Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD50 → Feedback comment stats → Andy Beers
Feedback comments for LD50
Andy Beers's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Andy Beers's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 4 15:11:06 | Gaia | ♥ 1 | Theme is great. I wish I would've understood a bit more about how fast my powers would go away before they needed to cooldown, definitely more of an 'experience' than a game which I think is pretty cool, love to see the different projects people can create. I'm personally not a fan of the humor but I imagine it'll be a hit for many others. Well done to get what looks to be a pretty polished game given the time constraints! | |
| Apr 4 15:19:08 | 8m 02s | Way before death | ♥ 2 | Graphics and music are really fun, Theres a typo in the controls where it says WA and it should be WS. The game feels too difficult, I got past the second level but the 3rd feels impossible to me which is a bit frustrating because it's fun to play and i'd love to see the other levels. Movement is slightly weird to me, i think it might be easier with a typical WASD movement with ignoring the rotating/aiming, just my 2 cents. Great job! it is really fun! |
| Apr 4 15:25:53 | 6m 45s | Quackenfarm | ♥ 1 | Awesome game, I love the duck! Art is really cool music makes me happy, the font is over the top and makes it hard to read certain things. It seems like a super interesting concept with lots of different strategies, really loved this one. Great job! |
| Apr 4 15:32:44 | 6m 51s | Life will never end | ♥ 0 | lifewillneverend.JPG Cool simulation, not really sure what I'm supposed to be doing other than watching it, but watching it is pretty fun, would be cool to add different colors for each life if that even makes sense, could be trippy and cool :) |
| Apr 4 15:36:03 | 3m 19s | Save Gogo | ♥ 3 | Very interesting concept but feels like a mobile app type of thing where I have to set reminders to keep feeding him! sounds like work :( I do really love the concept and I think something like this could easily go viral. Best of luck with it and keep making stuff! Awesome job |
| Apr 4 15:39:28 | 3m 25s | Drater | ♥ 1 | Unfortunately I'm having issues running the game, My machine refuses to open the game as it is very confident it's a virus. let me know if this gets fixed, based on the art, I'd love to try it! |
| Apr 4 15:56:04 | 16m 36s | Pooh-Pooh | ♥ 2 | Funny idea, the music is catchy, I wish there was some scoring system so I knew what my 'best' was, I guess it's number of screens? Anyway very cool for the theme! |
| Apr 4 16:02:36 | 6m 32s | Stupidly Inevitable | ♥ 0 | Very difficult but signs of real progress. Great work for only working in Unity for a few weeks and keep it up. Animations are really cool and the Health bar work is great too. Stay ambitious and at the same time try to scope out a reasonable sized game for LD 51 :) |
| Apr 4 17:04:08 | 1h 01m | Nature's Delay | ♥ 1 | this was really fun! I wish there was something else to do while i was waiting for the refreshes, maybe clicking on individual people to get rid of them, anyway it's super fun and tense waiting for the weapons to cooldown, great job with the sound effects as well naturesdelay.JPG |
| Apr 4 17:20:30 | 16m 22s | Musical Thrones | ♥ 2 | really fun mini games, and music! enjoyed this one a lot. A few comments: 1. first play through it took me awhile to understand that i had to use the arrow keys for the symbol choosing, i was clicking on them 2. symbols seem to give very little time on the 3rd choice 3. typing words didnt need to be typed in order great job! musicalthrones.JPG |
| Apr 4 17:34:56 | 14m 26s | Ludum Dare | ♥ 2 | I agree with William that the game would benefit from a guide of how to play inside of the game. Also opening the game was a bit shocking as the colors were very bright. Very interesting design and cool interpretation of the theme! |
| Apr 4 18:22:28 | 47m 32s | Bombthrow | ♥ 1 | Really fun game with good level design for the time constraints. Controls felt pretty nice too overall. Missed some background music and maybe could add another feature like doors or something. Great job! |
| Apr 4 18:27:51 | 5m 23s | Extremely Exteme Sports | ♥ 2 | Loved it, controls are fun, great to play against others, art is simple but funny, music is catchy but not super on theme if i'm honest. maybe some items on the map would be interesting, speed boost, shield, weapon etc. Great job adding multiplayer! |
| Apr 4 18:36:17 | 8m 26s | Captain Starforce | ♥ 2 | Fun and interesting take on a classic that's already great. Few comments: 1. would love to have some indication of where the base is on the map, i got filled up with crew and got frustrated trying to find my way back home 2. initially the graphics are pretty tough, hard to tell an asteroid compared to the background 3. music is awesome 4. I'm not sure what the top bar was supposed to be :( maybe i didn't get that far? |
| Apr 4 18:46:42 | 10m 25s | 2D Platformer | ♥ 2 | Awesome job finishing this project, a pretty basic platformer but they are always fun in my eyes, also nice touch adding the map after losing. comments: 1. Try locking the z rotation of the character so it doesnt tilt over (Freeze constraints Z rotation) 2. the one moving platform on the right seems to move through the character sometimes, either its just moving too fast or you can try to update the character collision handling to be continuous instead of discrete on the Rigidbody component of the player 3. Try playing around with some music / sound fx! it's super fun and adds a lot to games |
| Apr 4 18:57:57 | 11m 15s | Global Eggstermination | ♥ 1 | Great little horde game, love the characters a lot, music is good, seems like there's a dominant strategy to keep looping around but overall nice job, had fun with this one :) |
| Apr 4 19:05:24 | 7m 27s | Parachute | ♥ 3 | @remco it's a P not an F ;) graphics are cool, music / sound effects are cool, but the gameplay is pretty minimal. great job with the artistic side of things |
| Apr 4 19:16:01 | 10m 37s | ENTROPY | ♥ 0 | fun game that's pretty easy to understand but easy to get yourself into trouble, if you're not careful and sometimes even if you are! finger drumming was funny but almost took away from the enviroment, would've loved some technoy type music for this one |
| Apr 4 19:21:20 | 5m 19s | Frantic Alchemist | ♥ 1 | Graphics are awesome, gameplay is a bit simple, I also think some sound effects would make it go a long way. |
| Apr 4 19:31:12 | 9m 52s | Outside the Town of Malbork | ♥ 1 | wow i'm not sure what I just played but I loved it. so weird and interesting, I'm also in the camp of not usually liking visual novels but this was cool and I have no idea why. Great job |
| Apr 4 19:40:04 | 8m 52s | An Inevitable Race | ♥ 0 | Love the visuals and sound effects here, gameplay was okay and I understand it was focused on the storyline but got a bit stale towards the end. Great submission overall as it's really polished for 48 hours |
| Apr 4 19:48:02 | 7m 58s | Can I Win as a Lv. 1 Slime? -underdog rising- | ♥ 1 | awesome graphics and music, funny premise. I keep dying and I ran out of energy to keep collecting flowers :( |
| Apr 4 20:14:44 | 26m 42s | Don't Melt | ♥ 0 | Agree that the camera should be inverted by default, had to change that. I got right to buying the flight tickets twice only to get hit by a car right before! well designed, could use some music though! |
| Apr 4 20:17:55 | 3m 11s | CounterSplit | ♥ 1 | Simple idea but infuriating! i wish I could find some different strategy but I always seem to die at a similar point, would be cool to get some timer slowdown effect as it gets closer to 13? also i think sometimes the balls get off screen and are impossible to slice but maybe it was just on web. Cool idea and works well! |
| Apr 4 20:24:54 | 6m 59s | Last Minute On Earth | ♥ 1 | fun game as others mentioned, simple but interesting enough to get your pulse up. Great job, i made it 12+ minutes |
| Apr 5 21:29:36 | 25h 04m | The Pit | ♥ 1 | Cool concept. a few comments: 1. it's frustrating to not be able to move left and right very fast 2. I wish i could queue up cards before the fall starts 3. Looks like a UI bug where it will always 'deal' 5 cards at the start? or at least one extra one. Great job! it's a really polished game for 48 hours and I think scaling the replay with the same deck amount would fix the infinite possibilities |
| Apr 5 21:39:17 | 9m 41s | Dire Darkness | ♥ 1 | Great job finishing the game! A few comments: 1. It felt a bit too easy to stay alive, i was surrounded by zombies and my health bar was barely going down 2. No reloading made the shooting less stressful than typical horde games 3. Would be cool to add some music or different characters moving at different speeds 4. a pretty simple shooter but still fun to get some headshots! Could be fun to track kills somewhere on the screen as well. |
| Apr 5 21:48:30 | 9m 13s | Infection | ♥ 0 | Pretty fun game and I initially thought it was too easy until i noticed i was out of bullets! I think I got lucky on the path to win but it was fun. Loved the art but I couldn't tell the difference between alcohol and penicillin, is there any difference? Also I couldn't figure out how to restart the game. Great job! |
