corgicommander 2015-04-21 03:54
unplayable without a game controller
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD32 → NEG [controller req]
By joshua_burr
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 2 | 82 | ||
| Fun | 454 | 3.15 | ||
| Audio | 454 | 2.92 | ||
| Innovation | 725 | 2.73 | ||
| Overall | 743 | 2.95 | ||
| Graphics | 781 | 2.72 | ||
| Mood | 790 | 2.66 | ||
| Humor | 809 | 2.24 | ||
| Theme | 878 | 2.71 |
unplayable without a game controller
I feel the controlling of the characters to be somewhat floaty and stiff. However once me and my friend got used to it, it was a pretty fun and hectic multiplayer game. Pretty good job! :)
Looks good. But I only have a ps3 controller.
Great concept, clean controls. A few too many buttons to learn right away, but I won't rate you down for that.
Playstation controllers should work fine
hi joshua. you mentioned issues with my game. i uploaded a webplayer edition. please give that a shot.
too bad that i dont have a controller...or friend :D
Controls clunky at times and unfortunately not playable without someone else. A 1-player mode could be of great value.
looks interesting, please add keyboard controls
There is no point in adding keyboard controls as the game is purely multiplayer and there is no way of having two players on one keyboard. I realise that this isn't a very accessible format but I didn't have any choice (without making a different game entirely).
Really tricky to master but with some time, could be a great multi player battler. good work!
Could be fun if the controls were better. It's really hard to do anything if you're new, I imagine you guys are well acquainted with your own controls, but think about others.
Please add keyboard controllers.
Thanks for putting work into the control system! A lot of games put more work into style over substance and it's really nice to see that you didn't. Keep going buddy!
Why can't 2 players use one keyboard?? Strange statement. Played so many games like that, also the very common 2 player hot seat pattern is gamepad for player 1 and keyboard for player 2
Because you need an analog input for the grapple hook (ideally another one for the dashing as well) so each player would need a mouse. It is definitely possible for some games, just not this one. Yes, you could have one on controller and one on keyboard.
I have a controller, but only the left analog seems to be working in this game. It's an old USB Thrustmaster so nothing exotic.
I'm using 'InControl' (https://www.assetstore.unity3d.com/en/#!/content/14695) to handle controller input. I've checked their website and Thrustmaster controllers aren't supported yet. I've sent an email with a request to support them.
Nicely done. Style/animations look great, and the grappling hook was fun to play with. I just tried it out alone, but could see it being really crazy/awesome with four people.
funny game, but please add keyboard support!
While I understand that it might not be accessible to most without controller, he kinda put that parenthetical in the title. So anyone coming in here acting surprised about that fact is kinda silly.
I think you should still offer keyboard as an option. Most people only have one controller.
The physic is really nice, I love how using the grapple feels, however, it's really hard to damage the other player because they are really small.
Anyway, good job!
Finally a multiplayer game!
I like how the bodies stay after deaths!
(used 2 360 controllers, worked great. Also, for those with PS4 controllers, you can use a tool to map input to 360)
PS4 controllers should work automatically. I just tested on OSX and it worked.
I checked it out solo to get a feel for the game, couldn't find anyone willing to play atm so I'll just go over what I thought about the mechanics in general.
There's a fair amount of polish to everything, and most actions come across very smoothly without any sort of graphical/mechanical issues. I was mostly surprised by how well the grapple hook mechanic worked, specifically that it would wrap around the corner of an object if it was attached on top.
I think it was also pretty impressive after learning the controls a bit to find how nicely the potential actions play with each other. Like grappling to an object and doing a dash to hurl yourself up on top of it.
I did find the controls somewhat awkward to learn however. They didn't feel very natural to pick up in some aspects. For instance, when I'm grappled to something, I think I may have found it more intuitive to push up on the thumbstick in order to reel myself in (since climbing walls works in kind of a similar way), rather than having to learn another button to do that functionality. It's really more of a thing that comes with lots of playtesting and feedback I'd imagine though, which obviously for a game jam you get little of while working on the game.
Also I found the movement to be somewhat floaty and difficult to maneuver precisely. Even just doing it solo I had a hard time trying to hit the non-moving 2nd player, so I can imagine two players trying to hit each other could be... time consuming unless both are somewhat experienced with the game.
There are lots of good ideas here, and plenty of solid executions of some of the things I've mentioned... but even though the majority of the game is very sleek and polished feeling... I can't help but think that the drawbacks mentioned above hold it back a great deal.
Also, as a side note: I'm not entirely sure why everyone seems to be so put off that the game requires controllers to play. I think that decision allowed extra time to get that control method working really well. If a controller + mouse and keyboard option were added it'd be great for added accessibility... but I don't like all the extra pressure put on the devs to add in mouse+keyboard support when the game isn't really designed to be played that way. We do Ludum Dare to experiment with game creation (and control methods), not to harass people who don't follow those norms.
Controls feel good and the music isn't too bad either. Reminds me of high school days of playing Worms and getting entirely too creative with the ninja rope. :)
Feels like N+ in multiplayer mode, which is awesome :)
It looks cool - though I found it hard to get two controllers together to play
Pretty fun. A couple of thoughts:
- Having to switch between buttons for movement and right stick for grappling is cumbersome. Is that deliberate?
- Have you ever played a Worms game? I'm thinking Worms World Party specifically. They do grapple + move + retract/extend on the same stick and jump + release on the same button, and I think that'd work well here. You might also be able to support keyboard that way.
- Wall movement is nice.
Great job working with the time restraint. The game was simple but still a lot of fun. The art and sound were minimalistic but still felt great. Would have been fun to try the multiplayer verion.
The control is a little hard, but it's fun.
This simple, but is fun! :) Controls work like a charm and I liked this "grapple/ball" mechanic! :D
About not accepting keyboard input I can understand. After playing it with a controller, you realize it just wouldn't work with the mouse. And that's not a bad thing, it's like choosing the proper medium to send a message.
The game is quite refined and work on graphics are nicely done. There's also room for improvement, but the game, as is, is quite fun to play! :D
Fun to control and stylish
I won't rate this because I have no one to play with, but I did check out both compo and post-compo versions and I really love the rope swinging.
Fun once you get over with the frustrating controls. Nice entry :)