Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD55 → Feedback comment stats → ValentinWB
Feedback comments for LD55
ValentinWB's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | ValentinWB's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 16 13:08:49 | Summoner's Tower | ♥ 1 | The game might need some balancing adjustments, for example it is kind of frustrating when killed enemies do not drop ingredients, but the gameplay idea is very clever and leaves room for upgrades ! also very cute artstyle ๐. Congrats ! | |
| Apr 16 13:26:37 | 17m 48s | Sorcerer's Army of Summons | ♥ 2 | the grid movement is a nice twist on the formula ! Nice work on the models too, nice game ! |
| Apr 16 13:52:09 | 25m 32s | Monster Monastery | ♥ 3 | I am impressed by the amount of options the game gives you, as a counterpart players may need a tutorial or hints on what to do. Very good job on the assets too, the game has a clear identity, good job ! |
| Apr 16 14:02:01 | 9m 52s | The Demon Cube | ♥ 2 | Nice execution of the genre ! The game would benefits from some sfx for sure, or maybe go all in on the juice effects ๐ Anyway the core mechanics are there and it works pretty well so good job guys ! |
| Apr 16 14:15:44 | 13m 43s | Bean and Brew | ♥ 4 | Woaah it is gonna be hard to top this, the graphics are crazy good, mechanics are really fun (especially spamming frog and causing a mess haha) and you event went in with the mario bros reference. Goated game in my book ๐ |
| Apr 16 14:33:03 | 17m 19s | Leprechaun's Gold | ♥ 5 | The core mechanic is very funny, some adjustments for difficulty could be to shorten the inputs to summon, allowing longer levels. Nice game ! |
| Apr 16 14:52:10 | 19m 07s | Clone fest | ♥ 7 | Alright so I think you nailed the summon part screen.png |
| Apr 16 15:07:35 | 15m 25s | The Ball and the Island | ♥ 1 | I felt like some slopes were harsh to climb and it impacted a bit the pace of the game, on the other hand the momentum jumps felt very good ! and I got all of the strawberries ๐ Very cute game ! |
| Apr 16 15:33:58 | 26m 23s | Zodiac Legends | ♥ 0 | Great mechanics with plenty of room for upgrades ! Good job ! |
| Apr 16 22:46:56 | 7h 12m | The Acolyte's Handbook | ♥ 1 | First of all good job on the overall mood of the game, the sound effects are spot on. About the handbook mechanic I think it could be cool to have it as an overlay or at least placing it on the screen in a way that does not prevent the player from interacting with the game view. Congrats anyway and good luck for your project ! |
| Apr 16 22:55:53 | 8m 57s | Peter Piper in A Rats Tale | ♥ 1 | Your game settles a very good atmosphere ! the music and graphics were very suiting and I really like the character running animation ๐ Congrats on your entry ! |
| Apr 17 11:52:27 | 12h 56m | Siela | ♥ 3 | Congrats on the atmosphere and visual effects, one of the best I have seen in this jam. |
| Apr 17 12:20:45 | 28m 18s | Split-Decision | ♥ 3 | Ok it took me a little time to get the mechanic but it ends up working very well ! Congrats on the graphics, the palette, UI and in game visuals are very clean ! |
| Apr 17 12:45:35 | 24m 50s | Summing Circle | ♥ 2 | Oh that is a nice one ! I find it impressive you came up with such a simple yet clever idea for a puzzle game, well done ! |
| Apr 17 13:05:16 | 19m 41s | The Children of the Hand | ♥ 2 | The core concept of the game is very interesting and I think it appeals for more polish ! For example allowing the user to end the buying phase quicker. Also I found it a little hard sometimes to summon my monsters for some reason, maybe it comes from that damn webgl. Anyway impressive job on the monster design, congrats for your entry ! |
| Apr 18 12:53:34 | 23h 48m | Rain Summon | ♥ 2 | Loved the visuals, and it looks like you have got a great gamecore for a future 2d game now. Good job ๐ |
| Apr 18 13:07:35 | 14m 01s | Heroes of Keys & Kingdoms | ♥ 1 | Woah that's an interesting idea, I could really see this type of game using a daily challenge mechanic like you have in some words games nowadays. Awesome job guys ! |
| Apr 18 13:51:23 | 43m 48s | Where Have All the Globbletops Gone? | ♥ 3 | I was not hooked at first because it took me some time to understand where the game was going but oh man do I not regret putting the extra effort. Beyond all the graphics, sfx, music, monster design, incredible mood and everything, this game also has some great natural pace to it which I am sure required some work as well. Hats off, you got me inspired ! |
| Apr 19 19:06:59 | 29h 15m | The sumoner | ♥ 1 | Allowing the player to summon slimes is a cool twist to the formula. I just have one suggestion for the pacing though, 5 minutes might be a bit too long for the few mechanics available, so either shorten the win time or add some new ways to diversify the gameplay, but I am aware that this is hard to do in the time span of a jam. Very nicely done though, congrats on your game ! |
| Apr 22 11:56:32 | 64h 49m | Globeba | ♥ 0 | I am amazed by the amount of content you guys were able to pull out in the span of a short jam, also I am wondering how do you guys manage to keep a clear objective with such a big team ! I have always thought going in jam with too many people was far from easy management wise. Anyway congrats to you guys you have made an amazing job ! |
| Apr 22 19:39:42 | 7h 43m | If Only | ♥ 1 | These are some really tricky puzzles right there my brain is overheating ! I like the twist you brought to the box moving puzzle genre, coupled with some nice soft graphics ! Well done ! |
| Apr 22 20:03:09 | 23m 27s | Pictomancer | ♥ 2 | All nice and cute ! I remember you guys from the chicken game which was already a classic, please keep on the good work this is brilliant ๐ ! |
| Apr 22 20:59:31 | 56m 22s | One Hell of a Maid | ♥ 1 | Cute game, gave me a good laugh ! Good job ๐ |
| Apr 22 21:49:38 | 50m 07s | Summoner Symbols | ♥ 1 | Played the game with friends (as I am too dumb to solve the riddles alone), we were all amazed ! Also nice conclusion letting young folks know you can get what you desire by summoning the devil ๐ |
| Apr 22 22:11:44 | 22m 06s | Path of Aratron | ♥ 1 | Interesting idea ! My brain went overheating a little but now I think I can do programmation |
| Apr 22 22:22:09 | 10m 25s | Manku the Magician | ♥ 5 | Had a good laugh ! I love how accurate the chat is, even though it kinda hurts. Well done guys ! |
| Apr 22 22:29:39 | 7m 30s | Butler! Summon the Imps! | ♥ 2 | Nice twist on the puzzle bubble type ! really like those tiny mechanics that you've added as well as the polishing work which is impressive ! Congrats ! |
| Apr 22 22:38:49 | 9m 10s | Salmoning | ♥ 5 | I am amazed by all the little features you were able to add in your game, although some of them feel like they could have been replaced by some gameplay elements ๐ but I get the idea of making a hyper polished game and it honestly does the job, congrats ! |
| Apr 23 08:20:46 | 9h 41m | Dark Roast Cafรจ | ♥ 1 | Very solid entry ! Only thing I was a little confused about was the table thing at start. I guess putting one table by default could do the trick. Anyway I am convinced there would be a lot of potential if you were to make a more complete version with better upgrades etc. the core mechanics are already very cool ! Congrats ! |
| Apr 23 08:37:46 | 17m 00s | IWANT | ♥ 1 | Thats a cool and interesting gameplay ! I like when jam games take an overused genre and add some twist to it ! There is definitely some room for improvement here but the current result is already quite nice and polished, congrats ! |
| Apr 23 10:13:16 | 1h 35m | wiz | ♥ 1 | Wooaah wave 18 kicked my ass ! The gameplay is very clever and the overall game feels very juicy ! Very nice job ! |
| Apr 23 10:30:46 | 17m 30s | SUMMONING | ♥ 1 | Nice and juicy ! |
| Apr 24 08:55:09 | 22h 24m | Pandaemonium | ♥ 0 | It's a solid idea, I think just some more gameplay variants and a tiny bit of polish would improve the game so much, but hey it is a game jam after all so that's already very good in such a short time span. Congrats guys ! |
| Apr 24 09:05:45 | 10m 36s | The Witch's Dungeon | ♥ 1 | So I see that most comments already adressed the tiny issues with the game, on the other hand I think you really found a banger idea right there ! definitely some room for improvement but there is a lot of potential if you are willing to keep on working on the game. Well done guys ! |
| Apr 24 09:14:09 | 8m 24s | Orcs vs Skeletons | ♥ 1 | Ok so after playing it for a little while I kinda found tricks for the shape detection to work a little better, now I guess what could be done with a little more time is balancing enemies and spell cooldowns or something. Anyway it is a really creative idea and you were able to put it together in a shorter amount of time so.. Good job ! |
| Apr 24 09:35:12 | 21m 03s | The Summoner's Apprentice | ♥ 2 | Most of the downs of the game have already been written here, but I would still say that adding a step by step tutorial for the first summon could be a good thing so that players are not confused as soon as the game starts, there are a lot of elements to play with and in a specific order, so it is easy to fail your summon without understanding why. Nevertheless I think the core mechanic is very cool, I am sure you will get better at implementing ideas with time and learning of the new engine. Congrats for your game ! |
| Apr 24 09:48:02 | 12m 50s | The Curse of Lake Pineview (Gameboy Color) | ♥ 1 | I love the combat mechanic ! It has room for variation and little twists but the core is already very pleasant to play with. I am hyped for the rest of the game now ๐ Very well done ! |
| Apr 24 09:54:46 | 6m 44s | Cultists Feast | ♥ 1 | Very good job considering the shortened time span ! Not much more to say, it is a solid 12 hours jam game ๐ |
| Apr 24 09:59:46 | 5m 00s | Meteor Portal Siege | ♥ 1 | The knights sound effects are PERFECT ๐ ! Its a cool arcade mechanic, only the portal orientation is not very clear at the beginning but you eventually get the hang of it. Good job on your game ! |
| Apr 24 10:08:56 | 9m 10s | Damn! Jury Summons?! | ♥ 1 | Nice and simple gameplay but still has some interesting little mechanics. A very good idea for a jam game overall ! Congrats ! |
| Apr 24 10:14:32 | 5m 36s | Bony Barricade | ♥ 0 | Cool twist on the tower defense genre ! For now the game does not have many mechanics there is room for improvement so thats promising ! Good job ! |
