Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Feedback comment stats → digitaldude555
Feedback comments for LD41
digitaldude555's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | digitaldude555's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24 10:04:16 | The Magic Shotgun Coloring Book | ♥ 1 | Theme 5/5 coloring book and top down shooter combined into a unique and fun game. Audio 5/5 can't find anything wrong with audio, shotgun sound is great. Graphics 3.5/5 mostly for that great dodge roll animations and I like the UI fits the game well. Fun 2/5 too short to be fun, finished the game twice in 1 minute. Innovation 3/5 standard top down shooter but the coloring book mechanic is innovative. mood I leave blank cause I got no clue what to rate it, humor 2/5, didn't find anything funny really. Overall a 3/5 could use some more content just keep the same enemies and gun but have more intricate patterns to fill in like letter Z or something or a cross shape. | |
| Apr 24 10:30:44 | 26m 28s | Sudoku Junction | ♥ 1 | The frog puppet and voice saved the game Audio 5/5. Graphics 2.5/5 the character designs are directly from animal crossing right, so can't rate too highly, I like the design of the building. Innovation 3/5 good concept but the execution of the idea drags it down. Theme 3/5 same thing as the innovation very interesting idea but not a good execution. Fun... and I hate to say it man but 1/5 I was confused most of the game fell off the map everywhere and when I finaly made it to the job I tried to do the sudoku puzzle and it said go home after 5 seconds. Went to my apartment fell off the map again then went back to work and this time it gave me 15seconds for the puzzle... Mood is a 4/5 mostly cause of the chill background music. humor 5/5 for the kermit for the way you drive the car. Overall 2.5/5 I would have liked more sudoku time. |
| Apr 24 10:49:17 | 18m 33s | Snail and Salt | ♥ 2 | Took a bit to figure out but its pretty fun, I honestly think thats your strongest category there was a hidden layer of strategy in that game which made it fun and not mindless. Fun 3/5 Graphics 3/5 I like the look of the snail and the lettuce but the ui looks very bad. Theme and Innovation 2.5/5 I think you executed your idea as well as you could but there wasnt really room to make anything very unique or innovative. Overall 3/5 good effort and I missed one lettuce so couldnt get perfect run but I did beat the game. |
| Apr 24 12:09:16 | 1h 19m | Pipe Warrior, Mech Dream | ♥ 2 | Innovation 5/5 very good, Theme is 4/5 you combined two incompatible genre and they worked very well together. Audio 3/5 I dont know if this accordion music is the best fit lol. Fun: 3/5 it's difficult no doubt but I got the hang of it, I would have liked for the turns to be a bit faster like Olivier said. Problem is everything just takes very long to do so that reduces the fun a bit. Humor I leave blank, mood is a 3. Only bad part the graphics very simple and plain I give a 2/5. Overall good effort enjoyed playing it 3.5/5. |
| Apr 24 12:42:00 | 32m 44s | What did you say Captain? | ♥ 2 | I was sceptical of how well this could work but you made a fantastic game from these two ideas. innovation 4/5 and 5/5 for the theme. Audio 4/5 was great really fit the space shooter vibe. Graphics 3/5 were alright just the standard ones you see in almost all shootem ups. Fun 3/5 the controls were actually pretty good for a text game of course that slows the game down considerably and that doesnt work with a shmup. I'd have liked more hints on what to do I never figured out how to go faster and what do you type when it says where do you want to go? overall 3.5/5 |
| Apr 24 13:11:08 | 29m 08s | CCC: Cyber City CAB | ♥ 2 | Mood 5/5 the music and the imagery it fits well with the dystopian description you gave about the game. Audio 4/5 Graphics 3/5 Pretty simple graphics not much to say here would have liked more landmark buildings and not all black. Fun 2.5/5 There are things that are fun like destroying the enemy cars and dropping off passengers and there is difficulty in navigation and also the huge difficulty spike where a dozen cars are shooting at you gets crazy. Theme 3/5 I am certain I played games with score attack raciing and shooting almost certain, been done before but you did a good take of it. Innovation 2/5 nothing really innovative here. Overall 3/5. |
| Apr 24 13:31:43 | 20m 35s | Zeus Fever | ♥ 4 | You just buy the towers and then play match 3 section to get the bullets for the tower guys. I really really like the the music and sound effects 5/5. Graphics 4/5 are great too. My biggest problem was the theme, it just feels like two games independently rather than a combined one, 95% of the time playing I was looking at the match 3 section. 2/5. Innovation 3/5 nothing really innovative here just standard tower defense and match 3 game. Humor 4/5 just because of the intro. Fun 3/5 tough one to judge, I love match 3 and tower defense, but it got hard very quickly by wave 4 the monsters over ran me and I was constantly short of bullets. The tower defense section needs balancing. overall 3/5. |
| Apr 24 13:50:54 | 19m 11s | Bob Ross Adventure | ♥ 0 | Well I am on firefox and the browser version wont work for me. Download exe doesnt open. How can I make it work? |
| Apr 24 14:06:39 | 15m 45s | Scarry | ♥ 3 | Graphics were alright, liked the design of that monster truck, the weird obstacles tho.....looked like poo. 3/5. Mood and Audio both 4/5 mood not 5/5 cause while it was scary it felt like I was a toy car racing around a carpet. Theme 2/5 plenty of car games have collecting things and avoidng enemies. Innovation using the microphone as a boost was a good idea, especially for a horror game. 4/5 Fun 2/5 sad to say but searching for those cookies got really tedious. Overall 3/5 |
| Apr 24 17:42:51 | 3h 36m | Spiky | ♥ 5 | Love the music man. Graphics are great too with the paper cutout character and the boxes. Gameplay is fun and challenging, very polished like others said. My only criticism it doesnt fit the theme well, I have seen this type of game before and it was one genre, usually its a game like moving a robot with card instructions to get into a goal so this game is one genre not combination of two. Overall 4/5 Good job man. |
| Apr 24 18:18:42 | 35m 51s | Ping Bang Pong | ♥ 1 | This game is fantastic man, like a pingpong hotline miami or superhot lol, music is great really adds to the mood. Graphics are nice and clean. Great take on the theme, only thing to critique is its not very innovative but the rest of the categories you did well in. overall 4.5/5 from me. |
| Apr 25 14:31:13 | 20h 12m | Eggstinction | ♥ 2 | Everything is great from the audio to the graphics, its very humorous. Very polished game, tho it does seem that every level takes place on the same map. Overall 4/5. |
| Apr 26 11:18:22 | 20h 47m | Fat Panda! | ♥ 2 | Art is 5/5 fantastic art/character designs and animations, music fits well with the Japanese asthetic and mood. I like the concept and you combined two genre well the mouse minigames were more creative than the jumping though. my problems are sometimes the sushi are so close together you can't dodge any of them and you lose two lives. I also agree with the other comments the jumping feels off but I dont know exactly why. |
| Apr 26 11:33:27 | 15m 05s | Super Dashball | ♥ 2 | Graphics are simple and clean. I really like the responsiveness when you hit the wall you "juiced" it well. I got a score of ten until I realized dashing awarded more points more risky behaviour rewarded. That's good game design. You combined the genre as well as it could be done I think. Anyway my score was 16 on vanilla, tried other game modes but they didn't add anything that made them better than good ol vanilla. Couldn't test the two player mode but that one looks fun. Overall 4.5/5 |
| Apr 27 13:29:00 | 25h 55m | Dating Clicker | ♥ 2 | Decent art and I like the tune that plays, would be nice like kalavecy said to have a number next to the things you bought to tell you how many you bought. Maybe also place the house on the field with the tree and when you buy a new boat/house it upgrades on the tree screen. I didn't understand the dating aspect at all, you just answered yes/no and then you never see those people again or the helicopter.. |
| Apr 27 20:34:11 | 7h 05m | Legend of Zoom | ♥ 1 | Fantastic game one of my favorites this ludum dare, theme and innovation are 5/5 really deserve to place high in theme category. Sadly I couldnt beat final boss no matter how many times I tried, after 5 times I just gave up. |
| Apr 27 20:58:02 | 23m 51s | RTHM | ♥ 2 | Played 10 minutes and I never found a date, I think it would be better game if the responses weren't random. Good effort tho, I like the concept. |
| Apr 28 14:54:25 | 17h 56m | Nanashi | ♥ 2 | The good: Like that ambient audio track in the background adds to the mood but no sounds for shooting, really like the graphics especially the ship design. The theme, I like it combining shooter with break out, some maze game. The Bad: As everyone said controls, the most frustrating controls I have ever encountered on ludum dare. When you are building a game above all else make sure it controls well. Anyway I know you fixed some stuff in new build but I can only vote on the one submitted during the jam. |
| Apr 28 15:20:28 | 26m 03s | Remote Bot | ♥ 2 | Theme 6/5 just amazing concept you thought up as platformer that relies both on strategy and reflexes/timing. Also the sound is great and I like how the red cubes seem unhappy when they kill you. No complaints form me, great effort. |
| Apr 28 15:38:15 | 17m 47s | SURVABY | ♥ 2 | I really like the graphics, you can see the consistant art style across all the assets which isnt always the case for ludum dare games. Was fun for a while but then I got sad that inevitably the babies and me would die. Only bad part I think was the theme, see I was playing an FPS today its objective was shoot guys and hold a button to lower a barrier, this game reminded me of all those objectives that happen all the the time in fps and thats one genre not two. And finally those sounds were terrifying form the zombies and also babies crying and turning blue, but that fits the mood of the game perfectly. Well done. |
| May 11 13:13:41 | 309h 35m | Blocks'N'Blaster | ♥ 2 | Very very polished great audio, graphics animations pretty much everything. Idea was executed well but I think these two genres dont go together at all would rather just play tetris, I guess that fits the theme lol. |
| May 11 13:27:27 | 13m 46s | Missile Mayor | ♥ 1 | Love the music, one of the best takes on the theme I've seen so far. Graphics are alright i've never seen this type of game have anything but minimalistic graphics. The problems are simple balance issues like repairing silos cost a lot should probably cost 50 same as building, massive snowball effect if things start to fail then you have already lost. As for suggestions I suggest adding upgrades like auto-collection on the buildings and maybe shields for the buildings. Good luck on getting to 20 votes. |
| May 12 13:05:50 | 23h 38m | Cross Word Shooter | ♥ 1 | Its an interesting take on the theme for sure, I like the martian background. Problem I got was it makes you prioritize making short words, if you mess about looking for longer words then chances are you will take much more damage. |
| May 12 13:21:00 | 15m 10s | Wordslide | ♥ 2 | Like many others have said its a very good artstyle one of the best i've seen this ludum dare, the combination actually works really well, you wouldnt think so if you just heard the idea but you made it work and made it fun. Good job. |
| May 12 13:34:16 | 13m 16s | DroneOut | ♥ 2 | I like the bullethole effect you did, gameplay was fun for a while. Game doesnt really match the theme competetive shooter is one genre. |
| May 13 17:08:40 | 27h 34m | Nintendating | ♥ 2 | This game is very strange, you did well with the audio, art was okay. It's a pretty creative idea for the theme would never have thought of that. Needed more indication of how things were going I was just clicking random things til I won. |
| May 14 10:26:55 | 17h 18m | Flying By Yourself | ♥ 1 | That was incredibly unique game wow just wow, I'd say its similar to frog fractions. art sound mood are all top notch. A solid 5/5 from me. |
| May 14 10:37:25 | 10m 30s | TinyWorlds | ♥ 1 | It's incredibly polished, graphics are looking very good, sound is great and its fun to play. Great take on the theme as well. My only complainant after I won the last level it looped me back to the first one, there should be a win screen. |
| May 14 11:38:41 | 1h 01m | Cold Stars. Empty Voxels. | ♥ 2 | I pretty much exclusively used shift controls to move around, it was very disorienting. Graphics are a bit plain but I like the effect when the blocks explode. |
| May 14 12:46:30 | 1h 07m | Totempo | ♥ 4 | Wow absolutely amazing game, everything was great, love the art/sound style, the two genre you made them fit perfectly and its very fun to play. 5/5 overall. |
| May 14 13:29:15 | 42m 45s | Skate'n'Snipe | ♥ 2 | It was alright, favorite part was the music. Was no challenge to the game and the art was very plain. I would suggest having moving targets or targets closer together to civilians for added challenge. |
| May 14 13:52:31 | 23m 16s | Boxing Surgery Simulator 2000 | ♥ 3 | Great all round game, graphics and animation are good. Sound of the punches were perfect. Surgery section is fun but only when you figure out what to do, needs some hints or tutorial. Same with the word bubble section need some basic instructions. Anyway best I could do was make it to round 8 tried a few times. |
| May 14 13:59:15 | 6m 44s | Rapid Fire | ♥ 2 | Art was good and music wasnt bad, problem as everyone said controls. The jumping is very floaty and you only do a full attack while holding x not pressing it, still I never managed to hit a cannonball. My suggestion is fire the cannon when the player can see it, so that the player can react to it rather it being down to luck. |
| May 14 14:52:20 | 53m 05s | My first day in the agency | ♥ 2 | The artstyle is great but the game is very hard, wasnt even able to beat the first level |
| May 14 15:13:01 | 20m 41s | Pinboy-an RPG+ Pinball game | ♥ 1 | Art is gorgeous probably my favorite of the games I reviewed. Great take on the theme pinball with rpg like quests is not something I would expect to ever work. The sounds I didn't like but thats just a personal prefrence, also I got stuck on the level it just kept bouncing on the house and it was impossible to progress(screenshot) Screenshot (2087).png |
| May 14 15:25:15 | 12m 14s | Flowers in the frame | ♥ 2 | Screenshot (2088).png Flower I made. Pretty fun game a lot of replay value, art was really good. Hope you get to the 20 needed for rating. |
| May 14 15:33:08 | 7m 53s | Sword step | ♥ 1 | Yeah the concept is good you can make a bigger game out of this, I also agree with the guy that said your character needs to be a different color so you can tell where he is. |
| May 14 15:41:02 | 7m 54s | Black Hole Zoo | ♥ 1 | My funniest game I rated so far good work I like the sound the guys make when the black hole gets them, level 3 was a bit hard but I beat it, rip earth. My problem though it doesnt follow the theme that well. |
| May 14 16:01:19 | 20m 17s | Baseball Nightmare | ♥ 1 | Graphics are good add to the mood with the fog and mist around the ghosts. Like people said gameplay too basic it doesnt feel like two genre but just a shooter with a baseball skin. Anyway good work. |
| May 14 16:14:10 | 12m 51s | Brains of Racing | ♥ 1 | Yeah artstyle is pretty good and unique, the theme idea you have is really good but cause its a turn based racing game it feels very slow and there is three laps around the same course can get boring. Still good job on the game. I think you got your 20 votes needed. |
