Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD38 → Feedback comment stats → mar3k

mar3k

Feedback comments for LD38

mar3k's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		mar3k's comment
Apr 27 11:36:02		Echo Lands	♥ 1	Cool game, nice graphics/animations and sfx. I like how unique it is, but the combat is a bit too hard (getting the correct position to hit the enemies). Good job
May 3 10:23:47	142h 47m	Colonize	♥ 1	I like the game, I finished it and quite enjoyed it. But it felt a bit empty What I liked: - The art - That I could help the villagers with mining - The whole feel of the game (building a village) - Possibility to chat with villagers What could be better: - More resources - Make villagers more useful - I felt like there was no need for having more than 6 villagers - The ending was a bit plain Overall nice entry, simple but fun, really reminds me of games like Ikariam/Travian
May 3 10:33:49	10m 02s	Solitary Freedom	♥ 1	Nice game, the art is great (love the saturation that adds a lot to the whole feel of the game). Also the music/sounds were quite nice for compo entry. And having the start screen with loading text (story) and the music it has adds so much to the game. Oh also it is pretty hard to figure out the puzzles. Good job!
May 6 19:50:11	81h 16m	Micro Mayor	♥ 2	Cool idea. The game is fun and I like the music and the dialogue, but I had some problems. The UI started to mess up after few minutes (there were buttons stuck on the screen) and for some reasons all the the buildings disappeared after i clicked on the dialogue message (I suppose that the sell button was stuck there and was activated for all the building). But other than that it was nice.
May 6 20:00:02	9m 51s	A lone colony on a small planet	♥ 1	I love really small res pixel art/games so this one was just for me! You did really nice job with the graphics for what you had - mostly with the UI (it is not clustered). The game is a bit slow though (lots of waiting) also it would be nice if there was some kind of threat or something that would make you lose so you would have to play around it. Oh also tutorial would be really nice, cause it takes some time to figure the game out. Good job overall!
May 6 20:09:53	9m 51s	Protoware Planet	♥ 1	Really nice game, love that VR vibe and the effects (reminds me of Kung Fury or Hotline miami) - the game is bit short, but its fun and has nice sfx and music. So overall a really good job!
May 6 20:19:02	9m 09s	The Cookie Knight	♥ 0	Cool game, but pretty hard, would be nice if there were some kind of checkpoints or similar stuff. Also the character kind of slides on the material which makes it really hard to control. Good job though.
May 6 20:25:59	6m 57s	Brawll	♥ 1	I love the idea. It is really fun and would be probably be even more fun against a real player. Good job (also with the sfx and music)
May 6 20:33:47	7m 48s	Tribal Tension (Twitch)	♥ 0	Really cool game... The art is nice and the fact that it is played on twitch makes it even better. It seems to work really well and is fun to join in. And I even managed to win a battle with smaller army :D. Great job overall! Also I feel like they should really make category on Twitch just for games like this, cause it is fun to play.
May 6 20:41:56	8m 09s	Conquery - Conquer The World!	♥ 1	Simple graphics, but fun to play even though it is pretty hard. The sound effects and the music is nice and overall concept is promising and quite unique. I would say that you did a nice job here!
May 10 12:31:17	87h 49m	Calor	♥ 0	Overall just an amazing entry! The graphics are simple but nice, the music is ambient and not distracting and the combat is unique and fun. Also the tutorial is really well done and complex! Only flaw might be, that you made it a bit more complicated and Im worried that lot of people will just click quickly through the tutorial and will end up lost in the game! But from me a big thumb up! Great job! Oh and also, you commented on my game (thanks for that) and you said to tell you when I fix the bug it had - so I finally had some time and fixed it (sorry it took so long). Cheers
May 10 12:44:36	13m 19s	The Deific's Guide to Creating, Exploiting, and Destroying Pocket Worlds	♥ 1	I would like to start by saying that I really like the concept, the overall idea is pretty cool! The graphics were okay, there was not much of the of course so there is as well not much to say about it, but you did a good job with the book, I like that the tutorial was actually me reading a manual (and it included jokes, which is a big plus (from me at least)). The music was nice, it was fitting and wasn't distracting at all and the sound effects were a bit "funny", but I guess you aimed for that feel (judging because also from the text in the book). One thing I didn't really like, was speed of the game. It was a bit slow for me, but nothing too bad. So yeah, overall a nice entry! Good job! PS: You commented and rated my game (so thanks for that), but there was a bug and you said that you would like to see more of it, so if you want you can now, I fixed the bug. Cheers!
May 12 20:28:44	55h 44m	Tiny Planet	♥ 0	Im a fan of low poly art and you did pretty good job with yours. The overall graphics and animation feel was pretty nice. If there was some good ambient music it would have been even better. The concept is pretty good, but it would have been a better if you utilized more the planet rotation action, it felt like if the game was on 2D word there wouldn't be much more difference. But maybe that changed later in the game, but I stopped playing after some time cause I got 2 crashes and I didnt feel like replaying it all over again. There is the crash message - it happened after I selected both players and right clicked instead of left clicked https://i.gyazo.com/0f760cb8b71d15b102e0ef5f48c12fda.png Other than that the games looks nice and well thought through. Good job!
May 12 20:40:38	11m 54s	The Aliens	♥ 0	Cool game! First of all I would like to say, that I glad to see some more devs using Java and making their own engines as well and have to give you a big thumb up for the particle effects I really like those and know how hard it is to make a good ones. I quite like the game, it was simple but fun, the controls were a bit wonky and by that I mean the way the ship flew and also I found an exploit where I just was spamming the fire and never got hit, so maybe that could be fixed with making a longer cooldown on firing. Also one more thing I would like to point out is that it would be better if the enemies spawned right away after the 1st one died, cause there were a lot of time where nothing was happening and I was just waiting for the correct distance to get an enemy. But overall it is a nice entry...Oh also the music and sound effects were nice as well! Good job!
May 12 20:47:55	7m 17s	A lot of life in a small world	♥ 1	The concept is pretty nice and unique, but the execution would need some more work. Not just adding more animals, but also make it more interesting add some animations and like screen warning for stuff like when animal is going extinct or animation for when there is a tornado and probably something to keep the player going, not just seeing the animal count going up, but also getting new species in the process. I think if you would have more time and knowledge (as you said) this could have been a really solid entry! Good job though!
May 15 19:18:01	70h 30m	Expand	♥ 0	The game looks good from the pictures but you've forgotten to export an exe file so I cannot run it ;)
May 15 19:24:57	6m 56s	Talk Isn't Cheap	♥ 2	The music is just amazing and the UI as well. The overall concept is appealing to me, but there could be some stuff done differently, so it isnt always the same which is how it kinda feels right now, but still is cool. Would love to see more of this in some post compo version where is has more features. Great job!
May 15 19:33:27	8m 30s	Spider Royale	♥ 0	The concept is great, art and music as well, but the gameplay seems to lack something. Dont get me wrong it is cool and all, but gets boring after while also the controls are so damn hard I get something done most of the times only by luck. But great job anyway!
May 15 19:39:39	6m 12s	LD38: A Space Odyssey	♥ 0	Interesting idea, and nice music. Also with that name I was expecting it to be a parody on the book 2001, which would be cool as well :D
May 15 21:30:51	1h 51m	Natantes Paradisum	♥ 0	Really cool game. there were others quite similar, but this one was the best one I played so far. Nice graphics, cool features, like the soil. Yet still after some time it became a spam game for me, but that might be just because this is not really my type of game and I would need something really unique to keep me playing. But as I said, really good game! Great job
May 15 21:33:37	2m 46s	Crates	♥ 0	Nothing too unique, but solid entry.
May 15 21:59:18	25m 41s	A world too small and no jetpack	♥ 2	Love the graphics and the idea. But the game seems to be bit hard for me
May 15 22:09:36	10m 18s	A Lighthouse Story	♥ 1	Great graphics and effects, unique gameplay and game overall. Was bit short and there ofc wasnt much to play or do badly in here, so maybe it would be cool if there was maybe more decisions and therefore different endings. Good job and thumb up for going a different path!
May 15 22:14:22	4m 46s	Aircraft Carrier Simulator	♥ 0	Good models, physics and idea/concept. But wasnt really my type of game...not much happening and in the end I ended up just sabotaging it all and pushing other jets of the board :D But it is a good entry! Nice job
May 15 22:26:21	11m 59s	Until Tomorrow	♥ 1	This was so cool, love the story, the graphics (and the way there was the minimap and also the full map), nice ambient music, there were also some jokes and really cool twist at the end! Good job!
May 15 22:32:44	6m 23s	Flerth	♥ 2	This is such a cool idea! The graphics are nice, the music and sfx as well, and just smashing the people by itself is so satisfying
May 15 22:41:28	8m 44s	Feather Fighter	♥ 1	When I first opened it my first words were "this looks so cool" and it surly does even in the game - I love those graphics and animations, so well done. The idea is quite simple but cool and fun and finished, it's a bit hard to kill the birds, mainly because of the controls, so maybe if there was shooting with mouse it would be better, but then it maybe would be too easy. Great job overall!
May 15 22:46:27	4m 59s	coollapse	♥ 1	Really simple game but felt oddly relaxing.
May 16 11:33:08	12h 46m	vijver	♥ 1	As it was said here before, not sure if this could be called a game, but it is nice relaxing interactive project, that is for sure. Maybe one thing that would make this more relaxing would be some nice ambient music.
May 16 11:41:52	8m 44s	BUTERATOS	♥ 2	This game is all about the aesthetics I would say, the art is amazing (love the comic at the start) and the music as well, but the gameplay is the weaker side of the game. It is the usual shooter game with nothing too unique (you should add something more unique to it if you want to make it a full game I think) and also there were some bugs, like enemies shooting after being dead or animations not being executed properly. But otherwise it is a really nice game and as I said the art and music are so well done, same as the world design. Good job guys
May 16 11:45:57	4m 05s	Taste the rainbow	♥ 0	Nice game, was bit short and not hard to win, but I didnt get bored after first 2 minutes which is always good.
May 16 11:52:08	6m 11s	Ship in a Bottle	♥ 1	I like that you took a new path and tried to make something unique, which this was, but didnt feel too much like a game, which I supposed it shouldnt(?). I also like the way you tried to make it feel "artsy" which it was - the background and the piano music - but it was kind of broken by the 3D models made the way they were, it would have been lot better for the rain to be drawn and the fishes, fisherman and bottle as well. Also the ending screen was bit odd (seemed like you were only trying if you could make that cube rotate - didnt see a reason for it to be there) Well anyhow nice job and thumb up for taking a new approach.
May 16 11:58:14	6m 06s	RocketFlee	♥ 1	Nice music and cool idea, good job.
May 16 14:50:08	2h 51m	Asteroid Hopper	♥ 1	Really cool game, played it till the end and had fun. Nice graphics and audio and in fact I also liked that the levels weren't that difficult. Great job!