Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD42 → Feedback comment stats → Ethan Nachreiner
Feedback comments for LD42
Ethan Nachreiner's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Ethan Nachreiner's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 12 23:18:32 | A Way Out | ♥ 1 | The game is very cute and the art works really well! I found the movement a bit sluggish for my liking, but the interpretation of the theme was pretty good! Maybe the instructions were unclear, but I enjoyed finding out that I had to shoot the wall after a few seconds of shooting the red balls (might of been my fault 😅). Overall I liked the game, but it is certainly in need of more content. | |
| Aug 12 23:24:19 | 5m 47s | Tunnel Ride | ♥ 1 | The game feels really nice, and this is one of the most "complete" interpretations of the theme I've seen! I like how the game has multiple stages to it, where at first the walls start closing in then the player slows down. My biggest problem with the game is that you have to press the mouse button every time you want to shoot. But overall, what this game does it does very well! 😄 |
| Aug 12 23:53:52 | 29m 33s | TightFloe | ♥ 1 | Well that certainly was an experience... I love it. No seriously, I thought the concept was great. Also, "Peace is dead" made me laugh 😄. Learning a new tool can be difficult, and I hope I'm not being harsh when I say that it shows; but I still had fun playing the game. Also (in my first attempt) when the iceberg started drifting away I jumped off of it and waited on the mainland, and watched as other Father Penguins murdered (?) others as the camera drifted further away... so that was neat. |
| Aug 13 00:02:43 | 8m 51s | Meager | ♥ 1 | I love it! 😃 I'm impressed that you managed to fit a multiplayer mode in, along with the regular mode. While I don't find the idea where movement *feels* like it's turn-based (but it's not) very interesting, the execution was done very well! I also spent quite a long time trying to beat the "impossible" level... the name certainly doesn't lie. |
| Aug 13 00:29:36 | 26m 53s | TooooClose | ♥ 1 | Simple but very well made! The "feel" of the game is just right! The movement feels responsive and the goal is very clear! My one complaint is that it takes way too long to get back to where you were when you died. Maybe add checkpoints, or like @ngupsilon said maybe cut off the first level? |
| Aug 13 02:32:46 | 2h 03m | Blockage | ♥ 1 | First of all let me say that I beat the game 😅(I know this because (spoilers) it just sends you to the menu at the end). I loved the level where you have to build the staircase while on a layer of the blocks. But my main problem with the game is that it isn't really about solving puzzles as much as it is about circumventing the physics system. While you may think what I just said was hard, the truth is that I kinda really liked it. I feel like I shouldn't have, but I did. Every solution feels like I cheated, which I find fun. This game certainly isn't for everyone, but it definitely feels like it's for me. TIP: Stack blocks on top of each other but with a slight gap so you can use them as a very steep staircase! (P.S. That giant chasm in the last level can go die.) |
| Aug 13 05:46:14 | 3h 13m | Leaving Room | ♥ 1 | Short and sweet! Well... sort of sweet, more depressing really. I loved how you incorporated the story with the mechanics. Maybe I'm overthinking it, but when "she" was introduced and the game became harder I thought that the story and gameplay was a bit disconnected (to me as a player, she was just another obstacle); but then when the game became easier I also kind of missed her (because the game is only interesting when it's actually a challenge). The gameplay, graphics, and sound all succeed in doing everything they functionally have to, and the game just has a nice overall tone. Great game! (Although I do wish it was a bit longer.) |
| Aug 13 06:24:25 | 38m 11s | Computer Funfare. | ♥ 1 | I love the graphics in the Burn-Out and Rodger games! The best out of all of them is definitely Rodger. Burn-Out is... frankly... kinda boring (personal taste probably) (and the meters are a bit glitchy). Shooter takes way too long to get interesting, and even then it's too easy. But Rodger is just really good, and I hope you expand on it in the future! There was one really good thing in Shooter though, the way the sound gets super intense as time goes by (but the sound doesn't really match the actual difficulty). Sorry if I sound a bit harsh, your game has some of the best graphics I've seen so far in this jam! (And Rodger is genuinely fun.) And it's also really impressive that you made not 1, but 3 games! |
| Aug 13 06:32:27 | 8m 02s | Missing Space | ♥ 1 | Interesting game with a lot of potential! Here's a bullet list of things I would change/add: - Make it so the player dies when the void consumes them, instead of getting stuck. - Make the enemy and player health visible. - Make the enemies have less health, but make more of them. - Add screenshake and other effects to make the shooting feel better! - Add randomness to the angle of the enemies (that updates every second or so), that way they won't clump together and it will look more interesting! I'd love to see this get expanded on! |
| Aug 13 06:39:24 | 6m 57s | Space Debris | ♥ 0 | The graphics are amazing! The game is fun, and I like the general concept. I just wish the animation was better. Maybe add some effects like explosions, and use some "linear interpolation". I was gonna complain about the bullets staying for a bit after they hit something, but it's actually kinda interesting. My biggest complaint is that the game takes a bit too long to get interesting, and when it does it's still too easy. But all in all it's a fun little game, and a lot of the individual graphics are genuinely impressive! |
| Aug 13 06:48:04 | 8m 40s | Beyond Space | ♥ 0 | This is probably the best compo game I've played so far! Super impressive! All of my complaints are just tiny little things (I wish you started a bit faster/more powerful, I wish it was more obvious the white void kills you, I wish the shop was a bit easier to interact with). Seriously you should be super proud of this! Parts of it can look a bit messy, but overall this game is incredible! |
| Aug 13 06:54:46 | 6m 42s | Please No Home | ♥ 1 | If you're having trouble playing this game then here's how to do it: - Right-click on PleaseNoHome.love - Open with... - "Look for another app on this PC" (or whatever) - Find PleaseNoHome.exe (in the same folder as PleaseNoHome.love) and select it Summary: Open PleaseNoHome.love USING PleaseNoHome.exe |
| Aug 13 07:21:46 | 27m 00s | Running out of Platformers | ♥ 1 | Fun little game! I liked the ending screen (although my heart skipped a beat thinking it was a loss meme). My favorite thing about the platforming was how you would jump farther when going up slopes. My least favorite thing about the platforming was how it lacked certain programming tricks that make platforming feel good (like coyote time). The art style was.... menacing. All in all, it's a nice game! |
| Aug 13 07:34:38 | 12m 52s | CRUSHED - Rage Inducing Platformer | ♥ 1 | The graphics are extremely polished! I think the platforming is too slidey, and I don't like how the obstacles slam back down when you release the mouse button. But everything else about the platforming is impressive! All and all this is a seriously great game! Also that ending... RIP. 😢 |
| Aug 13 09:11:57 | 1h 37m | One Man's Trash | ♥ 2 | This is the best hidden object game I've ever played. It's so good that it feels like an insult to call it a hidden object game. Whenever it introduced a new mechanic I would think to myself, "This game has MORE content!?!" All of the 12 levels are unique and fun, seriously the quality of this game has left me stunned. This is definitely the best compo game I've played so far! 😃 |
| Aug 13 21:13:58 | 12h 02m | Lava Rider | ♥ 1 | Okay, THIS is my favorite compo game I've played so far. It's so good 😄! I think my highscore was somewhere around 150. The game is fun, the graphics are incredible, honestly there's nothing to complain about! |
| Aug 13 21:26:58 | 13m 00s | As the world burns | ♥ 1 | This is definitely one of my favorite compo games I've played! I absolutely love it 😄! The art style is especially good, and I really like the music! While I do wish there was more feedback when an enemy gets hit (and maybe lower the enemy hp a bit), this game is still stunning! Although you should make it so your bullets can put out the fire, because if you get trapped in a room you just have to kill yourself (which seems a bit awkward). |
| Aug 13 21:40:22 | 13m 24s | Quantum Abyss | ♥ 0 | I really like this game! I especially like watching the little scientists hop around. Although I do think the game could use an extra mechanic or something that would make it a bit more difficult. I got the dark matter ending, which had a pretty dark subject matter (ba dum tshhh). I hope to see this game get expanded on, I really like it! 😄 |
| Aug 14 01:05:25 | 3h 25m | Out of Memory Exception | ♥ 1 | I really like the idea of being able to place your own platforms, and having a "stack" mechanic! But unfortunately I think your scope was too big. The platforming itself lacks polish, and it can be pretty frustrating when the enemy bullets keep knocking you back. Also, the precision platforming that's required late into the game can be really annoying (mainly because whenever you jump, you can never really be sure how far you will go). Sorry if I'm being too harsh, I hope what I said was constructive! Maybe remake the game with a smaller scope and put a lot of polish into it, then it might be amazing! 😄 |
| Aug 14 01:17:50 | 12m 25s | Stuck! | ♥ 1 | This game is very frustrating... but in a good way! 😄 I love the presentation! Although I do wish there was more variation between the levels, and I also think the game is a bit too easy. But this game absolutely nails the feeling and makes me actually tense! Great job making this game! 😊 |
| Aug 14 04:46:15 | 3h 28m | Starship Panic | ♥ 1 | I really like the idea of the game! Unfortunately there are quite a few bugs. I was able to beat all the levels (indefinitely, because it seems like the game just loops) by standing still in the vent area. Also, the shooting feels a bit too unresponsive. But I did like how you introduced couches later in the game! I think it could use a bit of work, but all in all I like the idea! 🙂 (Hope I wasn't too critical.) |
| Aug 14 05:02:45 | 16m 30s | Zero G Hero | ♥ 3 | I beat the game! Boy was that one of the more difficult games I've played so far. I really love the art style and animation. I do wish it had a better "game feel" (although jumping while sliding did feel good), and maybe less annoying enemy AI. But overall I really liked it (otherwise I wouldn't have kept trying to beat it)! But why does the game have lives when you can just restart the game? Also the gamepad controls didn't really work for me (only the movement worked). |
| Aug 14 05:55:07 | 52m 22s | King of Bjorp | ♥ 1 | Really fun and well polished! I'm currently not able to play with others, but the AI was pretty good! |
| Aug 14 06:02:21 | 7m 14s | Grid Locked | ♥ 0 | A fun little game! Simple, but I really enjoyed it. Although I do wish the shapes of the characters were more interesting (the player model reminds me of the default shape in Unity). |
| Aug 14 06:11:14 | 8m 53s | The Consumer | ♥ 1 | One of the most interesting games I've ever played! The actual gameplay could use some polish, but it was still very entertaining! 😄 |
| Aug 14 06:44:37 | 33m 23s | Gel Break | ♥ 2 | This is the best puzzle game I've played so far (for this Ludum Dare)! I really love everything about it! It's a bit too difficult (I spent a long time trying to beat that one puzzle with 3 green blocks on one row and a square of 4 spaces), but maybe I'm just too tired 😅! Oh and I tried out typing "42".... it certainly was a thing 😐. By the way, make sure you play and rate other people's games so your game appears higher in the searches! (That's probably why I'm the first one to rate the game!) |
| Aug 14 21:28:05 | 14h 43m | Escape from Space | ♥ 1 | Really fun game, I love the aesthetic! But I do think the game is way too difficult. But overall I really like the game, and your choice of engine is really unique! 😄 |
| Aug 15 08:12:48 | 10h 44m | Pre Alpha Build | ♥ 2 | I really like the game, especially the concept! The graphics are nice, and I enjoy the sound! There are some things I wish you could add, like having a minimum ore/power generation so it doesn't become impossible to build things. And maybe make it so you can flip the buildings (mirror them)? But all and all, it's a really great game! 😃 (And I laughed when I pressed the help button and got "Nope".) |
| Aug 15 08:48:48 | 36m 00s | Unfamiliar | ♥ 2 | ... this game has practically left me speechless. I started to tear up towards the end, I seriously wish I could give this more than 5 stars. While there are a couple of minor grammatical errors ("George always fills *your* with your favorite treats..."), the game is pretty much perfect. My favorite game I've played so far. 😢 If I had to complain about something, I would say the story is predictable; but I think that just made the game even "better" (more tragic). |
| Aug 16 20:28:54 | 35h 40m | Spiritship | ♥ 1 | I definitely really like the vibe and art style.... but like you said it isn't finished 😔. I hope you continue to work on it anyways, even if the jam is over! |