shanecelis
Neat concept. I went in a similar direction with my entry Dark Maze, so I can understand the difficulty in trying to make the sounds mean something.
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD16 → Soundscape
By atomic
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Innovation | 5 | 4.10 | 20 | |
| Theme | 4 | 4.20 | 20 | |
| Fun | 96 | 2.10 | 20 | |
| Graphics | 117 | 1.40 | 10 | |
| Audio | 28 | 3.11 | 19 | |
| Humor | 52 | 2.38 | 8 | |
| Overall | 47 | 3.10 | 21 | |
| Community | 47 | 3.29 | 14 | |
| Coolness | 59 | 12 |
Neat concept. I went in a similar direction with my entry Dark Maze, so I can understand the difficulty in trying to make the sounds mean something.
A great idea; I strongly feel, however, that you should have switched the 'UI' so that pitch indicated distance to the exit and beep frequency indicated distance to an obstacle. I think it's much easier to discern small changes in pitch than small changes in beep frequency, at least without busting out a stop watch.
I really like the idea, but was actually not able to succeed. I think I hit any pice of wall that was in the game :D
With no idea how fast I was turning, I found it very difficult to visualise the level.
What would really help is a visual indication of which way the player is facing, so you can tell whether you've turned 180 degrees and are sending sonar waves back the way you've come or if you're looking at a new passage.
Or if instead of distance to exit you had direction to exit (fast beeps = ahead of you, slow beeps = behind you).
A very good attempt at a very innovative concept! I couldn't stick with it long enough to finish, but I sort of like the idea. It is different!
Nice gameplay! I wasn't able to succeed but I think it was pretty cool.
Good achievement. I never got to the end, but I like the blind movement.
Great idea. But it would help if those beeps were far more frequent (or just a new one after every move), this way you have to wait all the time. Also a separate sound for your goal would be nice.
My character walked into so many walls, he's probably got an awful headache. :P I'm sure it's a good game, I just couldn't figure out what I was doing.
Very cool idea, and I wanted to like it,but I found it very hard. On my first attempt I never noticed the rate of beeping changing at all. The second time I managed to find a slightly faster patch but couldn't work out exactly where to go.
As others have suggested, more or different audio queues might make it easier. I've seenheard a game that used a wind sound to let you know which way you were facing - the wind is loudest when you're facing into it.
I would like to have been able to see a map showing my stumbling path after I quit.
This IS really hard. :(
I couldn't even come close. lol
Good idea, but sound indications aren't distinguishable enough.
Interesting idea, although I found it difficult because there wasn't constant audio feedback.
Great idea, but too hard for me to actually have the patience to finish it. Maybe it would've been more playable if you'd use stereo sound. And maybe defining turning a bit better, I had no idea how much every press turned the player.
Really interesting! Couldn't make it, and I agree with philomory; the game could be even better with the functions switched. Also, while playing, I though that the game was in a DungeonMasterish manner: you turn always 90 degrees. I think that might make it a lot more interesting.
Firstly -- i was unable to finish this game, it just wasn't enough information for me to find out, where i'm.
I was thinking about the possibilities, how to make this more enjoyable and still not lose the good atmosphere of absolute darkness and desorientation and i still don't have any idea how to do it better, but i see 2 blury possibilities which way it can go further. One of them was already discussed here -- staying at absolutely dark game, but tweaking various things such, that it will give one better information about the level (constant sound with varying pitch, volume, better 3d efects according to current room size etc.). I see second possibility in giving there a bit of visual information which shoud compensate the impossibility of using touch. For example to use rendered 3d hand, which one could lean against the wall with mouse and find out the angle between him and the wall without the need of rendering anything else.
But i liked this game a lot, i think i also had simulation sickness just from the sound and the inner picture of the maze i was absolutely lost in. ;)
Amazing concept, far too difficult, but it should be, and you shouldnt make it easier, I found it difficult to determine what different pitches and frequency I was listening out for, perhaps a guide at the start to determine this may have helped, might just be me though