Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD46 → Feedback comment stats → WFMG

WFMG

Feedback comments for LD46

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		WFMG's comment
Apr 21 16:49:46		FIREGUARD	♥ 3	It's a fun game, though it lacks some of the ambience that would make it feel more imposing. This is partly due to the lack of contrast in the lighting, as well as the somewhat irritating music. I enjoy throwing the sticks around, but it took a while before I realised I had to light them on fire. The particle effects are nice and the graphics are pretty great overall. It's a nice and cohesive style and it fits that "polished retro" look quite well. In one round/attempt, it seemed that no enemies would spawn, no matter what. I don't know what would cause this, but it's a minor issue since you can just refresh the page.
Apr 21 17:00:05	10m 19s	Gryphon Peaks	♥ 0	Loved the graphics, as everyone agrees. The game was a bit short, though. Short and pretty weird. I wish the FOV had been higher and the camera controls had been the other way around, but overall, nice. Weird, but nice. Feels very gamey. That's something to chew on.
Apr 21 17:08:56	8m 51s	Message	♥ 3	I like the visuals. They were nice, though a bit inconsistent. The camera was way too zoomed in on the character, though. It was really hard to see the obstacles ahead of you. The music's nice and fits the electronic theme. I say great job!
Apr 21 17:19:15	10m 19s	Save the Kindgom! A Knight, a Prince and a Monster	♥ 1	I almost beat it, but then it crashed! So frustrating! It becomes pretty methodical rather quickly, but it surprisingly sucks you in a lot despite having no fullscreen mode or particularly amazing graphics. The music is nice.
Apr 21 17:26:00	6m 45s	Ballad of the Bard	♥ 3	It's very interesting visually and the concept is cool. As a musician myself, I enjoyed this concept, though it got a bit repetitive in practice. That said, it is clear that all of you are talented game developers. Well done! The mood was really relaxing. I just kept forgetting about the fire.
Apr 21 17:35:28	9m 28s	Planets wars	♥ 1	Really nice graphics. I didn't expect the execution to be this great. I do wish there were a respawn timer, though. That and a few seconds of invincibility when you first respawn.
Apr 21 18:00:26	24m 58s	Field Hospital	♥ 3	Amazing! Lots of talent there! It was extremely immersive.
Apr 21 18:06:52	6m 26s	OVERHOSPITALIZED	♥ 2	Pretty fun, though the memes were a bit overbearing and not that funny. The gameplay is also very difficult. It seems to be a bit of a developer game in that it's too hard for people who didn't make it and know the ultimate strategy to it. You seem to have to be perfect in order to save a significant amount of people. Pretty good overall, though.
Apr 21 18:18:49	11m 57s	Flower Defense	♥ 1	Took a second to figure it out, but it's a good game. The pixel scale of the graphics is a bit inconsistent, but that's how it goes in an LD game. It is impressive how far it goes, as can be seen in a previous screenshot, and I like the idea of collecting resources as a more interactable process. Almost inspirational. That's really good.
Apr 21 18:26:56	8m 07s	El Burritón	♥ 3	Very fun game! I enjoyed holding down so many buttons. I truly felt my skills were put to the test. This was a very creative idea and you executed it well.
Apr 21 18:34:05	7m 09s	Tower of BOOM	♥ 1	It was fun, though only once I realised I had to use my arrows keys to move properly. A and D move the character as well.
Apr 21 18:46:18	12m 13s	Inanis	♥ 1	Fun game, though the meta commentary was not always accurate. I just don't know how you could possibly beat that boss. Whomst'd'veever does that is a true GAMER MOMENT.
Apr 21 18:51:22	5m 04s	Street Flight	♥ 1	This is really cool. It really is Flappy Bird 3D. However, I noticed that I could easily cheat by flying to the top of my range and flying above everything. Some more polish, a road between the houses, and this is a masterpiece.
Apr 21 18:58:07	6m 45s	Defend Pangolin Eggs	♥ 2	It's a well-made tower defence game, but it's a bit long-winded for an LD game. It's not the most innovative thing in the world, but I think you might have a commercial hit if you work on this some more.
Apr 21 19:08:12	10m 05s	Broken Threads	♥ 1	Kinda quirki doe! 😳 Just be careful you don't piss off people thinking that you're putting a virus on their PC.
Apr 21 19:22:17	14m 05s	Tumbleweed	♥ 2	Oh my god. Wow. These graphics are literally AAA. How are you guys so talented? The game is peaceful too. It has more gameplay than a lot of LD games, and yet the gameplay is not the focus, nor does the game feel stressful or intense in that way. I wish I could create graphics like this. The only issue I found was that the poems faded out a bit fast, though I was reading them out loud for the stream. Amazing.