Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → tomdeal
Feedback comments for LD43
tomdeal's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | tomdeal's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 3 18:20:14 | Sacrifices To Wooblicitus | ♥ 1 | Cool game! You did very well to incoporate the theme and it was fun to play. Also plus for making a html5 web version, always nice to be able to play without installing something. The controls, especially the hit detection could be a bit better and after the first wave I was unsure what to do now, since the pickup mechanic is not explained. But I figured it out. My final score was 50, is that any good? :-) | |
| Dec 3 18:28:20 | 8m 06s | Offshoot | ♥ 1 | Nice idea. I like the way you implemented the theme, making every level harder. Unfortunately, once I sacrified my leg weapons, I could not make a jump in the 4th level. Also, the enemies are quite hard to in the beginning. Cool game with good audio :-) |
| Dec 3 18:35:56 | 7m 36s | Your Previous Body Save You | ♥ 1 | That is a great entry! I love the concept, very clever and good use of the theme. Graphics are matching, too, only missing some nice audio tunes. Also, the controls and the physics are off sometimes. But a very good game, had a lot of fun playing it. |
| Dec 3 18:41:33 | 5m 37s | Boits | ♥ 1 | Nice entry. The swarm AI was good most of the time, only one of the 4 teams managed to screw up and hit the same block for 60 seconds :-) I won with 10 to 7 to 3! Maybe the tutorial should also be mouse controlled, since the game is. And it was very tiny in the zoomed out mode, maybe increase the size of the game objects a bit without having to zoom in and out all the time. Good game! |
| Dec 3 18:48:05 | 6m 32s | Dot, The Wanderer | ♥ 2 | The idea is good, I can see where you were heading. Playing the game was a bit problematic though. The sheep are scattered with a lot of enemies in the way, maybe shrink down the map and reduce the number of enemies to make the game a bit faster. I never managed to collect more than a few sheep before I was hit too many times. |
| Dec 3 20:00:26 | 1h 12m | Conga Line Survival | ♥ 1 | I like the game, it is a cool twist on the classic snake. I managed to get a score of 18. It starts out quite easy, but at 10 people, the difficulty rises (in a good way). I don't like the background colors, they make it hard to see people and enemies sometimes. Otherwise good entry! |
| Dec 3 20:05:24 | 4m 58s | Brace For Impact | ♥ 1 | Nice entry. I like the ship graphics and especially the indicators on the bottom, they provide a good feedback to the player. The game could be a bit harder, in the beginning it is quite easy to dodge the rockets. Also, I managed to get hit once, and then after a while I saw the "You made it" screen wth time left 00:51 and 4 engines. Does this mean I finished the game or it is a bug? Because in the description you mentioned two minutes :-) Some spacey music could also spice up the game. |
| Dec 3 20:12:05 | 6m 41s | Two Minutes 'Til Tribute | ♥ 1 | Cool idea. I like the upgrades on level up, that was a nice suprise. Also good implementation of the sacrifice mechanic. Two minor things I did not like: Sound effects are missing, which would be very nice in this genre. And the restriction of the play field feels strange. Maybe add a border graphic (some kind of force field maybe) to show the edges of the game area. Nice entry :-) |
| Dec 3 20:18:05 | 6m 00s | Finding the Lamb | ♥ 1 | Great game! The presentation, the audio, the visuals are all excellent. Maybe having the option as mentioned above to select the name from the book would be cool, but that is only a minor complaint. Had fun playing it, and of course murdered the wrong person on the first try :-) |
| Dec 3 20:23:57 | 5m 52s | The Temple of Falala | ♥ 1 | Good entry! Matching graphics and good audio. Gameplay is solid and executed well. I was a bit puzzled by the altar first, killing a lot of people and not knowing if this was the right way. But I managed to get some keys before dying. The map could be a bit smaller, but still a solid entry. |
| Dec 4 00:27:45 | 4h 03m | God Servant | ♥ 0 | Nice entry. I like the premise of the game, finding stuff for sacrifice. Some cool 3d models in there, too. On the gameplay side, it is really hard, I could not keep up for long. Maybe slow down the sacrifice counter and add another layer like obstacles to improve the game. Not a bad game though :-) |
| Dec 4 00:33:51 | 6m 06s | Tiny square - Ludum dare 43 | ♥ 1 | Edited this comment because it seems the black bars are intended :-) I just rated the graphics, which are quite good! I did not rate the other categories because: When creating a game in unity, always apply Time.deltatime to the inputs (and adjust the speed values accordingly). That way you get the same speed on every computer. I'm running a 144hz monitor, so the game got really fast to the point where I could not control anything anymore. |
| Dec 4 00:38:44 | 4m 53s | Floofs | ♥ 1 | I like the game. The floofs are really adorable. Maybe a mouse control would make sense, it is a bit hard to look around with WASD. But I managed to get 82 points, then I had to sacrifice my last pink floof. Poor floof.... |
| Dec 4 00:45:37 | 6m 53s | Non-increasing 451208114412965 | ♥ 0 | Great game! I really liked the mood, the art, the music, all that fit quite well. Sometimes the text went away too fast (I used itch.io web version) but I guess it wasnt a problem. Really good entry! |
| Dec 4 00:51:12 | 5m 35s | Fading Light | ♥ 1 | Grats to your first LD Game. I bet it was a blast :-) Your game is very ambitious, and for a first game, it is very good! It could use some highlights for Parts that you can use, but the graphics are cool and it had a good feel to it. |
| Dec 4 10:27:21 | 9h 36m | The secret experiment | ♥ 0 | I feel like a mouse in a labyrinth :-) Interesting concept, I like it. The yellow cheese graphics color could differ a bit more from the background color, but that's the only issue I had when playing the game. |
| Dec 4 10:32:49 | 5m 28s | Keep Trying | ♥ 0 | This is a really cool concept! You show allow more categories to be voted, for example your audio is fitting (even if there is no music). I had some problems with jumping, maybe the ground detection is a bit buggy. But with enough volunteers, I was able to beat the levels. Also good idea to have a level select on the main screen, especially for game jams. |
| Dec 4 10:41:20 | 8m 31s | The Life of a Corporate Drone | ♥ 1 | Day 17: While typing this comment, the bar closed down. Still shopping and playing at the arcade. Lost my family on the first day, cant sleep since the second day, no food and no job. But also no chores, yeah! Just shop and play all day :-) Great concept, nice graphics, even with a day night cycle! The first days feel a bit rushed due to all the bars going down. But once you settled for some of the rooms, it becomes very easy. Nice game! And with completing this review, I didnt went to the shops anymore and now I'm dead in the arcade after 30 days and 8 hours :-) |
| Dec 4 10:44:51 | 3m 31s | Entry for 43rd Ludum Dare | ♥ 1 | The music is very good. Gameplay works, however it is a bit frustrating to start from the very beginning each time . But maybe this is a sacrifice the player has to make ;-) |
| Dec 4 10:55:53 | 11m 02s | Fenik | ♥ 1 | I had to double check that this is not a jam entry :-) Great game, great music, great art. I've got no complaints at all, even the gameplay is on track :-) One really minor thing, it is a bit too easy, but overall a very good entry! |
| Dec 4 14:01:03 | 3h 05m | Break a leg | ♥ 3 | I like the art and the sound, they match really well. The gameplay is solid, however the hit detection response on enemies is either not there or I'm missing enemies and hit the wall behind them :-) |
| Dec 4 14:35:17 | 34m 14s | ANKH | ♥ 0 | Really nice game, one of the best I've played so far! Amazing for your first LD! Had a lot of fun playing it. The difficulty between the levels varies a bit, but overall a great entry. Too bad you used some of the gameplay mechanics only in the last level, I would have played 50 levels :-) |
| Dec 4 14:40:16 | 4m 59s | Warlock Quest | ♥ 1 | It took a moment to find out what to in the first level. After I eventually did not create sheepblocks right infront of me, I had fun playing it :-) |
| Dec 4 14:43:37 | 3m 21s | Space Station Gamma-7 | ♥ 1 | This reminds me of the Resident Evil 1 Tank controls. The Iso View is nice, and the gameplay is solid, however sometimes the people I tried to rescue got stuck on corners, and the time limit is really hard. Good entry! |
| Dec 4 14:50:03 | 6m 26s | Blood For Blood Gods | ♥ 0 | So much blood in the end! I like how the blood cubes stay, making the field really ... well bloody in the end. Also, the nosferatu-shaped enemies often tried to chat with one another, making it easy to kill them (I think it is a pathfinding bug, but I found it positive for the gameplay). The only minor issue I have is the balance, the game feels a bit too easy. In the end I managed to kill 45 enemies for 508 blood in 186, and only died because I wrote this review ;-) But better make a game too easy for a gamejam than too hard, so I guess it is ok. Nice entry! |