Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD56 → Feedback comment stats → Yorsh

Yorsh

Feedback comments for LD56

Yorsh's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Yorsh's comment
Oct 7 01:11:40		CLICK THEM	♥ 2	It's short and sweet! It's obviously not very innovative but for a first entry it's probably better to focus on making a solid, complete game as you did. Congrats!
Oct 7 19:36:58	18h 25m	Gnomania	♥ 0	The game is complete and works fine, congrats! Graphics are cute, sound does the job. I got stuck multiple time at the start, it seems that if you don't do the correct build order you get stuck, that's an issue imo. When you get how things work, the game kinda plays itself but it's already pretty good for a jam. Good job!
Oct 7 19:46:17	9m 19s	Slimeow Game	♥ 2	Graphics are amazing, good sound choice, and the overall mood is fun and engaging. Gameplay looks cool, but I gave up after a while cause it's way, way too long to gather fishes imo. I click once, then wait a minute or more before doing anything else. So looks like a fun game, but can't really tell atm. Other than that, it's very well made. Great work!
Oct 7 19:59:42	13m 25s	Invertaburied	♥ 0	Nice exploration game. It feels complete. Music is cool (tho too quite, I thought it had no audio at first). It feels nice to level up. The pace is too slow tho imo, everything takes a long time to do. I struggled to understand why I could dig things or not at first, the water bar UI is not that clear at first glance. So it's lacking a bit of fun for me, but the rest is well made, good job!
Oct 7 20:13:12	13m 30s	Soot & Stinker	♥ 1	Cool small game! It's short and sweet and works pretty good. Graphics and sound are nice. Foot behave strangely sometimes tho. Good job!
Oct 7 21:24:18	1h 11m	PogoCombo	♥ 1	Graphics and sound are amazing! Controls are very weird but that's intended I suppose, and that gives a unique feel to the game. Very nicely done, especially for a compo. Congrats!
Oct 7 21:47:09	22m 51s	Our flap of wings	♥ 2	Looks very pretty, music is superb. It's an interesting idea of gameplay, tho it's a bit restrictive to be only limited to a small circle, sometimes I would like to push someone with a different angle (I understand it would raise other issues). It looks like each time I drop a butterfly I'm on a different instance, idk if it's intended, something is weird or every butterfly ends up moving in between. In any case, great job!
Oct 7 22:05:29	18m 20s	The Red Beetle Squad	♥ 3	Really cool idea! It's sweet, looks fantastic and music is amazing! It takes a few runs to understand what you are doing but it works well when you do thanks to the diverse classes. I think the communication is a bit too limited tho, but overall you managed this complicated idea very well!
Oct 7 22:27:53	22m 24s	Beetle Tower	♥ 4	Really fun game! Graphics are cute, sounds are cool and music is awesome. Controls are neat and intuitive, I really like the feeling of picking up a guy, giving it a tool and putting it back in. It's probably a bit easy as long as you pick a bit of everything, but for a sweet and short playthrough it's totally fine. Also really well polished on top of all that. Great job!
Oct 8 02:12:03	3h 44m	Critter Switcher	♥ 1	Looks and sounds amazing! Gameplay works well once you get the hang of it, creatures have interesting patterns to figure out. The dungeon is too big imo, I felt like I was clearing way too many rooms before finding a room with something meaningful in it. Overall a very solid game, good job!
Oct 8 02:25:14	13m 11s	A very small seed	♥ 1	Very sweet game, very relaxing. It has some very small issues as others said, but the game very much succeed at what it's trying to do. Graphics and sounds are really well made, especially for a compo. Congrats!
Oct 8 18:15:32	15h 50m	Laverino	♥ 3	The game is well complete. Good idea to for an escape game, it's always fun. Cool mood. Puzzles are a bit simple but why not. Some interactions where a bit awkward, it's probably lacking some polish and bug fixes due to time constraints. Congrats!
Oct 8 18:26:37	11m 05s	Critter Cannon	♥ 1	Couldn't get pass the first shooting, it freezes and crash :/
Oct 8 18:33:11	6m 34s	Buzzzy Buzzy Beez	♥ 2	Chill game! It's very well made, it feels good to play. Graphics and sounds are cute. It's lacking a bit of things to do in my opinion, but that's already really good for a jam. Good job!
Oct 8 18:46:41	13m 30s	A Bug's Wife	♥ 2	Very cute and very chill! Puzzles are well balanced (or maybe slightly too easy). 8 puzzles like that are the perfect length for a jam game imo. Sounds are very nice and gives a lot of personality to the game. The puzzling mechanic is not very innovative but it works. Great job!
Oct 8 19:01:55	15m 14s	Mini Beasts	♥ 1	Very well made! Puzzles are interesting, mood is very chill and relaxing. Congrats!
Oct 8 19:22:40	20m 45s	My Keyboard is Full of Ants!	♥ 2	Amazing game! I'm really bad at these kind of games + not a native speaker but I still enjoyed it a lot. Feedback are great, graphics are beautiful. It's a great take on the theme and a nice twist on word games. A run is maybe a bit too long imo. Fantastic work!
Oct 8 19:41:05	18m 25s	I Have Put The Creature Into My Gun	♥ 1	Fun game! The introduction of the mechanic is really funny and well made. It's a great take on the theme. Graphics are cool, tho I would have loved to see the gun. Level design is pretty good for a compo. Platforming controls are pretty basic and could be improved, but it's still totally fine for a jam. Congrats!
Oct 9 02:11:24	6h 30m	TINY PACK	♥ 1	Wow amazing game! It's very, very polished. Strong mood, excellent graphics and sounds. This looks like the work of a small studio for the jam category, being 1 person in compo is insane. Also it has nothing to see with your LD54 game I remember playing last year, it makes it even more impressive. I'll probably come back for a second attempt later. Congrats!
Oct 10 00:10:42	21h 59m	Black Harvest	♥ 2	The creature design and voices are top notch and immediately creates a really cool mood. Houses are fine although I don't think it really add to the visual appeals either, it's really mostly the creatures doing the heavy lifting. I like the gameplay in two phases. The light ray focusing a single dude works, although it could have been interesting to have it roam on its own and kill creatures in its area. Good job!
Oct 10 00:30:29	19m 47s	Mini Beaker	♥ 4	Really cool take on the theme, it's fun and original. It's really funny and beautiful. Gameplay works and is fun. It's not very clear what's going to make you loose or not before it happens, tho it's not too much of an issue given the mood of the game. The game clearly achieves perfectly what it's made to be, congrats! Uhh additional feedback tho, why does the name and thumbnail have nothing to see with the actual game? Maybe I'm missing something cause I'm confused. In game it's Tricky LD creators with cute creatures, here it's mini beaker with a poker coin or something like that.
Oct 13 03:18:38	74h 48m	Wink and the Fae	♥ 2	Cool game! It feels pretty good to play, it's short and fun. Graphics are nice (I love the overlapping sheets, I may steal this in the future ahah). Music is great. Gameplay is simple but interesting. I find that there are some discrepancies in quality in between things of the same kind. Eg the flash on hit is great, but it's lacking some simple particles & sounds to really make the hits feel great. Enemy death anim is really cool looking, but the gun fire anim is meh. Looks to me like you spend too much time on some specific things trying to make them too good, and then run out of time to polish the rest. If you can fix this, your next entries will really feel amazing to play. Now I don't mean to say that it's bad now, it's really good already. Congrats!
Oct 13 17:56:14	14h 37m	La Révolution Francheese: Bonamouse	♥ 5	Interesting game! Graphics are good, music is cool. The controls doesn't really fit the character (why would he slides like that?) tho it does fit the gameplay by making it more interesting to move around. Feedback on bringing back cheese to the forst are really nice, tho it's really lacking on the recruiting part (not sure when/how I recruited them cause no visual cues I could notice). Other than that gameplay works well. Congrats!
Oct 13 18:12:13	15m 59s	Pom Planet	♥ 3	Really cool game! It's beautiful, music is great, I especially like the added instruments when reaching the goal. Puzzles are interesting and well made. I find the puzzle mechanic to be a bit tedious after a while tho, but that may just not be my taste. Really nice polish, everything looks and feel great. Great work, congrats!
Oct 14 19:39:46	25h 27m	Watch your step	♥ 2	Really fun take on the theme! It makes sense, it's original, and it affects gameplay. It's fun and well balanced in difficulty imo. Music is really cool and goes well with the tone of the game. The art style also goes well with the game, tho it's lacking a little bit of colours or something, (maybe brighlty colored people?). It lags slightly, which is probably due to the high number of characters. It's probably easely improvable, tho I 100% understand that it's really not a priority for a jam. Really great game overall, congrats!
Oct 14 19:53:01	13m 15s	TinyWar	♥ 2	Sweet game! Art is pretty good, tho I think it would look much better if drawn at the right size (the line art is scale up/down here and not consistent in between objects). Gameplay is simple but works. I agree with a comment above, first level is a bit too full of stuff, it's better balanced in later levels. That's time you could save to work on particle effects next time for example. 3levels feels right for a jam. Congrats on making a complete game!
Oct 14 21:42:57	1h 49m	ECHOES OF THE GNOMES	♥ 1	What a strong mood! Same as other comments, not sure how the flashlight works on the gnome. Cool art and creepy music. Congrats! Small advice for Itch, you should export the build with a resolution of 1280x720 so it displays nicely in windowed mode, then we can put it full screen 1920x1080 with the built-in button (in Itch I set the resolution to 1280x760 to include the unity bar at the bottom with said button).
Oct 15 01:14:12	3h 31m	Tiny Rexes: Professional Dinosorting	♥ 1	Very cute! It's both simple to understand and fun to play. The use of the mixed colors (orange, green...) is really smart, and it really adds a lot to the gameplay. Graphics are great, and very time efficient I assume. Maybe it's missing just a little something (idk what) to the water/bridges to elevate the game from good looking to beautiful. Amazing game!
Oct 15 01:21:25	7m 13s	Tiny Colony	♥ 0	Impressive polish, especially for such a small team. The one detail that looks a bit rushed is the line showing the mouse drag while aiming. Other than that everything is pretty much perfect: amazing art style, feels great to play, sounds is top notch. The fact that you can load multiple little guys in the slingshot really separates the game from others planet-gravity games that I've played in jams + it works wonder with the theme, so great idea. 1/5 because of the line thing (just kidding).
Oct 16 02:07:32	24h 46m	Bugged Off!	♥ 2	Nice game! Gameplay is really unique, that's a cool idea that goes well with the theme. I don't find it particularly fun to play even tho it's innovative and well made, it's probably not my taste. Great art style for a compo, looks relatively quick to make yet it has a very clean and finished look. Great job on the game!
Oct 16 02:29:58	22m 26s	ArachnoNinja	♥ 1	Really interesting game! First of all, the mood is really cool, those spiders in the dark lights are creepy. The music tracks are really amazing and really adds to it. Art style is really good and goes well with the game, as individual art assets looks fine but not great on their own, but together it looks great. Gameplay wise, it's really packed with ideas! I love the switch in gameplay when you find the sword, you feel powerful. It's overall pretty hard (which I like), but also a bit frustrating (which I don't like too much but it might be intended? If not, less content but more polish would be good). Great game, congrats!