Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD50 → Feedback comment stats → Shrillwhip
Feedback comments for LD50
Shrillwhip's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Shrillwhip's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 11 18:15:15 | Earworm Jam | ♥ 3 | Jeez, this looks really good. Not just "game jam" good, but just good, period. I'm a sucker for rhythm games so the gameplay loop really appealed to me as well. Maybe I just have no rhythm though, but I felt like the timing window of the key presses was too narrow. Maybe that part could be tweaked a bit to not be as strict. Btw, that song is brilliant. | |
| Apr 11 18:49:22 | 34m 07s | Mythic Garden | ♥ 4 | Man, people are getting really good at 3D art. Amazing presentation, this genuinely looks like a studio made 3DS game or something. And the gameplaye genuinely had me hooked for a bit. Cute music too, overall I enjoyed this quite a lot! |
| Apr 11 19:04:12 | 14m 50s | Will There Bee Another? | ♥ 0 | This was a cute and charming game, I really enjoyed it. The writing was good, it felt oddly realistic somehow. The art is really pretty too. The only complaint I have (which is a large one) is that it's way too minimalistic. I would really like to see you make something bigger and more ambitious, since there is clearly a lot of talent at display here that I feel isn't being fully utilized. |
| Apr 11 19:12:41 | 8m 29s | B-Game | ♥ 1 | Really nice graphics! And fun gameplay concept, I just felt the game wasn't very clear at communicating the objective. It took some stumbling around until I figured it out. |
| Apr 11 19:19:25 | 6m 44s | We Need To Talk | ♥ 2 | Not gonna lie this really made me smile. Art and presentation was really good (although the artstyle looks a bit.. inspired ;) ). Super cute character designs and effective animations. The gameplay concept is very fun and simple, it was genuinely fun to play! |
| Apr 11 19:27:06 | 7m 41s | Pizza Gal | ♥ 1 | Yo the pizza girl is mad cute, the artwork is just great in general. The concept is interesting too, I feel like it would have been more engaging if it started out a bit faster. |
| Apr 11 19:35:56 | 8m 50s | RIG WRECKENING | ♥ 3 | Man, I really dig low poly artstyles like these. The presentation is fantastic. The character feels good to control, although the camera can be a bit janky and the level design and objective isn't the most intuitive. But these things are just a matter of polish which you don't get to do a lot of during a jam. This is a really high quality entry overall. |
| Apr 11 19:46:31 | 10m 35s | Mr. Final Boss | ♥ 2 | Jeez louise, this is on an insane level of quality for a game jam. Mind-bogglingly good graphics, awesome artstyle, fun and engaging gameplay and sick music. I really have no complaints, I wish you make a full game in the future. |
| Apr 11 19:50:17 | 3m 46s | Venting Machine | ♥ 1 | I love your art and character designs. This was a cute take on the homerun contest type genre of games, but nothing you really haven't seen before. Still, the gameplay is fun and the art and characters are enough to keep my interest. |
| Apr 11 20:01:48 | 11m 31s | That Toilet... Feels so good. | ♥ 1 | Cute game, I enjoyed the artstyle and the cozy gameplay. The sound design is a bit jarring; the loud sounds take you out of an otherwise comfy experience. |
| Apr 11 20:05:36 | 3m 48s | Wizard Hunt | ♥ 1 | Cool game, I liked the character designs and spritework. The gameplay is quite fun and engaging, even though it isn't something you haven't seen before. |
| Apr 11 20:27:50 | 22m 14s | Did I Just Poop Myself by the Produce Section | ♥ 1 | I absolutely adored the artstyle in this. The Undertale-style gameplay gets a bit repetitive after a while, would have liked to see some more variety in the attack patterns. |
| Apr 11 20:34:40 | 6m 50s | Somnipathy | ♥ 4 | Nice game! The graphics are obviously really well done (that title screen is mind-bogglingly pretty). The gameplay feels a bit unfocused, and gets repetitive after a while. Still, I like the concept of a point and click game where you are being chased, it could just benefit from a bit more polish with regards to the gameplay. |
| Apr 16 18:03:59 | 117h 29m | Catocalypse | ♥ 3 | Really nice and cute art, I especially like the design of the main character. Presentation is very good, however I feel that the game could be more clear on how you're supposed to play it. Is the player supposed to memorize the stuff in the tutorial, or am I missing something? Because in that case I feel like it would make for a more intuitive experience to show that information via gameplay (maybe by cut and pasting the pictograms in the tutorial screen into the game, e.g. as posters on the wall so you can always see them). Also the music is cool and well made, but doesn't really fit the mood and aesthetic of the game. Overall though, a really well made and well put together game, and a fun but simple concept. I just wish it was a bit more intuitive to play. |
| Apr 16 18:40:43 | 36m 44s | Super Mowser Bros | ♥ 2 | Fantastic presentation, the graphics are absolutely stellar. I like how you went for the artstyle of modern Paper Mario games while combining it with a grittier more comical take on the character designs. Maybe it's just me, but gameplay is a bit confusing and I wish that it was a bit clearer how to play the game. I'm not a huge fan of lengthy tutorials at the beginning of the game, I'd much rather the game show me that stuff via gameplay. But obviously that's harder to do when you're constrained for time in a game jam. Really innovative and interesting concept, however. |
| Apr 16 19:02:06 | 21m 23s | Hymenoptera King | ♥ 1 | This is such a cool game. The presentation is awesome, I really dig the low poly aesthetic. Music fit the mood but was a bit repetitive. Taking a hold of a hornet and flying around the stage made for a genuinely fun experience. |
| Apr 16 19:08:36 | 6m 30s | Stay Afloat | ♥ 0 | This looks great, really love the aesthetic. The Crash Bandicoot style 2D platforming is fun, not a lot of variety but that's expected for a jam like this. Good job! |
| Apr 16 19:15:09 | 6m 33s | Bomb Digging | ♥ 2 | Fun little game with cute graphics! I wish you could detonate the bomb directly instead of waiting for it to detonate, so you don't have to wait every time. And the sound effects were nice, but a tad bit loud. Other than that, solid entry. Good job!! |
| Apr 16 19:32:42 | 17m 33s | Ydunian Prune | ♥ 1 | Amazing game, my favorite gam so far this jam. The gameplay loop is well thought out and engaging, the graphics are fantastic and the music is extremely pleasant to listen to. Overall it was a very comfy, soothing gameplay experience. My only criticism is that the battle happened in a flash, and I lost all my progress instantly. It didn't seem like I even had time to do anything. Btw, thanks for playing our game on your stream, I really enjoyed your voice acting! :D |
| Apr 16 20:25:03 | 52m 21s | Slime Showdown | ♥ 3 | This was seriously fun! Engaging, enjoyable gameplay and nice art. Good work! |
| Apr 16 20:41:27 | 16m 24s | Giraffe o'Clock | ♥ 1 | Really well put together game. The gameplay is fun and the level design is solid. Dialogue... is not great. It's too long, self-referential and relies too much on breaking the 4th wall. The humor does not feel very organic. The rest of the game is great though, the DDR minigame was such a cool surprise. The art and music are good as well. Good job! |
| Apr 18 13:19:54 | 40h 38m | Live For Later Or Live For Now | ♥ 1 | Cool! I love stuff like this. Very immersive, surreal experience. I just wish there was more variety, especially since the assets were so minimalistic and simple. Either way, it was an interesting and unique game. Good job! |
| Apr 18 13:51:54 | 32m 00s | Penguin Rituals | ♥ 0 | I loved this! One of my favorite entries this jam. The characters are charming both in terms of design and writing, and the gameplay was engaging and interesting (the overworld exploration reminded me a bit of Yume Nikki). The orb sections were challenging, but not unfair. The music really set the mood, the game has this melancholy vibe which contrast really well with the cute characters. Overall, great unique entry. Please keep making games! |
| Apr 18 14:00:08 | 8m 14s | Tide of Rot | ♥ 1 | Very fun game! It reminded me of the flying levels in Cuphead. |
| Apr 18 17:16:20 | 3h 16m | The Death Delayer | ♥ 1 | I love the character designs and animation in this. The gameplay is quite fun as well. However the music doesn't really fit the atmosphere in my opinion. Overall, solid game! Good job on this one. |
| Apr 18 17:21:19 | 4m 59s | Door Man | ♥ 1 | This feels really polished. The music and sound design is very nice. The character feels nice to control, the puzzle design is good, and the graphics are solid. My only criticism is that the game is a bit short. Good job! |