Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → GenericToast
Feedback comments for LD43
GenericToast's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | GenericToast's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 8 06:32:21 | Upsystem | ♥ 2 | Really nice atmospheric sound effects but i was pretty lost at what i was supposed to do. Perhaps a more detailed tutorial could have benefited the game. Other than that, a really cool concept and being able to work with such a large group of people to create a game within the given time is quite impressive! | |
| Dec 8 06:49:36 | 17m 15s | Blood, Sweat and Taxes | ♥ 0 | Unique take on the theme and cool concept. The user interface could be improved though such as showing what items you gave when in the different menus and the amount of money you have. Also when accessing a menu, every single option is shown. Instead of that, you could make it so that only the options that are possible should be shown. (eg. only show 'plant corn' when you only have corn seeds) A mini in game tutorial could also help players to understand the game a little easier. Overall a cool game which just needs a little bit of polish |
| Dec 8 06:59:35 | 9m 59s | Sacrifice to the Flames | ♥ 2 | Amazing artwork and music! The fire and smoke aesthetics also looked really cool. It took me a little while to figure out what i was supposed to do so a mini explanation at the start could help. Perhaps some more stuff could have been added to further increase the replay-ability of the game. Overall, a great looking game with a cool take on the theme! |
| Dec 8 07:23:27 | 23m 52s | Diaball | ♥ 1 | One of my favorites so far! Amazing aesthetics combined with simple but fun mechanics make this a great game. I like that the UI is part of the level itself so the screen doesn't end up cluttered. The music and sfx are also great and helps to add greatly to the game. The only thing a little off is the theme, which the game doesn't really have a huge connection too. However, this game is overall very impressive and a great fun to play! |
| Dec 8 07:40:39 | 17m 12s | The Pink Slip | ♥ 1 | Fun little game with a great personality and a cool artstyle! I managed to find the (not so secret?) ending where i took down the boss. This reminded me of papers please with the similar concept of choosing who to fire or keep. A small problem i had with the web version of the game (i was playing on chrome) was that the text box was a bit small and difficult to click on. Other than that, i really enjoyed playing it! (Also RIP bill's dad) |
| Dec 8 08:15:59 | 35m 20s | Grauby Grauby | ♥ 1 | Really nice graphics and sounds! The level design is also great with good difficulty progression. The game has a simple but fun mechanic. I feel that this game could be a really fun mobile game if you decided to continue working on it. One bug i encountered was I could not move anymore after dieing later in the level(i was playing the html version on chrome). Other than that, really fun to play! |
| Dec 8 08:23:46 | 7m 47s | Viking Snow Fight | ♥ 2 | Great looking sprites and cool music! I like that the enemies actually try and block/avoid your snowballs instead of only moving randomly. |
| Dec 8 08:36:52 | 13m 06s | Silent Whisper | ♥ 1 | This game sets a really great mood with amazing looking graphics and atmospheric sounds. It reminded me of fighting fantasy games with the different decisions you could make and the story telling. If this was made into a fully fledged game, i would definitely get it. Great entry! |
| Dec 9 07:06:16 | 22h 29m | Wild Heat Showdown | ♥ 1 | Really impressive being able to make a game with randomly generated levels within the given time! The minimap is also a very nice addition to help players keep track of where they are since the levels are random. The movement speed when going up and down ladders could be increased a little as it felt a bit slow. An aiming indicator could also be added or the mouse cursor could be made visible as i found myself clicking outside of the game a lot of the time(i played the web version on chrome). Overall a cool game with some nice music and quirky backstory! |
| Dec 9 07:22:02 | 15m 46s | Shadow Lands | ♥ 1 | This was an extremely fun game to play! Solid level design coupled with simple mechanics made for a really fun experience. The sounds and music also added greatly to the atmosphere and mood of the game. I found the final boss a little challenging at first since it could push me around but after a couple of tries i managed to defeat it. Overall a really well made entry which i thoroughly enjoyed! |
| Dec 9 08:02:22 | 40m 20s | Sacrificial Sam | ♥ 1 | Really fun and well designed puzzle game. The level design is solid and the game mechanics are well thought out. The music was also good and the various sound effects were nice. Being able to produce a game like this in 3 days is really impressive! I managed to find all 3 "secret" items and get the (good?) ending and i liked how you had to replay the levels to get them. Definitely one of my favorite entries so far! |
| Dec 9 08:16:22 | 14m 00s | Turtle Torture | ♥ 0 | Pretty good for a game made in a day. I liked the art and user interface. A way to speed up the time could be added as i found myself waiting a lot for the next day to come. I also came across an issue where my items would disappear if i picked them up while i had a full inventory. With some added content this could make for a really interesting game! |
| Dec 9 08:55:53 | 39m 31s | Jamming Dilemma | ♥ 1 | A pretty simple but fun game! A great game for your first ludum dare entry. One problem i faced was when dragging some of the idea cards, some of them would go off screen and i wasn't able to pick them up again. Other than that, good job! |
| Dec 9 09:05:26 | 9m 33s | Sheepy | ♥ 0 | A nice looking game with good environment and character models. I found the game pretty difficult to play on the web version though due to the character continuing to move forward when clicking and dragging a sheep. Sometimes the sheep would also disappear when i click on it once. I'm sure the windows build works fine though so i recommend people play that version instead. Overall a really cool looking game! |
| Dec 9 13:02:27 | 3h 57m | Can't Get No Sacrifaction | ♥ 1 | A really smart take on the theme!(This was the first game idea i thought of doing but eventually changed it XD) Theres a way to stick to walls by holding the movement button, but should be a very easy fix if your'e using unity's physics(because iv'e also encountered this before in another one of my games). I like the use of the "cutscenes" at the start to help set the story of the game. Overall, this game could have a lot of potential if the mechanics were a bit more polished. |
| Dec 9 13:13:15 | 10m 48s | ScreenCrifice | ♥ 1 | A really cool game idea and take on the theme! I liked the idea of the actual pixels on your screen slowly being sacrificed. Some audio would have really added to the experience. |
| Dec 9 13:26:24 | 13m 09s | Sacrifice Now | ♥ 1 | A neat game with some nice artwork and great sound effects. When i reached the final tile the game text kind of skipped past it and i just ended up at the victory screen. Other than that great job! |
| Dec 10 11:58:48 | 22h 32m | Overtime | ♥ 2 | A really great story and a nice take on the theme. I found this game very refreshing as it is so different from all the other typical entries. Even though there isn't much gameplay, the story makes up for it. I also liked that there were multiple endings to the game. Great job! |
| Dec 13 06:37:15 | 66h 38m | Battling Madness | ♥ 1 | Great looking art and cool sound effects. I encountered a bug where i sometimes got stuck to the sides of the play area. Was hoping there would be unique enemies who did different attacks instead of just walking towards the player. Still a great entry! |
| Dec 18 15:16:11 | 128h 38m | Sacrifice Powers | ♥ 0 | Cool concept that could be improved on by adding more powers. Currently the game plays out very linearly since each power can only be used once(not including the one that the power returner gives) so maybe a turn based cooldown would have been better? Also, the main menu and play again buttons don't work after finishing the game. Overall still pretty fun and a good game idea! |
| Dec 22 09:45:51 | 90h 29m | The Resistance | ♥ 0 | Really well thought out game mechanics and design. The only thing i felt that could be improved was the difficulty progression between the stages. The puzzles are already semi challenging from the first few levels so some easier levels at the beginning would have been nice. Other than that, this is an extremely good compo game!(as expected from you 😉 ) |