Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD44 → Feedback comment stats → mamoniem
Feedback comments for LD44
mamoniem's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | mamoniem's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 1 05:01:06 | Our Dear Friend | ♥ 1 | I did enjoy playing "Our Dear Friend", the final product is really well polished comparing to a jam entry! The art is amazing, the sound fx and music is well done, the mechanic though isn't really perfect, I love grappling hooks, but this one was different, for example: why it shoot in short distance, while at the same time i can't see beyond few centimeters from the player, it would have made more sense if i can shoot it for longer or even infinite distance (again this is from only the fact of not seeing where i'm shooting it). Also it would have made more fun if i can use the grappling hook to kill the spiders, then i would have needed for the right click button mechanic then. I can't imagine shooting the grappling hook to start swinging, i don't see where the hook ends, and when i move there, i find a dead spider :D that would be fun! Again, for a jam entry, i'm amazed, and it is really nice. Well done! -m | |
| May 1 05:10:08 | 9m 02s | BatteryWars | ♥ 2 | Nice game! and at some point it becomes tense :D You've done a good job, not only in picking the game idea, but also in kinda balancing the game, i liked the idea of how many bullet you need to shoot an enemy and what is the return type of battery to get! I would say the only issue i had while playing that i had the feeling that all enemies almost sharing the same speed, which i guess very similar to the player speed, which made it easy to get stuck in a corner surrounded by all the different types of enemies. I would not mind that scenario, but only if I've the ability to shoot faster, or even shoot more effective bullets with higher damage. Good job! -m |
| May 1 06:49:21 | 1h 39m | Sinner | ♥ 3 | The game seem nice...HUGE credits screen, but hard to play, I don't know if I've played the jam version or the updated 1.1, but i had hard time in correctly do the action at the desired direction. I could be looking left, but when dash, the girl dash right, and could be looking right and when i use the weapon it hit at the other direction. Which made me die fast, and die a lot. Music and mood were nice btw! -m |
| May 1 06:57:06 | 7m 45s | Ancient Current See | ♥ 1 | Good take on the theme. It was hard to get the point at first, i keep pressing "E" and nothing happens, until mistakenly I've don it while being within the blue circle, then it was the "Ahaaaaa" moment. The game is overall nice, and fitting theme perfectly, also impressive that you used godot engine, which is something we don't see a lot recently. My only issue with the game, that i've always been thinking i'll be using the sword :D it is there, so i must use it, but I didn't so far!! -m |
| May 1 07:01:58 | 4m 52s | How can a Demon merchant be this cool!? | ♥ 0 | Oh,..old school text adventure...We not used to play that type of games nowadays!! It requires some Imagination =D for the graphics! I imagined playing it as pixel art!!! Good job! there is one note though, google chrome is reporting the file, and asking if i'm sure that i want to download that suspicious file, and even after downloading, the windows defender say it doesn't trust that file, and when i ran it, windows say it is from unknown source, am I sure about this!!! So I trust and bypassed all that, but may be other person won't, and might simply delete it before playing. -m |
| May 1 07:11:14 | 9m 16s | Our Mechanical Life | ♥ 2 | hahaha, yea, better to start the comment laughing, as this is what i really felt while playing. The game started normal, like any other game, i move, and collect items, and read the text on the screen. I liked the idea of collecting anything and everything =D nothing harmful, but this actually as much as it made me happy, it made me suspecting that is something will happen. And suddenly things started to speed up :D It became crazy, hahaha, can't be fast enough to read, and can't control what to collect, it became crazy, and I liked it! specially because I expected death, and it did happen! KUDOS!!!! -m |
| May 1 07:37:48 | 26m 34s | Rent for Life | ♥ 2 | Never been a reaper before, so it's new to me :D First attempt, I was experimenting the game, and the controllers, it took time, so I only collected 3 lives, but then the boss came and say I disappointed him, i then noticed that there were timer counting. So in the following attempt i focused on collecting 10/10 lives, and I did at the last couple of seconds, but the big guy said I disappointed him again.. I kept trying, but he always say I'm disappointing him, so I assume there is something broken in the game loop/logic. I would recommend you show the controls at the main menu, may be making the UI larger, specially the time so I can see it, may be the countdown timer make sound of ticking at least when your time is near an end. The souls/people, might need to be more at first, at least at first time to play, so player don't need to keep walking more just to reach one person in the middle of no where. Also fixing navigation will be nice, as the people used to walk through the fountain. -m |
| May 1 07:43:38 | 5m 50s | Servant to the Reaper | ♥ 1 | Good game, Good music and amazing art quality! -m |
| May 1 07:51:56 | 8m 18s | Heart of the Grove | ♥ 0 | Lovely meaningful game, with fancy UI and amazing art and music. The game was freezing for few frames, specially when starting it, but i'm okay with that. I like the entire package together, well done! 5/5 start on all aspects btw! -m |
| May 1 08:03:14 | 11m 18s | Maeko's Memories | ♥ 0 | A nice telltale take for the jam! -m |
| May 1 09:40:37 | 1h 37m | Gainz 4 Cash | ♥ 3 | Wow, when i saw 450MB for a jam entry :D i thought it must be an open world game, but later after 1 hour of slow internet downloading I figured out how funny and silly it is :D |
| May 1 10:08:41 | 28m 04s | The Trials of Marzbān | ♥ 0 | Oh man, i'm good with the game, but why many games this time near 1/2 GB in size !!! |
| May 1 10:15:43 | 7m 02s | Catch all the coins | ♥ 1 | Crazy one, it started boring game, and ended up being very challenging. Also good job, as it seems you made your own game from scratch not using any modern engine, via something like allegro, which is impressive! Regarding the gameplay, my only recommendation is to make sure no coins are spawned behind the UI text, as most of the time, I know that I've collected everything, but the level not ended, and by looking carefully, i find a coin is behind the text. My only recommendation is not about the game itself, it is to use something like itch.io or dropboox, as mediafire required med to use VPN to access it. -m |
| May 1 10:19:11 | 3m 28s | Dont Drop The Bass! | ♥ 0 | haha, I liked that soundcloud game! |
| May 1 18:00:24 | 7h 41m | Demonic Dealings | ♥ 1 | "WOHAha HA HA Haaaa" =D Nice one! |
| May 1 18:14:57 | 14m 33s | Your Life, My Currency | ♥ 1 | "Hated Strawberry" of course sending her straight to hell!! I love your game, it is simple, easy to understand, and funny to play even with that simple clicking controller! It reminded me with papers Please, but in more ironically way! Good graphics for a jam game, nice music and amazing evil laugh! Well-done! -m |
| May 1 18:17:30 | 2m 33s | Potion Wolf | ♥ 0 | That skating wolf! it is hard to understand first, but with couple of tries, I got it! -m |
| May 1 18:19:59 | 2m 29s | Greenback | ♥ 1 | Funny game. I assume the dash sound effect is actually you performing it, right? -m |
| May 1 19:57:52 | 1h 37m | Black Friday Shopping | ♥ 3 | Good to play! |
| May 1 20:39:20 | 41m 28s | Penny Arcane | ♥ 0 | Wow! |
| May 1 22:56:36 | 2h 17m | Social Livestock | ♥ 0 | I am impressed with the quality! |
| May 2 08:01:49 | 9h 05m | Experimental Treatments | ♥ 0 | I can run the game without any issues. Good idea! -m |
| May 2 08:18:38 | 16m 49s | Heart Knight | ♥ 1 | Impressive! Amazing! Innovative! IMPOSSIBLE! |
| May 2 08:31:02 | 12m 24s | Life Pact | ♥ 2 | I love the game, and love the art style more! |
| May 2 18:21:48 | 9h 50m | The Steep Price Paid in Grey Dale | ♥ 4 | That's a AA game for a jam! Well done! -m |
| May 2 18:31:37 | 9m 49s | The Giving Thing | ♥ 1 | That art! |
| May 2 18:37:58 | 6m 21s | Blood Type Z | ♥ 1 | I loved your art style more than anything else! |