Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → Roka Josh
Feedback comments for LD43
Roka Josh's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Roka Josh's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 4 17:14:21 | Istenek | ♥ 2 | Fun little game, the graphics are nice, although I would of liked a bit more to the sound design. I also like the idea of sacrificing different resources in order to reach the raid requirements however I only had to do this once in order to win, so maybe a greater focus on that in future? I appreciate how hard it is to balance strategy games on a time frame however, so great effort. Well done and good luck! | |
| Dec 4 17:19:07 | 4m 46s | Suicide crowd | ♥ 1 | Good game, quite fun and has good potential replayability. Sticks to theme well as well so that's good. Great job and good luck! |
| Dec 4 17:23:39 | 4m 32s | Learn to be a self stopper! | ♥ 1 | It's a great idea, and I would love to see this as a polished and finished game. The core concept itself is very interesting, however I agree that the presentation is a bit quick and I didn't fully understand what was going on I'm first playthrough. Good job and best of luck! |
| Dec 4 17:49:50 | 26m 11s | Deadline | ♥ 3 | Great game, very engaging and a brutal story. I also love the art style and the music, however if I was being supercritical I would say to have more variety in the music, again though being super critical. There were 3 occasions where I had no food and nobody died as well, but aside from that amazing game. Fantastic job and good luck! |
| Dec 4 17:57:03 | 7m 13s | Sacrifices must be made | ♥ 0 | Good effort nonetheless, and what turned out is still a fun game at it's core. Minus things like the players I generally like the art style a lot and the music was also nice. One thing however, it seems a bit too grindy and long in order to progress so maybe change that in future. Good effort however and good luck! |
| Dec 4 18:07:11 | 10m 08s | The Unbinding | ♥ 3 | A great idea and executed well, sticks to the them perfectly. I like the music, however the graphics could be a little better for me, still not bad for what the are trying to convey. I found it quite confusing at the start, not much was obvious for me, however they may just be me. Once I got the jist though I got really into it, and I liked it a lot. Fantastic job and good luck! |
| Dec 4 18:17:26 | 10m 15s | Exploding Sport | ♥ 1 | Good game and I like the audio in it, especially the narrator, and I feel it is very fun and replayable. I do think however the tie into the theme is fairly weak, but the game makes up for this. Great job and good luck! |
| Dec 4 19:07:31 | 50m 05s | Silvercliff Killings | ♥ 2 | Outstanding game, checks all the boxes with the theme, graphics, sound, and mood especially. Absolutely brilliant, amazing work! |
| Dec 4 19:11:58 | 4m 27s | I'm Bored So Let's Sacrifice | ♥ 1 | Good game, thought it was pretty funny and has good replayability. Good job and good luck! |
| Dec 5 17:35:28 | 22h 23m | Ludumiumings | ♥ 2 | Very nice game, well made with great polish, one criticism is with selecting miners when the are grouped up together is quite difficult but apart from that everything is great. Great job and good luck! |
| Dec 5 17:42:54 | 7m 26s | Cultists vs Demons | ♥ 1 | Congratulations on finishing your first game, it turned out really well! Music and sound effects add a lot to a game, but I can understand the difficulties of trying to get it in on time. I would love to see this developed further in the future with more enemies, attacks and maybe different characters you can pick up. Lots of potential. Good job and best of luck! |
| Dec 5 17:48:17 | 5m 23s | Whole Hole | ♥ 0 | A great idea, nice art style and fitting to the theme, however I found the movement to be a bit buggy and inconsistent. There was one occasion where the character got caught in between two spears and flew up. Good job however, and good luck! |
| Dec 7 23:03:33 | 53h 15m | Dare to Risk | ♥ 1 | Good game, I liked it a lot and thought it was very replayable. I would also like to see a game with more than one computer on a larger map to see how that would work. |
| Dec 7 23:13:15 | 9m 42s | Sacrifical Flight | ♥ 1 | Good little game, would love to see this developed more if the people had certain statistics and other factors which makes the decision of who to throw out harder. Good job, and best of luck! |
| Dec 9 20:05:53 | 44h 52m | A Starving Monk | ♥ 1 | Good game for your first entry, I liked the story at the beginning and the audio and graphics suit the game well. I would say however that you should make the movement more fluid to make it more enjoyable, and also I don't see how it ties into the theme that well. Good job though and good luck! |
| Dec 9 20:15:27 | 9m 34s | Nature is Harsh | ♥ 1 | Great game and a great idea to fit the theme, fantastic job as well with the narration I thought it was very funny! Great job and best of luck! |
| Dec 9 20:26:59 | 11m 32s | Otto | ♥ 0 | Nice game, I would love to see this be carried on further with development, trying to add more parts and make other parts better/more usable. One issue I had however was the camera, as I could barely move and it made snapping parts together very laborious. Other than that great game and good luck! |
| Dec 9 20:36:33 | 9m 34s | Hello operator. | ♥ 1 | Great game, I would love to see more of this and for it to become a proper papers please style game with multiple endings depending on decisions you have to make. I understand that not everyone can make music but even sound effects add a lot to a game, and I think this effects the mood quite a bit. Apart from that great job and best of luck! |
| Dec 9 20:47:04 | 10m 31s | Trahere | ♥ 2 | Great game, I love the art and although the audio isn't yours it adds to the mood perfectly. Fantastic effort, and I would love to see this developed more in future! |
| Dec 11 21:24:50 | 48h 37m | Hire Power | ♥ 1 | Solid game, some really good game design as well especially regarding introducing new mechanics to the player, generally solid puzzle design. I don't really understand the calling mechanic however as it didn't seem to do anything (could be a bug?). Great game however, amazing job and best of luck! |
| Dec 19 17:28:32 | 188h 03m | Garry's Sacrifice | ♥ 1 | Great game, really enjoyed playing and finding the strategy. I found once I had 4 positivity towers, 2 barbeques, 2 catapults and 2 of the beating things, It was easy. Good job and best of luck! |
| Dec 19 19:34:01 | 2h 05m | Broken Knight | ♥ 2 | The game has great potential, you should seriously consider working on it post Jam, I think it would be great if you did! The jumping felt really off sometimes however, and I missed platforms because the player didn't jump as high as before, and also jumping on the slope was a nightmare. Anyhow, good game and would love to see this be developed further. |
| Dec 21 16:08:01 | 44h 34m | Altar War | ♥ 0 | Nice game, it got hard very quickly after being easy for a while. Would like to see more be added to this, like perhaps different types of enemies? Great job and good luck! |
| Dec 27 13:21:11 | 141h 13m | Organic Harvest | ♥ 0 | Great game, I love what you have done with the theme! Very original. Great job and goo luck! |
| Dec 28 16:30:06 | 27h 08m | Fridge Raider | ♥ 1 | Very fun game, I liked how you interpreted the idea and I think you have pulled it off very well! Great job! |
| Dec 28 16:36:48 | 6m 42s | God given gifts, taken | ♥ 2 | Great game, would love to see this being developed further, I had an issue with some of the tile sprites when you jump you can see lines in between them, but apart from that solid game. Great job! |
| Dec 28 16:50:34 | 13m 46s | Suicide to step upside | ♥ 0 | Good concept, however I got caught in a loop where I kept on dying over one of the moving saws and couldnt move or get out. Would like to see this developed more however, with a bit of polish it could become a great game! Good effort and best of luck! |