tentativedibs 2014-04-28 03:33
Fantastic
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD29 → Giant Pumpkin
By musket
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graphics | 17 | 4.46 | ||
| Theme | 52 | 3.97 | ||
| Overall | 56 | 3.92 | ||
| Innovation | 68 | 4.00 | ||
| Mood | 123 | 3.70 | ||
| Fun | 143 | 3.61 | ||
| Audio | 237 | 3.30 | ||
| Humor | 320 | 2.83 | ||
| Coolness | 1460 | 46 |
Fantastic
Good art - I loved that you were able to make a resource management game in such an unconventional way!
Great style, a little confusing with the controls though, since if you hold down the mouse button it'll just autoclick anything underneath.
DAMN, this game is fun! And addicting... The graphics are awesome too! The right balance between complexity and simplicity! I love it!
A five ton pumpkin is pretty absurd, and I could probably do a lot better now that I know how it all works. The art is really pro.
I love this one. This made my day. ^^ Very good one.
Truthfully not my kind of game but I can see the game there for people who enjoy these things! Great art style / polish. Found the fact that your leaves would randomly face downwards to be a little annoying, not sure if there's something I was missing there.
Whoa! A two-and-a-half ton pumpkin, and that was only my first try. Nice graphics, great use of the theme, unique concept.
Wow, one of the first games I genuinely had fun with! Great job and an awesome take on the theme.
Very cool. The whole game looks great, and the novel content is awesome. Reminds me of "Reach for the Sun." I got hit by the energy negative feedback loop - the weeds and bugs had blocked enough of my leaves that it was hard to get enough energy to pay for the pesticides and weed killer. I also noticed that weed killer occasionally has a bug where it spends the resources but doesn't remove the weeds.
I'm terrible at these types of games, but I had some fun with this :). Interesting idea. Very nice graphics and animation too!
Very cool art and gameplay, congrats!
The weed cutter didn't work, so all my leaves got covered in darkness. :(
Really nice game though! I especially like the resource balancing, great job on that. Very up-lifting graphics and sounds as well.
This is lovely. Nice work!
Clever take on the theme, and gorgeous art. Very nice job, it was fun to play and watch that pumpkin grow, even though I felt so many different ressources were unnecessary
Really ace game! Fun creative premise
Love the art! A little more instruction would be nice. Took a little bit to figure out what everything does. Played 5 games so far, still haven't able to grow the pumpkin around the rock :( Really enjoyed it!
I spent so much time in this game! The best so far, very polish (a bit unbalanced, but nothing critical). Love it.
Great idea!
Played it til I won. Great game! I really like the art.
aww lovely style. I adore illustrations of the ground in section, and you're using it very well. Also, I love the five ton pumpkins! Kudos!
I'm a terrible, terrible farmer :(
Would be a good mobile game!
This game is difficult for me to score well, since there's a lot of different aspects to it to consider. Simply as a game, the difficulty of recovering from certain feedback loops--like if none of your leaves function and you have no store of sunlight to grow more--is frustrating, particularly because the player can tell that they've finished playing, with no ability to "retire" the game at that point. At the same time, as an educational tool, this is really neat. The graphics are glossy and clean, and all of the SFX are textbook.
The other thing is that, looking at the point of view, the player is simultaneously portraying farmer and pumpkin. I think I would have preferred a pumpkin trying to get large for different reasons--to become the pumpking?--and purchasing various evolutionary effects to aid its own advancement would be more interesting. For example, plants evolved caffeine content as a natural insecticide, so you could do something like that. This would also differentiate your game a little bit thematically--I don't mean relative to the LD theme, just in general.
A couple of bugs, too, with the weed killer not functioning, and I've never been able to buy resources like water or nitrogen and have them actually show up in my stores.
Finally, the past few times I've played, I didn't actually notice the buttons in the top right corner allowed you to scroll up and down. I just saw your twitter key and my eyes glazed over, thinking it was yet another one of those "share on social media!!" button panels. Doing something to set these keys apart visually would help a lot with that.
Still, this is a very polished, well-constructed game! Thank you.
very nice style and idea! great game
Made a 71 tonne pumpkin lol How did they manage to get a badge on it? Well done on the top ranking.
Great graphics, but the "weed killer bug" is awful :(