Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD45 → Feedback comment stats → Mr ChocolateSalmon
Feedback comments for LD45
Mr ChocolateSalmon's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Mr ChocolateSalmon's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 14 03:37:35 | Shi no ganbo | ♥ 4 | Really nice game with beautiful 2D art and music. The movement felt a little off to me, especially in the early platforming section, and sometimes items I threw would get caught if I was still too close to a wall. But I enjoyed the game and the short narrative woven into it. Good job! | |
| Oct 14 10:35:56 | 6h 58m | Leverage | ♥ 1 | Mate, I won it but it's tough. Some of the mechanics make it more frustrating than challenging at times, but the idea behind keeping all the switches turned on was interesting. I did enjoy all the abilities, and winning the game felt rewarding, but there was times where I accidentally turned off my own switches which got annoying. The way it introduces turning the switches on was good, but I don't think there's a reason the player would turn off the switches, so I'd probably disable it :) Overall, I enjoyed it 😄 |
| Oct 16 06:19:04 | 43h 43m | ØJE | ♥ 3 | A brilliant game. Everything from the art, to the feel, to the gameplay was top notch. I really love how you're building up your level, and can choose to win the game early at any point. And also how you can restart with nothing, and destroy all your creation. If there was one thing I didn't like, however, it was that some parts felt quite frustrating and annoying. Especially accidentally hitting a lower checkpoint, or some of the platforming requirement minute accuracy. Overall though, a beautiful well done game! |
| Oct 16 06:33:38 | 14m 34s | Soul Avenger | ♥ 0 | The art and theme were great! Some of the mechanics were a little weird though, the dash wasn't always responsive, opening chests doing do anything half the time, when walking too far to the left/right, sometimes everything would disappear (I assume it jumps you to the otherside), but then sometimes I managed to walk outside of the map into a blue background. But the idea was solid and it was fine for a game made in a couple days 🙂 |
| Oct 16 06:46:14 | 12m 36s | When Nothing Came | ♥ 2 | Absolutely beautiful! I love game that take a different approach, and this was perfect for a game jam, and used the theme in an excellent way. You could tell it was something you were passionate about, and it shows in the art style, the flow of the game, and the story. The music did cut out quite early for me for some reason, but returned again after I'd explored the house which was fine. Oh, and on that, I really like how you'd be able to completely walk past the house if you weren't clicking on everything. Nice touch! Congrats on a great game 🙂 |
| Oct 18 11:36:37 | 52h 50m | Merge 'em Wars | ♥ 1 | Pretty good game. Trading was a little weird at first, I thought I'd be able to combine things of different types to create new cards, but could really only merge cards of the same types. Game play loop was smooth, graphics were nice, and overall I enjoyed playing 😄 |
| Oct 19 09:56:33 | 22h 19m | Warp Trash Flotilla | ♥ 0 | Definitely one of my favourites so far. Concept and execution are top notch. Add more levels and I'd happily play them. Great job! 😄 |
| Oct 21 09:44:04 | 47h 47m | Naked Guy | ♥ 1 | Nice little game with simple mechanics. However, I found that even if you were caught, you could continue playing and get to the end to pass each level. But other than that it was a good simple game 🙂 |
| Oct 21 10:16:31 | 32m 27s | RUST vs THE HIVE | ♥ 2 | Not too bad. Felt a little weird and without purpose, and couldn't figure out how to shoot with the right mouse button, but the graphics were nice and the gameplay was smooth. Good effort! |
| Oct 21 10:31:03 | 14m 32s | Ghost Memories | ♥ 1 | Aw lovely little game. The mechanics were nice & unique, and the short story was well done. The menu however was a bit hard to navigate. It might have been better using the left/right arrow keys to go between the two sides, as sometimes pressing Z & X didn't do the thing it was supposed to. But other than that, well done! 👻 |
| Oct 21 10:36:59 | 5m 56s | No Bullet Hell | ♥ 0 | Love the concept! Execution was pretty good, maybe just the moving needs to be tightened up a bit. A bit more AI would also go a long way with this one. Overall though, I enjoyed it! Good job 😎 |
| Oct 25 09:00:04 | 94h 23m | Slinger | ♥ 1 | A smooth and enjoyable platformer. I understood the sling mechanic, but it did feel a little too precise and unforgiving at times. Adding a bit of support so it doesn't directly throw you into spikes if you press when you're right on top of it (or as someone else, adding a grace zone) would be ways to make it a little more user-friendly. The boss fight at the end was really great, if perhaps a sudden shift from the original tone. But again, based on my game I can't complain about that too much aha. The sling again though in that last section was a little hard. But overall, love the direction and execution and hope you continue it further 🙂 |
| Oct 25 20:49:38 | 11h 49m | Basil | ♥ 1 | Excellent and well polished game! Was literally bout to make a comment that there wasn't enough challenge after everything had been made, but then noticed that the rafts burnt up after a period of time. Simple but fun! Good job! |
| Oct 26 06:55:56 | 10h 06m | cakewalk | ♥ 1 | Hey not bad! Simple and a catchy theme song, and had enough difficulty to provide new challenges each level. Not much else to say. Good job! 🍰 |
| Oct 26 07:25:54 | 29m 58s | Sand&Sea | ♥ 1 | Lovely little game. Took me a while to understand what to do, and I didn't really have a need to place sand which kinda confused me. But once I knew you had to click the images down the bottom to place sand creations, I was able to win the game. Congrats on a great game! 🏖 2019-10-26 (1).png |
| Oct 26 08:06:40 | 40m 46s | A Dream of Wings | ♥ 1 | I really enjoyed the story, and the mechanics were well done. It perhaps got a little repetitive after a while, and begging still felt like a better option than working, but I achieved a couple different endings and still enjoyed the game. Congrats! |
| Oct 26 08:44:35 | 37m 55s | The beginning of the end | ♥ 3 | The game was really great, and I loved the story and concept. The dialog boxes being reversed was also a nice touch. A couple of sections confused me a bit, making me think I had to backtrack, and the music got a little repetitive as a result, but other than that I enjoyed it! |
| Oct 27 11:36:42 | 26h 52m | Kitty Litter Defence | ♥ 1 | Gorgeous game. Got a little repetitive, but the abilities were nice and simple. Fits the theme fine as well. Good job! |
| Oct 28 08:41:37 | 21h 04m | My Stuff is in There! | ♥ 1 | Instant classic 😉 Nah it was actually pretty good! The story was great and had a good message behind it. The gameplay was simple and easy to understand (once I realized about 'listening' to other characters - perhaps that should have been emphasised a little more). I think you did a great job! Congrats |
| Oct 28 08:52:33 | 10m 56s | Ludum and the Lost Pages | ♥ 1 | A nice polished platformer with simple mechanics. The abilities were pretty good, it just may have been good if the invincibility showed you how long was remaining, as a couple times I thought it didn't finish until the countdown was over. Overall though, I enjoyed it! Good job |
| Oct 28 09:02:05 | 9m 32s | Many Mini-Minions | ♥ 0 | Little bit confused on the goal of the game, some more in-game tutorial prompts would have been nice. Graphics were beautiful though, and it felt like it could be a neat little mobile game. Also congrats on 20 ratings! |
