Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD45 → Feedback comment stats → winslow
Feedback comments for LD45
winslow's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | winslow's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 6 23:52:10 | Last Goodbyes | ♥ 1 | I really enjoyed this. As I write this it brings tears to my eyes so you did amazing on the mood. The last year has been relatively tough as well with my grandma passing away and a few other things. This game in a way brought a small amount of closure or calmness. The visuals and music we're great too! Well done all around. | |
| Oct 7 00:03:11 | 11m 01s | Nothing To The Moon | ♥ 1 | Loved the sound effects! Great comedic timing. At first I was confused what the game was in "zone 1" where you hop on the platform but I quickly understood it after that! I really liked your usage of the theme. Nothing to something! Great job! |
| Oct 7 00:37:37 | 34m 26s | Yogurt's Quest | ♥ 1 | Beginning was confusing. Wasn't clear what I was suppose to do with falling star section. So I kept running into the big stars thinking that was taking me to another world. Like @gerugames mentioned once I tried surviving it lasted a bit long for my taste. Framerate was sporadic during the falling star section and platformer. Sometimes it would be really fast and others it would crawl. This was on a decent desktop in Firefox. The jumping didn't feel natural and felt to short on the jump. It made jumps that I would have expected to clear very difficult and frustrating. I think with some polish to improve performance and controls with clarification in the beginning for the falling star section it could be an enjoyable game. Some fitting music would really help pull the mood together for the starry platformer. |
| Oct 7 04:15:37 | 3h 38m | Nothing On Frontlines | ♥ 3 | Sound was a little hard on the ears with headphones as it was repetitive but otherwise awesome entry. It was fun and controls were good. FYI the 'Q' I thought was a magnify glass for a second instead of a Q Key. |
| Oct 7 04:23:43 | 8m 06s | Monster herding | ♥ 0 | @ryu I can't seem to get it to play properly. Here's a screen cap. I click build turret and I select a bullet type but nothing happens. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgq0hTgzmeA |
| Oct 7 05:01:11 | 37m 28s | Devour | ♥ 0 | Missing file for Planet1.jpg Windows 7 64bit devour-missing-file.PNG |
| Oct 7 05:08:16 | 7m 05s | Build up Speed | ♥ 1 | I like the concept. Was a little bored in the first 2 training sessions but that's life. This game teaches you much like game jams that you don't win the race without training & learning. I think some little animated sprites running would be a great addition and help polish the game. |
| Oct 8 18:21:50 | 37h 13m | Gravity Fusion | ♥ 2 | Awesome game! Really love the added and unexpected humour in the 2nd (?) to last super particle really made me laugh! I got it to cap out at a mass of 1M. Some performance hits once I started spamming particles everywhere. |
| Oct 8 18:49:32 | 27m 42s | Collect Recyclables | ♥ 1 | Overall I really liked the idea and game. Especially with the recent closure of rePlanet recycling in California we all need to do our part of reduce, reuse, recycle. I played the web version (Firefox) and came across graphic performance problems of stuttering which made the game jarring to play. I also got the character to go backwards through the level which was cool. Really enjoyed it. Great entry! |
| Oct 8 19:24:34 | 35m 02s | OH GOD! | ♥ 2 | Graphics were good theme was good. Platforming controls were clunky and I kept getting the feeling of it doing what I didn't want it to do which is frustrating and thus I stopped playing after falling off the same platform a couple times. Here is a good interview where Tommy Refenes discusses how he programed the controls for super meat boy (timestamp at 43:53) https://youtu.be/QVpSIdWE0do?t=2633 |
| Oct 8 19:39:10 | 14m 36s | The Card Crafter | ♥ 1 | Really enjoyed this turn based game! Everything was well built out with the power ups and the card buffing etc. |
| Oct 8 20:05:45 | 26m 35s | Robo-Fort | ♥ 1 | Awesome game. Controls were hard to use and my robot was sliding all over the place. I also found it more beneficial to hit the robots with my own robot instead of place boxes since I didn't take any damage. Controls made me slowly give up. |
| Oct 9 00:29:16 | 4h 23m | Super Goat Life | ♥ 6 | Played this for a solid 10-15 minutes. Really enjoyed it but couldn't find the hidden one. Note: You may want to create a death box so if the user does get out of the map they die and reset. Is the hidden one related to the big burger? You also made me kill all the bats looking for the secret ability. I found some plain white sphere but didn't do anything. Great game I feel the directions and encouragement of what the player should be doing has room for improvement. |
| Oct 9 23:20:23 | 22h 51m | Lovely World | ♥ 1 | Overall enjoyed the game. The graphics, sounds and mechanics were great! I had a few frustrations in the first level due to where I placed my initial wood plank it meant I didn't have the extra one I needed to complete the level and I couldn't pick up an existing plank to reuse. Character moved to slowly for my liking and thus I got bored while waiting for the character to walk across the map. |
| Oct 10 02:48:55 | 3h 28m | World Collector | ♥ 1 | Amazing all around. Great work. I would encourage you to turn this into a full game. |
| Oct 15 20:55:18 | 138h 06m | Server Error | ♥ 0 | Good idea but unclear on certain things. The text was hard to read and I couldn't find a place to determine what my current money balance was at the time. The other issue I had is I would create 2 videos one after another and then go to upload them but it would only upload the last one made. Potentially eating into my money balance (but again I couldn't find where that balance was). With some additional polish and clarity it could be a fun game. |
| Oct 15 20:59:42 | 4m 24s | Chomp.io | ♥ 0 | Fun game. Hitbox issues but other good. The progression from small to big character could/should be drawn out. Otherwise you're the biggest character on the map within 15 seconds. |
| Oct 16 02:28:34 | 5h 28m | The Journey with Her | ♥ 1 | Amazing puzzle game. Loved the mechanics and abilities of each character. The graphics and showing which character was active was great. Overall I really enjoyed this game and brought back memories of playing portal 2 co-op. I'd encourage you to continue this game it could be a great game. The only down mark I have is the audio/music. I applaud you for what you created during the short duration but I grew tired of the repetitiveness of it and I muted my sound around the 4th or 5th level. Additional work on the audio would help pull the game together. I really hope to see this to a full game. The story was great too. Text a little hard to read but otherwise amazing job! |
| Oct 16 02:48:56 | 20m 22s | Star Battle | ♥ 1 | Fun game with great music. The physics were great. I found it really fun but the novelty ran out after the gold atoms started dying after being depleted. It then became very hard to get the last remaining atoms and became less fun during that time. |
| Oct 16 03:00:07 | 11m 11s | EEPROM | ♥ 1 | Got into an infinite loop on level 2. Use 5 Nop 1 Mov. Also no way I found to reset a level when I've messed it up so you have to refresh in order to keep playing but that resets to level 1. Instructions weren't clear what each command did so I struggled to understand exactly what I was programming and thus used trial and error but then when I failed I couldn't reset the level. Overall fun game but a little frustrating as it wasn't 100% clear how the commands worked and specificially the timing. Edit: Now I see the instructions on this page. You should add them to the game intro so players know. |
| Oct 28 05:33:06 | 290h 32m | Palely | ♥ 2 | Loved it was a little unsure of how to play in the beginning and that was frustrating and almost quit but glad I kept playing as it was very enjoyable. FYI on Linux Mint I had issues where I couldn't pick up the letters or interact with the scene. Worked fine on Windows 7 though. |
| Nov 2 17:50:50 | 132h 17m | Scrap Time | ♥ 1 | Awesome game with incredible polish was a ton of fun! I'd highly encourage you to make this into a full game! Great job on LD45 |
