Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD58 → Feedback comment stats → ProtoHere
Feedback comments for LD58
ProtoHere's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | ProtoHere's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 7 02:47:57 | ＄ECURITY CHECK | ♥ 0 | art is incredible! I think starting off it was pretty unclear what the goal of the game was. Like im not sure what exactly the point of placing and organizing the items was besides the general idea of "collecting." Ran into an issue where I would pick up an item and try to place it and it would prevent me from doing anything with that item. Very cool game! | |
| Oct 7 03:02:17 | 14m 20s | Seal the Deal! | ♥ 2 | Pretty simple and i like the vibe! I was considering doing a similar concept but with ebay auctions. I think the gameplay is pretty repetitive and doesnt provide much of a challenge, just a test a patience really. Good job though, great work for such a short time period! |
| Oct 7 03:38:25 | 36m 08s | Daft Punks | ♥ 0 | plssss speed up the character cuz its rough trying to do anything.. also cute art, veery nice! |
| Oct 7 06:27:19 | 2h 48m | Crimson Punk's Gem Hunt | ♥ 1 | really awesome concept and pretty solid execution! i actually quite like the movement and physics, which i think is really hard to pull off with 3D platformers so good job! |
| Oct 7 06:37:16 | 9m 57s | Collect or DIcE | ♥ 2 | actually incredible |
| Oct 7 06:47:33 | 10m 17s | A1 MAS Collector | ♥ 4 | hi there! you mention there being a web version that is more up to date? could you link that as well pls |
| Oct 7 06:52:31 | 4m 58s | Grand Trash Auto 3D | ♥ 5 | its pretty frustrating to move the truck and I think the time doesnt actually go up when you feed the monster, but maybe i just wasnt playing well enough. Vehicle movement is tough to do for such a short time period so I respect the ambition |
| Oct 7 07:13:07 | 20m 36s | Enchanted Blackjack | ♥ 1 | I think this is a super neat idea! i really like the concept and having multipliers and free hands on cards is pretty fun. Unfortunately the deck is shared between the dealer and the player which means the dealer benefits as well when you add more 10s and aces. Also i think the game does not scale to fit other resolutions so some things seem cut off on my computer. I hope you expand on this idea in the future cause id love to play a full version! |
| Oct 7 07:17:05 | 3m 58s | Counterfeit | ♥ 2 | hi there! im trying to play your game but the rar files are confusing me. How can I extract these two separate parts? Its giving me an error |
| Oct 7 07:49:43 | 32m 38s | Clawful | ♥ 5 | this is actually really cool! im surprised about how well the claw physics works. the 3D modeling goes crazy too |
| Oct 7 08:04:00 | 14m 17s | Unholy Black Hole | ♥ 0 | this is some pretty impressive stuff for a compo entry! nice work on the graphics and SFX :) Ivve had some issues with the demons behaving weird and chasing in undesired directions which i think takes away from the satisfaction of consuming the npcs |
| Oct 7 08:08:15 | 4m 15s | METALOBAZA | ♥ 2 | the movement seems a bit inconsistent and i wasnt able to get very far into the first level unfortunately becuz of this |
| Oct 7 08:11:53 | 3m 38s | The A?! game | ♥ 2 | incredible. i have no mouth and i must AAA |
| Oct 7 08:28:19 | 16m 26s | HUEVO | ♥ 3 | Simple, cute game! Progression seems pretty easy, and at a certain point the limiting factor is how quickly you can click and drag the eggs to sell them. I think instead of the second feeder (which i think is useless if you just get the auto feeder?) it might be good to have something that automatically collects some eggs and sells them, or combines eggs into super eggs of high value. nice work! |
| Oct 7 18:49:00 | 10h 20m | A Lifelong Hobby | ♥ 1 | you did a great job mixing up the gameplay and pacing it out so that the player has to engage with every new element. I really like this game! I kind of wish there was a way of using the cards in some kind of gameplay, but that would probably be asking too much for a game jam haha. nice work! |
| Oct 7 19:01:28 | 12m 28s | Claw & Collect | ♥ 0 | Pretty cute game! i do wish there was some amount of strategy to it, though. Right now its just RNG based it seems |
| Oct 7 19:14:02 | 12m 34s | Type II | ♥ 4 | I love the theming!! very solid andcohesive game. Its fun working out new strategies to try to maximize energy collection. I settled on making a ton of sattelites with oblong orbits so they nearly all the time there is at least one satellite really close to the star |
| Oct 7 19:20:22 | 6m 20s | Catch a Critter | ♥ 1 | this is HARD!! but also adorable and really well made, and the art is awesome. great job! |
| Oct 7 19:33:08 | 12m 46s | Energy Rush | ♥ 0 | unsure how to complete a level. I think the general concept of guiding light and collecting it makes sense and could be interesting, but I think in combination with a maze where you dont even know where the goal is is frustrating. The music and art are nice though and the mouse movement feels good. |
| Oct 7 21:22:29 | 1h 49m | Human Collector | ♥ 1 | very simple and satisfying! I wasnt sure what the yellow boxes did. I think something that modifies gameplay a bit more would be a good addition as well |
| Oct 7 21:28:39 | 6m 10s | Soularis | ♥ 1 | a lot of fun! I will say that it gets really laggy pretty quick because of the sheer number of objects, and using explosions seems pretty over powered. Pretty satisfying game though! |
| Oct 7 21:56:21 | 27m 42s | C.A.P.S | ♥ 5 | really awesome! quite a bit of depth, though some of the coin mechanics arent very intuitive until youve used them a couple times. |
| Oct 8 01:01:30 | 3h 05m | Starbearer | ♥ 1 | Nice job! i like the skills and the game reminds me a lot of metroidvanias ive played |
| Oct 8 01:19:57 | 18m 27s | Collectorogue | ♥ 1 | This is really interesting! Ive never seen anything like this and i really like the 2D graphics and sfx. I agree with @binarydiv that splitting it up into two phases could allow more time for the player to engage with analyzing the items, rather than just stacking as much as possible. Also the cat is much too easy to deal with, up until it turns invisible! |
| Oct 8 01:33:30 | 13m 33s | Astro Gourmet | ♥ 3 | no idea whats going on! |
| Oct 8 01:52:28 | 18m 58s | Taos K.O. | ♥ 1 | incredible. I wish the combat was clearer so it was easier to strategize around, because how a team will work together is a bit ambiguous. Otherwise, everything about this game is phenomenal especially for a game jam. great work !! |
| Oct 8 01:58:27 | 5m 59s | Marble Trouble | ♥ 4 | incredible! I was hopingh to play more but had the bug where the game comes to a halt and i cant continue. Music and art is phenomenal, and genuinely fun |