Darwinphony | That video you posted is very helpful, especially in understanding how the little creatures reproduce and evolve. The game itself is definitely one of the most original and innovate things that I've seen in the competition so far. |
| Aug 28 07:55:00 | 4m 00s | Ikaruga Devolved | Looks slick and the mechanics were interesting, good work. |
| Aug 28 08:01:00 | 6m 00s | Species:Chappy | Really interesting little puzzle game idea, I liked how cross-breeding took effect as populations mixed. Hope you develop it further. |
| Aug 28 20:28:00 | 12h 27m | History of the black pixels | Ran okay for me. Nice concept, I liked the idea of taking the pixels from other creatures to evolve your character. The levels were a little awkward to navigate at times but a solid entry overall. |
| Aug 28 20:44:00 | 16m 00s | Epocalypse | This is good fun, combining resource collection with a top-down action mechanic was a nice idea. Plays well and there is potential here to develop this into something really interesting by adding a bit more variety and making it a little more challenging. |
| Aug 28 20:54:00 | 10m 00s | Universal Adaptors! | Fits the theme very well and the level design is good. The jumping felt a little strange to me, almost as though it was levitating or a jet pack or something - a little too smooth and slow to rise. Overall, good work. |
| Aug 29 06:53:00 | 9h 59m | RUN DINO RUN ! | The game looks really great, fits the theme perfectly and has nice, simple mechanics. |
| Aug 29 07:03:00 | 10m 00s | 133 | It's like a little rogue-like on fast forward - great mechanics, this has loads of potential. Very polished, not quite fitting the theme but a great job overall. |
| Sep 1 11:12:00 | 76h 09m | Artificial Selection | Good effort, I think you're a little hard on yourself - LD is tough and you've got something out there that you can build on. I had a bit of trouble with the shooting, the bullets only appeared infrequently but other than that it could work well. I liked the idea of evolving when you die. |
| Sep 1 11:29:00 | 17m 00s | Firefly | Works well for me, it took me a while to work out what was going on even with the tutorial but when I did it was just brilliant. One of the best concepts that I've seen, fits with the theme really well, looks great, sounds great and is fun. Congratulations. |
| Sep 1 11:44:00 | 15m 00s | Adlus: Mouse Of Truth | It's definitely odd but I liked it, I thought the art style and mood were excellent personally - very different and works well. Very surreal (that's a good thing in my book) just needs more gameplay to it. |
| Sep 1 11:51:00 | 7m 00s | A Walk In The Park | Interesting idea, took me a while to work out what was going on. The atmosphere is very good. |
| Sep 1 11:56:00 | 5m 00s | Super-Human | The sound effects and ending made me laugh. The gameplay was fun with interesting mechanics, good job. |
| Sep 1 12:04:00 | 8m 00s | Evolving Empire | Wow, impressive stuff. I love turn-based games, this is much better than the one I made. Classic gameplay, minimal but effective graphics. Very ambitious, could do with a little more feedback when research has been completed but other than that great work. |
| Sep 1 12:11:00 | 7m 00s | Kings of the Archipelago | Visually it's very nice and it's a good concept that fits the theme. Would be great to see it in a more complete state eventually. |
| Sep 1 12:32:00 | 21m 00s | The Horrifying and Viciously Aggresive Though Strangely Susceptible To Evolution Monsters From Some Mysterious Random Tomb | That is one long title! A few little issues as others have mentioned but a pretty fun little game. I like the idea of species of monsters evolving. |
| Sep 1 12:38:00 | 6m 00s | the Evolution from zx81 | It is a little difficult at times, I managed to fall from the top almost all the way to the bottom when the gaps aligned but it's a good effort, fits the theme nicely and has interesting but simple game mechanics. |
| Sep 1 12:45:00 | 7m 00s | Germ Wars | Nice concept, it's a bit difficult to get into but fits the theme well. Might be nice if it was a bit slower paced to begin with but good work overall. |
| Sep 1 12:50:00 | 5m 00s | Beetlefield : The Forecast | Brilliant concept and very polished. You've got some great ideas in there like the DNA sharing. Great work! |
| Sep 1 13:18:00 | 28m 00s | Bit-Craft Evolution | Great game, very fun and polished - the effects were excellent and the ship evolving mechanic was a nice idea. |
| Sep 1 13:38:00 | 20m 00s | Influenza | One of the best ideas that I've seen so far. It took me a little while to work out what I was meant to do and there is a fair bit of waiting around occasionally. Other than those minor criticisms it was great, it had lots of character and good progression. |
| Sep 1 13:46:00 | 8m 00s | Tonality | Worked fine for me. Amazing idea, very original. I found it a bit too difficult (even changing the settings as you suggest) but making the tutorial interactive was an excellent touch and helped a lot. Nicely done. |
| Sep 1 14:26:00 | 40m 00s | Jump'o'lution | Got stuck in a few places when I ran out of energy and that was frustrating. It's a simple, interesting concept though and quite fun when you get the hang of it. |
| Sep 1 14:39:00 | 13m 00s | Planets | Good game, it's kind of like a reverse asteroids or something rather than breaking them down you're building them up. Works well with the simple control system and slick presentation. |
| Sep 1 14:55:00 | 16m 00s | Tribal Warfare | Nice game, a simple rts is great idea. I got the hang of it quite quickly and beat it on my first go but not without a bit of a challenge. Hope you build on this further. |
| Sep 1 15:00:00 | 5m 00s | Manual Population Control | Even with the gameplay video I was a bit lost to be honest, I could have done with a tutorial. I think this idea is great and I can see how it fits the theme, the visuals and audio are very polished too. |
| Sep 1 15:14:00 | 14m 00s | Lepton's Quest | Very original way of creating artwork, the presentation is incredible and the best looking and sounding thing that I've played so far. It was fun to wander about and explore, shame you didn't manage to get the combat in but it was so ambitious that it's understandable. |
| Sep 1 15:23:00 | 9m 00s | Simplex Evolution Tabulae Ludus | I enjoyed this a lot. As others have commented it is a bit easy once you get the strategy figured out but I had exactly the same trouble with my own entry, so I can understand completely. Great to see another turn-based game, it looks slick and plays well. Great job. |
| Sep 1 16:10:00 | 47m 00s | Paprika Blue | Visual stunning and very smooth, I'd love to see this developed further. |
| Sep 1 16:20:00 | 10m 00s | Vesuvius | The game works fine for me. Lovely atmosphere and style. I liked the idea of the game and was confused at first but I learnt how to survive the fall and the lava whilst playing. |
| Sep 1 16:41:00 | 21m 00s | Tiimmmeeee | Fun little game, although I got stuck so I checked the spoiler link and I'm still stuck. I get the battery from above the toilet and then return to the room with the bed in it and zap it but nothing happens for me, no hole appears. It's possible that I'm missing something obvious, anyway nice little game with an interesting concept. |
| Sep 1 18:01:00 | 1h 20m | Monkey Trial Turnaround | This is different from anything else I've seen in the competition so far, quite an original approach to the theme and nicely written. I enjoyed it a lot. |
| Sep 1 18:08:00 | 7m 00s | minogear | The visuals are excellent, love the minotaur and how it changes as more gear is added. Perhaps not entirely in line with the theme but a good game with the potential to be developed further. |
| Sep 1 18:22:00 | 14m 00s | Evidently | Great little gory game and a funny approach to the theme. Well done. |
| Sep 1 19:00:00 | 38m 00s | Constructor | This is very well made, looks good and the audio is fantastic. The game mechanics are solid - it took me a few attempts to get the hang of this, however, once I did there wasn't much to do after building up my town other than waiting for the debt to be paid off. Overall, a good, polished entry. |
| Sep 1 19:03:00 | 3m 00s | Beatbox Evolution | Interesting idea, there is potential there. |
| Sep 1 19:14:00 | 11m 00s | Parthenogenesis | The game has a good atmosphere, it took me a while to work out what I was supposed to be doing - could've done with a bit more help. Original concept, fits the theme nicely, good attempt. |
| Sep 1 19:33:00 | 19m 00s | Catching Life | A nice, simple game. The video was very helpful in understanding how to get started. It's an original idea, I hope you have the time to build on it as it just needs a bit more depth. Well done. |
| Sep 2 08:54:00 | 13h 21m | Survivalism | A cool little game. I thought it was a bit fast paced to begin with but then I got the hang of it and it was fun. A little bit of warning/feedback when there are off-screen enemies flying towards you would have been nice. It looks good and is very smooth, great work! |
| Sep 2 09:03:00 | 9m 00s | I'd Change the World for You | One of the most fun entries that I've played, solid game mechanics and great level design. I had a few little collision issues here and there where my character wouldn't activate a switch but in general it played well. Great entry! |
| Sep 2 09:40:00 | 37m 00s | Dinolution | Really fun game with very classic mechanics. I liked the dino evolutions/power-ups and the effect where the music changed when you went underwater was a lovely touch. Great work. |
| Sep 2 09:47:00 | 7m 00s | The Last Creationist | Crazy game but pretty funny and fun to. Good effort. |
| Sep 2 09:56:00 | 9m 00s | Ultimate Plant | Super little puzzle game. Fits the theme brilliantly and is yet very original, I'm impressed with the tutorial too - it teaches the basics of the game well. Great game! |
| Sep 2 10:16:00 | 20m 00s | Trinity Labs | Great idea, I like that you've given physics to a match 3 game. I did have some trouble as it wouldn't always register that I had 3 objects of the same colour next to each other. Really interesting though and worth developing some more. |
| Sep 2 10:23:00 | 7m 00s | cell.evolve | Looks, sounds and controls great. It could be a bit more challenging earlier in the game but it's a good entry. |
| Sep 2 11:11:00 | 48m 00s | Title Goes Here... | Nice game. Most of what I'd criticise has already been said (e.g. lack of feedback, grinding) but don't get me wrong I enjoyed having a go on this and think you've made a good looking, smooth game with potential for further development. |
| Sep 2 11:29:00 | 18m 00s | Digital Generation | Excellent take on the theme - good idea! It was quite a challenge in places but I got through to the end. This is a great entry, well done! |
| Sep 2 11:37:00 | 8m 00s | Egocell jam | Impressive especially since this was written with C++. Good work, I like the fact that the animals try to jump over obstacles and gaps when they chase you. |
| Sep 2 18:18:00 | 6h 41m | Evolve and Conquer | This won't run for me, I've ensured that I've got the XNA framework installed but when I double-click on the exe file nothing happens. Evolution.exe appears in the processes tab of my task manager but the game isn't loading up. |
| Sep 2 18:25:00 | 7m 00s | Convergent | A very trippy game, odd concept but pretty playable. Hope you develop it further. |
| Sep 2 18:38:00 | 13m 00s | Total argument | Quite a fun little game, classic mechanics but implemented well and an interesting take on the theme. |
| Sep 2 19:58:00 | 1h 20m | Unnatural Selection | Fantastic little game that has a lot of potential to be developed further - hope you do carry on working on it. |
| Sep 2 20:06:00 | 8m 00s | Evolution Heroes | Looks good and is a decent concept, I found it a little difficult as the sprites were very small and the levels were quite crowded. It's a good effort and quite fun. |
| Sep 2 20:23:00 | 17m 00s | How evolution really works? | Excellent little game, very funny and original. |
| Sep 4 12:25:00 | 40h 02m | Fire Frog | Couldn't run this on Windows 7 64-bit, it loaded a black window titled "Level: 1: Are you ready?" and nothing happened after that - tried a couple of times. |
| Sep 4 12:35:00 | 10m 00s | Beyond Darkness | Tried to run this on Windows 7 64-bit and couldn't get it working. Every time it tries to load I get an error prompt saying "LD24_WIN.exe has stopped working." The errors in the command prompt are that it failed to load the textures for the logo, title and background. It also fails to load the fonts and stops after trying to load mordernantiqua12.fnt. I tried downloading the file again but I get the same error. |
| Sep 4 12:42:00 | 7m 00s | Dragonkin EVO | The 32-bit version runs fine for me on windows 7 64bit. All works well, fun little game and fits well with the theme. A little feedback would be good (e.g. animation/sound effects when you are injured) but other than that it's a good effort. |
| Sep 4 12:59:00 | 17m 00s | EvoGoop | Plenty of good ideas, I liked how you incorporated the theme and how some evolutions would affect others (e.g. you needed to be light in order to fly). I did get stuck in the ground after evolving arms at one point and had to restart. There is plenty of potential for this to be developed further. |
| Sep 4 13:05:00 | 6m 00s | Evolution Strategy (Web) | It's a nice concept that fits the theme very well and it looks great too. Hope you get the chance to develop it further. For a first LD this is a good attempt. |
| Sep 5 19:18:00 | 30h 13m | Slime Fighter | I like the idea of combining an rpg with a beat 'em up, it looks great and plays quite well. |
| Sep 5 19:30:00 | 12m 00s | Ludum Card Evolution | Great to see a card game, I love these kinds of games and wasn't expecting to see one based on this theme. I enjoyed it once I got into it but some elements are still a bit of a mystery to me, more explanations of icons and cards would be good. Great effort though. |
| Sep 5 19:39:00 | 9m 00s | UN-Natural Selection | Fantastic game, looks brilliant and fits the theme really well. It was a real challenge to maintain genetic diversity. |
| Sep 5 19:50:00 | 11m 00s | Pasazh | The game is visually great and plays well too. Nice work! |
| Sep 5 20:08:00 | 18m 00s | Biods | The web version didn't work for me even after I updated silverlight, it just didn't load. I tried the windows version and that worked fine. Interesting idea, I got through level 1 without knowing what was going on but after that it became more challenging and fun. Cool entry that fits the theme well. |
| Sep 6 19:16:00 | 23h 08m | PixelVolution | It looks great and has a fun intro. Shame you didn't get the chance to develop it more. |
| Sep 6 19:25:00 | 9m 00s | God Called in Sick Today | One of the best concepts (and titles) that I've seen in the competition. Great little sandbox, would be nice to see it developed further. |
| Sep 9 09:01:00 | 61h 36m | Prance Prance Evolution | Fun game, I like the idea and it plays well. As mentioned some animation would be nice, as would little features like the ability to name horses. Great entry though. |
| Sep 9 09:08:00 | 7m 00s | Get Your Cell Together | Lovely interpretation of the theme, good work. Pressing the z button repeatedly got a little tiresome but the game was fun and looked good. |
| Sep 9 09:18:00 | 10m 00s | Buffalo Joe | A fun little game although evolution that could be developed further. Looks great, I'm impressed to see such a good 3d game in 48 hours. I had a few collision problems, sometimes my buffalo went through the wolves and the baby buffalo would collide with me or themselves and get stuck when trying to move towards food. Good entry. |
| Sep 9 09:39:00 | 21m 00s | .Evolvorous. | This is pretty great, I love turn-based games and this fits the theme perfectly. Well done. |
| Sep 9 09:43:00 | 4m 00s | Natural Selection - You vs the World | Very original concept, played well once I got used to it. Great entry. |
| Sep 9 09:49:00 | 6m 00s | Negemon | Great retro style visuals and funny too. |
| Sep 9 09:58:00 | 9m 00s | Leap of the Lemmings | It's a funny idea that fits the theme. Could be turned into an interesting game. |
| Sep 9 10:10:00 | 12m 00s | Fantasy Map Tactics | It's great to see more turn-based games in the competition, I really like a lot of the ideas in this entry. It has a tenuous connection to the theme and is a bit too easy but it looks great and there is plenty of potential for an amazing game to come out of this. Hope you develop it further. |
| Sep 9 10:19:00 | 9m 00s | Soul Jar | Wow, the atmosphere, sound and visuals are superb. The game is lots of fun too. I hope you develop this further. |
| Sep 9 10:28:00 | 9m 00s | The World of What? | Looks fantastic, would be nice to have the help screen accessible throughout the game though - I had to restart the game to view it again. It was quite confusing initially but it is a very polished entry. |
| Sep 9 10:35:00 | 7m 00s | Primordial Soup | Great idea! Just needs a bit of work on collision and polishing up the attachment system. |
| Sep 9 13:03:00 | 2h 28m | Evolutionary Designer | Very original mechanic and fun too. |
| Sep 9 13:06:00 | 3m 00s | The ducks are taking over!! | The game could do with a bit more content and development but it has solid mechanics and is pretty fun. |
| Sep 9 18:57:00 | 5h 51m | Cuboid Sandbox | Fun sandbox that looks great. Well done! |
| Sep 9 19:01:00 | 4m 00s | FOR THE darWIN | Fabulous looking game with a simple concept that's fun. Good work. |
| Sep 10 12:16:00 | 17h 15m | Coin-Operated Afternoon | I thought this was great, loved the use of stop-motion photography (great to see the Hero Quest figures in there too, that brings back memories!). Very original entry, well done! |