Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD57 → Feedback comment stats → Sharky3188
Feedback comments for LD57
Sharky3188's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Sharky3188's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 7 12:49:09 | angler | ♥ 2 | Nice work, very solid effort for 12 hours! Love the rustic art style. Gameplay felt like it could have been a tiny bit more engaging, but overall good entry. | |
| Apr 7 12:58:55 | 9m 46s | The Investigator | ♥ 1 | I like the overall feeling of the game, I think its mainly lacking some user feedback. I often wasn't sure if I was clicking on the right things. So having some sort of highlight/animation/etc on the areas you can interact with would help. I think it could have gone a bit further of the depth theme, but overall great job. |
| Apr 7 13:07:14 | 8m 19s | Depth of your Thoughts | ♥ 2 | Great work on your first 3D entry. I noticed a bug where you can spam jump and enable yourself to fly :D. Otherwise the atmosphere was good, I wish I could understand the text as it felt like I was missing out on a lot of engaging parts of the game (maybe add translations in the future?). Music fit in well, and the theme felt decent. |
| Apr 7 13:11:46 | 4m 32s | The Deepest Descent | ♥ 3 | Love that intro cutscene! Overall pretty good game, my only complaint would be, I wish the character wasn't at the top of the frame, maybe more one third off from the top. Overall good audio, art and gameplay. |
| Apr 7 13:20:42 | 8m 56s | Echoes of the deep | ♥ 1 | Loved the way you did the radar in this. Really good getting to select the loadouts as well. Overall fits the theme pretty nice. The atmosphere was surprisingly tense for a cute little 2D game. Great job. |
| Apr 7 14:20:52 | 1h 00m | A Very Deep Tunnel | ♥ 1 | I love the way the music grows more and more each stage you get to, a really great touch. Each new level reveal feels very satisfying with the light and audio. Good take for the theme. My only criticism is i think the collection could be something other than bees. Overall though great entry, spent longer on this than i expected i would. |
| Apr 8 00:52:55 | 10h 32m | Riches From Below | ♥ 4 | Awesome entry! The visuals are great, really nice aesthetic, very dredge like vibes. Really fun take on the theme. All the little details are really well made, like how each diver jumps out the boat. Great clean UI really nice to see. Hilarious you can actually kill the divers, didn't expect it the first time around and gave me a good chuckle, the hull 'thunk' is both satisfying and hilarious. Searching for treasure with the divers is really clever, a fun balance of trying to drop off as many as possible while also keeping them all alive. Overall a really great job. |
| Apr 8 01:22:38 | 29m 43s | HellDigger – A Cozy Idle Game | ♥ 2 | Decent little idle game, the art makes it pretty fun to see what's deeper. A little slow at the start and i wish there were more options than just giving 100 workers, maybe a 10 or 100 add? It would be nice if there were some kind of thing i could do while idle, maybe a clicker or something, but overall good job. |
| Apr 8 01:45:44 | 23m 06s | Froggy Towers | ♥ 1 | Great entry, changed my life. Theme 1 star. |
| Apr 8 04:20:20 | 2h 34m | Ball Pit | ♥ 0 | I really like the dash mechanic, adds to the speed run feeling of the game. It would have been good if the keys controlled the ball and the mouse controls the aim to avoid awkward steering. Save points are nice so glad you added them. Good job. |
| Apr 8 04:32:24 | 12m 04s | Depths Of Terror | ♥ 1 | Nice arcade shooter would be great with a few more enemy types, great work overall. |
| Apr 8 06:08:38 | 1h 36m | Bedrock Rush | ♥ 3 | Really well polished game, the music was awesome, really added to the fun. Great graphics and fun gameplay. Had a bug where i got locked into a section of track that was too low and kept going out of bounds. Overall a great entry. |
| Apr 8 07:09:03 | 1h 00m | The Depths, A Floppy Cat Adventure | ♥ 2 | Controls felt pretty wild to me, i sort of felt like i wasn't really in full control, took a while to get used to. Feels pretty unique, a lot to explore. Didn't get heaps far as my sub kept exploding, which was an unexpected cool part of the game. |
| Apr 8 08:42:11 | 1h 33m | Mecha-Mice: Expedition | ♥ 1 | A fun take on the theme with robotic mice. Overall the gameplay was a bit rough around the edges, i think with some polish it would be really fun. I really enjoyed building an army of mice, however i was never really sure when or why they would explore or get converted. Maybe some more tutorialisation would help. The rocks are devastating, didnt pay attention for 2 seconds and my whole mouse army was gone :(. Great visuals and atmosphere. |
| Apr 8 08:55:11 | 13m 00s | into the forest depths | ♥ 1 | Love how the post man just rocks up with a knife covered with blood and offers people a package. Great entry! The atmosphere and world building are excellent. There's a hint of humour thrown in and some fun mechanics which I feel more games should look into doing. Had a minor bug with the grandmas who body going missing after 1 hit, but not a major issue. Would have loved this with some audio i feel like it would have elevated the whole thing. Art looked beautiful, love all the creature designs. Really good job. |
| Apr 8 09:15:11 | 20m 00s | Archeologic | ♥ 5 | A really cute game with great art style, atmosphere and audio. Unfortunately let down by some frustrating game design. Overall i think the concept is a fun take on some of the ideas. However i was constantly having visual issues not being able to see what I was doing and select blocks. I wish that the camera had stayed centred on my character and there was a different sort of visual que to show you were about to run out of time. Maybe something crushing blocks above? Very satisfying getting the bombs and hitting a good combo. Overall a good entry on a bunch of different fronts. |
| Apr 8 09:40:22 | 25m 11s | Cheese is the Reason | ♥ 1 | Fantastic entry! wow, so much art, super impressive you got so much done, it really gave the whole game a sense of polish that I didn't expect to see. Voice acting was 10/10, some great humour. All the camera angles felt really cinematic and complemented all the environments. The movement felt really clean and intuitive to use. If I had any sort of feedback it would just be more gameplay, but for what you did it was great. |
| Apr 8 11:53:59 | 2h 13m | Debts in the Depths | ♥ 1 | Wow such an impressive game, i don't know how you managed to fit all that in within 48 hours, insanity! Looks and plays amazing, the sprites are really well designed and animated. Both impressive that it looks so polished and it's super fun to play. Amazing entry. |
| Apr 8 12:24:25 | 30m 26s | Downstairs | ♥ 4 | I loved the atmosphere in this game, really unsettling and the controls added a nice amount of tension without feeling too frustrating. One minor complaint, esc key closing the application killed me, i was pretty deep into a run and hit the key out of habit to pause, and it totally ruined the run. The up key on the jump was also a bit cruel, caught me out a few times, but it did add to the tension. Art and audio were great, overall very nice game. |
| Apr 8 12:35:32 | 11m 07s | The Cleaner of the depth | ♥ 6 | Beautiful presentation, very polished with the art, audio, camera work etc. Gameplay could use some clarification as to why i was being eaten, but everything else is amazing, I could picture a minimalistic puzzle game using this style. |
| Apr 9 11:47:59 | 23h 12m | Cave Escape | ♥ 3 | Great game, really fun to replay over and over. Great to try and beat that high score and a lot of fun chaining multiple good jumps together. Great entry. |
| Apr 9 11:53:01 | 5m 02s | Pogo Dwarf | ♥ 1 | Great entry, surprisingly fun, i thought the controls would make me feel more angry, but they weren't too bad to control. Some lack of checkpoints definitely got me raging, but overall great entry. |
| Apr 9 13:16:19 | 1h 23m | Mr. Money's Phenomenally Soggy Water Removal Romp | ♥ 3 | Such a great game! I loved the use of the theme mixed in with a cozy idle game with some fun exploration and humour. You solved all the issues i had early on with the movement feeling slow, and the roller skates/board felt great to zoom around on. Minor graphical glitch with the item i was holding flashing in and out, but game jams hey. Super solid entry. |
| Apr 9 14:32:29 | 1h 16m | Well Gnome! | ♥ 1 | Great game, super fun and entertaining. |
| Apr 10 06:40:05 | 16h 07m | Dig in, Gus! | ♥ 2 | Lovely entry, both fun and chill, really satisfying digging your way around, the character controls really nice for this kind of game. The animation on the grapple feels great, props to your artists. I could easily see this expanded upon adding upgrades etc. Great work. |
| Apr 10 07:36:19 | 56m 14s | Burrilka | ♥ 3 | The atmosphere is so good! The audio is done so well, i'd love to know how you did the voice radio effect? It adds so much. Love the art, super polished and well made, amazing entry. |
| Apr 10 09:02:20 | 1h 26m | Deep space journey | ♥ 1 | Very simple game, would love to see the basic premise expanded upon in some small ways to give more weight to the gameplay. The story absolutely captured an interesting atmosphere that fit well with the theme, I think expanding upon the interactions in the room would have been a chance for more story telling elements. As a solo dev well done. |
| Apr 10 09:51:04 | 48m 44s | Sinking Hope | ♥ 2 | Good atmosphere, i really liked the feeling of throwing the trident and swimming around. I wish the radar/compass was a little bit easier to use, but overall a good entry. |
| Apr 10 10:11:49 | 20m 45s | Home Deep Home | ♥ 2 | Beautiful, art, audio and atmosphere. I saw some comments about scope creep and i can see how that may have happened. Overall the game has a huge amount of potential, just a few UX issues i think would be great to clear up. Overall though i think its still a great entry and i played longer than i expected to. |
| Apr 10 10:17:23 | 5m 34s | Walking Simulator | ♥ 1 | Wild ride. |
| Apr 10 10:32:34 | 15m 11s | Dyamid | ♥ 1 | Great game design, some really fun puzzles from a simple but unique mechanic. Graphics and audio are also on point, great work. |
| Apr 10 12:26:23 | 1h 53m | Blip | ♥ 1 | Really fun game, great movement and unique mechanics. Its great to try and master the controls and get faster. Great entry. |
| Apr 11 11:24:21 | 22h 57m | Hooky Fish | ♥ 1 | Pretty simple, but well executed. I liked the water boosting sections, added a nice element of skill factor to the game which I didn't expect to see. I liked the progression of picking up new things from the ocean as you played. Perhaps a bit more feedback on the UI would be nice, but overall great work. |