Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD23 → Feedback comment stats → JaJ

JaJ

Feedback comments for LD23

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	JaJ's comment
Apr 23 17:56:00		Lonely Hated Rock	I liked it a lot but I can't figure out how to send an sos signal. It's also not completely clear te mo how things like healing work. Is just updrading a headquarters enough?
Apr 23 18:09:00	13m 00s	On Another Scale	I got to the end, but I got there so quickly, I might have missed a lot. I liked the music a lot, especially before it got upbeat.
Apr 23 18:19:00	10m 00s	caveman defending his cave from aliens while monoliths drop down from the sky	The game was fun, but what kept happening to me is that I died because of things outside of my control. (The location of the spaceship, the weapons I got, and especially, where the monoliths dropped) If the monolith drops in a location behind the spaceship, there seems to be nothing you can do.
Apr 23 18:32:00	13m 00s	Boxed	Awesome concept! Very innovative and I love the way you used the theme. I really wanted to play around and figure it out, but in the end the game proved to be too buggy for my patience. Especially when you try to throw a box against a pedistal odd things might happen and I kept getting stuck.
Apr 23 18:42:00	10m 00s	Gravity Sucks [WEB]	Nice game! A very polished entry. The one thing I hated was when a planet I didn't even set foot on yet exploded in front of me.
Apr 23 18:46:00	4m 00s	Zephyr	I liked it a lot! Best use of audio I've seen so far. I loved the atmosphere.
Apr 23 19:00:00	14m 00s	Minikin	Pretty long! It wasn't really hard, and it felt more like a level based platformer than an adventure game, but neither of those are bad things.
Apr 23 19:07:00	7m 00s	Nom Nom Planet	my score was 37150. It was pretty fun! The best part was that apparently your house can be three times as big as the world it is built on.
Apr 23 19:55:00	48m 00s	Tiny Dream	I got to the end. Are the multiple endings? I ended up doing nothing with that machine. The mood was great, but could have been better with some sound.
Apr 23 20:07:00	12m 00s	Bottlecolonies	very, very charming game.
Apr 23 20:12:00	5m 00s	Tin World	Very cute. I liked the title screen and the bold move to make the game impossible after a few seconds of playing. The controls were a bit slow, though.
Apr 23 20:16:00	4m 00s	A Tiny New World	There isn't much to do. Would have liked some sort of feedback for shooting those enemies.
Apr 23 20:39:00	23m 00s	Gravity Force 3	Pretty fun! Also very polished. The resolution of the web version was a bit large for my laptop screen.
Apr 23 21:05:00	26m 00s	Tiny Quest	Yeah! Gameboy graphics! <br/>I had a good time playing, but the boss didn't appear for me, which was weird.
Apr 23 21:13:00	8m 00s	Le Petit	Looks good and nice audio, but it gets too hard too quickly, mostly because when you fall down the double jump doesn't respond quickly enough. I didn't finish the game.
Apr 23 21:20:00	7m 00s	NanoQuest	The game could have been a lot more lively with some animations (and sound), but the concept is very nice.
Apr 23 21:28:00	8m 00s	Stargazer	This looks and plays great! I would use something other than numbers to show when something is about to fall down though.
Apr 23 21:37:00	9m 00s	Quark	It looks great, but it was a bit easy, and I really wanted to shoot something. <br/> <br/>Very good for a first entry!
Apr 23 21:55:00	18m 00s	Tiny Island Adventure	(almost) flawless!
Apr 23 22:01:00	6m 00s	Toad Warrior	This looks amazing and the controls are very original. I got stuck behind the glowing crystals on the right of the first level, though.
Apr 23 22:16:00	15m 00s	Dave is in a Fish Tank	Very fun! Really nice to play with.
Apr 23 22:25:00	9m 00s	Beyond	I loved the visuals but didn't think the soundscape was really fitting. I also had a hard time getting out of some of the pits in the terrain.
Apr 23 22:32:00	7m 00s	I Painted a Tiny World	The concept is great and I love the colors used, but the game is too hard, mostly because of what happens when you hit an enemy, it's almost an automatic loss.
Apr 23 22:40:00	8m 00s	Tiny Adventures In SPACE	There were some very funny elements to this, for example the weird objects floating through space and the fact that the protagonist completely missed that enormous purple planet the first time he passed it. I liked it.
Apr 23 22:44:00	4m 00s	TinyFish	Nice concept. It's a bit rough though and I managed to get stuck between two big fish somehow.
Apr 23 22:51:00	7m 00s	Full Metal Planetoid	Is there a strategy to it? I couldn't really figure it out, but sometimes whole chunks of the planet would suddenly disappear.
Apr 23 22:54:00	3m 00s	Congratulations Doc, it's a shrink ray!	Yes, being able to shrink ninja's makes up for a lot ;) <br/>Loved the text too.
Apr 23 22:59:00	5m 00s	Triskelion	When I killed one of the guardians the game froze. Overall the game was pretty nice.
Apr 23 23:08:00	9m 00s	Ant In Training	I liked the teleporting puzzles. I didn't realise there was actually a reason to go back other than a backup for when you get stuck until I read the comments.
Apr 23 23:12:00	4m 00s	ANtopia	Works great. I like the art and love the music. Reminds me of Super Metroid.
Apr 23 23:23:00	11m 00s	Tiny Defender	The art was charming, but the game lacked variation and I got bored with it in the right leg.
Apr 24 16:24:00	17h 01m	dLeIaFtEh	I liked the mood and art, but there is nothing interesting to do, really.
Apr 24 16:38:00	14m 00s	Dude, where's my planet	Looks and sounds beautiful. Game is nice too, but it can get annoying when you have to wait while hanging still in the air because of the lack of gravity.
Apr 24 16:46:00	8m 00s	Eye Quest	Pretty fun, most puzzles wern't really chalenging, but all were fun to play around with.
Apr 24 17:03:00	17m 00s	Download Incomplete	Feels very complete and polished. Could have used a bit more variation in the later levels though.
Apr 24 17:13:00	10m 00s	Tinysasters	Once I knew what I was doing this was a lot of fun.
Apr 24 17:25:00	12m 00s	Full Circuit	I have nothing to add to the above comments, making a mistake is punished too harshly, but the game looks great.
Apr 24 17:50:00	25m 00s	MakHappy	It's fun figuring out what everyone wants. I got stuck on both of the poop guys for a while, I couldn't find the toilet and I didn't know what to give to the other one, until there was only one thing left. I managed to finish it though!
Apr 24 18:06:00	16m 00s	Orbiter	It has a lot of potential but I got too bored to continue after day 14. It's very easy.
Apr 24 18:18:00	12m 00s	Going Rogue	I can see what this would have been like as a roguelike. Best part was using the pillar as a sword.
Apr 24 18:26:00	8m 00s	Prince of Leaves	Best music in a game so far!
Apr 24 18:34:00	8m 00s	Tiny World: The Musical: The Game	Very awesome. I figured out you could switch between paddles too late.
Apr 24 18:42:00	8m 00s	Intertubes	It was fun and I didn't encounter any bugs, so good job.
Apr 29 08:30:00	109h 48m	A Tenthlings Quest	Great mood and I liked the long cutscenes a lot. Combat could have been better (monsters kept running through you after you hit them), but there wern't that many enemies anyway.
Apr 29 08:43:00	13m 00s	Drill It!: Demolition Co.	Liked the faces as well. I didn't get very far because of how the keys were mapped, but I can see this being very fun.
Apr 29 15:03:00	6h 20m	Skully's Microscopic World	The concept is nice but it needs some balancing. I think the main thing that is wrong with it is that the game can become unwinnable long before you actually die, and when this happens the game becomes very boring.
Apr 29 15:14:00	11m 00s	Planet Master	Impressive, and I've played around a bit, but there isn't really a goal, is there?
Apr 29 15:23:00	9m 00s	Rockland	Looks nice! But I never got to make that call because the birds kept stealing my money!
Apr 29 15:34:00	11m 00s	Save the tiny world!	I wasn't able to save everyone because the enemies were too fast. But it looks great and the audio was good, and it was pretty fun as well.
Apr 29 15:42:00	8m 00s	The Collector	I don't know if it was your goal, but the world around you feels really big, making you feel really small. So good job on that. Also collecting monsters is fun, but it would be better if there was some kind of feedback that shows when you can capture a monster.
Apr 29 15:50:00	8m 00s	Tininess Defense	Very weird concept, but it does work. I lasted for about four minutes.
Apr 29 15:57:00	7m 00s	3 Arrows	I don't think there was enough contrast between background objects and objects you can walk on. I kept jumping on those acorns only to fall through them.
Apr 29 16:10:00	13m 00s	$ales	I couldn't get above 200K because of travel expenses, it seems trading in food is the easiest way to get rich. Fun game!
Apr 29 16:14:00	4m 00s	GERMS: A Ghost Story	The controls wern't amazing. Too little friction, but the idea is very cool.
Apr 29 16:19:00	5m 00s	Rat Conquest	This looks great, but faster movement would have done wonders for the game, it's really slow now.
Apr 29 16:40:00	21m 00s	Deconstructorium	This game fits the theme the best so far I think. It's also really fun.
Apr 29 16:49:00	9m 00s	Bactarium	I'm king of the petri dish!! <br/>A bit easy and not much replayability after you win, but pretty fun the first time you play it.
Apr 29 16:58:00	9m 00s	Tiny Galaxy	Really nice game, could be great if developed further. Reminds me of pacman and clu clu land.
Apr 29 17:06:00	8m 00s	Bright Worlds	Fun idea, nice sound and graphics, but I don't see the theme in it.
Apr 29 17:15:00	9m 00s	Secrets of The Universe	Killing the zombie took way too long and some of the paths you had to take were really boring, but it does have potential. I liked the idea of flat squares floating in space.
Apr 29 17:31:00	16m 00s	Interstellar Planet-Ship Adventures: The Search for... $@#% Aliens!!!!!!	I finally managed to get some youth to train when I got an error I couldn't ignore (something with the variable 'mating') I see the potential but I think it was a bit too ambitious for 48 hours.
Apr 29 17:44:00	13m 00s	Tiny Galaxy	Looks really nice and there is a lot of variation
Apr 29 18:13:00	29m 00s	Evolve	lots of fun. I have no real complaints.
Apr 29 18:29:00	16m 00s	Exposed	Stunning! Found everything except the eyes.
Apr 29 18:38:00	9m 00s	Rocket Boat	Pretty hard. But the game looks and sounds great.
Apr 29 18:51:00	13m 00s	T in Y World	This is hard to rate because I love it so much and I don't really know why.
Apr 29 18:57:00	6m 00s	Space Rescue!	Fun game. Some problems are that you can lose your ship in space when you go outside of the screen, and the controls could be a bit more precise.
Apr 29 19:11:00	14m 00s	Bottled Worlds	Very nice! I did manage to get stuck in the walls a couple of times though.
Apr 29 19:23:00	12m 00s	Galactic Messenger	I could never find the planet I had to go to, even if the directions stated it was very close. It was weird. But I like the idea.
Apr 29 19:31:00	8m 00s	Spitoon	Very nice concept for a puzzle game! Very original.
Apr 29 19:36:00	5m 00s	Junior's Car	The game is very short and I'm missing a highscore table. Other than that, I liked what you did with the theme.
Apr 29 19:39:00	3m 00s	Tiny World's Lunar CTF	It's incomplete, but it looks great. Could be the start of something.
Apr 29 19:55:00	16m 00s	Combat Cubes	Pretty great. I'd like to have more control over my team. Perhaps you could make them attack the last enemy I was attacking or something like that?
Apr 29 20:01:00	6m 00s	Disregard All Humans	Charming! Short, but fun.
Apr 29 20:19:00	18m 00s	Little Sky....	A take on the theme I havn't seen yet (after playing 75 games.) The story was interesting but the game itself not that much.
May 2 14:48:00	66h 29m	Recluse	Cool concept! I was actually trying to get the game to play in full screen or increase the window manually somehow before I gave in and thought "Fine, I'll play the game in this rediculously small window, but I'm not going to like it." <br/> <br/>Well I did like it.
May 2 15:08:00	20m 00s	Stupid Ants	I see where this could go, but as it is, I couldn't even get close to 200 (got to 90) without just removing all the boxes.
May 2 15:20:00	12m 00s	Path O' Invasion	The controls wern't the most convenient, and I didn't really get enough feedback on when a cell was taken over, but it does have potential.
May 2 15:29:00	9m 00s	Spaceship In The Sky With Colors	This game can get hard on your brain and there is a bit too much memory involved. But it's a game that gets a lot more fun once you know what you're doing.
May 2 15:36:00	7m 00s	Survivor	I kept hoping I would be surprised by a new game element. As it is, it works, but it's very simple. The game looks very nice though.
May 9 11:52:00	164h 16m	Overpopulous	Presentation is great. Game is great too, but it doesn't feel as much like colonising as it does like just smashing into things. One of my plays the planets were invisible until I smashed into them.
May 9 12:01:00	9m 00s	Astro Break	Great! Everything an arcade game needs to be, simple, fun and polished. A catchy tune would have made this even better.
May 9 12:10:00	9m 00s	Little City	I didn't get the feeling the bars in the top had any meaning and I wasn't able to swing any of them either way. Do they do anything? I liked the visual style.
May 9 12:37:00	27m 00s	Memento XII	Amazing, very beautiful and moody. Might be the best entry I have played.
May 9 12:44:00	7m 00s	Tiny Wizard	This was great, looks good and fun to play. There is in my opinion too little feedback when you get hit. And you are pretty much doomed when you get stuck between enemies.
May 12 12:19:00	71h 35m	Hero of Rain	I love this genre, and even though the game ended in the middle of the story, it felt as one of the most complete in its genre made this ludum dare (as far as I played them.) You could do a little more with the visuals to make it really feel like a world inside a raindrop, perhaps some blurry backgrounds that show hints of the bigger world around it. The audio was moody, but I think inside the raindrop the storm wouldn't sound so clear, but more hollow and deformed.
May 12 12:37:00	18m 00s	My Little Dungeon	Great visuals and sound, and a very original idea! I agree with the earlier comment that it feels too slow. Also, when I got to the yellow-ish skeletons, they refused to attack me and I couldn't proceed.
May 12 12:41:00	4m 00s	Get The FROG Off My World !!	I yelled at 65 frogs! Simple but funny.
May 12 14:59:00	2h 18m	[Darkness Creeping]	While the mood was great and the concept clearly very clever, I had to start the game over a couple of times because I got stuck in walls or died without explenation, Even though I knew where the red key was I was never able to reach it because of these bugs. I bet there was still a lot to see after that, but I just didn't want to have to start over again. That may sound negative but I gave you a lot of stars for this, just not that many for 'fun'.
May 12 15:13:00	14m 00s	Away from Home	Very lengthy and mostly fun. There are a couple of small things I would change. First of all I would give the player information about something before they do that thing. After I went to another planet I got a message that going to planets costs 5 oil. I felt kind of cheated and would have liked to know that earlier. Also, when I opened one of the chests my coal fell into a bottomless pit, never to be seen again, that was kind of frustrating.
May 12 15:18:00	5m 00s	Save the World	Having mouse controls would improve this game, the concept is very smart though and there is a lot of potential, not that it wasn't fun already! <br/> <br/>I did miss a score system.
May 12 16:01:00	43m 00s	Cracked	The game felt more like a memory game than a puzzle or strategy game, but the concept and controls were very simple and elegant, something that's not easy with this genre. Some little tweaks in the concept could turn this into a very smart game.
May 12 16:50:00	49m 00s	The borders of Tiny World	The first level showed the game's potential best. Even though the concept of flipping the level isn't new, there is still a lot that can be done with it. The randomly generated levels did generate a lot of frustrating situations, though some were quite fun/ funny as well. If you tweak the level generator this could be a lot less frustrating an a lot more fun.
May 12 17:05:00	15m 00s	Planetline	This is pretty solid. The game looks good, and the sounds that are there work well. The game's difficulty seemed to come more from the controls than the presented challenges, which can get frustrating.
May 12 17:17:00	12m 00s	Tiny girl	I laughed when I saw the title "little girl" in combination with the controls "X - bomb" and "Z - shoot" and continued when I saw that all the enemies where shooting what seemed like deadly hearts. I had fun though, and the flower boss was well done. The transition to the boss was also surprising.
May 12 17:36:00	19m 00s	ONLY US	Really good, the best part was that the further you went to the right, the more isolated you felt because it would take so long to get back to your partner.
May 12 17:46:00	10m 00s	2 Tiny Gods	The idea is very nice but it didn't really shine through in the game itself. There was also a mix of very different graphic styles that didn't work well together, but the game concept has more potential than a lot of games I have seen.
May 12 18:57:00	1h 11m	Gale Axile	I BEAT IT!!! <br/> <br/>That was really hard. I think there might be more ways to get stuck with the random generator than you realise, and the game keeps getting easier instead of harder, but those things are easily forgiven when you consider how much depth this game has, and also, because I BEAT it.
May 12 19:09:00	12m 00s	Mayor vs Aliens	Nice fun game. Aiming was a bit weird (I never seemed to hit anything) so I mostly bounced. Got a score of 1500
May 12 19:25:00	16m 00s	Moon Base	I also think the difficulty curve is way too steep. On the other hand you get an original concept, charming visuals with great animations and very pleasant sound effects.