Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Feedback comment stats → Sibi

Sibi

Feedback comments for LD41

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Sibi's comment
Apr 24 20:29:45		SmackPaint! Combat Painting with Ross Bob	♥ 1	Very unique experience. Great use of the theme. The controls could use some fine tuning and I'm not sure what the red pen-like drawing on the canvas is about. Other than that a great little piece!
Apr 24 20:38:41	8m 56s	Rhythm Racing	♥ 0	Wow, that was difficult. I am already bad at rhythm games and the multitasking made didn't help, so I was mostly crawling along :D That being said, I really loved the music and the art style. Feels very polished and probably a lot of fun if you are any good at this type of game ;)
Apr 24 20:57:11	18m 30s	SPORTS	♥ 2	good game..well done...nice job :D Really great game! Maybe having a bit more control over the ball would have been nice. I was mostly clearing out enemies since the AI was much better at actually handling the ball ^^ Other than that a really brilliant game. I went back to try and salvage my first huge loss but got beat in the last few seconds. The visuals are stunning although I would have liked for the weapons to have some more impact/over the top animations (the sword one is already perfect). Overall a crazy and fun game!
Apr 24 21:04:02	6m 51s	Math Drag Racer - First Ludum Dare and First Game Ever.	♥ 2	Cool concept and congrats on your first completed game :) Unfortunately the best strategy seems to be being as slow as possible with the answers instead of as quikc as possible because you keep accelerating and the time is slowed. Also I wouldn't mind having a little longer track and sub-second timing ;) Keep on going!
Apr 24 21:14:50	10m 48s	Goal Defense	♥ 1	Nice idea. To me it felt like the best strategy was lining up until you hit an enemy and just sit there until he dies. Maybe add a little more variation in the shots to make it more about catching those balls. A little bit of sound would also go a long way. Cool to see a mobile first game in the jam :)
Apr 24 21:20:03	5m 13s	Infinite Typer	♥ 1	Awesome graphics and sound! Really difficult game. I would appreciate a noob mode :D I just kept on running into cars, timing is really hard.
Apr 25 05:39:38	8h 19m	BallRunner	♥ 0	Wow only 10 years old and already making game with Unity. I enjoyed my time with this game. Especially the level where you had to be on 2 different sides with the balls. That really showed the potential of the idea. Keep it up!
Apr 25 05:55:45	16m 07s	Aggroculture	♥ 1	Cool concept! At first I was focusing too much on shooting the enemies. But once I realised that I only need them for resources the game became a lot more fun. The enemies were quite fast and small which made it a bit difficult and sometimes the hitboxes were a bit unforgiving. I mostly watered the plants with my own blood because otherwise I had to really be lucky for the enemies to get close. I would have liked more feedback on which plants are watered instead of just the slight change in shade. But still a really cool game!
Apr 25 06:08:50	13m 05s	EXTREME EXTERMINATION DEFENSE	♥ 1	Oh wow another entry using cars to build towers :D I really enjoyed this game. Although I didn't feel like the speed and jump towers were really worth it because I had to go there to get some benefit and couldn't stay close to the base. I would have liked to instead be able to upgrade my car. The controls are really good and the enemy variety was impressive. Great job!
Apr 25 06:26:51	18m 01s	Grow Germinate upGrade entanGle	♥ 1	Nice game but I had some trouble with getting the resources I wanted. Especially getting more suns. I was mostly just hammering E to get enough resources since there didn't seem to be anything bad happening to you anyway. Could use some balancing but I enjoyed the art and music and had a relaxed time :) 👍
Apr 25 20:22:05	13h 55m	Ludum Dare Review Meta Game	♥ 1	What an amazing idea! I just love all things meta! And since I have no friends over I decided to let the computer play, which became a meta game in itself :P Btw the third puddle is totally OP! You only need an average of 18.16 dice throws to get to 5 stars and it wins 64.37% of the games with 3 players where all pick different puddles. The second puddle has a crazy variance though. Thanks for this cool game!
Apr 25 20:40:19	18m 14s	Alien Holes	♥ 2	I love the concept! It was really challenging but I managed to get an amazing score of 2 :D Having more control over the camera would have been nice and maybe a slightly weaker laser would have helped. I basically had to aim at the balls from the top to control them and sometimes they glitched through the world. Making the hole a bit more forgiving would also be cool. Overall still a solid Compo entry!
Apr 25 21:04:06	23m 47s	Fishy	♥ 1	Awesome concept and presentation together with the code! Really shows you how simple it can be. I ended up binding the commands to hotkeys on my keyboard :D It was still quite a button mash fest to get to the ring. Some more decision making would probably help but might deter from the minimalism. Really cool entry!
Apr 26 19:36:00	22h 31m	Wild Cards	♥ 3	Holy shit. I wanted to rate some games, yet here I am 2 hours later having only played this game. The LD version definitely has some problems but you fixed most of them already. At first I just completely ignored the fact that you can throw away cards and the game felt very difficult. But after realizing my mistake the game became kind of easy by just focusing on the bow. I still haven't figured out if you can win the game. Definitely my game of the jam so far. Would love to see this continued. If it got some more depth like deck building I would spend money for it. Amazing work!
Apr 26 19:46:08	10m 08s	Golf with Guns	♥ 2	Awesome game! I love golfing games and this was the best spin on it I have seen in this jam! I liked how the difficulty gradually ramped up and got to the right amount of challenging in the end. Maybe I would change the that shots are counted even if you are just shooting zombies. Right now it seems to be the best strategy to just focus on the ball(s). Thanks for making the hole so forgiving and not making me putt a million times with zombies around :D
Apr 26 20:31:14	45m 06s	Dodobrawl	♥ 1	Nice little game. There didn't seem to be too much strategy but I liked the card variety. I didn't really think the timer was necessary but since you are only playing one card anyway it wasn't too bad. Nice art style!
Apr 26 20:43:27	12m 13s	Ms Grunhilde's Sandwiches	♥ 1	What a lovely little vignette! You have an amazing style of writing. I could really see the scene unfolding in my head and felt connected to the characters. A shame that the game was so short as I was just settling in while making some lovely sandwiches! Also the text was a bit hard to read and I would have loved some more gimmicks like the magical turning sandwiches into bread that's already there. I tried delivering just bread or the knife or building 3-sliced sandwiches but to no avail :( The controls and entire presentation were as smooth as the peanut butter!
Apr 26 21:08:23	24m 56s	Crane Command	♥ 1	Cool little game. Unfortunately it crashed for me and I would suggest distirbuting the game without an installer next time ;) Really unique genre with the crane game and well executed. Maybe there were too many units at the start because it felt a bit static. Btw is there actually a healer? Awesome music and presentation!
Apr 26 21:19:02	10m 39s	Fatty Boy Run	♥ 2	Amazing visuals and sound! For me the best strategy seemed to be to only go for one color so you didn't have to worry about the match 3 part which unfortunately kinda defeats the purpose ^^ And in the end I died with a score of 97 although I made the right posture. Maybe it was because I was a little off to the side somehow. I would have also like if the game sped up some more and the fatty boy became a real runner ;) Except for those nitpicks I had a blast :)
Apr 26 21:39:26	20m 24s	Fun Block Game	♥ 0	Wow what a great concept! This felt like a demo for a full game, very polished. I can't believe how much my brain got confused with the two control sets :D It was also really cool how you had to be intentionally bad at tetris to create a way and not destroy the ground beneath your feet. Good use of scripted blocks to teach concepts!
Apr 26 22:02:30	23m 04s	RaceTD	♥ 0	Interesting take on racing meets TD. We did a game with those genres as well ;) I really liked the graphics and choice of music. It took me some time to understand that the towers act more as a barricade/bumper. I was able to win on my second go by building walls of towers and focus on keeping the lower parts of the track clean :)
Apr 26 22:29:35	27m 05s	Jeff From Accounting	♥ 0	Okay, holy shit. Just wow. Such a unique concept with gorgeous art and amazing sound. Everything was just perfect. The only thing that could be improved is the boss fight at the end which felt a bit anticlimactic. He just died like any other enemy and I had to find and clean up the little guys. Definitely the best jam game I have seen!
May 13 14:29:38	400h 00m	Fight for the Mike!	♥ 0	Nice art and cool concept! Unfortunately it was hard for me to figure out any kind of strategy. It was mostly just selecting my guys and sending them towards the enemies. Good little compo entry!
May 13 14:38:42	9m 04s	Pretty Pretty Pirates	♥ 0	Really funny idea! It would be great to have some form of feedback that you actually selected a character. Also mouse versus keyboard seems a bit unfair :D
May 13 14:48:51	10m 09s	Dungeon of Amplidi	♥ 0	The dungeon building was really awesome! Could use some more depth to it. Right now there seems to be no real point in dropping in goblins except for the fun :D
May 13 14:56:35	7m 44s	Space Fighters	♥ 0	Awesome game! I liked the build up of different enemies. I don't really see the racing game part except for the visuals. The sound effects are just amazing :D
May 13 15:03:25	6m 50s	Augmented Reality Virtual Pet Stealth - Browser Playable	♥ 0	Brilliant idea! I have never seen those genres combined. It was a bit difficult to tell if the dog could see me and to know when and why I lost. But otherwise solid execution. Very unique art style!
May 13 15:10:41	7m 16s	Supreme Racing	♥ 0	Nice work! As others have said the game is too fast to make meaningful decisions. Also the typing doesn't really blend in that well with the racing. It seems to be just a more difficult interface. I loved the crashes and it was smart to stick the player to a lane! 👍
May 13 15:50:32	39m 51s	The Tactical Trio	♥ 1	Awesome game! It's way more tactical than it first appears. Good tutorialization as well :)
May 13 15:58:34	8m 02s	FootBulls	♥ 0	Brilliant idea and execution! It's a shame you couldn't get a form of AI working. Would have loved to play this against the computer. Also the music didn't work for me in the web-player.
May 13 16:29:59	31m 25s	Car Defense	♥ 0	Nice mashup of the two genres! It's fun to see people who chose the same genres but came up with a completely different game :)
May 13 19:23:37	2h 53m	Symphonic Mission	♥ 2	Nice concept. I really liked the music. But to me it felt easier to avoid the enemies than to try and shoot them because you risk just hitting them that way. Also hitting the enemies was very difficult since the laser and the enemies themselves are quite small and you have not time/room for readjusting your shot. I would also like to see the shooting pattern adapt a bit more to the music :)