Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD46 → Feedback comment stats → polegar
Feedback comments for LD46
polegar's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | polegar's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 20 08:40:27 | Robositter Infernal | ♥ 1 | The gameplay is fun and challenging thanks to the increase of difficulty over time ! | |
| Apr 20 09:22:14 | 41m 47s | Fight the virus | ♥ 2 | Perfect usage of the theme ! It's a really smart representation of how the epidemy spread between humans (with or without mask protection)... and how difficult it is for doctors to threat all this amount of sick people ! I had fun playing your game, great work ! |
| Apr 20 12:41:13 | 3h 18m | Dungeon Feeds | ♥ 0 | The gameplay has a great feeling thanks to the audio and the very nice graphics. The only things that bothered me was the way enemy spawned right on the middle, it felt too hard to dodge them and I died a lot 😄. Overall, I had a good time playing your game and all the little details made it feels very polished ! |
| Apr 20 13:17:28 | 36m 15s | Save humanity: coronavirus killer | ♥ 1 | Good game, love the characters graphics, I had a good laugh when the first virus appeared and followed me with the main character running out like "Ohh shit !" 😄. I like the fact that you used the actuality to fit the theme. I try to leave a way of improvement in my comments : It would have been great to have little different assets for some levels like different floor or wall texture. But it's time consuming, I faced the same issue in my game. Anyway, really fun entry ! |
| Apr 20 14:05:53 | 48m 25s | Filicide | ♥ 1 | Wow such a good entry ! The atmosphere is really great, a bit like Katana Zero. You did a great job playing with the lights and the character line of sight. The audio add a lot to the mix ! Since you implore us to do so, I didn't cheese the game and had a great feeling with the gameplay, a little more difficulty would have been perfect. |
| Apr 20 19:26:05 | 5h 20m | Memories | ♥ 0 | Nice one, and original use of the theme ! Love the general atmosphere, thanks to the music that is pretty nice. I also like the fact that you did it with PICO-8 because it means that you had to develop a lot of things by yourself and I like this retro feeling. For the critisim : since the game is pretty intriguing I whish it was a longer |
| Apr 21 09:06:56 | 13h 40m | Keep Her Happy | ♥ 1 | This is a very original idea and a great use of deep learning ! Yes as you said in your last comment the game need a little more polish on the graphics but the mood is still quite nice thanks to the good audio. |
| Apr 21 09:28:20 | 21m 24s | The Gentleman | ♥ 0 | Really original idea and perfectly realized ! There is a lot of details that make it very fun and very clean. |
| Apr 21 10:56:28 | 1h 28m | A Support's Burden | ♥ 4 | Great game and great usage of the theme ! You managed to create a really funny game with good mechanics thanks to the comical duo of the silly and the smart guy, the graphics and the audio. The only drawback for me was the setup phase. The idea of peeking through the keyhole is great but it's a bit to short to fully prepare for this silly guy 😄 |
| Apr 21 12:28:08 | 1h 31m | Feed It! | ♥ 0 | Pretty fun mechanics thanks to the use of physics. The number of bananas expected to reach the next level is a bit to high. Once you figured out how to feed the monster you have to wait to long for the right boxes to come with almost nothing to do. A little adjustement on this and a bit more details on the graphism would be great. |
| Apr 21 19:13:23 | 6h 45m | The Monk and the Child | ♥ 2 | Yep your link seems broken |
| Apr 21 19:20:04 | 6m 41s | Keep The Spider Alive! | ♥ 0 | The idea is fun 😄 I feel the same when there is an actual spider in my appartement "no don't kill it !". Yes some more levels would have been nice to increase the difficulty a bit. |
| Apr 21 19:33:37 | 13m 33s | It's a survival game? | ♥ 1 | Haha your homemade audio made me laugh hard ! Actually the game was pretty fun I replayed it multiple time, but it seems like it's impossible to finish it, you have almost no time to keep the fire and your character alive. With a little more polish and a bit more actions to do it would have been great. |
| Apr 21 19:50:43 | 17m 06s | Return of the Viper | ♥ 0 | The game has a great feeling thanks to the deplacement that are really smooth and the sound effects. It's nice that you take time to create a little intro, it added a lot to the mix. For the drawback maybe a better sprite/animation for the main character would have been nice. Anyway good job ! |
| Apr 22 08:48:24 | 12h 57m | VAMP | ♥ 1 | Haha we had the same idea ! I wrote a 3D game engine from scratch but it was way more time consuming than I expected. So thanks to this experience I can realize how impresive your game is ! This is so clean for only 48 hours of work, sound, game engine, graphism eveything is really really smooth and fun to play. Amazing job ! |
| Apr 22 21:02:46 | 12h 14m | NWO Simulator - World peace is an inside job | ♥ 1 | I like the idea and the message behind your game, it's pretty clean and original. A bit of audio would have been nice to guide the user trough his actions, because it's a bit confusing in the begining. Good job 🙂 |
| Apr 23 13:10:05 | 16h 07m | Until Sunrise | ♥ 2 | Great entry ! Music and graphsm are amazings. The game is nice to play, controls feels good and the concept is cool. The only thing that bothered me was the fact that there is not enough upgrade to justify the 30 min timer. Maybe some cool but expensive upgrades like an AOE for killing enemies or a spell to make an enemy healing the fire instead of killing it would have create a desire to play longer in order to have a really powerful character. Anyway great job ! |
| Apr 23 13:33:19 | 23m 14s | Defend the Loot! | ♥ 1 | Good entry ! I like the fact that you create it from scratch, it makes the result way more impressive. For the drawback : It would have been cool to be able to start the wave whenever you are ready, because if you fail it is a bit frustrating to wait all the preparation to retry. |
| Apr 24 14:02:08 | 24h 28m | Alien Intensive Care | ♥ 1 | The most innovative game I played so far, one of the few where I really had fun playing with ! As some other people said it's too difficult, almost impossible ? I tried at least 10 times and I can't pass the 3 minutes mark. The sense of urgency that give the difficulty is great but it can be frustrating some time. Anyway this is one of my favorite, amazing job ! |
| Apr 24 16:34:52 | 2h 32m | Beached | ♥ 1 | Very original idea and really clean realization ! It's nice that you took the time to create an introduction with those funny dialogs 😄 The only drawback for me was the audio theme which was too short, so that was a bit repetitive during the entire game. |
| Apr 24 16:48:22 | 13m 30s | Battle Box | ♥ 1 | Very very original idea, it leads to a game with a really fun gameplay ! A bit of audio (even really simple) and a bit more graphisms would have been great because without it your game feels more like a proof of (a great) concept. Anyway this great since on top of that you had to discover unity ! |
| Apr 25 16:42:49 | 23h 54m | The Ill Divinity | ♥ 3 | Amazing game, one of my favorite ! I really liked the graphism, the gameplay and the level design. It's nice that you took time to create an intro and outro which improve the overall mood of the game. The only drawback was that I had to look in the comment to figure out how to finish the game, but once I figured out I liked the difficulty of this level. It took me 64 death, but I made my way trough the end 😄 ! And I don't know if it was supposed to be interpreted like this, but at the end you realize that the divinity is a cat (since when it opens it eyes it really looked like a cat ...) Anyway great job ! |
| Apr 26 19:34:22 | 26h 51m | Peanut Butcher | ♥ 1 | Funny idea and good realization ! I like the idea of level down, it's a good way to make the gameplay more and more challenging and it's original. On top of that you have good graphics and audio. Good game ! |
| Apr 27 13:05:39 | 17h 31m | Feeding Time! | ♥ 1 | Fun idea and gameplay ! It's nice that you created your own game engine and still had a really good result. The game misses a bit of audio for the overall experience and giving feedback to the player. Anyway great job ! |
| Apr 27 20:29:45 | 7h 24m | Twitch Feeds | ♥ 1 | I just got the highest score ! Really innovative idea, you should comment on other game to have more visibility ! |
| Apr 27 21:06:18 | 36m 33s | Square Loves Circle! | ♥ 1 | I loved it, it's really nice that you managed time to create a complete clean, challenging and moody game. On top of that you did it in webassembly ! That's really great |
| Apr 29 11:13:44 | 38h 07m | Xeno Tender | ♥ 1 | Really original idea that fits the theme perfectly. The retro feeling graphics are nice and I like the fact that you developped your game engine from scratch in JS. Since it's clearer what to do with the cat than with the other creatures, maybe you should have put the cat automaticly on the first level as a "tutorial". The game misses audio which yould have added a better feedback to the player and improve the overall experience. Anyway great idea and good game ! |
| Apr 29 20:07:43 | 8h 53m | Homestead | ♥ 1 | Great atmosphere, you definetly managed to create an horror game and it's a very original idea since I don't recall to ever saw an horror game during a Ludum Dare. It's a shame that you didn't have time to fully complete it (the scroll were a great idea), I will definetly play it again if you upload a POST COMP version. Good job ! |
| Apr 29 20:21:01 | 13m 18s | Super Simp Boy | ♥ 0 | Good complete game, with a nice intro/tutorial and loosing scene. And I always like to see games which are not created with Unity, thanks to that I can discover new library ! Nice job ! |
| Apr 29 20:32:02 | 11m 01s | Monster Love | ♥ 0 | Solid entry, since you put on a lot of work with a real level design with an increase of difficulty, a good music and a funny game/gameplay. The drawbacks for me are the sprite animation which stay in place when you stop moving, an idle sprite would have been great and the controls are a bit frustrating since you can't hit and move at the same time (even if it can be voluntary to add difficulty), but that is some details. Anyway great job ! |
| Apr 30 16:23:37 | 19h 51m | Conway's Garden of Life | ♥ 1 | Amazing idea and great tribute to John Conway. It would have been nice if you had time to add more features to make it more entertaining for the player like music and sounds/graphics effects when you reach a certain number of berries. Anyway great job and I like idle game ! |
| Apr 30 17:07:57 | 44m 20s | MIRACLE WORKER | ♥ 0 | That is amazing ! So much work done in 48hours : A 3D game with story telling with intro and outro, a lot of interractive assets, and some audio effects that fit perfectly the game. The only drawback for me was the clarity of the gameplay, even though I assembled all the broken piece and put the fuel in place I was stuck with nothing more to do and nothing happened. Maybe you have to do it in a specific order like in the playtrough but if it's the case it's pretty hard to guess. Anyway one of the most impressive entry for me. |
| May 7 20:03:48 | 170h 55m | RushBomb | ♥ 2 | Great idea and realization, I really like the mood that you created for your game thanks to the console graphics and the audio. They both go very well together. The gameplay was simple but fun, the firewall level is a nice surprise and change the rythm of the game. For the drawbacks : when you loose it's a bit frustrating because there is no loosing screen and the game stops. It would have been nice to restart from the level you were at. Anyway great job !! It's nice to discover that there are more people from the "no game engine team" 😄 ! |
| May 8 09:49:17 | 13h 45m | For Ducks' Sake | ♥ 1 | Amazing job ! It's the first game of the LD built with phaser 3. I wanted to try this library one day, is there a plateform where I can see your source code ? It's pretty hard to find good example built with phaser 3. |