Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → Mr ChocolateSalmon
Feedback comments for LD43
Mr ChocolateSalmon's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Mr ChocolateSalmon's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 4 03:49:21 | Sacrificed supplies | ♥ 1 | Nice and simple. Good job. Was a bit confused at the start and wasn't able to restart the game, but picked it up pretty quick. | |
| Dec 4 03:56:28 | 7m 07s | Run From a Bear Simulator | ♥ 0 | Hey good job. Some of the collisions were hard to judge, and even then the jumping and ducking didn't seem to always work 🙂 |
| Dec 4 04:07:20 | 10m 52s | Cosmo Buddy | ♥ 2 | Hey, I recommend itch.io for uploading games. Makes it a bit easier to download 🙂 Anyways, great game! Love the art style and music. I understand what you were doing with the crew members, but it still kinda just felt like the same character losing lives. Perhaps having each crew member dressed in something slightly different would have given a better effect of different crew members being present. Also, game ends suddenly if you win or lose. But other than that, I really enjoyed it. 👍 💎 |
| Dec 4 04:18:46 | 11m 26s | Decisions | ♥ 1 | Really fun. Always love a good puzzle game. Good job dude 👍 |
| Dec 4 08:22:18 | 4h 03m | Dilemma | ♥ 0 | Hard to control the dot. Not quite sure how to do it haha |
| Dec 4 20:43:48 | 12h 21m | Bee Defence | ♥ 1 | Hey beautiful, loved it. It's a very smooth and clean game. Controls are simple, and there's a nice level of difficulty. Good job 👍 |
| Dec 5 10:52:17 | 14h 08m | OVERCHARGE | ♥ 2 | Amazing game. Quality design and fun to play! A deep difficulty curve, but its to be expected. Really enjoyed watching your video on the creation process as well 😄 |
| Dec 6 06:50:18 | 19h 58m | ImminENT Danger | ♥ 0 | Good job! Really loved the mood and graphics. Had some weird bouncing when I was trying to walk past trees though |
| Dec 6 06:56:54 | 6m 36s | Flaming Resistance | ♥ 1 | Very good! Enjoyed the style and simplicity. Had some trouble figuring out how to ignite the second weapon, but it might just be my laptop haha. Other than that, I enjoyed it 🙂 |
| Dec 7 03:12:41 | 20h 15m | Sirius Galactica | ♥ 1 | Hey, great job! The art and gameplay were both really polished, and it was fun to play. I was a bit concerned how the oxygen worked, but when I read that it went down at the start of each round, it made more sense. I do agree with others that it's a bit easy to win the game without sacrificing any people or ships. I'd either make the game a little harder, or, make it so you have to sacrifice at least once if you want to make it to the last level. 👍 |
| Dec 7 03:52:39 | 39m 58s | Necroprancer | ♥ 1 | Good job on a simple and challenging game. Almost finished it, but couldn't quite get past the last part, and didn't want to do the whole thing again. Perhaps the collisions were a little too precise however, and I found that as soon as I died the character would start moving straight away, sometimes causing me to die straight away again. Other than that, good game |
| Dec 7 04:06:51 | 14m 12s | First time | ♥ 0 | Good job on your first entry. Better than what my first entry was haha. Music got a little repetitive, and I found it difficult to understand how you actually became bankrupt, but managed to save 7 people so that's alright 🙂 |
| Dec 7 10:25:40 | 6h 18m | Goblin Quest | ♥ 0 | A nice and neat game. Didn't get as far as a lot of the people here, but still enjoyed the gameplay and story. Good job 👍 |
| Dec 8 10:13:43 | 23h 48m | Cave Adventures | ♥ 2 | Great job. The controls were smooth and simple, the music was nice, and the puzzles were easy to understand. Having the X and R buttons was a little weird at first, but I got used to it by the end. It was annoying that sometimes I couldn't tab to the player until I'd placed a minion, but that's just a minor nitpick |
| Dec 9 05:01:29 | 18h 47m | Sacrifical Flight | ♥ 1 | Beautiful graphics and a simple mechanic. Manage to win the game without throwing anyone off the balloon which was nice (even though I wasn't half my gas as I thought you had to hold space instead of press it). But anyways, simple and functional entry, good job 👍 |
| Dec 10 01:31:23 | 20h 29m | Dare to Risk | ♥ 1 | Nice gameplay and easy to grasp mechanics. The UI did feel a little clunky at times, and I defintely started to lose track of which tiles I'd used each turn. But other than that, I enjoyed it. Good job 🙂 |
| Dec 10 04:54:34 | 3h 23m | Effigies | ♥ 1 | Really great puzzle game. Some of those last few were a little challenging, but I enjoyed it. Animations and game play were smooth and I didn't encounter any bugs. Good job! |
| Dec 10 05:08:58 | 14m 24s | Arkham 2043 | ♥ 0 | Really well made with some great art. Complexity and content included even though there was only a couple days in the Jam. Some audio/music is definitely needed to help maintain focus in the game, but I enjoyed it! |
| Dec 10 22:45:03 | 17h 36m | Farewell Dear Cargo | ♥ 2 | Really great game! Felt polished, balancing the plane was fun, and the graphics were beautiful 🐔 |
| Dec 11 07:10:08 | 8h 25m | Garry's Sacrifice | ♥ 1 | Overall it was quite a fun game. I did have a couple bugs however: - The WebGL version didn't render properly, and only showed a black background. Downloaded version works fine though - The item screen down the bottom got in the way of me collecting items at times - I feel as if there should be a button to return to the game, as opposed to having to press escape again - Also for some reason, I was able to drag both the health and positivity bars (while I was trying to figure out what to do haha) The gameplay was really fluid and the graphics were cute. I think a tutorial level would have been great, as otherwise reading through all the information on this page is definitely required. Intuitively, I didn't pick up that the meat towers should be used sparingly, or how to harvest the tears (I thought they were water drops). But, apart from those things, I feel you've done a great job! I'll have to give the level editor a go 😄 |
| Dec 16 04:39:28 | 117h 29m | 2305 : New Generation | ♥ 1 | I agree that the game had a great framework that I think will be really cool when it's fleshed out a bit more. There didn't feel like a lot to do in the game, and I experienced a long pauses after dialog and interactions, and not being able to move when the suspicion was being displayed was a little annoying as well. But that said, the pixel art was pretty, it had nice sound effects and art, and I loved being able to make a choice at the end of the game 👍🏻 |
| Dec 16 05:05:21 | 25m 53s | Summertime Sadness | ♥ 0 | Definitely weird haha, but the controls and graphics are nice! |
| Dec 16 05:21:57 | 16m 36s | Just delete them | ♥ 2 | Loved it. Similar vibes to Doki Doki Literature Club or Undertale, which was nice. Definitely a unique concept and done well. I did notice a few bugs, such as deleting the buttons and being unable to bring them back for example, but for a game made in a couple days I think you did a great job 😄 |
| Dec 16 07:58:36 | 2h 36m | RAT LABS | ♥ 2 | The game was a little confusing. Took me a while to figure out how to accept projects or start them, and my game ended with an error when I tried to start one I'd already completed. But the graphics were nice and there seemed to be a level of planning required with making sure you didn't use up all the room. Overall, not bad! |
| Dec 16 23:33:45 | 15h 35m | Night of the Clawrm | ♥ 0 | Neat little game. In the beginning I walked straight into the cave and died before I realized I had to drag other people to it. The music was nice if not a little repetitive by the end, and the mechanics were fun. It was great how the other characters started chasing and attacking you when you start dragging another person. Added a bit more tension to the game. Overall, good job 👍 |
| Dec 17 00:32:50 | 59m 05s | The Omicron Fleet | ♥ 1 | A really unique and fun game. Loved it. Similar to a board game I almost created once. Liked the simplicity of the mechanics, but also the numerous strategies you could employ in regards to where to keep the ships and which formation to use. Maybe a minor nitpick, but being able to see the formations on the right of the screen just to help visualize which one was where would have been nice, and sometimes it could be hard to find the ships hidden underneath the flagship. But other than that, top marks for innovation and enjoyability 😄 |
| Dec 17 03:19:22 | 2h 46m | Planet Saver | ♥ 1 | The planet jumping was interesting, and it was kinda fun to jump between those planets. But at the same time, the swapping between planets felt a bit slow and disorientating; and because the planets were so small, the shooting felt a bit off as well. But I still had some fun and liked the simple art style. Good job 🙂 |
| Dec 17 03:28:57 | 9m 35s | Broken people | ♥ 1 | Good for your first attempt. The game is a little nauseating and frustrating at times, especially as the cubes are hard to click on. Maybe just using the mouse cursor instead of having to click would have been better? Anyways, hope you learnt a lot during the Jam 😃 |
| Dec 18 01:28:00 | 21h 59m | MindMaze | ♥ 0 | The game has a nice mood to it, and the character on the right is a nice addition (though I'm still not sure how he was affected by the levels?) The controls were a bit odd however, as up should have moved towards the right not the left, and the game-play started to feel a little slow and repetitive by the end; but overall the theme was present and the game was smooth 😎 |
| Dec 18 02:03:30 | 35m 30s | Model Trains Inc | ♥ 2 | ## I don't think they should be pushing my train off the track haha. TrainzScreenshot.png Nah look, I really love the idea and execution of this game. You successfully made little idiots that continually walk in front of my trains with no hesitation, and while that gets annoying, it's definitely adds an extra layer of fun to the strategies you need to employ. Very well done! And the graphics are beautiful. 🚋 **Just an FYI though, the game didn't render properly on Chrome, but worked fine in Firefox.** |
| Dec 18 06:49:57 | 4h 46m | Pew! Pew! | ♥ 0 | Very well made. The graphics and retro feel work really well, and the sounds are all top notch. Game-play is hard, but fun and rewarding, and the power-up mechanic, including the ability to sacrifice power-ups, is great. Good job mate 👍 |
| Dec 19 08:31:02 | 25h 41m | Making Ends Meet | ♥ 1 | Nice atmosphere! You captured the theme quite well, and the game-play was simple and easy to grasp, and the music fit nicely as well. |
| Dec 22 00:12:02 | 63h 41m | Apothecary | ♥ 0 | It's a nice looking game, and the core mechanic is interesting. However, it turns into trial and error really quickly. By the end I was just giving everything to some people to see what would work. It would be nice if a character's file disappeared when you correctly treated them, as opposed to having to redo their prescriptions each time. Good job though! |
| Dec 22 01:05:04 | 53m 02s | The Lost Company | ♥ 1 | A great game overall. The UI did feel a bit confusing at first. As someone else said, the big proceed button shouldn't be visible until it's able to be pressed. Also, having the hover reveal the details instead of having to click each character is a great addition, but I'd at least have the currently revealed character highlighted in someway (say, given an extra blue tinge or something), because at times I'd hover over a character, but then accidentally move the mouse a fraction over without noticing, and then rest the character when he may have had full health, etc. So some way to know who was actually being displayed would help with that. Also, I think a background behind the text in the button right would also help. I completely missed the two percentages at the start. Finally, having the descriptions of each button on here is good, but having a a description pop up when you hover over the buttons in-game would improve the experience a lot more. Game-play wise, I think healing needs to do a lot more, even when my troops had all eaten twice, rested, and were healed by the older doctor, their health barely improved. And even surviving another 10 day after repairing the radio is a bit rough. Overall though, still a great game which great executing of a great concept that really fits the theme. 👍 |
| Dec 22 01:47:06 | 42m 02s | Colossus | ♥ 1 | Great art assets! The gameplay was a little weird. I ended up using shift and up a lot, basically turning into a flying knight that needed to avoid the colossus' arms. And as others have said, using shift too much isn't the best on Windows. Perhaps Ctrl would have been better. |
| Dec 22 02:28:48 | 41m 42s | Game Jam Simulator | ♥ 1 | Awesome game! Would have been nice to have a little screen at the end similar to game dev simulator, with some funny reviews and a description of what the game may have been like. Just to add an extra layer to your game. Other than that, the graphics and audio are really nice. The game play is simple and fun. Could possibly have incorporated the theme a bit more, but overall I think you did a really great job 😃 |
