Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → sdelay
Feedback comments for LD52
sdelay's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | sdelay's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 12:38:45 | 4 Harvest Bags | ♥ 2 | Soo cool, you're creative! It required concentration, but I loved it and I won. Perfectly balanced. Maybe the speed of vegetables falling could increase at some point, for exemple at 1min. | |
| Jan 10 08:21:57 | 19h 43m | Sparkle Slime Mushroom Man | ♥ 1 | I am playing, and sudenly I realize it's been 15min of clicking, and everytime the time is up, I start a new game without even noticing 😃 Nice one, and kind of... addictive ! Maybe it's the grinding effect. I love te graphics, and all three bonuses are well designed. |
| Jan 10 08:43:25 | 21m 28s | Potion Panic | ♥ 2 | The idea is simple : grind and use what you got, but use with cautious for further levels. I havent defeated the boss yet, but I'm trying. And most of all, I love the art! bright colors, simple pixel art, but effective. Sounds effect are cool (especially when she gets hit) |
| Jan 10 10:31:16 | 1h 47m | Gun Harvester | ♥ 1 | Great game, the cool thing are : * graphics obviously, very polished and bright * animations : bullets, screen shakes * you give power to your enemy, and get the reward accordingly. The investment is a nice mechanic. It gets laggy with 4-5 roses (too many items to render I guess). But I played for 20min straight without even noticing. Addictive! |
| Jan 10 13:01:08 | 2h 29m | There is a rabbit here! | ♥ 1 | "One of them pulled more than 1900 carrots" I don't how is that even possible. I did 111 on my second try. Great game, requires focus to play. I love the tiny simple pixel art, and also simple animations. GG |
| Jan 10 14:29:11 | 1h 28m | mad veggies | ♥ 1 | Love those puzzles! Also the tutorial is good because progressive. I once had to go back to previous help to catch up a rule I forgot. A good thing you could add is a "replace". When you grad a veggie to a cell where there is already one, the previous go back to the list, and the one you drop replaces it. Here is a tiny level of mine : vW/FgQxtU"$gA Good game! Edit: I don't know how load level works, I tried to load other players level, but is doesn't seems to load anything. |
| Jan 10 14:51:17 | 22m 06s | Reap | ♥ 1 | 67 on my first, 85 on my second try ! I'm having a non-qwerty keyboard, so having also a possibility to move using arrows would be nice - because awsd keys are not nearby on my keyboard. The timer explained by the sun moving through the day is a neat idea, and well adapted. I can see an hint on your website's icon that you are using Godot : I love Godot! Anyway, good game. And top on theme. |
| Jan 10 15:02:00 | 10m 43s | Harvest Mole | ♥ 2 | Interesting game, the famous mole game ! Here are my feedbacks : * The time line should be in seconds, not percentage. Also maybe smoother that 5% per 5%. * The graphics and drawings are great, nothing to say. It is even the best point! * You need to have a user feedback when you hit something. Here it takes 1 sec for the mole to turn red, but it's too long IMO. It could flash or move right away. * Idea : Farmers or carots could pop just as mole do, and the game could be to react quickly but not to everythings that pops. * Your rules on the left : you could use icons instead of text. * There is something strange with the hammer : it does not seems to hit where I intend to. It is just a feeling, I can't explain why. Maybe can you add dust on the hit, so we can clearly see where it hits. I'm resaying what I was saying on feedbacks. User feedbacks are important. * On my 4th game, no mole poped at all, maybe a bug here. But anyway, it is a cool game ! |
| Jan 10 15:42:15 | 40m 15s | Fruit Valley | ♥ 1 | Yeah a platformer! nothing beats it. Couples feedbacks but I'm sure it's because you ran outo of time : * the falling that don't kill is strange, but makes it fun to play. No big deal falling out of a platform, just have to try again. * big scary monster are spawning real close, no time to kill them before they eat one fruit. And I love the mix with the tower defense mechanic. And exploring the universe is cool, with one tile you created it; Congrats! |
| Jan 10 16:30:38 | 48m 23s | Harvest Looper | ♥ 0 | Defending something is always interesting. The atmosphere is great, (special congrats to the exploded moon), and monsters are terrifying. The annoying thing is when monsters are coming from below: they destroy all the grounds to harvest new crops. The balance between defense and harvesting is well done. good game! |
| Jan 10 19:36:17 | 3h 05m | Night of the Zombie Chickens | ♥ 1 | Driving and splashing zombie chickens remind me of one scene in The Return of the King when mumakils are crushing riders of Rohan. With your game I feel like being a mumakil, and it feels goood ! |
| Jan 10 19:45:45 | 9m 28s | Ratalie's Escape | ♥ 0 | You have a great game! The story is nice, and explains it all. However, I found it super hard, for two reasons (maybe that is just me, I don't read comments above) * Keys (A + D + 1 + 2) are not easy on a non-qwerty keyboard, and without dedicated numpad. (I have to press Shift + 1 in order to have EMP or telepathy). Thoses are great bonuses by the way. * There is not enough gravity when the rat is jumping, it takes way tooooo long to start the fall and land. This is frustrating to me. I reached only 1/5 of the line, even on my 8th try. But I loved it, I would like to play a smoother version. |
| Jan 10 19:50:28 | 4m 43s | Afterlife Assistance Agency | ♥ 2 | The difficulty curve is interesting, and well adjusted imo. Good game, simple to understand (yes, the first soul is easy) because of the increasing difficulty. The hand manipulation is smooth, along with the animation. Good job! |
| Jan 10 19:54:00 | 3m 32s | Eternal Harvest | ♥ 1 | After 3 reloads of the game, still the arrows are not working, is it me or they are not working? I don't understand why, you guys seems to be able to play. I too want to beat level 5! |
| Jan 10 20:05:49 | 11m 49s | Market Restaurant | ♥ 2 | Nice managment game! * Graphics are smooth. maybe brighter colors to be in the mood of veggies and restaurant. * Nice camera movements in transitions * Nice music atmosphere * The mechanic is nice, using trending combos after a bit I realized I should buy any vegetables. * I think it miss a global objective like "reach XXX yummies to make Robert the client happy" of something like that. That's a complete and nice game, could not say it was made in only 48h, great job! |
| Jan 10 20:18:16 | 12m 27s | Down to Earth | ♥ 1 | 1475pts, and 1900pts on my second try. * Leaving the mouse to use E to plant or harvest crops is not convenient. * Pickups seed should be automatic, not pressing E. * I love the watermelon attack (is this a watermelon? I looks like so). It is quiet efficient. Is it random ? or every 15 shoots or something ? * All art is perfect, really : colorfull, animation. * Yeah, aliens do attacks farmers, and farmers do defends themselves with vegetables ! 😃 I really loved your game. Congrats on a such a polished job. |
| Jan 10 20:39:34 | 21m 18s | Harvest Soon | ♥ 1 | I love thoses simplified versions of famous games, here you made a ultra-simplified-version-of-stardew-valley, and it works pretty well ! Everything is pretty intuitive, thanks to the grid and the tools. The combination of grinding, harvesting, watering and surviving works great. I was wondering if your map had a limit and I checked :) It's a pretty big map! I lasted for 15 days. Congrats for this game I loved! |
| Jan 10 20:56:55 | 17m 21s | Puzzling Harvest | ♥ 1 | I'm stuck at level 5 😢 Puzzles are great, graphics are perfects, logic is good also. Good game I love it! (I would love a hint for level 5!) |
| Jan 11 09:59:37 | 13h 02m | Combine Harvester: Time Attack! | ♥ 1 | Bim ! Screenshot from 2023-01-11 10-58-02.png I had to try for 4 times the level 5, but I did it! Always satisfying to harvest fields, isn't it? Nice game, I enjoyed it |
| Jan 11 13:31:34 | 3h 31m | Shroomer Caves | ♥ 2 | 13:33:99, then on my second try : supercrystalfound.png I love this game! between Dome Romantic and a harvesting game. Good balance between management and action! |
| Jan 11 17:29:42 | 3h 58m | Body Harvesters | ♥ 2 | It is a nice game you've made, some animations are cool (the spaceships flying, the guy walking, people flying) City improvments are well done : are buildings made randomly ? I think it lacks a global objective (like survive for 10min, or reach a population of 1k, ...) to keep the player focus. anyway, good game! |
| Jan 11 17:32:15 | 2m 33s | Catchy | ♥ 1 | Your game is one of my favorite : * nice atmosphere * nice polished graphics (you reached what you aimed for, that old map aspect * intersting to navigate, use the wind and the sail * I was not very lucky. It could be nice if the luck "increase" with the time, or with the score in order to see rare fishes. * Nice to explore the seas and island and reach map's limits Congrats! |
| Jan 11 17:39:13 | 6m 58s | Combine Harv-racer | ♥ 1 | Fun game, the speed of it make it exciting! 2:45 on my first try, 2:15 on my second. Do you plan to make a multi player game "the Grand Prix"? |
| Jan 12 08:37:15 | 14h 58m | Energy Harvest | ♥ 0 | It's good you handled the theme that way, it changes a lot from all crops-related games! Love the simplicity of the rules "go there in no time", and yet the difficulty of the game itself. When the two balls get close (at level 2), the camera is close also , and it prevents me to see where the next cube is. But I understand that having a camera following 2 moving objects is a challenge. Good game! |
| Jan 12 08:46:51 | 9m 36s | Harvest Day | ♥ 1 | Cool game (physics!!!) * Menu and level selection is original, love it, but ths waiting for level apples to fall is too long. * The physics and weight are well managed. * I would love to have a display of all fruits of the level all at once, instead of one by one. But that's just me. * Love the music also, the choirs ❤️ |
| Jan 12 10:52:36 | 2h 05m | Late Harvest | ♥ 1 | It is like a snake game with no tail isn't it? Love the coloured garphics and the eating animation :) Well done and the game is finished! |
| Jan 13 08:38:53 | 21h 46m | Crop Circle | ♥ 0 | 2009 is my best score ! Really enjoyable game! love the art, the animations, sounds effects. |
| Jan 13 14:17:23 | 5h 38m | Kingdom's Logistics | ♥ 1 | Impressive for a compo : I know there is a loooot of coding: the supply chain, the placing of the buildings, the food logic, the hungry logic, the money logic. I can recognize myself in this sort of coding and game. I think this is well balanced (I had one peasant that died 😢, I din't expect that) Also I love this pixel art. * the smoke of the bakery is great * the wings of the windmill also. GG ! |
| Jan 14 09:06:29 | 18h 49m | Crops Survivor | ♥ 0 | Cool game, although I'm not a fan of vampire survivor logic, I recognize it's well done. I reached level 6, nice upgrades! I love the flowers and their "ground" associated. Well done! |
| Jan 17 09:53:14 | 72h 46m | The Crystallographer | ♥ 1 | THAT is a good action/managment game, always harsh to choose between benefits or investments. I love the intro screen also, looks good to me, I love the character. Well done for this lovely game. I did 4600$. |
| Jan 24 21:16:03 | 179h 22m | Danger in the Potager | ♥ 2 | Great job ! * Love the graphics, the menu picture * The wind effect making some of the grass move * the shot animation * the mechanic : simple yet effective * the fact that carrots are coming from differents place, like army strategic positions * The boss idea: "oh no it's the tomato" made me laugh! * The boss is waaaay too hard to defeat in my opinion * The progress bar : it's a good idea to have one, but the guy walking is not logical, because the actual hero is staying in the garding, not moving. Anyway, I Love it. |
