Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD54 → Feedback comment stats → Stronf
Feedback comments for LD54
Stronf's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Stronf's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 1 06:41:07 | WordDish | ♥ 1 | Managed to get all the words in left without deletes although it took some time. Really great and addictive game. Very minor suggestions could be to explain that you can also fill in the words vertically or diagonally, which I only understood mid-game - I was about to complete the required word and suddenly my vertical row disappeared (small horror element? ;). Although I see a benefit from this - a need for additional planning and thinking how you put the letters. | |
| Oct 1 08:33:12 | 1h 52m | If I Fits, I Sits! | ♥ 1 | got to 1667, liked the game and its connection to the theme was a bit confused in the beginning, thinking the point was just to fit in the box, as soon as I figured out you need to fit the cat as precise as possible, the game was even more enjoyable and fun :) |
| Oct 1 18:07:08 | 9h 33m | President's Secretary | ♥ 0 | The idea is amazing, this is something that fits the theme great and a lot of people will relate to. What I especially liked is the causal relationships of events and that time of the day matters. One suggestion to the current version is to be able to put an event at any time of day (on Sunday I was left with only one event. It should happen at evening to proceed and as it was the only event, I could only put it at morning) A suggestion for an expansion could be to add the indicators of current situation of external affairs / popularity etc to be seen before the game over screen |
| Oct 1 18:35:24 | 28m 16s | Rectangular rhythm selection game | ♥ 3 | wow, I had no idea what I was doing in the beginning, in the middle and in the end I still have no idea how I have beaten it but I had tons of fun and enjoyed it a lot. Definetely a unique take on a rhythm game |
| Oct 1 18:45:38 | 10m 14s | hypno-room | ♥ 1 | fun game with innovative idea and clear goal, speedup button is great, did not like the music though |
| Oct 1 19:21:08 | 35m 30s | Don't Touch The Pylon. | ♥ 2 | nice short and simple, fits the theme well |
| Oct 1 19:31:22 | 10m 14s | Fish 'n' Ships | ♥ 2 | liked the idea, fits the theme well and may be addicting if expanded i got to max of 130 pts and would prefer to see the village HP scale as well |
| Oct 1 19:38:53 | 7m 31s | Boxed In | ♥ 2 | nice game with simple mechanics, can't say it is much innovative, but it's fun, runs smooth, and fits the theme I like the progression with the "tutorial" and first few blocks but gets quite challenging already at the score of 10 |
| Oct 1 19:44:57 | 6m 04s | Cramped Choices, a Lifetime Dilemmas! | ♥ 3 | Like the idea (very relatable), the theme and the style Was not entirely sure if the choices are randomly generated and would be interested to play a more expanded versio n with more options |
| Oct 1 19:48:52 | 3m 55s | Unstable Resource | ♥ 1 | graphics look sus, rules remind of pazaak from KOTOR 1/2 |
| Oct 1 20:02:21 | 13m 29s | Tow To Tomorrow | ♥ 1 | wow, really impressed it was made this quickly nice graphics, thematic concept, deceptively easy controls, fun gameplay. Was stressed but finally managed to get the biggest ship to the red dock (after crashing several of them previously:) (also found a small bug - if you dock the ship and then detach the line and push the ship with your tow, you may get the money twice) |
| Oct 1 20:15:27 | 13m 06s | Voynich Lecture | ♥ 1 | i don't know what I just played, but it was fun and had a lot of humor, the disappearing ink is also a nice touch. Got 3/6 in the end, was only sure about 1 answer) |
| Oct 1 20:17:25 | 1m 58s | Match Two (Prototype) | ♥ 1 | really nice idea that could be developed further |
| Oct 1 20:41:53 | 24m 28s | The Signal | ♥ 2 | Wow, it is amazing it was done in two days, impressive, great game, nice voice acting, interesting levels, overall positive impressions. sometimes I got stuck too much in some levels (magnets and last level), it took many loops for which the voice recordings became irritating a bit |
| Oct 1 21:23:51 | 41m 58s | Canals | ♥ 2 | nice play on the theme, engaging mechanics, interesting to see how this concept can be evolved would prefer more instructions, but as soon as I understood the gameplay, everything went very smoothly |
| Oct 1 21:44:22 | 20m 31s | Rolling Over It | ♥ 1 | Getting over it vibes are very clear, i definetely did not ragequit after being close to the end). Very liked the innovative concept with the dice, this turns a platformer into a planning game with a twist. Not sure it fits the theme, but it is a great concept and great execution |
| Oct 1 22:10:06 | 25m 44s | Bon Voyage | ♥ 1 | The new season of Survivor looks ....good. Overall idea is fun and humorous, fits the theme well, I especially liked the first part of doing the choosing and would prefer more interactivity in the second half or at least some scoresheets with fates of everyone. There's also a small bug where Game Over screen keeps on adding days the crew have survived. |
| Oct 2 05:48:35 | 7h 38m | Misplaced Tie | ♥ 0 | Clear and fun, an interesting new take on escape rooms, also liked the visuals |
| Oct 2 06:14:31 | 25m 56s | Brain Manager | ♥ 1 | not sure I would have got it without your tips, could only get to the end of first week. Then after reading the tips everything made much more sense and got to the end of week 4. Fits the theme, interesting concept and clear idea, great job |
| Oct 2 10:10:17 | 3h 55m | Feng Shui Struggles | ♥ 1 | Great job: clear objectives, very topical, challenging, yet engaging. My small concern is that levels 1 and 4 are much more challenging than the rest. And level 5 is a masterpiece ;) |
| Oct 2 18:44:51 | 8h 34m | Hole in the Well | ♥ 1 | great work on audio, nice idea and nice dialogueswith humour, would like to have some end goal |
| Oct 2 18:54:28 | 9m 37s | This Game Only Weighs 8 KB! | ♥ 1 | very peculiar interpretation of "limited space", couldn't have thought of it, nicely done The game is straightforward, short, some of levels are more challenging and interesting |
| Oct 2 19:19:46 | 25m 18s | A Tail of Escape | ♥ 2 | very captivating game, loved the artwork, the photos, the ability to save and was very surprised by the amount of options and pathways you could put in a game in such a short deadline. The plot is interesting, sometimes dark, sometimes humorous, great job overall |
| Oct 2 19:28:40 | 8m 54s | 300 Hryvni | ♥ 1 | nice simple idea, would like to play more levels of it to fully evaluate this |
| Oct 2 19:34:39 | 5m 59s | Spectra | ♥ 2 | saw entries with similar ideas, but the style and change of pace, shape, and colors was very cool. Sad you didn't have time for sound, it could have a great contiuation, well done |
| Oct 2 19:46:07 | 11m 28s | Introvertigo | ♥ 6 | Love, love, love it. The concept, the visuals, the storyline, the play on the name One of the funniest things i've experienced across games here, well done |
| Oct 2 20:06:49 | 20m 42s | Floppy Drive Lemonade Stand | ♥ 1 | Nice concept, fits the theme well, there was just a lot of text on the right with requests - that was a bit hard-to-read. i would like to see more goals (e.g. get XX dollars by next week), good job overall |
| Oct 3 09:32:01 | 13h 25m | John Apple Wants Phone | ♥ 1 | Concept and gameplay is fun, wasn't sure if there is any end goal to it or just putting the pieces all together. Also liked the graphic elements of the game |
| Oct 3 09:37:48 | 5m 47s | Full Circle | ♥ 1 | Liked the entry, fits the theme well. graphics, sound design and gameplay are nice, loved the "dash" feature. got only to 30 seconds max, but still nice job! |
| Oct 3 09:41:47 | 3m 59s | Sun Runner | ♥ 0 | could not run, for some reason crashed when I clicked on Level 1 :( |
| Oct 3 09:52:09 | 10m 22s | Golden Billion | ♥ 2 | "Plague Inc but we can do ourselves without the viruses". I managed to save humanity, overall fun game, interesting interpretation of theme, gets a bit repetitive in the end and I did not understand the need for +1 mln button. I can see how it can be developed to a good longer game |
| Oct 3 11:39:10 | 1h 47m | Packed Ride | ♥ 2 | Like the concept, fits the theme well, got 4.33 in the end. I can see the game working well expanded Regarding points for improvement - I agree with tutorial being quite a lot, I would like more indication what is wrong within the bus. Also the process of putting people in the bus is a bit confusing due to perspective, maybe could be solved by highlighting which place you are putting the person into just clicking the place. But overall a good entry, nice job |
| Oct 3 15:10:11 | 3h 31m | River City Transit | ♥ 1 | i've seen a few metro/bus games during this LD, but punching everyone around is a very useful and pleasant mechanic. I was not entirely sure I understood the point of game correctly, but i got to the end stop and it was very funny |
| Oct 4 09:38:13 | 18h 28m | But we still love each other | ♥ 3 | like the entry, fun and clear, fits the theme, great job |
| Oct 4 15:24:33 | 5h 46m | The Final Moments of Jeffrey Epstein | ♥ 3 | Humorous and funny, nice graphics, the twist is epic, well done, |
| Oct 4 20:18:22 | 4h 53m | Tidal Towns | ♥ 2 | very fun and engaging game, clear play on the theme, liked the resource management part and design. Currently got to 3rd level but plan to return later to finish the game. I have not finished it, but already want more levels :) I think in the beginning it needs some time to understand what's going on, not only in terms of mechanics, but understanding what solution is right, but from 2nd try you have an idea and everything should go smoother. Another small point is that you try to jump straight to the action and forget to read you tutorial tips in the bottom, could make it a bit more clear Great job, one of my favorites! |
| Oct 4 20:43:25 | 25m 03s | Plan It Out! | ♥ 2 | Great entry! What I liked: fits the theme, storytelling aspect is amazing, the notes between weeks were interesting to read. I've seen other entries based on calendar, but this is unique, personal, and relatable. What I would liked differently: the font was a bit hard-to-read, I was not sure what "Extra 1 hour" was for. I think the first 3 weeks are particularly easy, from difficulty standpoint it could have started at week 3 and would be a good progression. There was no much need for an eraser |
| Oct 4 22:03:24 | 1h 19m | Bert the Introvert | ♥ 2 | relatable, fun mechanics, little voiceovers were fun. Losing personal space quickly when wife is near is an additional humourous touch |
| Oct 5 10:08:34 | 12h 05m | Chrysopelea | ♥ 1 | Liked this entry! fun and difficult game, fits the theme, interesting mechanics, nice sound design, great humour in descriptions, liked the options to undo turn or level and to skip a level, would probably suggest to make errors more visible |
| Oct 6 07:47:46 | 21h 39m | Savespace | ♥ 1 | Good entry, fits the theme. Especially liked the concept, I can see it being developed further Was not entirely sure if I did correct things, but have beaten the game. Was a bit stressful with the limited time, would add a timer for choosing the files, also you can probably scale up the difficulty by adding the need to put files to different folders. |
| Oct 6 08:44:08 | 56m 22s | Final Frenzy! | ♥ 1 | Amazing entry Loved the gameplay, the play on the theme, visual style is great, very fun to play and humorous (my favourites for now are "and throw it all away", "0.85m deep" which is a trick not used in exam, and the ending of literature text). I can also see how this game can be expanded further! Great job! The only note - could we both take and drop an item with just the left click? I have seen another similar mechanic with notes for exam during this jam (Voynich Lecture) but that one is very absurd. This one is more straightforward and logical |
| Oct 6 12:28:24 | 3h 44m | I Do | ♥ 3 | very fun game, creative play on the theme, clear gameplay. A bit too much details, but you don't expect everyone to spend 30 minutes making a table with all guests and getting perfect score. The premise of second level is hysterical. One thing was unclear in first level - I thought the guests not sitting at tables would also come, so I placed them across the room and was surprised when only seated guests arrived Overall great job! |
| Oct 10 19:04:07 | 102h 35m | Just... Make It Yourself! | ♥ 1 | very fun game, voice effects are amazing and the best part of experience, gameplay is clear, enjoyed it very much not sure how well it fits the theme, but great jon anyways |
| Oct 11 11:15:03 | 16h 10m | Rush Hour | ♥ 1 | fun game, liked the play on the theme, graphics and gameplay are nice as well (falling into abyss is a fun addition). i agree with others that the premise is a bit too similar to Fall Guys but overall positive impressions |