Sooo... I have finished the game and here's my honest review and feedback.
Narative
- Falling from the plane story would have been much funnier, if not spoiled in the entry description - What should be upper case letters are upper case in one lines, and lower case in the others – makes it a bit difficult to read - Nice meta-humour with references to LOST, WD-40, Starfield with Frontier (?), Animerica - Loved the charisma check part! Great reference to BG3(?)! - Overall subtle and pleasant humour! - Last cutscene is amazing!
Gameplay
- Boat feels like boat in animations and physics department, cool! - Lack of camera rotation controls is really noticeable. Could have been even isometric without rotation, especially given that it becomes isometric (or very close to isometric) during dialogs - There are different character models, wow! - Some dialog options disappear when talked, some stay, IDK if it’s intentional. Options with what to do next are okey to stay, narrative options questionable - Full game would benefit from UI directions for discovered islands or a map - Struggled too much to figure out where to use the fishing rod and/or find Barry. Even started second play through thinking there is a bug that doesn’t allow me to fish on the tree island
Controls
- Move in the mouse direction would have been a nice option - Boaty controls a bit painful, A/D for direction instead of rotation would help a lot. Boat still can rotate according to it’s slow to response physics - Fog as a world border would have been better
Graphics, art and visuals
- Great visual style! - Hide object (or make it semi-transparent) if it’s between camera and player would have been nice - Some sprites give 3D vibes and feel in place (ex: grass) at a specific camera angles, some are very 2D (ex: trees, jars on the ground on the lighthouse island). Seems to do with sprites angle being not ideal for the angle of camera, and the fact that camera is perspective and changes Y-rotation while sprites stay static - Interesting solution for the buildings to place multiple sprites there, can use an upgrade for the full game though
Sound
- Great background music choice! - Great subtle sound effects overall! - Lack of boat sound effects was definitely noticeable :(
Bugs
- Coin between the trees (on the Windell island) you can’t get to - Sprites popped in a couple of times when approaching starting island from it’s West - Waves showing up on the tree island's ground - Characters fallback to “have you find [that thing I asked you for] yet?” after their ark completed
---
Overall
10 out of 5, great entry!