Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD39 → Feedback comment stats → edmond00
Feedback comments for LD39
edmond00's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | edmond00's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 31 11:34:22 | And Here Again | ♥ 1 | The mood is nice but the the game is a little hard to understand. I think you should add more explanation about the purpose and the rules of your game. Also, the music was not playing (It is may be only my machine because I use a mac and the mac version was not working so I used the windows one with wine). But I listened it apart and it was good ! | |
| Jul 31 12:04:38 | 30m 16s | The adventure of Dotty | ♥ 3 | The idea around meditation is interresting and it is nice to have a progressive difficulty that let the player learn the basis. The controls are not very intuitive but I suppose it is a part of the game. Still, I wonder if it will not be better to remove the run mode that is not very usefull and always decrease energy when you walk instead. In my opinion, the narrative phases was a little too long. Also you need to chose between the humoristic and cute cartoon and the dark music from the eighties. |
| Jul 31 12:31:32 | 26m 54s | Power Grid Manager | ♥ 2 | 7120 points ! It was very fun, mostly at the end when all become crazy. The concept is simple but it is nice to have the button and the broken key to add challenge. The music and graphics are well suited. Good job ! |
| Jul 31 13:15:58 | 44m 26s | Ten Little Letters | ♥ 2 | It is a very good idea. It is nice to see the letter with the dot where we have clicked at the end. The minimalist design is good. However, it is too hard. I tried a lot of time and never succeed to have more than 3 letters. There are too many letters that are similar (O/D, X/K,...). Also, I think you should use a font where all the letters have the same dimension (for example, here the W is larger than the D so it is hard to visualize the border of the board). But it stays a very good game ! |
| Jul 31 13:43:43 | 27m 45s | Character Building | ♥ 2 | I lost my children :( The situation and the results of our choices are sometime a little random but this is a clever use of the theme in a narrative game ! The retro design and sound are good but the text a little hard to read. |
| Jul 31 14:47:26 | 1h 03m | Highway to the Nearest Gas Station | ♥ 2 | At first, I thought it was a funny little simulation game. Then I saw my car slide down during a stop and I started to become a little anxious. Then I lose my sense of direction and I was afraid to backtrack. Then I was wondering if it was an infinite road and I panicked. But I finished to the gas station so everything is ok. Very good horror game. |
| Jul 31 15:01:33 | 14m 07s | High Rise | ♥ 1 | I rose to the 90th floor. As the tallest residential tower (432 Park Avenue) has only 85 floors I consider that I won. I like the visual and the music but I found the gameplay too repetitive. |
| Jul 31 15:20:21 | 18m 48s | Cities | ♥ 2 | Good idea and very great mood ! The ways to show which lightpost is selected with the intensity of the light, or the risk of power failure with the sound and blinks are very nice. But from the level 4, it's become too difficult too handle all the lightposts and citizens. Also, it will be great to make the rotatable lightposts easily recognizable. |
| Jul 31 15:47:51 | 27m 30s | INVISIBRO | ♥ 1 | The gameplay is classic and the game a little short but the graphics are good and the difficulty challenging. And it is nice to have a cute end screen that end the story after the very difficult last level ! |
| Jul 31 16:03:47 | 15m 56s | Powerpoint Panic | ♥ 0 | Very original idea and nice graphics. A good parody of business meeting ! But the game is too simple and a little repetitive even if it is nice to have 3 different gauge to describe the audience. I think you should make the audience's attention decrease faster. |
| Jul 31 16:21:39 | 17m 52s | Automated Explorer | ♥ 2 | Great game ! The concept is interesting and well exploited. There is a lot of contents and the retro graphics and music are also good. Good job ! |
| Jul 31 17:04:05 | 42m 26s | Head of State | ♥ 0 | It looks interesting but it is a little hard to figure the word that you can use. |
| Aug 1 14:10:29 | 21h 06m | Don't Let the Light Go Out | ♥ 1 | Great game, fun and challenging ! May be the gameplay is a little classic, but the ambiance and controls are good. It is nice to have various enemies as it forces the player to use different strategy to kill them and make the jetpack useful. |
| Aug 1 15:04:20 | 53m 51s | Drawing with Light | ♥ 1 | The idea is great idea and it could make a very good game. But in the present state, it is frustrating because the player spend more time to die because of the bad controls and jump than to explore the main concept of the game. I think you should make the jump and the obstacle easier and the light-gun "puzzle" harder. Here you have too many energy to put mark and even without mark you can finnish a level. As this is an interesting mechanic, I would like to play to an improved version ! |
| Aug 1 15:39:14 | 34m 54s | Lost Cluster | ♥ 0 | I like the intention to make a relaxing space game. The game is pleasant , but as it is focus on exploration, I would like more various scenery and more fluid movement. Also, it is a little sad to encounter wall of asteroid when you explore, you should try to make an infinite world. |
| Aug 2 12:10:15 | 20h 31m | Wormrun | ♥ 1 | Very simple and short, but enjoyable with good music and graphics ! It is just a little sad that the game over was just a pop-up window. |
| Aug 2 12:48:24 | 38m 09s | Nyctophobia | ♥ 2 | Nice game with a very good mood. I liked the music and the small narration. But it is too difficult. I make a lot of try but I did not succeed to go to the end. May be it needs a way to regenerate our light. |
| Aug 2 13:17:30 | 29m 06s | S.O.S. | ♥ 0 | A simple game, but I liked the fact that the gameplay features (the day/night cycle, the phone battery) contribute to the difficulty as well as the immersion. I would just replace the cactus wall by something less artificial. |
| Aug 2 15:34:55 | 2h 17m | The Wiz | ♥ 2 | Relaxing game. The gameplay is a little too simple but the music and the choice of color make the mood very unique ! I liked the elements only here for the ambiance (the lightnings or the birds). |
| Aug 2 15:52:12 | 17m 17s | LOW BATT | ♥ 4 | It was an unexpected game but nonetheless it fit the theme. I liked he music that we generate as playing. It is nice to have a countdown clock even if it is just a relaxing game. Thanks to that, it give it a proper end rather than the player quitting when he begins to be bored. |
| Aug 3 03:45:16 | 11h 53m | Enerzoid | ♥ 0 | I liked it very much. My best is 11. The minimalist design enhances the addictive gameplay. The difficulty is good except may be when two successive orbs pop on the opposite side of the screen where is too difficult to grab and a little frustrating. I liked that there was no interruption of the game between two try. Also the sound design is very good. It is relaxing while adding pressure when your score begin to increase. |
| Aug 3 04:23:50 | 38m 34s | Electric Neon | ♥ 1 | About 200 points using normal mode. The atmosphere is very good so even if the battery system wasn't challenging in normal mode, I enjoyed to simply drive the car in this scenery. I would like to play the same game in a bigger environment ! |
| Aug 6 14:01:39 | 81h 37m | Overshadowed Road | ♥ 1 | Fun game with very good visual and music. I agree with @gilborn about changing one row only when pressing the button (or making the change a little slower). Also, I think the difficulty could be more interesting with less battery. |
| Aug 8 12:37:23 | 46h 35m | Aesthetics Raider | ♥ 1 | The gameplay is simple but the combination of the soundtrack and visual creates a strange and funny ambiance ! At first, I did not notice the dash button and I finished the game without using it. I tried a second time using it and the difficulty was a little simple as long as you do not try to beat your best time. May be the dash should also consume a few energy ? |
| Aug 8 12:59:34 | 22m 11s | Running out of Power Inc. | ♥ 1 | Good little game. The narration is interesting and the platform is challenging (but the wide spikes are little frustrating) and it was nice the the two was linked sometimes. However, I agree with @superpokeunicorn when he says that the reading occasionally led to weird pacing. The minimalist design works well. Good job ! |
| Aug 8 13:19:34 | 20m 00s | Power Ring Facility | ♥ 1 | With its original concept and its good minimalist design, the game is very fun but it become too difficult for me from the level 2.001, I would like to have a checkpoint in this level. I think you don't need the overload mechanic as the game is already very challenging without. I will try another time to see the end ! |
| Aug 13 17:10:02 | 123h 50m | Dying (Phone) Light | ♥ 0 | The idea is interesting. However, even if the game is supposed to be painful, you should sometime give the player some real way to charge is phone to keep him hoping win the game. Here, it seems that every time you begin to charge your phone, it stop after one or two second so it give the impression to the player that it is useless to play. Also, it would be nice to have a more various gameplay for the immersion. |
| Aug 13 17:23:04 | 13m 02s | Superstuff | ♥ 0 | The gameplay is simple but thhe difficulty is challenging and it is interesting to choose between laser or jump to pass an obstacle. It would be nice to have sound effect when you jump/shoot laser. |
| Aug 13 17:47:43 | 24m 39s | Tiny Wiring | ♥ 0 | Very good game. The concept is interesting and the level design is good. It is nice to have various mechanics as the key or the enemy, it adds complexity and immersion to the level. The minimalist visual is well done. However, the controls are not very intuitive at first so it could be nice to show visually which generator is selected. Good job ! |
| Aug 13 18:03:36 | 15m 53s | Night shift | ♥ 0 | The visual is very good and it succeed to make the game immersive even it the gameplay is very simple. It is very nice to use buildings lights to show the decrease of energy. But the gameplay become quickly repetitive so I think it needs more various mecanics. |
| Aug 13 18:17:22 | 13m 46s | Rocket Bow | ♥ 0 | Fun game with good visual and excellent music. It just need a more challenging difficulty and a scoring system (and may be some sound effect when you touch an enemy or a ghost). |