jami 2013-04-29 21:17
"The sprites show some black glitches resulting from the sprite filters, I did not have time to remove these." Dude, you made 8 games in 48 hours, I can deal with some glitches :) Nice work!
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD26 → Minigames Octacade
By bvanschooten
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 2 | 98 | ||
| Fun | 323 | 3.24 | ||
| Overall | 406 | 3.31 | ||
| Humor | 465 | 2.36 | ||
| Mood | 639 | 2.79 | ||
| Graphics | 751 | 2.77 | ||
| Audio | 877 | 2.14 | ||
| Innovation | 951 | 2.57 | ||
| Theme | 1022 | 3.00 |
"The sprites show some black glitches resulting from the sprite filters, I did not have time to remove these." Dude, you made 8 games in 48 hours, I can deal with some glitches :) Nice work!
Wow, *EIGHT* games in one? How did you manage that? I enjoyed the Manic Miner Clone. But you nailed Axis Invaders, this one is great. I had a good time playing it :).
Very good job !
Wow, 8 games. Great job!
This game is nicely done, but that would have been really better if there was a pause at the beginning of the game. I mean, it's impossible to understand the rules of the runner game in less than a half-second.
Nice game. Great job making 8 in 1. Must have been a challenge.
No way! Minimalism too easy for ya? Times it by 8!
Fun minigames. Would have liked a "restart this minigame" function instead of constantly going back to the mainscreen. But fun!
Quit fun … congrat
Quite Fun ! Congratulation
Ambitious.
Excellent collection, and a testament to what can be done in 48 hours, which is absolutely mind-blowing, as some of these games aren't that obvious to recreate in such a short period!
My only complaint is that the controls could use some tightening on certain of the games; especially bearing in mind that some of those games want you on your feet quickly.
Also, it would be very nice to be able to restart a game from inside the very game, and not through the main menu.
As a side note, something like food for thought: any of the games on its own fits the theme perfectly. But can a collection of 8 minimalistic games be considered minimalistic as well? ;)
Congratulations! :)
Interesting concept, but those colors!
I so missed the music in digger ;).
Wow, 8 finished games in 48 hours, congratulations! Most of them are old-school hard, I like it.
Wow, and I had problems finishing one game. Awesome stuff! That's a lot of different mechanics to finish in such a short time. I like the psychedelic graphics, and the sound fits nicely. I had the by far the most fun playing Leaping Larry. My least favorite might be Axis Invaders simply because I suck at it. I really wish there was a restart button though. Great job creating all of these.
Hi all! Thanks for your comments! I now have a postcompo version with a restart game button, and without the black sprite glitches and other minor tweaks.
GG :D
You made 8 games? Bravo. That's a positive side. Now let's mention negative sides:
* Poor graphics. The game seems tailored for many pieces of different color and material. Character sprites, tile sprites and background sprites don't match at all. On top of that, scaled sprites look blurry, which is bad, and they are even, erm... let's say "bugged with black", even in the post-compo.
* Poor controls. Especially in Dragonflight and Cave destroyer, but in others too. Keys work not intuitive when you press several at a time (In Leaping Larry you often can't climb ladders holding right or left; In Icebreaker you often don't stop moving in some direction (or can't push a block) if you hold another key). In Digger placing/removing dirt is unintuitive.
* BUGS. In Toad Trek (not post-compo) I reached the end, got over the upper edge of the screen, and didn't get anything. In Digger, enemies and stones someimes count tile you stand on empty, even if you are placing dirt at the moment.
Oh, and you actually use "R" as back and "Z" as reset? You might want to swap them, I am used to reset with "R". And add a "back" key.
The only game I fully liked is Axis Invaders, though it still had many graphic glitches. Next time consider making one game, but doing it properly.
Excellent! Perfect for my short attention span. I enjoyed being taken back to the golden days for some of these, though "axis invaders" is a new idea to me and deserves more exploration! Really good entry.
Among the 8 minigames I like Axis Invaders... I enjoyed that shooting game.
The graphics doesn't match with each other... But good job making the 8 games in 48 hours... It was a good game :D
@madball, "Next time consider making one game, but doing it properly."
This comment doesn't seem in the LD spirit at all. Are you angry with me for creating these games? Don't you remember that once upon a time you yourself created 6 minigames as an LD entry?
I'm not angry at all. After all, it's your decision and your games. But I prefer playing one good game, not eight average. And I think that your ideas are better than games.
Oh, and about my entry for the MiniLD #32, it was the theme.
(Now I think I really make lots of games. Well, if you think I should also make less games, just tell me.)
Hi Madball, good to get a conversation going. Of course, this is just an experiment. The idea of minigames, the graphics, etc. I don't really plan to make minigames next LD, even if just because you don't seem to get specific critiques. What I do like about your critique is that it's actually the most detailed. So let's talk about that.
General: The games have flaws, like every LD entry, but I believe they are not gameplay breaking. I still enjoyed playing most of them myself after I submitted them, my favourite being Roof Escape. I am intrigued by simple games, because my experience is that, in the wild, people often like my simpler games (as simple and even as rough as these minigames) better than my more complex ones. Also, you have to be extremely efficient to get around in the game industry. Unfortunately there are only few people in LD submitting minigames overall, and I'd have liked to play your entry too if the file wasn't removed.
Dragonflight: the controls are essential to the game (Joust).
Larry: I copied the controls from the original (Fast Eddie). I do want to improve them because I like this game.
Icebreaker: press Z, then a direction, to push a block reliably.
Toad: thanks for finding that bug, it was a typo.
Digger: yes, this game is a little quirky. It's also possible to spawn stones if you stack them the right way.
R and Z keys: I used the R key for restart at first, but I really hated moving my finger off the Z key every time, so I changed it to Z.
Graphics: I think they are far more pleasing than having programmer-drawn graphics like most LD entries including my own (I am not a graphics artist). I know some people like these colour schemes. The black edges look ragged because Java2D does not support alpha blending. The sprites have been scaled using a "stained glass" distortion filter to make them look more organic.
That's surely a long answer... Thank you for taking your time.
Wow, all these are quite fun, with the odd original twist on some classics. I had a play with the sprite generator too - very nice and good fun in itself. It seemed like the sprites in these minigames don't look as crisp (some antialiasing ?) compared with what the generator produces - I think it would look better if they maintained their clean pixelated look.
Wow, very ambitious and quite an impressive feat of timing. I'm sure you had a lot of fun this LD, hehe. (: Axis especially showed off a talent for making fun simple games.
While not really original, it was still a fun ride.
A bit shoddy, but the variety of retro games is nice.
graphics were great -- nice concept -- my favorite was roof race -- great job