elenesski 2015-12-14 18:45
Good idea. Wasn't sure how it met either theme. Took too long to get to the bad guys.
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD34 → ReachTheTop
By coldman
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 3 | 57 | ||
| Humor | 459 | 2.41 | ||
| Graphics | 464 | 3.12 | ||
| Audio | 577 | 2.41 | ||
| Overall | 658 | 3.03 | ||
| Fun | 661 | 2.91 | ||
| Mood | 694 | 2.66 | ||
| Innovation | 891 | 2.24 | ||
| Theme | 956 | 2.00 |
Good idea. Wasn't sure how it met either theme. Took too long to get to the bad guys.
great idea but It crash :(
A really good framework for a BoI-like game! Thought the combat wasn't really a strong point but again, its a pretty ambitious game and a short time span.
Nothing to do with the themes, but nice little game. I liked the art.
Hey everyone, thank you for the feedback !
@sergicollado: Can you tell me on which "Downloads and Links" ?
When it comes to the music it would be nice if the melodies were more directed, also the sounds themselves didn't fit together all that nicely. Cute graphics though. Probably would've enjoyed it more if I got some better feedback when an enemy is hit, maybe with some sound and visual effect.
Funny game! Level design was good! The game has potential to be very nice!
The game's in the right direction but the combat needs some work.
I'll agree that it was a good idea, and I liked that the levels changed each time I played. The sound was pretty solid as well. I think it was a good attempt. That said, it sounds like you want some honest feedback, so I will give a little.
I think the two main complaints I could raise might be around player/enemy movement. Not having the player sprite face a direction (or having some other indicator) made it hard to tell where my attack was going to go. I can remember what direction I last walked in, but it's a little unexpected to not have that visual aid. Additionally, it feels weird that enemies don't stop moving/slow down/change direction/do something when they're hit.
Please don't be discouraged; as I said, I still think it is a good entry.
As a last note, the theme is present, though maybe a little subtle. The plant growth links the levels together.
@cppchriscpp: Thanks for the honest feedback. It does not discourage me. It's the opposite. I'm trying not to skip any comment you guys left her, take note, and I started working on a post-compo version ;)
Nice game, I wish there would be feedback on if I hit the enemy or not. Nice Music
Overall it was actually really good. The combat needed a little work but other than that it was great, exploring the world/levels and trying to get further up the tower. Great stuff overall!:)
Too few enemies plus huge prices makes me sad.
My hands were cramping after a while, even with the iron sword I had to hit monsters just a bit too long. I wasn't sure when I was hitting things as there's no feedback of a normal sword swing vs hit, but the little character is cute and the idea, though not awfully original, was well executed for a 2-day compo. Nicely done. Hope you'll continue it for a bit. Maybe reduce slime HP by 30% or so and add some new mobs!
Hello @zenmumbler, thanks for the feedbacks :) Actually yes I'm working on a post-compo release and hope to show it soon. I made new graphics, sounds and a bit different than my compo entry. Your feedbacks are taken into account for it too !
Really cool so far although there's plenty more you could improve on like feedback for hitting enemies or getting hit and maybe some different types of enemies.
But for what you have so far it's great! Keep it up!
Even though it crashed sometimes when playing the windows build (I think when it tries to load the red tile set...), I really enjoyed playing this! With some post-compo polish, this can be really fun!
Interesting game
Confusing game. In my second try it froze on "Floor 1" screen. But in my playthrough, I think it wasn't clear what I was supposed to do. And the combat was hard, you can't hit the enemy unless you're in a specific distance, not near and not far. I think you could work on the music too. It'd give a big plus to the game. There's potential, but it's hard to achieve it in 48h. Anyway, good job finishing it!
Cool!
Obviously very limited, but I see you didn't have much time. Definitely a good start, don't give up on it!
Music could do with some work I think, and the theme connection is a bit weak..
But the art is really cool and the controls are smooth. Sound effects are good.
Actually, I see that you're climbing on these things which I suppose are growing. So that's cool!
Interesting, but I think some feedbacks are needed (when you hit a target specially). It took me some time to understand how to leave the shop, and that the rooms where random. Otherwise it's fun
Cute graphics. Game got a little frustrating when moving to a rooms with nuts, not sure if it happens every time but the two nuts I found unavoidably damaged me when I entered the room.
Cute, fun game! I included it in my Ludum Dare 34 compilation video series, if you’d like to check it out :) https://youtu.be/r75qiAihqqk