Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD46 → Feedback comment stats → Yorsh
Feedback comments for LD46
Yorsh's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Yorsh's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 20 13:14:18 | The Dark | ♥ 1 | Really nice atmosphere ! I feel like the sound clip you used doesn't match the mood of the game tho (it's kind of 8-bit ish, I would have prefered something more organic). | |
| Apr 20 14:48:31 | 1h 34m | Rolly and the Flower | ♥ 1 | I made it to the end, that's really good ! Physics and controls are great, the sound is great, and there is quite a lot of content. A little thing : some levels end up being more or less randoms, I took some elevators while praying nothing would hit me instead or figuring out the patern, because figuring out when to go is not clear enough imo. |
| Apr 20 17:10:40 | 2h 22m | Save Dave | ♥ 1 | That's super smart and really well executed ! I loved That I first thought it would be a shooter, then a tamagotchi, then actually both. |
| Apr 20 17:39:33 | 28m 53s | Keep Everything Alive | ♥ 2 | Simple game but it feels great to play. The only thing is that I would make "intervene" on a button as well, to avoid doing it by misstake. |
| Apr 21 12:46:55 | 19h 07m | Flippy Fish | ♥ 1 | It feels soo good to play, nice job ! The difficulty is also well adjusted, it's "easy" but it pushes you to make misstakes. I made it to 120 :) |
| Apr 21 14:43:43 | 1h 56m | PlantArtica | ♥ 1 | Strong atmosphere, the freezing to death mechanic is interesting and works well with the enemy, the ice and the destroyable platforms. Plus there is quite a lot of content. I also love the story elements here and there. The controls are a bit too strict for my taste tho (this said I do suck at platformers). |
| Apr 21 17:11:32 | 2h 27m | Eggscuse me! | ♥ 0 | Great level design, and by great I mean I hate it. |
| Apr 21 21:29:21 | 4h 17m | Pet shop INC. | ♥ 0 | It's simple gameplay-wise but it feels really good to play, and I had to get the different animals to see what they looked like in the store. Solid entry, nice job ! |
| Apr 22 09:09:13 | 11h 39m | Plant Life | ♥ 1 | The mechanics are introduced at the right time, just when you are getting comfortable with the old ones. It's hard. |
| Apr 22 10:39:37 | 1h 30m | Zen Watering | ♥ 0 | Hey that's not that zen, that's some hardcore watering we are doing here ! I liked it a lot tho. It's beautiful, the plant must have taken a lot of time to get right I suppose ? I also like the cute ending. Max grade in graphics and mood at least, favorite compo game so far :) |
| Apr 22 12:11:09 | 1h 31m | Blokrok | ♥ 1 | The game feels polished and complete, and is fun. The difficulty goes from easy to very hard too fast imo. I also find the cage interesting since you can push the rocks in, but I find it too hard at the moment. If it were something like 3 times as large, you could reliably send rocks by bumping them in the right direction, instead of simply trying tp send them in the area of the cage and hope for the best. |
| Apr 22 15:41:38 | 3h 30m | Dont Drop the Plant | ♥ 2 | So everyone praising the art style, but to me it's the weakness of this game. It's hard to tell where you are going to land, and it's hard on the eyes (too bright) and on the brain. I only played the first few levels because of the reasons above, but the level design looks good and it felt pretty good to move around, so it's a nice game overall (plus it looks like there are quite a lot of levels for a 48h game) |
| Apr 22 20:31:09 | 4h 49m | Tumbleweed | ♥ 2 | That's nearly perfect for me. I'm just going to talk about what I didn't like as much since everything else is just 5/5. The gameplay is good enough for a jam, it's nice but it's not breathtaking. I think that it could be smoother if the wind kept pushing forever or something. Again, it did not deserve the game at all. Now, the only real thing that I found is that the tumbleweed is just a static mesh rolling, and it shows. Since it's the main character, I think it would have been a good idea to allocate time to improve it and make it have some physic instead of something like the end cutscene (which is really cool, but no one would have complained if it didn't exist). |
| Apr 22 21:58:51 | 1h 27m | LD46_Charger | ♥ 2 | I didn't find the gameplay that fun, but I think it delivered what it wanted to, just not my taste. Other that than it's just so charming, I love the mood, the animations the art style the sound the feel etc. I'm taking notes. |
| Apr 23 11:45:55 | 13h 47m | Operation Asteroid | ♥ 1 | That's a nice game ! A lot of stuff for a compo game. It has lasers going everywhere so that's cool. Manual fire has the potential to feel better tho. First making the visual effect start from the bottom of the screen so it would look right without having to move the camera. Then not having to preshot stuff to hit, which is always complicated in 3D given that depth is pretty hard to estimate. First person lasers are always hard to get right in my experience, that's not an easy task in 48h. |
| Apr 23 12:11:59 | 26m 04s | Come to Mama | ♥ 2 | It's beautiful and very polished, great job. The monster eating the baby animation and sound are especially nice. The only thing that bothered me is picking stuff up when I don't want to. I believe it could work as it is if you were locked into moving along the grid (it would become part of the puzzle). Since you can move freely tho (which is probably better) I would prefer to pick up and throw things by pressing and releasing a button. |
| Apr 23 12:31:45 | 19m 46s | Metamagotchi | ♥ 1 | Well uhh, It's not very engaging gameplay-wise obviously, but I still really like it. It feels really good and it is beautiful. Spending time on nonsense is probably what lead you to making such great stuff, but I hope you can balance your time just a tiny bit more toward "Finishing important stuff" next time so I could give you 5/5 in everything :) Also, if you haven't seen it already, here is another really well made tamagotchi game : https://ldjam.com/events/ludum-dare/46/save-dave |
| Apr 25 15:32:15 | 51h 00m | A Very Fishy Game | ♥ 2 | It's simple but relaxing, I like it. The sound effects however don't really match the mood and are way too loud. In my experience (as someone who doesn't know anything about sound) when going for relaxing stuff, just record youself doing pretty much anything that makes sound and you get much more natural and organic sounds. |
| Apr 25 16:03:13 | 30m 58s | Unsplashed | ♥ 1 | It's a nice idea, and the game is cute. It lacks a bit of polish tho, but that's always a struggle when going solo. |
| May 1 14:59:46 | 142h 56m | What the Firetruck!? | ♥ 2 | It feels super good to play, and it's really polished. It's not crazy innovative but it does have its unique mechanics. Great work ! |
| May 3 15:47:57 | 48h 48m | Stranded Pirates | ♥ 2 | I love the retro style but I did struggle to understand what was what, and where I could walk or not. Once I figured it out it's nice and fit the theme well. |
| May 3 16:01:06 | 13m 09s | Servant Snake | ♥ 2 | It's a nice idea and fits the theme. I feel like the enemies were too strong, as soon as one was close enough from a food I would just give up this one, other than that it's engaging and works well. |