Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Feedback comment stats → Tay

Tay

Feedback comments for LD41

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Tay's comment
Apr 24 12:54:47		Quickdraw	♥ 1	I really like the concept of it, I think the card mechanic would make a great game. I did end up filling my hand with a bunch of running fast cards and the enemies could have been a bit more challenging, not too clear if they need to hit you or when they shot near you you get damaged as well. With more diversity and time this could be a promising project :)
Apr 24 13:04:09	9m 22s	Cloak Wars	♥ 0	First of all, try putting the updated link on the game page above, I nearly missed it :) Fun little game, I found the "story" quite funny, also enjoyed that you took the time to put a cutscene in there. Mechanic wise, nothing too fancy but it was enjoyable. Also the music seemed to glitch a bit, sometimes when entering a room it would start even if there was always a track playing, or not start when none were playing. Anyway good work :)
Apr 24 13:13:20	9m 11s	Swap Swamp	♥ 1	Pretty cool game, definitely needs some getting use to. The idea and artstyle are great. Like herman pointed out, the bow is a bit too strong I believe.
Apr 24 13:30:59	17m 39s	Tempo Quest	♥ 0	Really nice game, the art is amazing. I felt combat was a bit dull, the actual attacking mechanic is awesome but I think I've got hit only once or twice, monsters just don't stand a chance. But the game does feel amazing. The dungeon black screen transition looked a bit weird to me(too drastic. One of my favorite yet :)
Apr 24 14:04:21	33m 22s	The Freedom Bus Tycoon Empire	♥ 1	Like safsom said, just changing the default background would go a long way. That aside, it's a quite enjoyable game. The tutorials definitely helped as without it would have been confusing at first so good job on that :)
Apr 24 14:16:37	12m 16s	Golf with Guns	♥ 2	Wow, I think this is my favorite entry so far, never knew I wanted a game like this before today. The execution could have been a bit better, the 2 last waves are way too hard compared to the ones before. But the main concept is really interesting. Would definitely buy a full version of this.
Apr 24 14:24:07	7m 30s	End of the day	♥ 4	I think this would make a good psychological horror game. xd Gameplay is super simple but there's something serving the next customer, then the next and the next... A bit more depth could be welcome though :)
Apr 24 14:34:45	10m 38s	BoomBall	♥ 1	Fun game to mess with. Sometimes I just can't shoot anymore, other times people just seem to get thrown everywhere. But all in all, it's fun :)
Apr 24 14:46:48	12m 03s	Harvest: The Farming - Red Owl Games	♥ 0	That's quite an interesting approach. I liked it a lot, but it felt quite luck based (I ended up discarding tons of herbicide/pesticide...) And the boost cards(other then working hard) felt a bit redundant as you pay x to get y bonus. But I think with a bit more work this could be quite interesting, like maybe with a whole farm rather then just 3 fields or something. Great work :)
Apr 24 15:00:18	13m 30s	Typical	♥ 3	Best entry I've seen so far. The audio is great, the game feels polished, the general idea is great. I would 100% play a full version of this, with more actions maybe items, etc... Really great work to all of you :)
Apr 24 17:21:42	2h 21m	Tofu Royale	♥ 0	What a funny little game. Good twist on the battle royale madness. Would have been nice for cooking to be a bit more present, but that aside it was quite good. Good work :)
Apr 24 17:34:28	12m 46s	LD41 - Pet Defense	♥ 2	Like Pure pointed out, the game is far too easy right now, way too much money and towers are way too strong, but that just needs some playtesting and tweaking. The art is pretty good and the TD part feels great.
Apr 24 17:43:51	9m 23s	Card Defence	♥ 1	I think the general idea is good. But there's some issues in the current version. I don't know if receiving only one card per wave is intended? I think getting more but make them weaker would make more interesting gameplay. Also at some point I just couldn't play anymore, I think some ui elements got overlapped or something and I just couldn't click on anything anymore.
Apr 24 18:08:16	24m 25s	Quest Sweeper	♥ 1	I had a similar idea at first, I think you manage to make a great game out of it :) the movement and all feels good and the fact that you added an actual goal rather then just pointing out the "mines". Good job ! :)
Apr 25 00:08:51	6h 00m	Trivia Kart!	♥ 1	Wow this is actually really fun, wonder why I never saw anything like it before. I wish there was a system to prevent same questions in a row, also the controls on the car could be a bit better/snappy. Good job overall :)
Apr 25 00:14:41	5m 50s	PROM	♥ 1	That's a pretty funny idea, and for a first game that's really good :)
Apr 25 00:21:09	6m 28s	Groovy Beat Shooter	♥ 0	That's a neat concept. Wasn't too sure if I was so much off beat or if the game had some delay or whatever. Guess I'm just really not that good at it. The art and soundtrack were pretty good :D
Apr 25 00:30:46	9m 37s	The Mad Tea Party - A Card and Run Game	♥ 3	Wow that's quite impressive, getting in so much in so little time. The graphics are nice and I really liked the voice over. Think it added a lot to the game. Good job, really good entry!
Apr 25 00:44:05	13m 19s	Jeff From Accounting	♥ 1	Wow, one of the best in my opinion. The visuals are stunning, gives me such a Bioshock vibe :O The typewriter gun is just too cool. Good job all around, awesome execution!
Apr 25 01:01:24	17m 19s	Gun Appetit!	♥ 0	The art and general feel of the game is awesome. My only complain is the ammo crafting, I had a hard time with, losing ingredients. But that aside, good job on this entry :D
Apr 27 01:38:35	48h 37m	Baseball Nightmare	♥ 1	The 3D models are really cool and the general idea/story is great. For a first jam this is definitely good :) I had some issues with the clicking(character shooting bur not rotating or just not shooting at all) and the difficuty seemed to ramp up pretty fast. But overall, great work!
Apr 27 02:00:13	21m 38s	Tetriphys: The Thing That Should Not Be	♥ 1	Fun little game, I feel like the space (shake) is a good idea and needs to be in the game, but it felt too strong. I just kept pressing it and eventually the blocks placed themselves. Maybe add like a cooldown or a limit so you can use it only in desperate times. :) Good work
Apr 27 03:44:10	1h 43m	Claustroom	♥ 1	This was a nice point of view on a traditional genre. The only issue I had with it is that I often ended up falling into holes but that's not that big of a deal. Really well executed idea. Good job :)
Apr 27 04:32:00	47m 50s	Puttsy	♥ 0	This is a really clever idea. Quite well executed too. I'd see a game like this in a big scale could be pretty good, with bigger maps with maybe 3-4 paths and an array of different towers to use. Good work :)
Apr 27 16:31:03	11h 59m	FAST CRASH	♥ 2	Fun little game. The visuals really stands out. I felt like the racing part could have been a bit faster, but overall it feels quite polished :)
Apr 27 16:55:37	24m 34s	Grantchester Meadows	♥ 2	Enjoyed this one quite a lot. I really liked the menu, grass and music. I think tower defense and clicker is quite a good mash-up. Would have been nice to be able to build our own towers, but that aside great submission :)
Apr 27 17:38:05	42m 28s	The Fat Man and the Sea	♥ 2	Funny little game, the art stands out from what I'm used to, I like it. Also enjoyed the fact that you added some backstory to it :)
Apr 27 17:51:47	13m 42s	Dainty Deprivation	♥ 2	I don't know if you're used to make racing games, but the controls felt really good. The models were nice and the music just complemented the game so well. Really good entry :)
Apr 27 18:04:02	12m 15s	Conquer a chef's heart	♥ 3	I like that you added both an attack and defense phase. It was a pretty interesting game even though it took a bit of time to get used to units/towers. The artstyle is nice, I feel like it gives an horror vibe to the game which is even funnier.
Apr 27 18:11:23	7m 21s	Car(d) Race	♥ 0	The game didn't work for me outside of fullscreen. The main idea is quite fun. With more card diversity I think it could be interesting, also cards should drop more often. Good work! :)
Apr 27 18:18:01	6m 38s	Might and Matchic	♥ 2	Pretty nice game, love the art and overall feel. Would have liked to see a bit more depth rpg wise maybe. Good work and solid entry !