Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → EggshellDog
Feedback comments for LD52
EggshellDog's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | EggshellDog's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 15:06:28 | Tactile Harvest | ♥ 1 | The animation got me. Didn't see that style coming, not much art/anim but all well polished and super smooth! | |
| Jan 9 15:21:02 | 14m 34s | Super Plant Farm | ♥ 1 | Nice, simple and fun. your cover img definitely attracts ppl that like Super Crate Box, and they (I) will love your game! |
| Jan 10 14:08:16 | 22h 47m | H.A.R.V.E.S.T. Harvest And Recon | ♥ 1 | I think the score is not displaying, I played it in 16:9 monitor. by the Christmas lunch I think you guys don't have enough time to polish the game, sorry about that. At least the core head cutting mechanism is finished, it does require some skill and I have some fun. However TBH the lack of animation, feedback and interaction etc, this feels not quite complete. but anyway always good to have a submission! |
| Jan 10 14:54:40 | 46m 24s | Gogo Rabbit's Trap | ♥ 1 | really great, it's the type I like. The sound effect got me right start of the game. hope there can be more interaction |
| Jan 10 15:21:08 | 26m 28s | There is a rabbit here! | ♥ 1 | just like last time a small and solid entry. every thing is good and the music with some little weird tune is great. just a game that too small to give a really high score. if you don't fix the bug maybe I will give it a try to 1000 and enjoy the rest as a rewarding section |
| Jan 10 15:36:33 | 15m 25s | Low Tide Treasures | ♥ 3 | the graphics really stand out, the animation, 2d and 3d art are all good as others comment. but I think you don't have enough time for the core gameplay. It is lack of interaction and goal, gold is useless and I thought it can be interact with the nest, really pity that can't really pick up the fish (i mean eat, maybe). The ebb and flow system is good and have potential to be developed will be a lot better to have more stuff! |
| Jan 10 15:49:15 | 12m 42s | Wheater of the Colossus | ♥ 1 | wow Colossus! I enjoyed a good fight. but the theme is weakly fitted, I spent like 20s to collect wheat and it already enough for my entire fight which mean I don't need to harvest anymore after 20s in the game. but I am glad you do that because the fighting part is much more fun than harvesting. Maybe can have more mechanism to interact with the wheat so harvesting is more meaningful but I know that require a lot more works. Having said that, comment in short, good fight but bad wheat |
| Jan 10 15:56:31 | 7m 16s | Cat Crop Collector | ♥ 1 | a bit horror, thanks for making the zombie not moving too fast so I can finish the game, mood is good |
| Jan 10 16:27:10 | 30m 39s | The organ trees | ♥ 1 | I think comments here are valuable and already pointed out the main issue so let me be the common LD comment. Really really great feeling on the graphics about the scenes combining with the camera movement. indeed not enough tut and having no sound to build up the mood drive player's passion out quickly. but can see a lot of potential and the heart/effort you put into this game :) |
| Jan 11 01:39:18 | 9h 12m | pachinko | ♥ 1 | mom already told me should not gamble |
| Jan 11 02:12:23 | 33m 05s | Tony Crow's Pro Scyther | ♥ 3 | come from your progress post, really well polished, feel very completed. and diff objectives give players lots of way to play in each 2 mins game. well done! |
| Jan 11 04:17:26 | 2h 05m | Click On Fish | ♥ 1 | what have I done.. |
| Jan 11 13:27:00 | 9h 09m | Crisis in Banana Republic | ♥ 2 | a rollback/restart/reset button would really help and make the gameplay more smooth but I guess you guys just dont have enough for more feature, nice puzzle though! |
| Jan 12 17:05:11 | 27h 38m | Combine Competition | ♥ 1 | simple idea, executed pretty well. I mean, you created a small game and it feels completed! it is a very good outcome as first jam, good job! |
| Jan 12 17:44:19 | 39m 08s | Souls harvest | ♥ 0 | nice! This is an additive game, there are a lot of feature can be added, enemy, shop, allies etc you must already know. It is already good enough for a game jam, just saying it will be nice to have more stuff! just a share, in one of my play when I play slothness the game crushed, forgot to screencap the error msg. |
| Jan 13 02:53:39 | 9h 09m | a farmer and his fields, bound together | ♥ 1 | so here we have a realistic farmer simulator... somehow I can't get to year 2 rea.jpg but I got and feel your message.. kind of thankful that the game end me before year 2, don't need to do it myself.. respect |
| Jan 13 03:22:59 | 29m 20s | Harvest Hewn | ♥ 1 | really solid and additive game! as other's comment that will be nice to have some one-time item as we normally can get fully upgrade in mid game but this is not really a problem for a game jam entry. I just don't really have much to say, nice! |
| Jan 13 05:25:35 | 2h 02m | KICK | ♥ 0 | to play the game with the all the background and oepration process in mind is ok. However, the game itself is unpolished, a bit art/ anim/ feedback will help a lot. Having said that, at least you finished the core mechanism completely which is good! |
| Jan 13 05:34:30 | 8m 55s | Buzzy Business | ♥ 1 | my god I hate that fly sound! having said that, I mean you did a great job on all the sound effect! I respect all lives, mosquito have to make their living so they bite which I understand. but still, I can't forgive anyone of them!! dieeeeeeee |
| Jan 13 07:51:34 | 2h 17m | Cake Sweeper | ♥ 1 | graphics stand out as a compo game! sad this is your third idea and seems you don't have enough time to implement more feature for it, but it is still a solid little game and feel completed! |
| Jan 13 20:47:55 | 12h 56m | Dead End Job | ♥ 0 | cool reaper jam entry, not the best but is a solid one, feel a bit unbalance but it is good enough for a jam entry. reaper harvest soul, is kind of classic. Having said all these, the graphic and mood do stand out, set up pretty good, nice! having a fun time playing it, once die in the 10 waves accidentally stuck in a corner, damn! |
| Jan 13 21:21:17 | 33m 22s | Orchard Archer | ♥ 1 | solid entry! really good shooting experience, the difficulties level up along the game process which is designed well, would like to have more type of enemy instead of just shoot flying ball but that's how you fit the harvest theme! so that's not really a cons, well done overall! |
| Jan 14 10:52:22 | 13h 31m | 'Arr-vest | ♥ 1 | solid little game, the core combat and upgrade mechanism are completed pretty well. The movement of the ship/cannon ball are too flat however, it does not quite feel like a ship moving on the sea and cannon ball should have like moving super fast as first and a bit slower over time. some more feedback/anim like shooting shake the ship a bit will add lot more juice to the gameplay. oh also having some effect on water will be great. Overall I think this is good but lack of polishing. good job anyway |
| Jan 14 17:00:17 | 6h 07m | Pseudo-Harvest | ♥ 1 | perfect fit for the theme and mean while having a unique and funny core mechanism. wonderful! will expect for more level! |
| Jan 14 17:19:25 | 19m 08s | Glean the Luminescent | ♥ 2 | cool mechanism to connect all stuff with the light(power)! finally rush collector and win at day 3, having fun with it! |
| Jan 16 12:40:12 | 43h 20m | The Pets Over The Innsmouth | ♥ 2 | lmao love your ending, he deserves better! |
| Jan 18 02:27:54 | 37h 47m | The Ballad of Eric Hernandez, Cattle Rancher | ♥ 1 | Art |
| Jan 18 09:13:44 | 6h 45m | Gummy Gobs | ♥ 1 | simple and fun little game, this is a cool idea to fit the theme and I love the overall art style, look so silly! |
| Jan 30 12:24:59 | 291h 11m | Red Harvest | ♥ 2 | quack |
