Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD40 → Feedback comment stats → edmond00
Feedback comments for LD40
edmond00's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | edmond00's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 4 13:13:17 | Populous | ♥ 1 | The gameplay looks interesting. I liked that the number of people jumping around the planet increase when the population increase, it give to the player a more concrete goal. But the rules are hard to figure and it is hard to understand how a ressource affect the population and why. I think you need to explain more at the beginning what is the purpose of the resources/influence/technology and how the cards work because there are a lot of unexplained info on screen. | |
| Dec 5 11:16:18 | 22h 03m | Proper Investment | ♥ 0 | Original Idea with intersting theme ! But because the player do not know how the different options works, it is hard to find interesting to choose instead of one other. I think you should explain more how the game works and give more feedback to the player. |
| Dec 5 11:37:02 | 20m 44s | Games Games Games | ♥ 1 | Very good idea to stack little classic game and let the player discovers them progressively when he lose. The controls and design is also good. However, it become too difficult too fast when you loose the first game. I think you should slow the bullet apparition when you pass to an other game to make the difficulty more progressive. |
| Dec 5 11:57:22 | 20m 20s | Dungeon Hoard | ♥ 1 | The enemy that stole your gold and the necessity to go put one coin in your chest before taking one other are interesting. However you should show when the character has a gold to put in the chest because I take time to figure why I could not take the other coin. The animation are also good. The game is may be a little easy. |
| Dec 5 12:11:34 | 14m 12s | Dense Revolve | ♥ 0 | The last phase is very hard but this was interesting to understand that must have only one bullet to jump high enough to touch the boss. May be there is too much effect for having bullet, slow done the movement and gravity can be enough I think. |
| Dec 5 13:24:28 | 1h 12m | SnakeBall | ♥ 1 | Nice little game with a good mechanic and an excellent level design. Well done ! |
| Dec 5 14:10:37 | 46m 09s | caffeine trip | ♥ 3 | A first I found the game a little boring and the main idea not very original. Then suddenly appear the psychedelic level. It was totally unexpected and the game become very fun. It become very difficult with the moving white platform but the twist make me want to finish the level to see if there was an other level after. Good job ! |
| Dec 5 14:29:50 | 19m 13s | SomeFin In The Way | ♥ 1 | I liked the graphics and the render of the sea is great. It could give to the game an very interesting mood with some sounds. The gameplay is may be a little too simple to be engaging. |
| Dec 6 12:24:21 | 21h 54m | Reaction Diffusion | ♥ 0 | You should indicate somewhere that you have to press C to choose because the continue button do not work. The animation is a little too slow to really appreciate but the graphic render is good. |
| Dec 6 12:47:42 | 23m 21s | Be Yourself | ♥ 1 | Good polished game ! On one hand, you want to survive but on the other hand, it is fun to see the animation of all the bubble accelerate and glue to the head, so the game is also fun to loose ! |
| Dec 6 13:22:44 | 35m 02s | Tri-Angle | ♥ 1 | 280 is my best ! The game is fun and challenging, so I have done many tries ! May the score depend too much of the luck and the ceiling was sometime frustrating but it is part of the fun and it is a little addictive anyway ! |
| Dec 6 14:00:27 | 37m 43s | 10 inches or less | ♥ 3 | I have finished the game without cheating ! The mechanic is very cool ! Most of the levels don't ask too much reflexion to be finished but the game stay fun to play even if easy. |
| Dec 6 14:17:13 | 16m 46s | Cairn | ♥ 1 | My highscore is 25. There is a little bug if you throw a stone above the screen. But the physic works well and the game is fun to play and a little addictive ! |
| Dec 6 14:52:18 | 35m 05s | The Weissman Challenge | ♥ 1 | The gameplay is challenging and fun to play even if as said before, that would have been great to have randomly generated sentence. Very good idea to use data compression as theme for your game ! |
| Dec 6 15:21:38 | 29m 20s | Click | ♥ 1 | Good rythm game with pretty graphics and excellent musics ! However, you should punish the player if he only smash without interruption the keyboard because you can win easily doing that. I think also that it could be encouraging to show the score during the game and not only at the end. |
| Dec 7 00:55:27 | 9h 33m | Leader's guidance | ♥ 2 | It was a pleasure to to serve my beloved supreme leader but my beloved supreme leader has to understand that contrary to him, it is very difficult for un simple human being to bring 5 pieces to the workstation in less than 30s without disturbing my coworkers. I beg my beloved supreme leader to be merciful with my family as they have nothing to do with my shameful failure. |
| Dec 7 05:01:13 | 4h 05m | Magus O-Minus | ♥ 1 | Really great mood with good sounds and graphics. Personaly, I liked the small screen ! The gameplay is fun to play while being enough simple to not encroach on the atmosphere and let the player immerse himself in the game. I was a little confused at first because i thought the right click was to speak and that there was a bug because ne message appear when i clicked on people and it is only after that I understand that smiley face was not a dialog button but an emotion icon. So may be you can make the icon more explicit. Also the end is very frustrating because like other players I finished on a dead end with a stair that was not working although the game is intriguing and I wanted to know more ! |
| Dec 7 05:53:15 | 52m 02s | Overdose | ♥ 0 | The difficulty is a little too simple but the game stay fun to play. Like for the ambulance, I think it will be good to have an indicator of how close tim is near to die / how many enemy there are to kill because in your first try you die without knowing exactly why. |
| Dec 7 13:15:06 | 7h 21m | Interview at Cacophony | ♥ 3 | It was very hard but I enjoyed this game ! It let the player confirm his ability to recognize instrument and this is interesting. I would like a little easier version. Good job ! |
| Dec 9 01:34:48 | 36h 19m | Ignorance is Bliss | ♥ 2 | Impressive work ! The cyberpunk mood is gorgeous! I would like to know which music you used for the game (I think there is a deux ex one ???) I think however that the player is too much lost at the beginning. Even if it is a game that need some time to be fully appreciated, giving clearer goals at the beginning and let the player try the mechanics of the game (wiretapping/sentinel) through small mission could let him be more easily involved by the story and understand how the game system work. The fact that you tape the conversation and need later to send them force the player to be attentive and this is great as you don't now precisely what you are looking for at first this is a little frustrating. Hopefully, the atmosphere is very intriguing so I still want to progress to know a little more about the game world ! |
| Dec 9 01:51:16 | 16m 28s | Money transporter | ♥ 1 | My best is 968$ ! The gameplay is simple but original to play and challenging even if a little easy. I would like if the car when it pass the border of the screen could teleport on the other border like in pacman. The game is fun to play, good job ! |
| Dec 9 02:06:15 | 14m 59s | Theme - The Game | ♥ 1 | I think you should indicate that the player can use the keyboard at some point because at first only the mouse is used and I was thinking it was that all along so I did not know how progress until I read comment. Also it is a little annoying to restart from the text popping screen when you die. |
| Dec 9 02:19:22 | 13m 07s | Fuga | ♥ 1 | The intro graphics, the core game and the music seem to come from 3 different game so it make the game mood a little strange ! The game is a little repetitive but stay fun to play for a little moment ! |
| Dec 9 02:30:34 | 11m 12s | テッ球 T E K K Y U | ♥ 1 | The graphics, sound design and slow-motion effect make this pong game very fun and enjoyable even if very hard ! |
| Dec 9 03:04:46 | 34m 12s | Busted! An Epic Cops Vs Robbers Endless Runner! | ♥ 1 | Good graphics, the render of the street is very good with some details and light effect. It was a little challenging to learn the timing to jump but after that the gameplay becomes too repetitive. |
| Dec 9 03:27:15 | 22m 29s | 25 - The Golden Age | ♥ 0 | Interesting, but the problem is that it is may be too easy to stay stable so you can play a long time without encounter the end screen and you come across the same situation a lot of time. So it become more fun to try to loose than to be stable ! |
| Dec 9 03:46:56 | 19m 41s | Techno Fever | ♥ 2 | Excellent atmosphere, the sound design and graphics are really great ! After that, the gameplay is very simple and the game is short. It is fun to play anyway but may be an other type of gameplay could have let the player enjoy in a better way the excellent mood of the game. |
| Dec 9 05:46:30 | 1h 59m | Conservation Island | ♥ 1 | Excellent game ! I managed the population during 286 seconds killing more than 1000 innocent rabbits, unfortunately, I ended with only female rabbit. The simple graphics are cute and it is nice to be able to rotate the island. the hammer is a little imprecise and the effect of the burning hammer a little confuse but the game is fun to play anyway. |
| Dec 9 06:28:15 | 41m 45s | Mister President | ♥ 1 | Very interesting interpretation of the theme ! The falling cash animation is a great feedback for the player. On the contrary, the bad effects of inflation are a little hard to notice although it is the core mechanic so it will be good to make them more concrete ! There is a lot of promising feature (choose our electoral promise, choose between inflation or debt) that could be really great if completely implemented ! |
| Dec 12 15:45:09 | 81h 16m | Drunken Avenue | ♥ 2 | Excellent game ! The minigames are difficult but challenging, specially the karaoke ! The main hub has a nice mood with good graphics. The cars on the road that an kill you and the drunkness levels are very interesting idea ! May be the loading are a little slow and some minigames a little fuzzy like the one where you have to avoid milk, but that remains a very good entry ! |
| Dec 12 16:02:56 | 17m 47s | The More The Merrier! | ♥ 1 | Very good idea and cute graphics ! The mix between a puzzle game and a gestion game is very interesting ! May you should bring people slower to give the player more time to think how to organise the room because it is hard to manage all the participant. |
| Dec 12 16:23:15 | 20m 19s | Project MADNESS | ♥ 2 | The game crash at the end of the 4th day but it was fun to play. Nice graphics ! May be 4 days is a little repetitive but some details, as the dog that you can not walk if it is raining, give a little life to the simple gameplay. Also I am not sure what was the effect of the energy drink so may be you can do it more explicit. |
| Dec 12 16:41:15 | 18m 00s | Soul Warrior Merope - Soaring Soul | ♥ 1 | Interesting concept, specially the indirect control of the ship by the ressources gestion that is very fun ! I am not sure that there was the need to add the increase of price as the points increase to this main mechanism. Good job ! |
| Dec 14 15:16:07 | 46h 34m | Stealy | ♥ 2 | Excellent game ! Really interesting gameplay. If fits the theme very well and all the mechanics (the choice of the building, the police countdown, the weight...) contribute to make this burglary simulation very immersive. May be a mechanic that force the player to take more risk, like the obligation to have X$ before X turn, is missing, but it is also very fun that the difficulty depends on the choice that make the player (choice of buildings and choice of the object to take inside the building). The fact that you can drop objet add some strategy to the game. Very good work ! |
| Dec 14 16:06:15 | 50m 08s | Feature Creep | ♥ 2 | It was a very funny experience ! The transition from a minimalist game to a messy one is very well done and the dialogue with the narrator well written. There small issues like the jump that are a little confuse and the lack of enemy once you killed them all but the concept of your game make this issues part of experience. There is a lot of new feature that are just new items so it can become a little annoying, but again it fits the message of the game and the interesting end when the game start to bug make up for it. Very good job ! |
| Dec 14 16:39:18 | 33m 03s | Computer-Man RPG | ♥ 1 | The main mechanic is interesting and at first it is fun and challenging to understand how it works. But it quickly become a little annoying because it is a little repetitive and the fight are too long and simple. But the sound, graphics and animation are all very good and make the game very enjoyable nonetheless ! I really like the style of the graphics between the gameboy render and the handmade pencil animation. The sounds during the attacks are dynamic and the music is catchy ! Good job ! |
| Dec 14 16:57:56 | 18m 38s | A cozy winter walk | ♥ 1 | Minimalist game with an enjoyable mood. I liked the cat that follow you. I was expected a little twist in the story or the gameplay at the end to fit the theme but finally I appreciated that the game stays very sober and cute even if it sounds like a misinterpretation of the theme ! |
| Dec 14 17:32:35 | 34m 39s | Between Stations | ♥ 2 | Very intriguing experience ! The game is interesting as it is but I wonder it could be more exciting if it was more difficult or take more time to find the tv sequence. Here, you can find them very quick so you play them without really interruption until the end. On one hand, it reproduce well the zapping effect but on the other hand, I think the player could feel rewarded and enjoy them more if he pass more time in the snow crash looking for them. Very good art that create a strange and hypnotic mood. Good job ! |
| Dec 16 04:06:09 | 34h 33m | Remembag | ♥ 1 | Nice graphics and music ! The gameplay is original and fit the theme but become quickly repetitive and as all object was positive, there was not so much challenge. |
| Dec 16 04:43:10 | 37m 01s | Jazzy Beats | ♥ 3 | A game very enjoyable and fun to play. Excellent graphics and music ! It is challenging, I tried 4 times but could not win. May be the attacks are a little unbalanced as other comments mentioned it. The gameplay is also interesting, I was very fun to convert you enemy to build an army. But is was also a little frustrating because the fans changed side too fast so sometime, fighting them seemed a little useless. Make the conversion slower and harder for the both side could make the fight pleasant may be. Great job ! |